Acting on Elder Abuse, Keeping Patients Safe
Safeguarding Failures of NHS Trusts, Social Services, the Police and other public authorities in Manchester.
Serious Case Review.
First Report
‘There can be no secrets and no hiding place when it comes to exposing the abuse of vulnerable adults.’
‘ No Secrets’ Department of Health, 2000
* All names have been changed.
All the events documented in this first report took place in the
first and second decades of the 21st century.
1. Blindness, Dementia, Hearing Impairment.
Sensory loss and enhanced vulnerability. Safeguarding referrals made by phone, by letter, by email and at a meeting with a GP. Warnings regarding the risks presented by a family member. Alcohol misused to ‘ manage’ dementia. Local authority assessment included many errors. Case closed by Social Services and NHS Mental Health Advice and support from Citizens’ Advice, Age UK Alzheimer’s UK and Action on Elder Abuse Formal Frail and Vulnerable Adults referral to Director of Social Services and NHS Mental Health No action taken.
2 A Pathway Created…
GP arranged home visit by consultant old age psychiatrist
One day after a further warning was given at the Patient Advice and Liasion Service office of the North Manchester General Hospital the hospital cliaised with the person identified as presenting a serious risk, Removed from own property, existence of this property not acknowledged.
3 Behind Closed Doors…
Access controlled, Human Rights Abuses. Deprivation of Liberty. Mental and general health care prevented. No vetting and barring of carers, no financial review. Locks on their own house changed. Financial and all other correspondence delivered to this address. Existence of own property not acknowledged by self-identified ‘ carer’ .
4 A Broken Trust…
One Patient. Two NHS Trusts, Two GP Practices, Two Histories
Sibling 3 ‘ Always well and active until May/June 2xxx, accepted by NHS Mental Health and Social Services. NHS documented history included :
aortic and mitral valve damage, caused by rheumatic fever at age seven.
Dementia, believed to be vascular, diagnosed by her GP before 21st June 2xxx.
Breathing problems from childhood. NHS records as COPD/asthma.Never smoked.
Care Cluster 12 psychosis identified.
Permanent and funded placement in care applied for by Social Services and granted
by the Manchester City Council panel
Rejected by Sibling 3 after a financial review was required.
Instead, serial ‘ respite care’ March, April, July August, October, November,
Use of two GP practices begins.
24 days in hospital, 22 days after ‘ medically fit for discharge’
In care, Catherine reported ongoing financial abuse to Jane
5 Serious Negative Outcomes
Use of two GP practices continues. Financial and legal activity ongoing, property construction continues. Police reject ‘ unfounded allegations’ .
Letters from NHS Trust psychiatrist to both practices on successive days.
Diagnosis of psychotic depression. CPN staff and Social Services accept claims of bulimia/laxative abuse for continuing weight loss. Placement in permanent care. Next day, collapse, slow heart, renal impairment, fits. Catherine reports emotional and psychological abuse, Consultant and care manager had received letter re ongoing human rights and financial abuse. Sibling 2 forwards email documenting six-figure abuse. Reported to Social Services by Jane . No action
6 A long meeting…
Extensive financial, physical and other abuses reported , a detailed statement given, signed and witnessed by a senior care manager and a social worker.
Physical and attempted financial abuse by Sibling 3 at a care home.
Reported to Social Services by care staff. No action taken.
MP challenged the lack of action following Jane’s statement reporting ongoing abuse.
Manchester City Council . Social Services Director response to MP
‘ The two officers have no recollection such encounter’
Denial accepted by General Social Care Council and Health Care Professions Council
Meeting when abuse was reported documented in Catherine’s NHS Mental Health records.
GMP request access to William’s NHS records.
7. ‘ The abuse continues here’
Physical, financial and other abuses continue in care. Reports to Social Services entered in NHS Mental Health records. No action taken. Capacity ruling by consultant. Solicitor didn’t accept consultant’s capacity ruling. Social worker gave Lasting Power of Attorney documents to Sibling 2. Unannounced visits to care home continued. Soiling incidents reported. Frequent soiling documented in NHS Mental Health records. Safeguarding and care complaints made to care home management and operating company. Meeting with Catherine’s consultant. Catherine gives her personal and career history correctly. Multiple serious care home failures identified by CQC. Fatal accident to another resident. Care home prosecuted and convicted.
8 Who is it that can tell me who I am ?
Who is this person ? Respect and Support for people with a degenerative brain disease. Effective Safeguarding, operated by the NHS, Social Services and the Police ? Is this achievable ? Dementia diagnosis and formal registration. Verification of all third party claiSibling regarding personal, medical and career histories. Check existing NHS records and GP care. Vetting and barring of all self-identified carers. Monitoring of finances. DoLS to apply in all cases of ‘ family’ or other non-professional care. .
9 An Inspector Calls…
The Police and the Crown Prosecution Service. Investigation into extensive financial and other abuses closed. Police claim a blind 98 year old would have been able to read, citing an opthalmology ratio confirming blindness. The police officer did not understand the significance of the number. CEO of the Trust acknowledges that data provided by a trainee registrar to a constable signifies ‘ severely sight impaired/blind – this cannot be disputed.’ Trust disclaims responsibility for Police interpretaion of medical data. Police dismiss NHS records of dementia and blindness as ‘ irrelevant’
10 Quis Custodiet ?
Questions for Patient Advice and Liasion, NHS England , the Department of Health, Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman, the Local Government Ombudsman, the Information Commissioner’s Office, Independent Office for Police Conduct the Health Care Professionals Council, the Office of the Public Guardian, the Court of Protection
Serious Case Review.
First Report
‘There can be no secrets and no hiding place when it comes to exposing the abuse of vulnerable adults.’
‘ No Secrets’ Department of Health, 2000
* All names have been changed.
All the events documented in this first report took place in the
first and second decades of the 21st century.
1. Blindness, Dementia, Hearing Impairment.
Sensory loss and enhanced vulnerability. Safeguarding referrals made by phone, by letter, by email and at a meeting with a GP. Warnings regarding the risks presented by a family member. Alcohol misused to ‘ manage’ dementia. Local authority assessment included many errors. Case closed by Social Services and NHS Mental Health Advice and support from Citizens’ Advice, Age UK Alzheimer’s UK and Action on Elder Abuse Formal Frail and Vulnerable Adults referral to Director of Social Services and NHS Mental Health No action taken.
2 A Pathway Created…
GP arranged home visit by consultant old age psychiatrist
One day after a further warning was given at the Patient Advice and Liasion Service office of the North Manchester General Hospital the hospital cliaised with the person identified as presenting a serious risk, Removed from own property, existence of this property not acknowledged.
3 Behind Closed Doors…
Access controlled, Human Rights Abuses. Deprivation of Liberty. Mental and general health care prevented. No vetting and barring of carers, no financial review. Locks on their own house changed. Financial and all other correspondence delivered to this address. Existence of own property not acknowledged by self-identified ‘ carer’ .
4 A Broken Trust…
One Patient. Two NHS Trusts, Two GP Practices, Two Histories
Sibling 3 ‘ Always well and active until May/June 2xxx, accepted by NHS Mental Health and Social Services. NHS documented history included :
aortic and mitral valve damage, caused by rheumatic fever at age seven.
Dementia, believed to be vascular, diagnosed by her GP before 21st June 2xxx.
Breathing problems from childhood. NHS records as COPD/asthma.Never smoked.
Care Cluster 12 psychosis identified.
Permanent and funded placement in care applied for by Social Services and granted
by the Manchester City Council panel
Rejected by Sibling 3 after a financial review was required.
Instead, serial ‘ respite care’ March, April, July August, October, November,
Use of two GP practices begins.
24 days in hospital, 22 days after ‘ medically fit for discharge’
In care, Catherine reported ongoing financial abuse to Jane
5 Serious Negative Outcomes
Use of two GP practices continues. Financial and legal activity ongoing, property construction continues. Police reject ‘ unfounded allegations’ .
Letters from NHS Trust psychiatrist to both practices on successive days.
Diagnosis of psychotic depression. CPN staff and Social Services accept claims of bulimia/laxative abuse for continuing weight loss. Placement in permanent care. Next day, collapse, slow heart, renal impairment, fits. Catherine reports emotional and psychological abuse, Consultant and care manager had received letter re ongoing human rights and financial abuse. Sibling 2 forwards email documenting six-figure abuse. Reported to Social Services by Jane . No action
6 A long meeting…
Extensive financial, physical and other abuses reported , a detailed statement given, signed and witnessed by a senior care manager and a social worker.
Physical and attempted financial abuse by Sibling 3 at a care home.
Reported to Social Services by care staff. No action taken.
MP challenged the lack of action following Jane’s statement reporting ongoing abuse.
Manchester City Council . Social Services Director response to MP
‘ The two officers have no recollection such encounter’
Denial accepted by General Social Care Council and Health Care Professions Council
Meeting when abuse was reported documented in Catherine’s NHS Mental Health records.
GMP request access to William’s NHS records.
7. ‘ The abuse continues here’
Physical, financial and other abuses continue in care. Reports to Social Services entered in NHS Mental Health records. No action taken. Capacity ruling by consultant. Solicitor didn’t accept consultant’s capacity ruling. Social worker gave Lasting Power of Attorney documents to Sibling 2. Unannounced visits to care home continued. Soiling incidents reported. Frequent soiling documented in NHS Mental Health records. Safeguarding and care complaints made to care home management and operating company. Meeting with Catherine’s consultant. Catherine gives her personal and career history correctly. Multiple serious care home failures identified by CQC. Fatal accident to another resident. Care home prosecuted and convicted.
8 Who is it that can tell me who I am ?
Who is this person ? Respect and Support for people with a degenerative brain disease. Effective Safeguarding, operated by the NHS, Social Services and the Police ? Is this achievable ? Dementia diagnosis and formal registration. Verification of all third party claiSibling regarding personal, medical and career histories. Check existing NHS records and GP care. Vetting and barring of all self-identified carers. Monitoring of finances. DoLS to apply in all cases of ‘ family’ or other non-professional care. .
9 An Inspector Calls…
The Police and the Crown Prosecution Service. Investigation into extensive financial and other abuses closed. Police claim a blind 98 year old would have been able to read, citing an opthalmology ratio confirming blindness. The police officer did not understand the significance of the number. CEO of the Trust acknowledges that data provided by a trainee registrar to a constable signifies ‘ severely sight impaired/blind – this cannot be disputed.’ Trust disclaims responsibility for Police interpretaion of medical data. Police dismiss NHS records of dementia and blindness as ‘ irrelevant’
10 Quis Custodiet ?
Questions for Patient Advice and Liasion, NHS England , the Department of Health, Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman, the Local Government Ombudsman, the Information Commissioner’s Office, Independent Office for Police Conduct the Health Care Professionals Council, the Office of the Public Guardian, the Court of Protection