2 A Pathway Created...

Social Services and NHS Mental Health closed the case.
Meetings with Alzheimer’s UK. 
Formal  Safeguarding  Vulnerable Adults letter, February  18th 2xxx
Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust.
Manchester, Director of Social Services.    
Sibling 3’s  brain tumour history cited and ‘other serious health problems’
No action taken
Debt  repayments to a financial  institution transferred to William and Catherine’s joint account
GP arranged home visit by psychiatrist, Catherine and William agreed
Catherine self-referring to A & E
Friends alerted Jane , train & car to NMGH. 
Sibling 3 present, left at once.
Further tests for Catherine identified calcified hyperexpanded small heart. , .
Further warning given at PALS office.
Catherine self referred again next day. General Hospital  liaised with Sibling 3.
Irregular conduct of Sibling 3  at the NMGH,
Catherine’s prolonged in-patient stay, 21 days after medically fit for discharge.
NMGH accepting Sibling 3 as self identified ‘ carer. No contact with Jane
Home visit from consultant old age psychiatrist missed, because of unnecessary inpatient stay.
Discharged to Sibling 3.
Post discharge mental health care rejected by Sibling 3.
Jane , nearest relative, no contact with Catherine and William for 18 months+.


Recognising that Social Services, Adult Social Care and NHS Mental Health responses to serious adult safeguarding referrals were dangerously inadequate, Jane  consulted Age Concern (Age UK), Alzheimer’s UK and Citizens’ Advice again. In warning referrals, reporting ‘soft evidence’ is difficult.  In meetings with Jane , guiding the preparation of a formal Frail and Vulnerable Adults referral letter to Manchester’s Director of Social Services, and to the NHS Mental Health authority, Alzheimer’s staff in her local town advised that Sibling 3’s indisputable medical history should be cited.  Sibling 3 had had nine hours of surgery for a brain tumour.  Reporting the exact nature of other serious but unproven concerns could be problematic.  Such concerns might include matters of law.
Staff at the Alzheimer’s UK office in Jane’s town indicated that focusing on the indisputable brain tumour surgery was important,given the medically documented possibility of personality changes.  Including a reference to ‘other serious health problems’ should alert  NHS adult safeguarding staff to significant risks. 
Hard evidence, in the form of bank statements, was not yet available, nor would it become available until the summer of 2xxx– that is, after  extensive financial abuse had already taken place. 
One basic safeguarding move  might include screening for  any legal recovery of debts.   Other known risks are identified in NHS choices, including drug and alcohol addiction.

NHS Choices   Abuse in your own home.

You're more at risk of abuse at home if:
. you're isolated and don't have much contact with friends, family or neighbours
. you have memory problems or difficulty communicating
. you become dependent on your carer
. you don't get on with your carer
. your carer is addicted to drugs or alcohol
.
Making repeated  referrals is time consuming, persisting in the face of official indifference and rejection is difficult.  Catherine’s mental health continued to deteriorate.  Both the physical risks presented by combined disabilities of William’s blindness and Catherine’s dementia and the external risk from an identified source continued.  Action on Elder Abuse recognises the difficulties of such situations. Few, if any concerned relatives and friends can mount a permanent guard on a vulnerable older person.  Nor can such people insist and ensure that they are contacted in any emergency, even when all contact details are documented in NHS and Social Services records.  Jane  was the nearest relative, and in April 2xxx, would be identified by Catherine as the poerson whom she wished to make all decisions for her. 1  In some families, a vulnerable adult’s nearest relative might live on the other side of the world.  Effective safeguarding should and must be the responsibility of the public authority staff who are trained and paid to undertake this work on behalf of all of us.

Catherine and William paid a cleaner who came to the house once a week. This lady was one of the many people who talked to Jane  to express their concerns about the risks presented by Sibling 3, especially towards Catherine.   Continuing to report concerns, Jane  was told by Social Services that there was ‘a carer’.  Knowing that serious concerns regarding Sibling 3 were well founded, and that the ‘private care’ claimed by Catherine meant the weekly cleaner, who recognised problems  presented by Sibling 3, Jane  warned Social Services that her retired headteacher mother was likely to sound authoritative .  Neither Catherine, nor William, nor their own parents had spoken with a local accent.  Five minutes later, and often sooner, Catherine would repeat the same statement. Several mental health records refer to the constant repetition.  2   Anybody who has experience of the endless repetition of this stage of dementia will know how demanding and even infuriating this can be for anyone trying to offer support and understanding. Most people do recognise that constant and exasperating repetition is a symptom of a distressing illness, do their best to offer support and care.  Recognising that someone  suffering from dementia has become ‘stuck’ in a sequence of repetition, it’s often possible to re-direct the conversation. 2

On February  7th  2xxx, William had another  ischaemic attack and was admitted to the North Manchester General Hospital.  On February 8th 2xxx, Frank, Catherine’s youngest brother was killed in a road traffic accident. 3  Catherine was heartbroken. More than fifteen years older  than Frank, she had been his first teacher at primary school.  She rang Jane  repeatedly to tell her of Frank’s death.  Jane  went to Manchester immediately.  Visiting her mother first, Jane  found her alone, facing the grief of sudden bereavement and renewed fears for William’s health.  At the hospital, William expressed his own concerns for Catherine.  Knowing that Frank had been killed, he wanted to be with his wife.  Despite the latest TIA, he still appeared to be  mentally sound.  Conditions in the ward were difficult.  When the patient in the next bed vomited violently,  visible particles of vomit landed close to William’s bed.  Airborne particles would be too small to see.  Fortunately, neither William nor Jane became ill.  A CT scan had been booked, but William did not wish to stay.  Apart from the unacceptable conditions on the ward, he needed to be with his wife, supporting her in grief, and also, as he explained to Jane , because it wasn’t safe for her to be alone with Sibling 3.  At this point, William was still well enough to recognise the risk to Catherine, and to speak candidly about this to his eldest daughter.  Jane went to the ward office to speak to the ward manager, explaining that William wanted to be with his  wife, as she faced sudden bereavement.  The manager said William could not leave.
Jane  reasoned that at 95, William’s priorities were different. His place now was with  his wife. William was grieving too.  Nearly 26 years older, he had known Frank as Catherine’s frail infant brother.  It was acknowledged that the discharge was against medical advice.  Jane  and William returned to the house in Blackley by taxi.  At 95, William could have suffered a fatal stroke at any time.  Three days later, the North Manchester General Hospital was identified as one of the three worst hospitals in the country.  On January 24th, the local MP had spoken in parliament about the problems in North Manchester. 4

Jane  consulted Alzheimer’s UK.  Staff at the Alzheimer’s office in her local town recognised the gravity of the situation, including the risks presented by someone  with  Sibling 3’s medical, financial and lifestyle history.   Delivering an effective referral, without making potentially unfounded  or unprovable allegations would be difficult.  Two meetings were arranged.  During the first meeting, the circumstances were discussed and analysed, including the responses from NHS Mental Health and Social Services.  At the second meeting, the next safeguarding action was considered.  As referrals to Catherine and William’s local Adult Social Care offices had been repeatedly dismissed, and the case closed, Alzheimer’s staff recommended  that Jane should send the formal Frail and Vulnerable Adults letter to the Director of Social Services, by first class next day delivery, and to send the same letter to NHS Mental Health, at the Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust

The letter was prepared and  posted as Alzheimer’s staff had advised  on February 18th  2. Jane warned Manchester Social Services that they would be failing in their duty of care towards Catherine and William if no action was taken.  The letter was simply forwarded  by the Director’s office to the  North Manchester offices in Harpurhey which had closed the case.  Manchester’s Adult Social Care staff responded to Jane ’s most formal referral concerning her parents  to tell her that Sibling 4 was ‘having a party for them’ . Sibling 4, who lived in  South America,  was making a short visit to the UK and the ‘party’ was to celebrate Catherine and William’s Diamond wedding.  The ‘party’ was to be held at the house of Sibling 3.  Jane  did not attend this ‘party’ for medical reasons.  When Jane was ten,  a  recurring medical problem was diagnosed by her GP as angioedema, then known as angio-neurotic oedema.  ( HAE) This was confirmed at a children’s hospital.  5   On February 19th, Jane  was affected by airways swelling.   Following  this  and other  angio-oedema episodes, Jane’s immunologist  urged  that stressful events should be avoided. 6

Family visits to Manchester continued and Jane  also visited on her own.  On August 22nd 2xxx,  getting no response from her parents.  Jane  travelled to Manchester by train.   Their house was deserted.  A family friend, Mrs C, suggested checking the NMGH. The hospital reported that Catherine was in A & E.  Mrs C’s  daughter, who is a GP, drove Jane  to the hospital.   Sibling 3 was present when they arrived.  Seeing Jane , she said, ‘ You must be psychic’, and left immediately.   Immediately concerned, Jane  identified herself  to staff as her parents’ eldest daughter.  For the second time in ten days, Catherine had self referred to the hospital, reporting breathing difficulties.  The A & E department appeared to be very crowded.   Catherine’s NHS records state that she had arrived at  10.46 a.m. 7
The doctor examining Catherine was attempting to guide her in the use of equipment to alleviate her breathing problem –‘ As if you are smoking a cigarette’ Jane  explained that her mother had never smoked and did not know how to inhale.  A diagnosis of COPD in a lifelong non-smoker prompts questions.  8 The doctor responded to this information, which was considered in conjunction with Catherine’s almost lifelong heart damage, caused by the attack of rheumatic fever when she was seven, 9

Taking blood tests was difficult.  Catherine had always been afraid of injections of any kind, a fear possibly associated with the extensive scarring left by smallpox and TB immunisations.  Speaking to Jane  and  gently reassuring Catherine, the doctor discussed Catherine’s fear of needles and explained why she was requesting a chest X-ray.  The full report of this A & E consultation and the results of tests undertaken  are in Catherine’s  NHS records. 9  Jane  did not see the results of these tests, including the X-ray analysis, until the end of August 2011.  The condition of Catherine’s heart, may indicate other reasons for Catherine’s frequent breathing crises. 10
While at the hospital and waiting for her mother’s formal discharge, Jane  went to the Patient Advice and Liaison Service office (PALS) to give a further verbal warning regarding the safety of Catherine and William, and the risks to both which were presented by Sibling 3.   
.  
When Catherine was discharged, Jane  took her parents to their own home by taxi, and rang their GP practice to notify them regarding the tests undertaken and same day discharge. Jane  then returned by train to her home in Cumbria.  She has lived at the same address since November 1985, with the same landline number.   Jane  had explained, on may occasions, that there was no mobile signal in this area of the Lake District. (There is still no signal.)   Jane  did not see  either of her parents again  for  over eighteen months, when Sibling 2 notified her that Catherine was in a local authority care home.  Sibling 2 was always aware  of Catherine’s placements in care.  Jane  was never given any information .  Both NHS  and Social Services staff would claim to be unaware of her existence. When proof of her relationship to her parents was required by NHS Trust Governance, Action on Elder Abuse advised how this can be demonstrated effectively.  Jane ’s NHS records from birth to eighteen, when she left for university would confirm her location and GP care throughout this period. 

Despite the serious warning given at the PALS office on August 22nd, when Catherine self referred again the next day, Jane was not contacted, although she was identified as ‘next of kin’  in her mother’s NHS records until December 6th 2xxx. She was not contacted by the NMGH when  William was admitted to the hospital in September 2xxx.

On August 23rd 2xxx, Catherine  had self referred  once  again to the  NMGH with breathing difficulties.   This time, she was admitted. Sibling 3, identified in all  Jane’s safeguarding referrals as presenting a serious risk,  became the NMGH’s only source of information concerning Catherine and William,,  although the hospital had correct records  of their exiting medical histories.   One adverse event  would have very serious consequences for Catherine and William. An  NHS hospital failed to contact  a vulnerable adult’s actual nearest relative and named next of kin, who had made all safeguarding referrals. The Hospital  liaised instead  with the person  identified in these referrals.  Failing to respond appropriately to safeguarding referrals enabled that person to assume complete control over every aspect of Catherine and William’s lives.  Catherine would spend over  three weeks as an  in-patient. Medically fit for discharge, she could have gone home the next day, and kept her appointment with the consultant old age psychiatrist.   The cost to the NHS of unnecessary inpatient time is indefensible. So is the cost of missed appointments, though Catherine herself had no means of keeping the appointment.

The day after Catherine’s admission to the NMGH, her records include an account of Sibling 3’s irregular conduct at the hospital. At 11.50 on August 24th, ie, not during visiting hours, Sibling 3 came to visit Catherine with William.  After five minutes, she left William there, in a wheelchair, having claimed to be a ‘full time lecturer’ .11  Two days previously,  when Jane  was at the NMGH with her parents, William was not a wheelchair user, walking beside Jane and holding doors open for her when  they were bringing Catherine back from X-ray.  Ward staff explained that it was not visiting time, but Sibling 3 left.   The Trust didn’t introduce open visiting until  2016.  At lunch time, Catherine asked for a meal for William, as Sibling 3 wouldn’t be collecting him until 18.00     Staff failed to contact Sibling 3 on the ‘ work’ number, but did manage to contact her.  Sibling 3  came to collect William. 
According to Catherine’s   NMGH records, she was ‘ Not found to be particularly SOB objectively.’ She was identified as ‘medically fit for discharge’  12 .  NMGH records document the action which would have very serious consequences.

In view of memory loss and re-attendances, social services input please,  (unless daughter ( redacted) happy to look after’ )

 Unless daughter happy to look after ?

In brackets, apparently casual and inconsidered, this phrase created the pathway for Catherine’s discharge into the care of the daughter identified in all safeguarding referrals as presenting a serious risk to both Catherine and William, The risk to Catherine would be greatest.

No investigation of ‘the daughter’ was undertaken, no references, no questions regarding her supposed  full time employment, her financial position, suitability as a carer for vulnerable adults with complex needs, no vetting and barring, no observation of her relationship with her parents, and especially  her relationship with Catherine.    Supposedly, being a ‘ daughter; was  all that was required.

In April 2xxx, when the Manchester City Council panel was asked to approve Catherine’s permanent placement in care, local authority staff consulted   Jane ’s Frail and Vulnerable Adults referral of February 18th 2006, , warning that Sibling 3 presented a grave risk to both parents, and especially to Catherine.  At 8.30  on August 24th,  ward staff spoke to Sibling 3.  Claiming to be a ‘ full time lecturer’, Sibling 3 stated that she was not happy for Catherine to come home   and would be having a meeting with Social Services the next day.   Jane had very different information regarding Sibling 3’s  occupational status.  NMGH ward staff had already observed irregular conduct on the part of Sibling 3.  According to  Catherine’s NMGH records for this admission, , Sibling 3 visited William and Catherine 2 or 3 times day.   The claim is not consistent with claims made regarding full time employment.  Sibling 3 did not drive or cycle, and the walking distance between her house and that of her parents is 25 minutes each way.   

Catherine would remain a patient at the NMGH until September 12th.  Neither the NMGH nor Social Services contacted Jane .  Catherine’s NHS  records also include Sibling 3’s failure to respond to repeated phone calls and letters from  Community Psychiatric Nurses  seeking to provide post discharge mental health support for Catherine. During the unjustifiably prolonged in-patient stay, August 23rd – September 12th, there are several references to Catherine’s dementia.

Released to Jane , on Catherine’s behalf,  in August and September 2011, many of Catherine’s records are heavily redacted, some pages being more black than white. Information presented in records for August 2xxx –  January 2xxx is analysed in Chapter 3, Behind Closed Doors and Chapter 4, A Broken Trust. All NHS records cited from three NHS Trusts were released after a prolonged application period. MP support  became essential.
In 2000, the Department of Health published An Organisation with a Memory, Report of an expert group on learning from adverse events  in the NHS.   Most of the examples cited in this report concern clinical accidents, the result, not of individual malpractice, but almost invariably, a sequence of events , contributing to the serious and sometimes fatal outcome for patients.  One of the cases examined concerns a fatal accident,  leading to the death of a child being treated for cancer, when an oncologist had other conflicting commitments.  Poor practice is identified –  that of expecting the oncologist to be in two places at the same time.  The wrong drug was injected into the patient’s spine.  The child died five days later. 13

Like the oncologist in this fatal incident,  Jane  could not be in two places at once, or three, or four.  As is in many other families, she had other commitments, including essential support for older and younger family members.  Keeping patients like William and Catherine safe, in the area where they lived, was the immediate responsibility of NHS and Social Services.  Both had full contact details for Jane .  Both had received  safeguarding referrals. Both were involved in discharging Catherine into the care of the person identified  as presenting a risk to both  William and Catherine. Jane had specified, accurately, that Catherine was at greatest risk.

Responding to Jane’s complaints about serious failings in her mother care, NHS staff in Manchester claimed that there is no evidence that Jane  made an attempt to ‘engage’ in her parents’ care throughout this period.  The PHSO accepted these claims, and endorsed Mental Health and Social Care Trust statements to the effect that Jane  had ceased to be her parents’ ‘nearest relative’ , as they were now ‘ residing’ with Sibling 3. The Mental Health Act is cited. The nearest relative cannot be arbitrarily excluded  from the care and support of a person suffering from mental illness because an NHS Trust has ignored referrals warning that a vulnerable older person is at risk. The Mental Health Act does not endorse the de facto kidnapping of vulnerable people , or any form of abuse, including the denial of mental health care.

1 16/04/2xxx, consultant to GP. MMH/ SCT
2 www.whentheygetolder.co.uk/how-do-i-cope-with-constant-repetitive-questions
3 Crash couple outrage - Manchester Evening News https://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk
4   Graham Stringer, Manchester Blackley,     ‘ North Manchester has some of the worst health statistics in the country.’  24 Jan 2006 : Column 372WH   Hansard, HC
5.   Hereditary angio-edema. ( HAE)   Airways swelling can be  life-threatening
6  2xxx was proving to be a difficult year. Two weeks after  Frank  was killed,  Jane’s mother-in-law suffered a heart attack and was admitted to hospital in Carlisle.  Not affected by dementia,and a former teacher herself,  she had tried to  encourage Catherine and William to accept support.
7 22/08/2xxx NMGH
8 Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: missed diagnosis ... - The BMJ
 www.bmj.com/bmj/section-pdf/900352?path=/bmj/351/8015/Analysis.full.pdf
9  Heart Views. 2016 Jul-Sep; 17(3): 120–126. doi:  10.4103/1995-705X.192572 PMCID: PMC5105226 Rheumatic Fever and Rheumatic Heart Disease a Historical Perspective   Rachel Hajar, M.D.   One of the dreaded infections that were modified by penicillin was streptococcal pharyngitis (rheumatic fever [RF]), which had a high mortality rate.
9  22/08/2006.  NMGH
10  Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease:  ibid
11  24/08/2xxx  NMGH
12  24/08/2xxx.  Catherine  would have been discharged, but for the fact that this was the third referral since 11th August.   NMGH records document the action which would have very serious consequences.
13  An Organisation with a Memory, Chapter Three.  Learning from failure 3:16.