Introduction

Why conduct a serious case review   ?

‘ Serious case reviews are an important mechanism to understand whether there are lessons to  be learned about how professionals and services worked together. They provide accountability and transparency within the service, to patients, public and the multi agency partnership.  Importantly, the review provides the opportunity to highlight good practice, equality issues and learning across the multi agency partnership.  

The word ‘ Serious’  has gone.   Such reviews are now defined as ‘Safeguarding’   Changing the words of a familiar text is almost traditional.   The criteria haven’t changed and  the word serious is appropriate.  It will be used here, reporting a case involving two very old people, William, then in his late nineties, and  his wife Catherine, who was in her  late eighties.  William was blind, they were both suffering from dementia.   The concept of ‘ safeguarding’ began with children.  Clearly children need protection, sometimes from their own families. Some adults need safeguarding too, including people like William and Catherine. .     Their  case demonstrates comprehensive safeguarding failures.    When  the abuse of William and Catherine was reported to Social Services , NHS Mental Health and to the Police, no action was taken.

The whistleblower was warned about wasting police time. . A care manager and a social worker denied any recollection of the three hour meeting during which serious abuse was reported and a statement given, signed and witnessed.  Requiring proof that William was blind,  the Police, who had been given William’s Registered Blind Person’s card,  obtained medical records directly from a trainee registrar at the Manchester Royal Eye Hospital -  then closed the case, claiming this was because William would have been able to read.    A  GMP  officer did not understand the significance of the number obtained from the registrar.  The opthalmology ratio confirms  blindness.  Obtaining access to Williams records from  the Medical Legal department, the police could have seen the certificate completed by William’s consultant opthalmic surgeon. The certificate states  clearly,

‘ This person is blind. They cannot do any work for which eyesight is essential’

Aged 98, blind, hearing impaired and suffering from dementia, William supposedly commissioned the building of a house on Cardigan Bay, spending their savings, and selling their house.  Catherine, his wife for over sixty years, mother of their four children and retired headteacher,  was to move into a Manchester care home.  Catherine had become Mary,  a state pensioner, with very few assets. 


This review of NHS, Social Services, the Police and other public authority failings examines the NHS and Adult Social Care  of William ( 1910 – 2009) and Catherine ( 1920 – 201l ) , including the ease with which their personal, mental health and general medical care was obstructed and compromised, core personal history misrepresented and financial assets misused  by another person, in a way which was of no benefit to either Catherine or William. Correct medical and personal histories are presented in their earlier NHS records.

Despite repeated safeguarding referrals, made by phone, by letter and in face to face meetings, two vulnerable adults were discharged into the care of the person identified in those referrals.  Financial abuse well into six figures is only one of the serious negative outcomes.

Recent legislation, including the Care Act of 2014  adds some measures which were not in place during the time frame of this review.  Such changes mainly consolidate what was always good practice.  Published by the Department of Health  20th March  2000, ‘ No Secrets’  begins with a robust policy statement.

‘There can be no secrets and no hiding place when it comes to exposing the abuse of vulnerable adults.’ 

                                 ‘ No Secrets’    Department of Health, 2000



Summary

When human rights abuses and ongoing extensive financial abuse of two people in their late eighties and late nineties, both suffering from dementia were reported to Social Services, NHS mental health professionals and the Police,  no action was taken. 

NHS Mental Health professionals accepted third party control over access to mental health care for a vulnerable  86 year old suffering from dementia.  Social Services officers denied any recollection of a long meeting during which they witnessed the signed statement of the person reporting  ongoing abuse and presenting evidence.

By phone in 2xxx  and 2xxx, then in written referrals and during a GP meeting in  2xxx and 2xxx, Jane  warned that her parents were at risk for two reasons, physically, because of the combined disabilities of blindness and dementia, and secondly, they were at risk from a relative, living nearby, identified throughout this review as Sibling 3.  Another family member, identified in this review as Sibling 2, provided  Jane  with the address of a property under construction, commissioned, supposedly, by 98 year old William, who was blind, hearing impaired ( uncorrected) and suffering from vascular dementia.   Given this information, Jane  had a personal and civic responsibility to persist in reporting the abuse to the appropriate authorities, beginning with reports to Social Services, identified as the lead agency. In 2xxx and 2xxx, ongoing and extensive abuse was reported to the Police and to Social Services and documented evidence of abuse presented, including bank statements showing the misuse of approximately £200,000 and  the ongoing sale of the house owned by Catherine and William.  No action was taken.  A care manager and a social worker denied any recollection of their three hour meeting with Jane , during which they witnessed Jane’s  signed statement.

Reporting abuse to the Police met with the response that the matter was ‘a domestic, we don’t get involved’. MP involvement  achieved initial Police investigation into  extensive abuse. Police constable accessed NHS data directly from a registrar, not from the Medical Legal department. . Police officers did not understand the significance of the number which confirmed that a 98 year old victim of abuse was blind.  Police closed the investigation, claiming that he would have been able to read.   Presenting a 98 year old victim’s Registered Blind Person’s card, and the certificate completed by a consultant opthalmic surgeon, confirming blindness, the Police responded that there was no evidence that he could not see anything. MP submitted the same records, receiving the same response.  Only a minority of people  who are recognised as legally blind have no sight at all, that is, have no light perception. (NLP) 

Media attention focuses on abuse in care homes, in hospitals and the abuse of vulnerable people by strangers.  Legislation and protocols define a plethora of safeguarding measures which operate in NHS hospitals, nursing and residential settings.  Care provision is monitored by the Care Quality Commission and  Healthwatch.  No such safeguards operate in private households, where people suffering from dementia and other serious health problems  of later life may be controlled by ‘ carers’ .  Self-identified carers, who are likely to be family members are not vetted. This includes their financial and employment status. 

When Catherine was admitted to the North Manchester General Hospital,on August 23rd 2xxx, she was already suffering from dementia, recognised by her GP and by the North Manchester General Hospital (NMGH) in the summer of 2xxx. Despite many warnings, the most recent given at the hospital’s Patients Liasion Services office (PALS) on August 22nd 2xxx, NMGH staff failed to contact Jane who was, after Catherine’s husband, William, Catherine’s nearest relative. Catherine and William’s eldest child was also identified as ‘next of kin’ in Catherine’s NHS records. In the UK, the term ‘next of kin’ is not a legal definition. Instead of contacting Jane , staff at the North Manchester General Hospital liaised with Sibling 3, who lived near the hospital.


In her safeguarding referrals, Jane stated that Sibling 3 presented a serious risk to William and especially to Catherine. Aspects of Sibling 3’s lifestyle were recognised by community workers and by friends of William and Catherine. Presenting soft evidence of serious matters is difficult. For legal reasons, many whistleblowers cannot access compelling evidence immediately, including financial evidence. Applicants for fostering children are subject to stringent vetting and barring. So are candidates for any paid employment giving access to vulnerable people and volunteers who will be working with vulnerable people.

Action on Elder Abuse  is familiar with similar circumstances in which a vulnerable older person has been discharged into the care of a person presenting a known risk.  Documented in Catherine’s NHS records the misrepresentation of her personal, medical and career history  was comprehensive. All NHS records cited were released to Jane  after a prolonged application period.   To obtain these records, MP support was essential. Many of Catherine’s records are heavily redacted, some pages being more black than white.

Extensive misrepresentation was achieved in the city where Catherine and William were born and lived for most of their very long lives, just over a mile away from the house where they had lived for nearly sixty years and the  school where Catherine had been headteacher.  Crucial medical history, including Catherine’s history of heart valve disease from the age of seven was ‘misrepresented’.  William’s blindness was not acknowledged, access to essential medical care for Catherine was obstructed for over a year, including mental health care.  NHS staff complied with third party directions concerning access to a newly discharged patient, suffering from dementia, cardiovascular disease and chronic breathing problems, usually identified as Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD)/asthma.  Catherine had never smoked.  Misrepresentation of core personal history facilitated the exclusion of the eldest of their children,  who was, after each other, nearest relative to both parents.  Next of kin identification was then changed, without any consultation. In Catherine’s NHS and local authority records, Jane ’s home address and landline number are given correctly.   There is no mobile signal in the area where Jane  lives. 

Subsequently, the alternating use of GP practices, including for key events only a day apart, further compromised the provision of appropriate medical care.  The first practice is marginally closer to the address to which Catherine and William were removed.  Both the North Manchester General Hospital and the Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust  ( MMH/SCT)  Care Centre sent letters concerning Catherine’s care and treatment including prescribed medication to alternating practices.  Monitoring of the cognitive enhancing, antipsychotic and antidepressant medications prescribed for Catherine was unlikely to be accurate. The use of both practices cannot be explained by public holidays.  While all access to Catherine and William was controlled by Sibling 3, their joint assets were being used to finance the construction of a property over 160 miles away. Permanent funded care for Catherine had been authorised in Manchester.  This placement appears to be based on the diagnosis of a mental health condition in the CC12 cluster.  Manchester City Council/  Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust, 23rd April 2xxx and 9th December 2xxx.  Despite this authorisation, and Catherine’s identification as presenting a risk to her husband, to herself and to others, the authorised placement and treatment did not proceed.  Instead, there was a succession of lengthy placements in respite care, and for twenty-four days inpatient care at the NMGH, although hospital records identify  Catherine as medically fit for discharge on the second day after admission. Prolonged periods in hospital damage people suffering from dementia.   

The need for a financial review is indicated in Catherine’s records.   No financial review had been undertaken.  Following the Care Cluster 12 request, Manchester City Council’s panel authorised Catherine’s placement in permanent care. In the case of a diagnosed mental health condition, in which Catherine is reported as representing  ‘a danger to her husband, to herself and to others’ such essential mental health  care would be funded.   

According to Catherine’s social worker’s  Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust report, when Catherine was placed in care, usually but not always at White Moss,  Blackley, she ‘seemed to behave quite differently with strangers’ and was able to be more articulate with them.’ 
 No explanation for the observed  and very marked difference in behaviour is offered.  Recognising Catherine’s severe weight loss, NHS Mental Health professionals accepted claims  of suspected bulimia or laxative abuse.  Force-feeding with liquidised sandwiches was  accepted  by Manchester City Council as  an ‘ imaginative response’ to Catherine’s reported refusal to eat.   Force-feeding of anybody is torture, used in military prisons operated by some states,   When a community psychiatric nurse (CPN) asked to see  Catherine  given something  to eat, Sibling 3 apparently expressed surprise when Catherine ate.   The misuse of alcohol in conjunction  withCatherine’s six medications, including  an antipsychotic and antidepressant  is documented in Catherine’s NHS records.  After  Catherine was given 40% alcohol,  further financial abuse was attempted at a care home.  The care home manager and staff  reported  this serious incident to NHS Mental Health and Social Services.  No action was taken.

The existence  and ownership of Catherine and William’s house in Blackley was not acknowledged by Sibling 3.   Locks on this property were changed, but all Catherine and William’s correspondence, including bank statements, cards and PIN numbers was still delivered to this address. Discharging vulnerable adults suffering from dementia, heart disease and chronic breathing difficulties into the care of a person identified  in safeguarding referrals as presenting a serious risk to  William and Catherine, and especially Catherine,  an NHS Trust enabled that person to control every aspect of their lives and prevent essential mental and general health care.  Authorising Catherine’s placements away from her own house and away from her husband, the local authority should have been safeguarding Catherine’s property.

Released to Jane , on Catherine’s behalf, on August 25th 2011 and September 13th 2011, many of Catherine’s NHS records are heavily redacted, some pages being more black than white.  When Jane  applied for William’s opthalmology records in 2013, providing his NHS number  Manchester Royal Eye Hospital number and the name of his consultant, Central Manchester University Hospitals confirmed that the records were available. Five months later, on October 9th 2013, the CMUHT claimed that the records ‘had probably been destroyed’  Jane  contacted her MP’s office immediately.   William’s  Manchester Royal Eye Hospital records were released  two weeks later. . Some key data was missing.  Further records were released in 2014 and 2016, in response to Freedom of Information requests.

Mentally and physically, the misrepresentation of medical histories had serious consequences, damaging the medical care and personal wellbeing of two frail and vulnerable older people.   NHS adult safeguarding protocols were disregarded.   Social Services safeguarding protocols were also disregarded.  This was acknowledged  in Manchester’s response to the Local Government Ombudsman.  No action  was taken. 

The NHS records include many references to communications problems, usually, when  hospital or other staff  were attempting to contact Sibling 3.   Jane, Catherine and William’s eldest child, nearest relative to both  parents  after each other, did not live in Manchester.  Jane  tried to keep lines of communication open, providing her home address, mobile and landline numbers, and email address. .  Contacted by phone, email or letter, she tried to respond promptly.   One CPN in the Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust  appears to have recognised the  problems  faced by anybody when an obviously frail parent or other older relative refuses care.  The same CPN tried again when a call had been missed   Jane  contacted the CPN  arranging to take a call during a family holiday.   The same  nurse invited  Jane  to contact her again if she had further concerns.  Reporting extensive ongoing abuse, and giving the address of the property in Wales supposedly commissioned by 98 year old William.  Jane  reported her very serious concerns to this CPN. Jane’s report of ongoing human rights abuses and extensive financial abuse was reported to the most senior mental health professional, a consultant old age psychiatrist. The consultant directed that the letter reporting ongoing abuse, including the misuse of over £160,000 belongong to William and Catherine  should be copied by email to the Social Services care manager.   This was done. No action was taken.


NHS Choices signs of family abuse.

What are the signs of Family Abuse?

Where abuse is intentional it is likely that the following signs will be apparent:

I. The older person may not be allowed to speak for themselves, or see others, without the presence of the family member (suspected abuser) being present

II. They may display attitudes of indifference or anger toward the older person, or the obvious absence of assistance

III.  A family member may blame the elder person (e.g. accusation that incontinence is a deliberate act)

IV. They may display aggressive behaviour (threats, insults, harassment) toward the older person

V. They may have a previous history of abuse of others

VI. They may display inappropriate affection toward the older person

VII. They may display flirtatious behaviour, or coyness, etc that might be possible indicators of inappropriate sexual relationships

VIII. They may create social isolation of the family, or isolation or restriction of activity of the older person

IX. There may be conflicting accounts of incidents by family, supporters, or the older person

X. They may display inappropriate or unwarranted defensiveness

XI. There may be indications of unusual confinement (closed off in a room; tied to furniture; change in routine activity)

XII. There may be the obvious absence of assistance, or attendance