1. Blindness, Dementia, Hearing Impairment

Sensory loss, dementia and enhanced vulnerability.  Safeguarding referrals made by phone, by letter, by email and in a meeting with their GP.  Advice was obtained from Action on Elder Abuse, Age UK, Alzheimer’s UK, Citizen’s Advice, the Office of the Public Guardian and the Royal National Institute for the Blind (RNIB) .

Background of William and Catherine
Catherine’s 40 year career. Teacher, Deputy & Headteacher
Rheumatic fever, aged seven. Aortic and mitral valve damage.
Chronic breathing problems, usually defined as COPD/asthma (never smoked)
Dementia recognised by GP and NMGH, June and July 2xxx.
William, tailoring. Serious injury to right arm. Early retirement.
Visual Impairment, Low Vision Clinic
Blindness recognised by consultant opthalmologist,  January 1997
Registered, BD8 1990 cert, Card & white stick, M/cr City Council, October 1998 
2xxx  First will. Bequests to 4 children, 7 grandchildren.
28th September 2xxx, Catherine confused, M &S  arrange transport home
First  safeguarding referrals made  by  Jane
Sibling 3’s property in Wales  had been repossessed. Debt proceedings.
Brain tumour surgery. Lifestyle concerns  known in the community.
Church community worker contacted Jane re Sibling 3
Sibling 3 using whisky to ‘manage’ Catherine.
Catherine’s July 2xxx self-referral,  A&E consultation,
Catherine acknowledges recent 'excessive drinking.'
Jane ’s referrals regarding alcohol abuse,
Community Mental Health Team  visited, saw whisky bottles.
Sibling 3 claimed whisky no longer bought.
Claim accepted by Mental Health Team. .
Hospital letter not sent to GP for seven weeks.
Social Services and NHS Mental Health had already closed case
‘ No role for us’ - blind 95 year old and  85 year old wife, diagnosed with dementia.

Registered and christened as Mary Catherine, Catherine was known from birth by her second given name.  Born on December 16th 1920, to Ann and her husband George, Catherine  was the eldest of her parents’ seven surviving children.  The seventh child,  Mary,  died soon after birth. Fourteen  when the baby died, Catherine never forgot this sister’s existence.  Only four when Mary was born, Catherine’s second sister, Celia, remembered that their mother came home from hospital in a taxi, and the baby sister she never knew was christened ‘ Mary’. Though premature, the eighth sibling survived, Catherine’s youngest brother, Francis, known as Frank.

In  a review of safeguarding failures by NHS Trusts and other public authorities, why  dwell on the name and short life of a baby girl who died soon after her hurried baptism ?  Mary’s existence and her place in Catherine’s personal history is important.  NHS Mental Health records refer, often, to Catherine’s detailed memory of her past.  Suffering from dementia and struggling to retain a sense of self, Catherine knew that she was not Mary, the name so frequently used by NHS mental health professionals, Adult Social Care and some care home staff. A Community Psychiatric Nurse (CPN) assigned to Catherine’s mental health care from December 2xxx until September 1st the following year  always referred to her client as ‘Mary’.  Evidently the nurse had learned very little about her patient. 1  Staff at one care home entered a report that ‘Mary likes to be called Catherine’, as if this was an eccentricity.  In the NHS, the practice of addressing service users by their first given name is almost ubiquitous.  Consent to address people by a forename is rarely sought, though for Catherine’s generation, the use of formal titles was normal, even between people who had been friends and colleagues for years.

When Catherine was identified and routinely addressed by NHS and Social Services staff as ‘Mary’, the use of the wrong forename was evidently not corrected.  The person most able to correct this error was Sibling 3, who, as self-identified ‘ carer’, became the source of all information concerning Catherine. For Catherine, the loss of the name which had always been hers and the use of the wrong forename exacerbated the distress of dementia.   NHS Mental Health and Social Services staff could not, of course, be expected to know about an infant death in Catherine’s birth family.

Removed from her home in Blackley, Catherine, married to William for over sixty years, mother of four, retired headteacher, relationship counsellor, dedicated member of a Community Health Council   and homeowner became ‘Mary’, whose assets were minimal.   According to her daughter, ‘Mary’ had always been well and active until  May,  later revised to June 2xxx.2   As ‘ Mary’, Catherine’s entire medical history was misrepresented.    Medication prescribed to  Catherine  while  Sibling 3 was her ' carer' could have been incompatible with   her  pre-existing conditions, including aortic and mitral valve damage.   Supporting a woman in her eighties, who was suffering from dementia, Mental Health staff had incorrect information about Catherine.  One NHS hospital psychiatrist regularly involved in her care reported that she ‘ talked a lot about Blackley, where she had lived as a child. ’ 3  Apart from two years at teacher training college during WWII, Catherine  had lived in this Manchester suburb all her life.  Until her marriage to William, she lived with her parents, her four brothers and two sisters.  After their marriage William and Catherine rented for a year before buying their first home.  Like  many of their generation, they didn’t move.  The house was close to the  school where Catherine taught for forty years, becoming deputy and then headteacher. It was also very close to  the Catholic church  in Blackley where they had married, and attended services regularly. Any psychiatrist prescribing complex medication, including olanzapine and escitalopram  to a woman in her late eighties, with heart valve disease  needed to know more about the patient.  Catherine’s profound anxiety was not simply an aspect of her illness. A major external cause  of anxiety  was not being recognised.


Referring to Blackley as the area where Catherine ‘lived as a child’ the psychiatrist whose patient she became was unknowingly participating in the falsification of Catherine’s entire life. For junior doctors, nurses and social care staff, such participation would be, it must be presumed, through ignorance of the true facts, rather than any deliberate fault, but the ease with which so much was ‘misrepresented’ is a failing on the part of the NHS Trusts and the local authority responsible for safeguarding vulnerable people.


Removed, abruptly, from the house which had been her home since 1947, and the church community which she had known all her life, Catherine believed, with good reason, that she was to be ‘put away’, in a permanent care placement, away from her husband, and rarely allowed to see him.  Furthermore, she believed that serious financial abuse was in progress.  Placed initially in local authority respite care, Catherine reported this to her eldest daughter., from whom she had been separated for over eighteen months.   According to the NHS Choices pages, if a vulnerable adult reports abuse, the person to whom this adult has spoken has several options.

Who to contact if an older person is being abused

If an adult has told you about their situation, you might want to talk to other people who know them to find out if they have similar concerns.

There are also professionals you can contact. You can pass on your concerns to the person's GP and social worker. Local authorities have social workers who deal specifically with cases of abuse and neglect. Call the person's local council and ask for the adult safeguarding co-ordinator.

You can also speak to the police about the situation. Some forms of abuse are crimes, so the police will be interested. If the person is in danger or needs medical attention, call their GP (if known) or emergency services if immediate assistance is required.

Delivering health and social care, people in senior positions bear the greatest responsibility. In any NHS Trust, doctors at every stage of their careers have a duty of care towards their patients. Social workers encounter individuals and their families at some of the most difficult times in life. People who have become vulnerable because they are suffering from dementia need effective safeguarding from the harm which they might suffer as a result of their illness, and from the harm which might be perpetrated by those who abuse the vulnerable. To achieve effective safeguarding, NHS and Social Services staff need to recognise and understand the people for whom they are caring. Appropriate care and support cannot be provided if core information is so easily ‘misrepresented’, sourced from third parties, and not verified. Catherine’s relationship with NHS Mental Health professionals was very seriously compromised when Mental Health and Social Services staff failed to challenge untrue claims made to them by a third party.


Catherine’s heart was damaged by rheumatic fever when she was seven, in the year when up to 15% of all children contracted the disease.

‘ Chronic rheumatic heart disease was the major pre-occupation of the practising cardiologist. Rheumatic fever had peaked in the 1920s and 1930s; indeed in 1927 the British Medical Research Council reported that 10 to 15% of all children in the country had been affected by rheumatism. ‘ 4
This damage would  affect her health for the rest of her life, and it is likely that the consequences of rheumatic fever greatly increased her risk of developing dementia. In the early twentieth century, rheumatic fever was ‘ One of the most dreaded infections -the leading cause of death in childhood.’

‘Rheumatic fever is caused by a preceding Group A streptococcal infection. Acute reheumatic fever Acute RF (ARF) primarily affects the heart, joints, and central nervous system. Of these symptoms, the autoimmune cardiac sequelae are the most dreaded for it causes fibrosis of heart valves, leading to crippling valvular heart disease, heart failure, strokes, endocarditis, and death. Generations of medical students have been taught that treating strep throat with antibiotics can prevent RF. Moreover, regular antibiotics (usually monthly injections) can prevent patients with RF from contracting further strep infections and causing progression of valve damage.’  5  After gaining her Higher School Certificate, Catherine trained as a primary school teacher, initially in Liverpool, before the students  were evacuated,twice, to other locations.  As a qualified teacher, she returned to live with her parents,  teaching at the school which she had attended herself.  Her entire forty year teaching career was at this school, where she became deputy then headteacher.    6

Born on September 21st 1910, William,  his elder brother James and their younger brother David lost their father in May 1915.  In the army reserves, having served in the Boer War,  he  was called up immediately when WWI began. William, almost four, remembered waving goodbye.  David, who was only two, didn’t remember their father.  Like many thousands of WWI widows, their mother, Margaret, couldn’t earn enough to feed, clothe and house her children. Instead of today’s annually uprated widow(er)’s pension and death in service payments, many WWI widows lost their children too. The boys were cared for at an orphanage. Like James, William and David, many of the boys had lost their fathers, not both parents.  Poverty separated them from their mothers too.  Later, William went to St Gregory’s Technical High School, then studied for City and Guilds qualifications in tailoring.  As soon as they could, the brothers lived with their mother again. 7

William met Catherine when he was twenty six and Catherine a fifteen year old grammar school pupil. They married in 1946, soon after William returned from serving in the Royal Corps of Signals during WWII and on the Rhine.  After the birth of their first child, Catherine returned to teaching immediately and would soon become the principal earner.  On May 16th 1959, a serious injury to William’s right arm made it difficult for him to continue working in tailoring. The accident happened less than two months before the birth of William and Catherine’s youngest child.  Making only a partial recovery, William returned to work in a restricted capacity until additional health problems prompted early retirement.

His sight began to deteriorate in the 1980’s and he had begun to suffer from transient ischaemic attacks.  His Low Vision appointment records and NHS records from the Manchester Royal Eye Hospital and the neurology department of the Manchester Royal Infirmary identify two conditions, age related macular degeneration, for which treatment was attempted without success, and also bilateral ischaemic neuropathy - stroke damage to his optic nerve.  There is no treatment for this condition.8  In October 1988, William  was admitted to the neurology department of the Manchester Royal Infirmary.   MRI and Manchester Royal Eye Hospital  ( MREH) records for this period document the continued deterioration of his sight.  William’s consultant Mr C Dodd, DO FRCS recognised the severe visual impairment as blindness in January 1997, but formal registration as a blind person didn’t take place until October 13th 1998.  In  October 1998, Mr Dodd identified his patient as ‘blind, cannot do any work for which eyesight is essential. ‘ The certificate completed by Mr Dodd was copied to William’s GP and to Manchester City Council.  William’s name was entered on the Manchester’s register of blind people. The Registered Blind Person’s card gave William access to local and nationwide services for people who are severely sight impaired/blind. In 1998, when William’s blindness was registered, this certificate was the BD8 1990.In 2005, the Certificate of Visual Impairment (CVI)  was introduced.  Like the current CVI, the BD8 1990 certificate is a legal document, confirming a major disability, recognised by all UK government departments, including HMRC, and by all local authorities. A white stick was issued,and William was also referred to Henshaw’s Institute for the Blind.  The Royal National Institute for the Blind made home visits.  Through his war time service in the Signals, William had learned to touch type. He could use the landline phone and a mobile. He used RNIB enabling devices, including adaptations to the kettle and cups.  He continued to operate the microwave, the TV remote and hi-fi. Catherine, always uneasy with technology, never changing a light bulb or a fuse, did none of this, long before she developed dementia.  She could and did read to William, especially works not then available as audio books, and also, works in French.  Both she and William spoke French well and were active members of Manchester Cathedral’s Toulouse Association.

Financial matters would not normally be included in an analysis of NHS care, but this review concerns adult safeguarding.  Financial abuse is just one of the many forms  of abuse which can affect vulnerable adults.  William’s existing blindness and the dementia which would eventually affect both Catherine and William caused them to be especially vulnerable to many kinds of abuse.
In 2000, William and Catherine drew up a home-made will, witnessed by the eldest of Catherine’s brothers and his wife and naming  only  Sibling 4 as  executor.   Solicitors would recommend two executors.  A sole executor might pre-decease the testator.  Each of their four children was to have a ten per cent share in their estate.  The remaining 60% was to be divided equally between their three grandsons and four granddaughters. In this amateur will, no provision was made for any subsequent grandchildren. 

William continued to experience transient ischaemic attacks, but in 2xxx and 2xxx, to family members with no training in mental health, neither he nor Catherine appeared to be mentally impaired.  In the summer of 2xxx, they welcomed visits by two of their grandchildren, enabling them to enjoy summer activities in Manchester. In August 2xxx a 17 year old  student from Krakow spent three weeks with  Jane and her family.   Learning that the visitor was from Krakow, William greeted her in Polish, having acquired conversational Polish during WWII 9  Catherine talked to the visitor about her closest friend since her schooldays, who was also from Krakow.  In the cafe of a city centre museum, Catherine placed the order for refreshments and paid for them.

Just over a month later, on Saturday September 28th 2xxx, Jane  and her family visited her parents to celebrate William’s  birthday. The previous weekend William and Catherine had been in London for the christening of their youngest grandchild.  Jane  was informed, verbally, by the friends who had driven them to London, that Catherine had become unwell during the prolonged return journey. 10  When  Jane and her husband Tom  arrived, William and Catherine were not at home. Eventually, a taxi arrived.  The driver, engaged by Marks and Spencer’s city centre store, explained that Catherine had been confused in the store.  William, who appeared to be in good health, explained that Catherine had been unable to use her store card or pay for shopping.  Catherine seemed unable to remember that the visit had been planned for some time. After the incident on September 28th 2002, and aware of Catherine’s continuing confusion and altered behaviour, Jane  stopped announcing visits to her parents, though she did, at least initially, phone them from the train. During school holidays, Jane  usually visited with her daughters.  When Sibling 3 visited, her behaviour towards Catherine gave cause for concern, but  there appeared to be insufficient evidence which could be reported to Adult Social Care.

In the summer of 2003, prolonged illness in the  family restricted Jane ’s visits to her parents.  In 2004, Jane  began to make telephone, written and face to face referrals regarding her parents’ safety .   Except for the phone calls, made by mobile and landline, all these referrals are documented in Catherine’s NHS records  Some of the phone calls are mentioned  in the NHS records, Initially, the referrals were prompted by the obvious physical dangers presented by the combination of William’s blindness and Catherine’s mental health problems, recognised by her GP as dementia in the summer of 2005.11 There were other serious concerns, regarding the lifestyle and financial circumstances of Sibling 3, who now lived in a neighbouring suburb in Manchester.  In November 1999 this  sibling  had undergone over nine hours of surgery for the removal of a  brain tumour.(meningioma). After an M.Sc , Jane worked initially in NHS epidemiology.  She is not medically qualified and therefore not in a position to express any opinion regarding potential long term effects of the tumour and its removal.  Sibling 3 had other problems, identified in safeguarding referrals as ‘ serious health problems’  Presenting hard evidence of the nature of such problems  would be difficult. Jane  consulted Alzheimer’s UK.

Other matters  concerning Sibling 3 were well known, referred to by people who contacted Jane  to express concern for her parents’ safety.   A  Catholic nun and community worker was making progress in persuading Catherine and William to accept help.  Progress was interrupted when Sibling 3 arrived at the house.  The nun was aware of Sibling 3’s lifestyle, raising this matter with Jane  herself, using a colloquial expression to identify Sibling 3’s  condition when she arrived. . Sister X  appeared to be aware of lifestyle choices which would not be acceptable in anyone applying to work with children or vulnerable adults.
.
In addition to the serious lifestyle concerns, Sibling 3 was acknowledged to have considerable debts.  The property in Wales where she had lived with a former partner had been repossessed.  Sibling 3 had placed considerable pressure on Jane and her husband,urging them repeatedly to buy the property on her behalf, using any savings and borrowing to raise the necessary sum.  Initially, they did consider the possibility of helping this  sibling,  arranging a building society meeting.  They recognised that making such a commitment would be unwise.  They were responsible for their own mortgage repayments and the support of their children.

Soft evidence of financial problems and other concerns about Sibling 3 could not be reported effectively.  Adult Social Care staff identified Sibling 3 as a ‘ carer’, who lived locally. Jane  had no official evidence regarding Sibling 3’s debts or of the debit recovery undertaken by a financial institution until Catherine and William’s bank statements and other financial records were released in 2009. 12   In the context of ongoing or suspected elder abuse, allegations aren’t enough.  Evidence is needed.  Even with fully documented NHS medical records and bank statements documenting extensive misuse of Catherine and William’s accounts, the Police were unwilling to accept a report of ongoing abuse of older people suffering from dementia.  The advice that Jane  should focus on  Sibling 3’s definite medical history was sound.  NHS records indicate that Sibling 3 identified herself at this time as  a ‘full time lecturer’, but could not be contacted on a  ‘work number’  given to NHS staff.  13  Jane ’s friends in the teaching profession in Manchester corrected  Sibling 3’s claim regarding a lectureship, having other information.  Sibling 3  had  to leave  a teacher training course after a year,  then studied drama and worked for some years in the theatre.  Later, a part time teaching role concerned English for speakers of other languages.  To remain in such a position, qualifications would be required.

Catherine remained reluctant to consult a doctor, but recognised now that her health was deteriorating,    NHS Mental Health records  state that she had refused support in the past. 14   This was not a valid reason for withdrawing support when Catherine  was  facing the first signs of memory loss. She did seek medical care. This is documented in her North Manchester General Hospital and GP records.  Recognition of healthcare needs came before more difficult mental health symptoms  began to affect her.  NHS records identify altered behaviour and memory problems  beginning three to four years before the  diagnosis of dementia. The earliest  of  Catherine’s NHS records released to Jane  is for January 5th 2xxx. This consultation and the medication prescribed focuses on her damaged heart, specifically, the aortic and mitral regurgitation.  15

On April 5th 2xxx, Jane  and one of her daughters visited William and Catherine.  Catherine was again extremely repetitive.  She appeared to be convinced that in order to obtain a prescription for William, she would need his WWII service number. Sibling 3 arrived at the house.  Catherine continued to be repetitive, insisting that the number was needed. In the presence of her parents and her eighteen year old niece, Sibling 3 became verbally aggressive and hostile.  When Jane  tried to re-direct Catherine towards a new subject of conversation, Sibling 3 said :
         ‘You and your husband.  How about a suicide pact ?
In any social context, it would be difficult to overstate the shock of these words, heard by William, Catherine, Jane  and Jane ’s daughter.  Visiting again, this time on her own, Jane  found Sibling 3 present.  This time, Catherine was rejecting her own prescribed medication, because the label identified her as Mary – an NHS practice  which could and should be changed.  A person’s first given name is not always the name used. Sibling 3  then acknowledged that she used whisky to keep Catherine quiet.  Catherine’s prescribed medication included the  angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitor, Ramipril,  Drinking alcohol with this medication is not advised. 16

Jane  reported Sibling 3’s misuse of alcohol to Adult Social Care immediately  This time, Community Mental Health were alerted, and did respond, but staff accepted Sibling 3’s claim that buying whisky for Catherine had ceased.  No such claim should have been accepted without evidence. 17  Completed on 21 06  2xxx, and identifying Jane  as the person who had made the  referral, the Manchester Care Assessment Schedule, includes  several serious  errors.  To assess care needs accurately,  accurate information is essential.  Catherine’s date of birth hasn’t been entered correctly.  The correct date would identify her as in her 85th year.  According to this document, William and Catherine’s ‘eldest daughter lives in the U.S.A.’  How was this  wrong information obtained ?  From what source ? Did the City Council staff make any attempt to verify this information ?  Catherine and William’s eldest daughter and eldest of their children is Jane   who has always lived in the U.K and has never visited the U.S.A. 

It is reported that they have five children. This isn't true.  They had four children, three daughters and a son, in that order. Especially for a woman, confirming and documenting correctly how many children she has given birth to, and the gender of these children is core personal data. Questioning a woman about the number, birth order and gender of her children is a normal part of mental health assessment.   Assessed by a consultant old age psychiatrist  more than five years after her GP  and the North Manchester General Hospital had recognised dementia, Catherine was able to give her core personal history correctly.  18 .

In the assessment schedule, reference is made to William’s ‘poor eyesight.’ The information is inadequate and not consistent with the information presented in the SPRITE referral form.19  In plain English,  William was blind.  He was a registered blind person, suffering from a major disability, caused by macular degeneration and stroke damage to his optic nerve. 20  His blindness was registered on October 13th, 1998, by Manchester City Council, after the council and William’s GP had received the certificate completed by his consultant opthalmic surgeon.    His name was entered on the city’s register of blind people.21 A consultant opthalmic surgeon had confirmed that William could not do any work for which eyesight is essential.  22   Losing his sight in his late eighties, William had not learned Braille or any other tactile code which would have enabled him to read.
In assessing care needs, the severity of a person’s visual impairment must be recorded correctly.  When the  Manchester Care and Assessment Schedule was undertaken, William was suffering from two irreversible conditions.  He had some peripheral vision. As his consultant explains, this would enable him to navigate familiar surroundings, using his white stick.  Having no focal vision,he certainly could not read. 23   Rejecting Jane ’s reports that her father became blind over ten years before the alleged abuse, Greater Manchester Police officers maintained that there was no evidence that William could not see anything.   In the context of  the extensive financial abuse  of two vulnerable older people, William’s blindness  and the concealment of his blindness  will be examined in  Chapter 9, An Inspector Calls.   According to responses made by solicitors, the Land Registry, Abbey /Santander, and the Prudential Insurance Company,they were not made aware of William’s blindness when major financial and legal actions took place. In the summer of 2xxx, one of these transactions involved the transfer of £150,000 from Catherine and William’s joint account and there was other significant financial activity. 24   The Assessment Schedule refers to Catherine’s heart defect. In conjunction with her GP’s diagnosis of dementia, by June 2xxx, and repeated in North Manchester General Hospital records on July 4th 2xxx, recognition of the heart defect is important, evidence that the local authority had Catherine’s correct medical history on record, long before this history was misrepresented by Sibling 3 in December 2xxx. (NHS records)  Catherine’s NMGH records, including the July 4th ECG, confirm that she did not suffer a heart attack. 25  The assessment schedule makes no reference to  the  serious concern raised by Jane , namely, the dangerous misuse of alcohol,  administered  to Catherine by Sibling 3 .

On the same Care Assessment form, it is claimed that ‘the family have power of attorney.’  This is untrue. Nobody had power of attorney, for either Catherine or William.  Power of attorney is granted to named individuals, whose identities must be verified, not to a ‘family’.  Before placing this claim on record, Manchester City Council  and NHS Mental Health staff  should have  asked which family member or members had power of attorney.  Before engaging in any financial relationship with any member of Catherine and William’s family, the City Council should have requested sight of a Lasting Power of Attorney document registered with the Office of the Public Guardian.   A Lasting Power of Attorney is an important legal document,  granted by a person identified as having the  mental capacity to appoint a trusted person or person to act for them, should they become unable to make decisions for themselves. 26   Attorneys appointed by the donor must respect the  Mental Capacity Act Code of Practice. 27   In 2xxx, following a  statement reporting  ongoing and extensive financial abuse, for which evidence had been presented,  Manchester City Council  officers continued to recognise someone who did not have Lasting Power of Attorney or deputyship as the administrator of Catherine’s financial affairs. ( See Chapter 7 ‘ The abuse continues here’ )

Dementia is cited in Catherine’s NHS records at the North Manchester General Hospital on July 4th 2xxx, after  her  self -referred admission to Accident and Emergency.  28  The assessment schedule makes no reference to another serious concern raised by Jane, namely,the dangerous misuse of alcohol – specifically, whisky, administered to Catherine by Sibling 3.  NMGH records for July 4th 2005 include Catherine’s concerns that she ‘ had started drinking excessively over the past 6 to 8 months’    Acknowledging this could have been difficult and embarrassing. 29
After this consultation, and the concerns raised regarding excessive drinking, the discharge letter to Catherine’s GP practice wasn’t sent for seven weeks.  The letter was addressed to the partner of Catherine’s usual GP.  The practice is 0.7 miles from the hospital. 30  Before the  GP received this letter, Social Services had already closed the case.    On August 25th, a CPN from the Mental Health and Social Care Trust wrote to Jane  informing her that Social Services had closed the case.  On the 24th October, the Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust closed the case, stating that there was no role for them.31 

This was completely inappropriate. A blind man now aged 95, and his wife, aged almost 85, were left without any support. In the ‘early stages’ of dementia, facing a condition for which there is as yet no cure, many people are frightened. Instead of abandoning older people who appear to be rejecting support, their justified fears of dementia should be recognised with respect and sensitivity. 32   Furthermore, it is in these ‘early stages’ of dementia that treatment and support should begin.
The first and most essential role for the NHS is that of providing support and reassurance for people facing illness or injury.   Diagnosing the ‘ early stages’ of cancer,   the NHS does not abandon patients who are distressed, sometimes in denial, and facing a difficult future. Offered support and reassurance, people are better able to consider treatment and care options.

Responding to Jane’s complaint about Catherine’s care after her reports concerning the misuse of whisky, the Trust responded that a liver function test had been negative.  Catherine’s report during the consultation on July 4th  indicated that problem drinking was a recent development.  After about six  to eight months of ‘excessive’ drinking, evidence of alcohol related liver damage would be unlikely.33 Sibling 3 had a acknowledged the use of whisky, as a means of managing Catherine, whose prescribed medication for her existing heart disease was not compatible with alcohol.  It was claimed that Sibling 3  ‘ had stopped buying whisky’ . Other  NHS records correct this claim.   The continued misuse of alcohol will be examined in detail in Chapter Five,  A Broken Trust, especially in the context of Catherine’s antipsychotic and anti-depressants medication,repeated placements in respite care and extensive financial abuse.

On September 21st, 2xxx William’s 95th birthday,  following correspondence with Jane , and further discussion by phone, Catherine’s GP, Dr A, of Blackley,   made a home visit. Jane  and Sibling 2 were both present when Dr A  explained why he thought  Catherine’s illness  was vascular dementia. In Catherine’s case, as her GP acknowledged during a telephone discussion with Jane,  the cognitive reserve, established through higher education and her forty-year professional career could easily skew the results of the basic Mini Mental State Examination. (MIMS)  34
Other aspects of her illness indicated more serious problems than the basic MIMS score might indicate.  Dr A also discussed  Catherine’s lack of insight and undertook to watch the situation from week to week’  Like Dr A, the CPN working on this case recognised Catherine’s lack of insight  into the effect of her illness on her daily activities.  Friends and neighbours continued to contact Jane , reporting their concerns.

1   NHS records,  MMH/SCT CPN  to Consultant 01/09/2008
2  MMH/SCT Event 9. 13/12/2007, also 20/12/2007 Event 12  Consultant to GP Practice A
3  Event 168 25/3/2010,MMH/SCT
4.  The forgotten past: The practice of cardiology in the 1950s and now  https://academic.oup.com/eurheartj/article-pdf/21/16/1277/17883228/1277.pdf  by D Julian - ‎2000
 5 1. Hajar R. Rheumatic fever and rheumatic heart disease a historical perspective. Heart Views. 2016;17:120–6. [PMC free article] [PubMed]

6 The HMI inspection undertaken in the final year of her career commends especially the work of the headteacher ]

Her Majesty’s Inspectors were succeeded bty Ofsted.

7 Personal information, family records,

8   Central Manchester University  Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust. ( CMUH) January 1997.
 9   Eighth Army, Italian campaign, including Monte Cassino.
10 The christening coincided with the  Countryside Alliance march.

11 NMGH records, GP, SPRITE, MANCAS,

12 Abbey/Santander accounts,, 21st century

13 24th August 2xxx . NMGH

14  07/12/2007  MMH/SCT

15 NMGH, 04/01/2004 Chest clinic to GP. ACE inhibitors prescribed.

16 The controversial indications for ACE-Inhibitors in valvular heart disease  https://www.escardio.org/.../vol4n13-Title-The-controversial-indications-for-ACE-Inh...by R Rosenhek - ‎Related articles   7 Dec 2005 -144
 17  Community mental health response to the PHSO
18   13/10/2xxx  MMH/SCT .
19  Sprite form,  4/10/2xxx
20   Manchester Royal Eye Hospital records, January 1997, October 1998.
21 Manchester  City Council Registered Blind Person B5959. Issued October 13th 1998.
22  BD8 1990, completed 13th October 1998, C Dodd, D.O. F.R.C.S.
23  Manchester Royal Eye Hospital records, 13/10/1998.

24 Abbey/Santander a/c, 2008

25  NMGH 04/07/2xxx
26 Make, register or end a lasting power of attorney – GOV.UK   https://www.gov.uk/power-of-attorney
27 Mental Capacity Act Code of Practice    Ref: ISBN 9780117037465, First published 2007, Third impression 2xxx
28  NMGH  04/07/2005
29  NMGH, 04/07/2005

30 NMGH 31/08/05 re 04/07/05 letter registrar to GP, includes excessive drinking.

31 24/10/2005 No role for us MMH/SCT

32 NHS RightCare Scenario https://www.england.nhs.uk/wp-content/uploads/2017/.../toms-story-full-narrative.pdf

33 Alcohol-related liver disease – NHS.UK https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/alcohol-related-liver-disease-arld

34 Cullen, Breda et al. “A Review of Screening Tests for Cognitive Impairment.” Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry 78.8 (2007): 790–799. PMC. Web. 19 Apr. 2018.
35  25/08/ 2xxx   Manchester Social services closed the case of a blind 95 year old, 85 year old wife with dementia.