10 Quis Custodiet ipsos custodes ?

Questions for Patient Advice and Liaison, NHS England ,  the  Department of Health, Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman, the Local Government Ombudsman, the Information  Commissioner’s Office,   the Police,  the Independent Office for Police Conduct the Health Care Professionals Council,  the Office of the Public Guardian,  the Court of Protection

Who will guard the guards? In the twenty first century, Juvenal’s  answer is only too accurate…  crimen commune tacetur - the common crime keeps its silence.     Violent attacks on older people   make the front  page, but such attacks  are unusual.  Elder abuse is, usually, a secret , silent and all too successful  category of crime.  Abuse is conducted behind closed doors,   where there is an expectation of trust.    Self-identifying carers  aren’t  vetted and barred, aren’t required to produce accounts and can exercise absolute control , even, as in Catherine’s case,  denying  vulnerable people access to health care.

Warning that two very old people were at risk  because of  dementia and blindness and at risk from a named person, giving grave reasons for this warning achieved nothing.   Manchester Social Services closed the case of a blind 95 year old, whose 85 year old wife was already suffering from dementia.   Warning  the Director of Social Services and NHS mental health professionals achieved nothing.    An urgent warning was given at the Patient Advice and Liaison Office of the North Manchester General Hospital.  One day later  a potentially abusive situation  became reality, when the person identified in safeguarding referrals was allowed to exercise absolute control over two vulnerable people.  The pathway created by an NHS Trust  exposed two very old  people, both now suffering from dementia, to very serious abuses dismissed by Greater Manchester Police officers as  ‘a domestic, we don’t get involved’.

The police take all crime seriously; you can expect them to listen to you, treat you with respect and take a statement. They will also be able to put you in contact with organisations that can help you like Victim Support. 1

Reported  to the lead professionals in the NHS and Social Services,  no action was taken to  investigate the abuse, of William and Catherine  and prevent further damage.  When evidence of ongoing   financial abuse, well into six figures,  was presented to Social Services, a care manager and social worker  took no action and denied any recollection of  a three hour meeting with Jane.   In the NHS and in Social Services, the guards failed to keep two very old people safe.    Appointed to investigate complaints  about the three  key  public authorities,  the NHS, Social Services and the Police,  every agency  except the Financial Ombudsman Service  rubber-stamped the  original failings. The FOS identified the case as a police matter.   

All abuse of older people is a crime.  Reporting crime to the police is a civic responsibility.  If the victims are old and ill, the responsibility is greater.


1 Crown Prosecution Service website, 2018.