3 Behind Closed Doors…
‘Social Services input required (unless daughter happy to look after?)’
Unsafe discharge of a vulnerable older person, suffering from dementia, heart disease and chronic breathing problems, to the person identified in safeguarding referrals.
NMGH, NHS Mental Health and Social Services failed to contact Jane, Catherine and William’s nearest relative, making safeguarding referrals for over three years.
No mental health care for Catherine for fifteen months.
NHS Mental Health staff complied with access directions from Sibling 3.
Sibling 3 failed to answer phone calls and did not respond to letters from a CPN.
Sibling 3 made untrue claims that Catherine was ‘ always well and active’ until May/June 2007
Existing, fully NHS documented medical history including dementia, aortic and mitral heart valve disease and chronic breathing problems.
Usually identified as COPD/asthma. (never smoked)
Deprivation of Liberty absolute, in a private house.
No vetting and barring of privately engaged carers.
Same owner-occupied address, 1947 until discharged to Sibling 3,12th September 2xxx
Locks on William and Catherine’s own house changed.
All financial and other correspondence delivered to this address.
Existence of house still owned by William and Catherine not acknowledged by Sibling 3
Extensive use of Catherine and William’s bank accounts.
Sibling 3’s utility bills and other expenditure identified in William and Catherine’s joint account.
Catherine told NHS Mental Health staff about her own house.
William represented by Sibling 3 as in possession of all faculties.
NHS records – Registered Blind 10+ years, then dementia & uncorrected hearing impairment.
Summary
In August 2xxx, Catherine self-referred to the hospital three times in twelve days, August 11th, August 22nd, when Jane was alerted by friends, and again on August 23rd. On August 1lth, Catherine was brought to the hospital by ambulance, just before 12.30. North Manchester General Hospital records for August 11th indicate that ‘the GP needs to be aware of the daughter’s concerns - unable to cope.’
By phone, by letter and during a meeting at which Sibling 2 was also present, Catherine’s GP knew of Jane ’s concerns and had promised to watch the situation. GP observation continued after both Social Services and NHS Mental Health had closed the case. In July 2xxx, Catherine’s GP took an important safeguarding step. On July 17th 2xxx, he requested a home visit by the NHS Mental Health consultant old age psychiatrist.1 The consultant’s secretary rang Catherine to discuss the appointment, speaking to both Catherine and William, who confirmed that the suggested time of 9.30 a.m would not be too early. This was arranged for Thursday, August 31st 2006. A letter was sent, confirming this appointment. Before this visit could be made, Catherine self referred to the NMGH on August 11th, arriving at the hospital by ambulance. NMGH records report that on August 22nd 2006, Catherine and William came to the hospital by private car with Sibling 3. As Sibling 3 did not drive or own a car, another person must have been driving. When Jane arrived at the NMGH with a GP friend, Sibling 3 left abruptly, saying to Jane ‘ You must be psychic’. A & E assessment of Catherine continued,
Jane explained to a doctor that Catherine had never smoked. Catherine was referred to X-ray. After the X-ray, Jane , concerned about Sibling 3’s troubling response to her own arrival at the hospital, went to the PALS office, to repeat her warning that her parents were at risk, and must not be discharged to Sibling 3. After taking them back to their own house and reporting Catherine’s tests and same day discharge to the GP, Jane did not see either of her parents again until she was able to visit her mother at the White Moss Care Centre over eighteen months later, in March 2xxx. Catherine had been placed there for four weeks in March and April 2xxx 2
Claims made in some of Catherine’s NHS records regarding her previous rejection of support are inappropriate. For many years, Catherine had been unwilling to seek medical care. The reason for this reluctance cannot be accurately determined, and her position regarding medical care had changed. NHS records held by two NHS Trusts include mental health assessments undertaken from 2xxx onwards, this being the date given for Catherine’s first contact with mental health services. Catherine had been known to older age services since 2xxx. 3 After their spouses, Jane was, in accordance with the Mental Health Act, her parents’ nearest relative. Authorised by public authorities, any placement in care, whether temporary or permanent, should have been referred to Catherine and William’s eldest child. The actual family structure is defined in Jane ’s formal safeguarding letter, sent to Manchester City Council’s Director of Social S-ervices on February 18th, 2xxx. 4
The earliest NHS records released to Jane are from January 2xxx These records confirm that before January 5th 2xxx, when her GP received a letter from the chest clinic at the NMGH. Catherine was actively and regularly seeking medical care. The onset of any form of dementia is distressing. The GP’s diagnosis of dementia was made in the early summer of 2xxx, before the Manchester Care and Assessment schedule (MANCAS) was completed on 21st June 2xxx. Dementia was recognised and cited in Catherine’s North Manchester General Hospital records on July 4th 2xxx, consistent with, as her records state, a history of memory problems and altered behaviour for the previous three to four years. Catherine’s GP for this period discussed the diagnosis of vascular dementia during telephone discussions with Jane , and also,during a meeting with Jane and Sibling 2 when making a home visit to Catherine and William on September 21st 2xxx. The same GP was aware, of course, that William had been blind for many years, and had suffered many transient ischaemic attacks.. Blindness recognised in January 1997 by his consultant opthalmic surgeon at the Manchester Royal Eye Hospital, and registered in October 1998 was concealed and denied ten years later, throughout the period when large sums, in the region of £200,000 were removed from William and Catherine’s joint and individual bank accounts. Responding to Greater Manchester Police , Sibling 3 and associates would report that William had no problems with his sight.
In the 21st century, dementia is the most feared of all conditions- more feared now than cancer or HIV. Any form of cancer, including a brain cancer, is recognised as a profoundly distressing illness. The courage of people suffering from cancer is respected and praised. Fundraising events are high profile. In hospital and at home, care is provided by the NHS. Dementia is punished, at every stage, treated, too often, as a form of delinquency, a social problem, referred to Social Services rather than to skilled mental health professionals. Assessments are undertaken, quantifying the supposed stage of deterioration and calculating the potential cost of ‘ care’, provided and marketed as ‘ social’. People suffering from dementia have a neuro-degenerative disease. They need far more than the supposed ‘ care’ of a chair to sit on in a ‘care home’, staffed, all too often, by some of the most poorly paid workers in the U.K. After their spouses, Jane was, in accordance with the Mental Health Act, her parents’ nearest relative.
On August 31st 2xxx, attempting to visit Catherine at her home, in response to the GP’s request, and in agreement with Catherine and William, the consultant old age psychiatrist found the house deserted. The house was deserted because on August 31st 2xxx Catherine was still an in-patient at the NMGH, where she had been since August 23rd and would remain there until September 12th. William was with Sibling 3. According to NHS Mental Health records, Catherine’s failure to keep the appointment with the consultant was identified as an indication that once again, mental health care was being rejected. It is important to recognise that Catherine herself did not fail to keep an appointment with the consultant old age psychiatrist. She had no means of indicating that this would not be possible. The explanation for Catherine’s failure to keep the appointment is simple, and Catherine was not in any way responsible for this failure. Admitted to the NMGH on August 23rd, she had been identified as medically fit for discharge the following day – and not, objectively, noticeably short of breath. 5
Following a prolonged and medically inappropriate stay in hospital, Catherine had been discharged into the ‘ care’ of the very person about whom serious warnings had been given. By phone, in formal Frail and Vulnerable Adult written referrals and finally, on August 22nd, face to face at the NMGH PALS office, Jane had given grave reasons why Catherine should not be discharged into the care of the unsafe person identified in referrals. Catherine was then denied all mental health and almost all general medical care for the next fifteen months. Catherine’s medically unnecessary twenty- one day hospital stay - three times the average hospital stay - was achieved because Sibling 3, self-identifying as ‘carer’ expressed unwillingness to have Catherine discharged sooner than this.
The cost per day of any hospital stay is considerable, and prolonged stays inappropriate for most patients. 6 Sibling 3 cited her supposed full time work, as a ‘lecturer’. The response of NMGH staff must be questioned. Contrary to claims entered in other Manchester NHS and Social Services records, including the June 2005 MANCAS schedule, no member of the family had power of attorney, for financial affairs or health care. Sibling 3’s commitments should not have been a consideration when Catherine was medically fit for discharge. Remaining in hospital for prolonged periods can be very damaging for people affected by dementia. 7 Hospital in-patient time is expensive, currently in the region of £400 a day. Fit for discharge a day after she was admitted, twenty days of Catherine’s in-patient stay were an unnecessary charge to the NHS, and certainly not in Catherine’s best interests. 8 In hospital, Catherine had indicated that she was eager to go home, by which she meant the house she had left by ambulance on August 23rd, to which she should have returned the next day. When Catherine was admitted to the NMGH on August 23rd 2xxx, neither she nor William were normally ‘residing’ with Sibling 3. 9 They had their own house, which they owned, in Blackley, in the community where they had lived throughout their marriage, close to the church where the elderly couple were well known. In July 2xxx both Catherine and William had confirmed that they were willing to accept the consultant’s home visit. 10
During Catherine’s three week stay in hospital,the NMGH and Social Services could have and should have contacted Catherine and William’s nearest relative, Jane. Jane , now with heightened concerns regarding the risks presented by Sibling 3 would have been able to support her parents. NHS and Social Services records document many failed attempts to contact Sibling 3, both during Catherine’s long in-patient stay of August and September 2xxx and on subsequent occasions. Two years later, Sibling 3 would once again leave Catherine in hospital for many weeks, after Catherine had been identified as fit for discharge within a day of admission. 11 Bank accounts identify this period as the most crucial for major financial abuse.
When Catherine was discharged by the NMGH in September 2xxx the discharge letter sent to her GP identifies dementia – a diagnosis which the GP had made himself fourteen months earlier. 12 Controlling all access to Catherine, Sibling 3 rejected ongoing mental health support, and also, general medical care, for an 85 year old with two damaged heart valves. Leaving the NMGH after three weeks instead of an overnight stay for assessment, Catherine was discharged, not to her own house, but to the house of Sibling 3, in a different suburb, served by a different Mental Health team. In August and September 2xxx, Catherine was a mature adult, not subject to any form of detention under the Mental Health Act. She had broken no laws. She and William were homeowners, with a retirement income more than sufficient for their needs. They had their state pensions, and also, Catherine’s headteacher’s pension, to which she had contributed throughout her unbroken forty year career. NMGH records for this period identify the ‘early stages’ of dementia. Absolute deprivation of liberty is not appropriate for people at this stage of dementia.13 Behind the closed doors of a private house, absolute deprivation of liberty can be imposed by a self-identified and unvetted carer. Under the control of another person, a vulnerable person can be effectively deprived of their liberty, under constant supervision and control, and not free to leave those premises at any time. Unable to leave the premises, they might have no control over food and drink, access to medical care, or to any social contact not sanctioned by the person who is controlling every aspect of their lives.
In Catherine’s case, this was respected by NHS mental health professionals, who did not challenge Sibling 3’s directions regarding access. From the day she was discharged from the NMGH to the address of Sibling 3, Catherine would be deprived of her liberty, unable to see her friends, and also, unable to access health care unless Sibling 3 permitted access to such care. Because all financial and other correspondence continued to be delivered to William and Catherine’s own house in Blackley, Catherine had no access to her personal accounts or to the joint account held with William.
Behind closed doors, Catherine would have no access to the house which had been her home for almost sixty years, to her personal possessions, to the health care which she had acknowledged was necessary, and the community where she had been known for so many years. Discharged to her own home, she and William could have been offered appropriate Social Services input. Because of William’s blindness, they could claim additional, non-means tested support. They would have had continuity of GP and consultant care, and time in which future care needs could be effectively and accurately assessed. Discharged to Sibling 3, Catherine would lose, immediately, what she needed most – NHS mental health support for a distressing and currently incurable illness. When a patient with recognised mental health problems is discharged from hospital, mental health support is offered. On September 19th 2xxx, when an initial post discharge Manchester City Council Mental Health Referral form was completed, Catherine was found to be confused. The completed form should have prompted immediate investigations. The address given is that of Sibling 3, identified in Jane ’s referrals as presenting a serious risk to two vulnerable older people. What would happen to Catherine and William’s own house, which they owned outright, paying council tax at that address? This is the address given in NMGH records when Catherine self referred on August 11th, 22nd and 23rd.
Supposedly, post discharge mental health care had been rejected by Catherine herself. Examination of Catherine’s NHS records confirms that care was rejected on Catherine’s behalf by Sibling 3. 14.
Mental and general health care for a newly discharged 85 year old vulnerable adult suffering from dementia, heart disease and breathing problems was vital. The use of the term ‘ vulnerable adult’ is much debated. Age doesn’t automatically indicate vulnerability, but anybody suffering from dementia is vulnerable. In July, Catherine had acknowledged her need for mental health support, agreeing to the proposed home visit by the consultant old age psychiatrist.
The response, or more accurately, the lack of response from NHS staff when faced with Sibling 3’s irregular conduct during Catherine’s in-patient stay and the failure to challenge the rejection of post discharge mental health care is unacceptable. Recognised by NMGH staff in July 2xxx, dementia was recognised again during Catherine’s in-patient care at the same hospital in August and September 2xxx and is cited in the discharge letter sent to her GP . Allowing a third party to reject medical care facilitated abuse. Denying anybody medical care is identified in the NHS Choices pages on Elder Abuse. Catherine was also denied appropriate medical treatment for the aortic and mitral valve damage and her chronic breathing problems. Doctors treating Catherine had suggested many reasons for her episodes of breathlessness. On the afternoon of August 22nd, the doctor to whom Jane reported that Catherine was a lifelong non-smoker was questioning the ‘ COPD’ diagnosis. Responding to the chest clinic at the NMGH, Catherine’s own GP suggested his interpretation of the breathing problems.
In September 2xxx, Catherine’s existing NHS documented medical history included three serious conditions. Rheumatic fever at the age of seven had caused permanent damage to her heart, sometimes identified in her NHS records as mitral stenosis. Other NHS records refer to aortic and mitral regurgitation. 15 Cardiovascular disease is an important risk factor in dementia. People with poorly controlled heart conditions are more likely to develop dementia, and neglect of heart conditions will exacerbate existing dementia. 16 In the interests of Catherine’s mental and physical health, treatment to alleviate the problems associated with the damaged aortic and mitral valve was vital. The association between dementia and heart disease is one of the examples presented in the BMA Safeguarding Vulnerable adults Toolkit. Card 11 includes the history of Mrs Edgman, who had faulty heart valve. 17 Maintaining optimal physical health, including the treatment of any chronic conditions, is important for everyone, including people who have dementia. 18 Denied general medical care for almost all of the fifteen months when she had no mental health care, Catherine’s existing dementia is likely to have been exacerbated by the lack of treatment for her heart condition for fifteen months.
Media attention focuses on abuse in care homes and occasional street attacks by strangers on vulnerable older people. Legislation and protocols define a plethora of safeguarding measures which operate in NHS hospitals, nursing and residential settings, and apply to employed caregivers, recruited by firms providing service. Guidance is offered by charities, including Action on Elder Abuse, Age UK and Alzheimer’s UK. Few, if any active safeguards operate in private households, where the self identified carer is typically a family member. If staff at a care home had informed NHS mental health staff that Catherine did not wish to received any health care, the response would have invited immediate questions. Self-identified carers, who are likely to be family members, were not vetted in accordance with the Safeguarding Vulnerable Groups Act 2006, which operated when Catherine and William were discharged to Sibling 3, or by the Care Act of 2014. Those responsible for elder abuse are frequently found to be family members. 19 Some carers are formally employed, through home care providers. Such carers will need to accept vetting. The NHS offers a list of providers. 20
Returning to Catherine’s situation after she was discharged from the NMGH on September 12th 2xxx, it’s clear that she had been actively and regularly seeking medical care. She had agreed to a visit from the consultant. Her GP recognised her anxiety about her mental health. When dementia is recognised or suspected, assessments are undertaken, quantifying the supposed stage of deterioration. In Catherine’s case, as her GP acknowledged during a telephone discussion with Jane , Catherine’s cognitive reserve could easily skew the results of the basic Mini Mental State Examination. (MIMS) 21 All her initial responses to mental health staff, including her reluctance to be referred to a consultant, should have been recognised by such professionals as an understandable response to a feared illness. At best, medications prescribed for dementia, such as donepezil ( Aricept) can slow down the disease in some patients, but for others, the value of such medication is limited, and the side effects unacceptable. Denying Catherine mental health care because her self-identified ‘carer’ rejected support was a serious failing on the part of NHS Mental Health staff, 22
References to the ‘early stages’ of dementia can be unhelpful. When pregnancy is confirmed, antenatal care isn’t delayed until it’s time to call the midwife. Unlike pregnancy, the identified ‘stages’ of dementia are only a rough guide. As a former headteacher, Catherine was markedly distressed by her mental deterioration, and initially, in denial. This had been Catherine’s position in the earliest stages of her illness. Self-referring to the hospital, and agreeing to a home visit from the consultant Catherine now wanted and needed help. Now, treatment was denied. 23 Treatment and other interventions at this earlier stage of Catherine’s illness was important. Deterioration might be arrested for a few months. 24
According to the Sprite referral form, Catherine :
Does not manage personal care
Forgets to wash or dress
Refusal to eat or drinking
Can be confused and forgetful
Accidentally overdosed on medication.
A handwritten record, linked to this SPRITE referral states that Catherine had ‘ overdosed on own medication and had given her husband too much warfarin’ . No other details of this reported incident are presented. The report states that she could be ‘ difficult to manage and ‘ manipulative’. No evidence is presented for these claims. It is also claimed that she had suffered a severe CVA, was very unsteady, and not suitable for rehab. According to this handwritten report, Catherine has carers twice a day. ‘Daughter is a full time teacher, home in the evening.’ PLEASE RING DAUGHTER PRIOR TO APPOINTMENT.(sic)
Undated, like too many of Catherine’s NHS records, which should be dated on every page, and should include the patient’s NHS number, the source of these unverified claims is not identified. Already, even at this early stage in Catherine’s exclusion from NHS care, an unverified claim regarding her supposed behaviour could discredit her position in any relationship with NHS and Social Services staff. NHS Mental Health professionals should not record such unverified and unsigned value judgements of any patient in their care. On the same handwritten sheet, the reference to a ‘severe’ CVA is not supported by other NHS records for this period. Claims concerning the supposed heart attack began circa July 4th 2xxx, and are not supported by the ECG at the NMGH that day. On July 4th, 2xxx, Catherine was discharged on the same day. No NHS hospital would discharge a patient on the day of a ‘severe heart attack.’
In the Sprite network referral of September 19th 2006, Catherine is identified as ‘ lacking insight, and failing to manage self care’ The same report refers to Catherine refusing to eat or drink. No action was taken, by Social Services or by any NHS mental health staff. Let us suppose that this case history is that of a child, also recently discharged from hospital, who has ‘accidentally overdosed on medication’, rather than an eighty-five year old, who was suffering from dementia. Action would be taken immediately. The child could be identified as being ‘at risk’ The parents or carers of this child would have serious questions to answer. Depending on the severity of the incident, the child might be removed. If,in addition to the obvious safety failing, parents or carers were refusing health care for the child, intervention would be urgent. In the case of an 85 year old, both NHS and Social Services staff appear to be indifferent.
Self-identifying as Catherine’s ‘carer’, Sibling 3 was preventing a recently discharged 85 year old with complex mental and general health needs from receiving NHS care and treatment. Given the serious consequences of the NHS response, repetition here is essential. Identified as ‘ lacking insight, and failing to manage self care’ , Catherine was reported as overdosing on her own medication and giving too much warfarin to her husband. For William, if this report is correct, too much warfarin could have had very serious, potentially fatal consequences 25 Whatever the accuracy of the statements made in this handwritten record, NHS mental health staff failed to investigate a report which includes a catalogue of claims which required investigation.
On October 10th 2xxx, the Community Psychiatric Nurse assigned to the case wrote to Catherine’s GP, informing him that the consultant, reporting that 'Instructions given on the referral emphasised to telephone Catherine’s daughter to facilitate a visit’
Referring to a care manager at the NMGH, the letter continues’ It is reported that she is now eating and appears well cared for’ ‘It is reported’ is not acceptable as medical evidence. The source of claims that Catherine, referred to incorrectly as ‘ Mary’ is now eating and appears well cared for is not given. Why did no NHS professionals know Catherine well enough to recognise that the name by which she was known was not ‘ Mary’. ? Second and third hand reports from Manchester City Council and NMGH staff are not acceptable when the subject is an 85 year old woman with serious health conditions, apparently rejecting all continuing care. Reports which use the wrong forename cannot be regarded as reliable. Claims regarding Catherine’s reported previous refusal to be referred to a consultant must be considered with the usual caveat. If a person clearly in need of support refuses help, this does not justify the withdrawal of all contact by NHS and Social Services staff. References to previous refusal of care are not consistent with her GP’s correspondence with the NMGH Chest Clinic about Catherine or her positive response when the consultant old age psychiatrist’s secretary rang to arrange a home visit.
The CPN’s letter to Catherine’s GP acknowledges that no contact has been achieved with Sibling 3, despite repeated letters and phone calls. The letter demonstrates that access to Catherine was prevented by Sibling 3, who declined to answer any phone calls, or respond to any letters. 26
On October 19th 2xxx, the consultant wrote to Catherine’s GP ( GP practice A) reporting that ‘our team have been unable to conduct a mental health assessment’ In his letter to the Chest Clinic on December 4th 2xxx, which gives Catherine and William’s own address, the GP refers to Catherine’s concerns regarding her mental health.
‘There is a question as to whether she is hyperventilating on occasions as she is very worried about her mental health.’ 27
Catherine’s general hospital records from September 2xxx to December 2xxx include three brief admissions to A & E by ambulance, on 28th September and 25th November 2xxx and 12th January 2xxx. According to A & E triage records, she was short of breath on all these occasions. On September 28th 2xxx and January 12th 2xxx, she was also distressed because William was ill. No other general medical care is identified in her records from September 2006 – December 2007. Catherine’s existing diagnosis of dementia confirmed that she needed and would benefit from mental health support, Timely support was denied to her.
On September 22nd 2xxx, having failed to obtain any response from her parents, Jane travelled to Manchester by train, bringing a birthday cake for her father and presents from the family, including a painting by one of her daughters, structured to be appreciated by William, using his remaining peripheral vision. Once again, the house was deserted. Family friends, including, this time, Mrs C, who had been able to help on August 22nd, did not know where William and Catherine were. On a warm September day, the birthday cake would deteriorate. Jane decided to take the cake and gifts to the church her parents had attended almost daily since Catherine’s retirement. Clergy agreed to find out where William and Catherine were and arrange for the presents and cake to be delivered. Jane provided her contact details. Nobody from this church contacted her.
On October 20th 2xxx Sibling 2 came to Manchester, and found that Catherine and William had been locked temporarily into their own house. In Manchester City Council’s response to the Local Government Ombudsman, this seems to be the only referral made by Sibling 2. Affected by dementia and blindness, neither Catherine nor William could open the door. The Fire and Rescue Service was called. 28 On October 26th, a letter was sent to the consultant by a community psychiatric nurse, claiming that Catherine’s care needs were being met by ‘ daughters and carers.’ As in the previous letter, the report presents information in quotes, including the approximations ‘appears to be’ and ‘ It is reported that’. Such unverified claims would not, it is to be hoped, be accepted in the case of a vulnerable child suffering from serious mental and physical conditions. 28 There is no evidence that any investigation into Catherine’s circumstances had been undertaken. Sibling 3 was not qualified to provide mental health care for anybody, nor was Sibling 3 qualified to treat serious heart disease. These records indicate troubling disregard for the mental and physical health of older people suffering from complex mental and physical health problems prevalent in later life. ‘ There’s a carer’ is not a substitute for the mental and general medical health care a patient like Catherine should have received from the NHS.
This review concerns safeguarding failures in the care of vulnerable adults suffering from dementia. Patient support and care for any other person is not usually included, but in the late autumn of 2xxx, the head of practice and the GP directly responsible for the health care of Jane and her family were aware of damaging action taken against them. On October 31st 2xxx, action taken by Sibling 3 and other family members would affect Jane and her family throughout the coming year. In August 2xxx, the head of practice urged that they should book a holiday for mid September 2xxx. They should not be in their home area for a high profile social event, held in South Lakeland at which many members of William and Catherine’s family would be present. In the 21st century, the misuse of various means of communication cannot be disregarded.
In December that year, Sibling 4, still in South America, informed Jane that Sibling 3 was ‘looking after’ Catherine and William. Friends of Catherine and William continued to contact Jane, reporting problems in gaining access to them. The distance between Catherine’s own house and that of Sibling 3 was short – just a mile and a half, but the area is poorly served by public transport, especially for anybody with mobility problems. Many of Catherine and William’s friends were no longer able to drive. As NHS records confirm, all access to Catherine had to be obtained with the consent of Sibling 3. All Jane ’s own attempts to contact her parents failed. Gifts, including flowers for Catherine and music for both were never acknowledged.
NHS Choices : Signs of family abuse.
What are the signs of Family Abuse?
Where abuse is intentional it is likely that the following signs will be apparent:
I. The older person may not be allowed to speak for themselves, or see others, without the presence of the family member (suspected abuser) being present
II. They may display attitudes of indifference or anger toward the older person, or the obvious absence of assistance
III. A family member may blame the elder person (e.g. accusation that incontinence is a deliberate act)
IV. They may display aggressive behaviour (threats, insults, harassment) toward the older person
V. They may have a previous history of abuse of others
VI. They may display inappropriate affection toward the older person
VII. They may display flirtatious behaviour, or coyness, etc that might be possible indicators of inappropriate sexual relationships
VIII. They may create social isolation of the family, or isolation or restriction of activity of the older person
IX. There may be conflicting accounts of incidents by family, supporters, or the older person
X. They may display inappropriate or unwarranted defensiveness
XI. There may be indications of unusual confinement (closed off in a room; tied to furniture; change in routine activity)
XII. There may be the obvious absence of assistance, or attendance
1. 17/07/2xxx GP requests home visit for Catherine by consultant (MMH/SCT)
2 White Moss Care Centre, Benmore Road, Blackley. Operated by Manchester City Council,. Now closed.
3 Event 106, 16/01/2xxx MMH/SCT,
4 This letter is cited in the Manchester City Council panel report of April 23rd 2xxx, a copy of which is included in Catherine’s MMH/SCT records.
5 24/08/2xxx NMGH
6 The UK had 2.6 hospital beds per 1,000 people in 2015, compared to 8.1 in ... Average length of stay for inpatient stays in the UK was 7.0 days in 2015
7 Half of Alzheimer's patients come out of hospital 'worse than when ...https://www.telegraph.co.uk 17 Nov 2009.
8 www.nhsconfed.org/resources/key-statistics-on-the-nhs
9 PHSO, assessment April 2013,
10 17/07 /2xxx, domiciliary visit request from GP to consultant.
11 . See A Broken Trust. NMGH records, July 16th – August 8th 2008.
12 23/08/2xxxX – 13/09/2xxx Discharge letter to GP, cites early dementia
13 A state of the nation report on dementia care and support in England
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/.../Dementia.pdf
14. North Manchester General Hospital, Manchester Mental Heakth and Social Care Trust, NHS records, August – October, 2xxx-
15 05/01/2xxx NMGH .
16 The later stages of dementia | Alzheimer's Society https://www.alzheimers.org.uk/about-dementia/symptoms-and...dementia.
17 52140 Safeguarding vulnerable adults PRINT_Ethics tool kit https://www.bma.org.uk
18 Living well with dementia - NHS.UK
https://www.nhs.uk › Health A-Z › Dementia guide
19 Financial : evidence review [PDF] Source: Age UK - - Publisher: Age UK
20 National homecare providers – NHS.UK
21 Cullen, Breda et al. “A Review of Screening Tests for Cognitive Impairment.” Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry 78.8 (2007): 790–799. PMC. Web. 19 Apr. 2018.
22Why early diagnosis is important - Dementia – SCIE https://www.scie.org.uk/dementia/symptoms/diagnosis/early-diagnosis.asp
23 Abuse and neglect of vulnerable adults – NHS.UK https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/social-care.../vulnerable-people-abuse-safeguarding/
24 Dementia: timely diagnosis and early intervention BMJ 2015; 350 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.h3029
25 Warfarin: MedlinePlus Drug Information https://medlineplus.gov
2610/10/2006. Visits to Mary have to be arranged with daughter. No response x2
27 GP to Chest clinic, 04/12/2xxx, The letter also refers to Catherine having developed dementia.
28 Greater Manchester Fire and Rescue Service, released William and Catherine in the late afternoon of October 20th.
29 Letters, 29 09 2xxx and 10 10 2xxx. No response from Sibling 3
Unsafe discharge of a vulnerable older person, suffering from dementia, heart disease and chronic breathing problems, to the person identified in safeguarding referrals.
NMGH, NHS Mental Health and Social Services failed to contact Jane, Catherine and William’s nearest relative, making safeguarding referrals for over three years.
No mental health care for Catherine for fifteen months.
NHS Mental Health staff complied with access directions from Sibling 3.
Sibling 3 failed to answer phone calls and did not respond to letters from a CPN.
Sibling 3 made untrue claims that Catherine was ‘ always well and active’ until May/June 2007
Existing, fully NHS documented medical history including dementia, aortic and mitral heart valve disease and chronic breathing problems.
Usually identified as COPD/asthma. (never smoked)
Deprivation of Liberty absolute, in a private house.
No vetting and barring of privately engaged carers.
Same owner-occupied address, 1947 until discharged to Sibling 3,12th September 2xxx
Locks on William and Catherine’s own house changed.
All financial and other correspondence delivered to this address.
Existence of house still owned by William and Catherine not acknowledged by Sibling 3
Extensive use of Catherine and William’s bank accounts.
Sibling 3’s utility bills and other expenditure identified in William and Catherine’s joint account.
Catherine told NHS Mental Health staff about her own house.
William represented by Sibling 3 as in possession of all faculties.
NHS records – Registered Blind 10+ years, then dementia & uncorrected hearing impairment.
Summary
In August 2xxx, Catherine self-referred to the hospital three times in twelve days, August 11th, August 22nd, when Jane was alerted by friends, and again on August 23rd. On August 1lth, Catherine was brought to the hospital by ambulance, just before 12.30. North Manchester General Hospital records for August 11th indicate that ‘the GP needs to be aware of the daughter’s concerns - unable to cope.’
By phone, by letter and during a meeting at which Sibling 2 was also present, Catherine’s GP knew of Jane ’s concerns and had promised to watch the situation. GP observation continued after both Social Services and NHS Mental Health had closed the case. In July 2xxx, Catherine’s GP took an important safeguarding step. On July 17th 2xxx, he requested a home visit by the NHS Mental Health consultant old age psychiatrist.1 The consultant’s secretary rang Catherine to discuss the appointment, speaking to both Catherine and William, who confirmed that the suggested time of 9.30 a.m would not be too early. This was arranged for Thursday, August 31st 2006. A letter was sent, confirming this appointment. Before this visit could be made, Catherine self referred to the NMGH on August 11th, arriving at the hospital by ambulance. NMGH records report that on August 22nd 2006, Catherine and William came to the hospital by private car with Sibling 3. As Sibling 3 did not drive or own a car, another person must have been driving. When Jane arrived at the NMGH with a GP friend, Sibling 3 left abruptly, saying to Jane ‘ You must be psychic’. A & E assessment of Catherine continued,
Jane explained to a doctor that Catherine had never smoked. Catherine was referred to X-ray. After the X-ray, Jane , concerned about Sibling 3’s troubling response to her own arrival at the hospital, went to the PALS office, to repeat her warning that her parents were at risk, and must not be discharged to Sibling 3. After taking them back to their own house and reporting Catherine’s tests and same day discharge to the GP, Jane did not see either of her parents again until she was able to visit her mother at the White Moss Care Centre over eighteen months later, in March 2xxx. Catherine had been placed there for four weeks in March and April 2xxx 2
Claims made in some of Catherine’s NHS records regarding her previous rejection of support are inappropriate. For many years, Catherine had been unwilling to seek medical care. The reason for this reluctance cannot be accurately determined, and her position regarding medical care had changed. NHS records held by two NHS Trusts include mental health assessments undertaken from 2xxx onwards, this being the date given for Catherine’s first contact with mental health services. Catherine had been known to older age services since 2xxx. 3 After their spouses, Jane was, in accordance with the Mental Health Act, her parents’ nearest relative. Authorised by public authorities, any placement in care, whether temporary or permanent, should have been referred to Catherine and William’s eldest child. The actual family structure is defined in Jane ’s formal safeguarding letter, sent to Manchester City Council’s Director of Social S-ervices on February 18th, 2xxx. 4
The earliest NHS records released to Jane are from January 2xxx These records confirm that before January 5th 2xxx, when her GP received a letter from the chest clinic at the NMGH. Catherine was actively and regularly seeking medical care. The onset of any form of dementia is distressing. The GP’s diagnosis of dementia was made in the early summer of 2xxx, before the Manchester Care and Assessment schedule (MANCAS) was completed on 21st June 2xxx. Dementia was recognised and cited in Catherine’s North Manchester General Hospital records on July 4th 2xxx, consistent with, as her records state, a history of memory problems and altered behaviour for the previous three to four years. Catherine’s GP for this period discussed the diagnosis of vascular dementia during telephone discussions with Jane , and also,during a meeting with Jane and Sibling 2 when making a home visit to Catherine and William on September 21st 2xxx. The same GP was aware, of course, that William had been blind for many years, and had suffered many transient ischaemic attacks.. Blindness recognised in January 1997 by his consultant opthalmic surgeon at the Manchester Royal Eye Hospital, and registered in October 1998 was concealed and denied ten years later, throughout the period when large sums, in the region of £200,000 were removed from William and Catherine’s joint and individual bank accounts. Responding to Greater Manchester Police , Sibling 3 and associates would report that William had no problems with his sight.
In the 21st century, dementia is the most feared of all conditions- more feared now than cancer or HIV. Any form of cancer, including a brain cancer, is recognised as a profoundly distressing illness. The courage of people suffering from cancer is respected and praised. Fundraising events are high profile. In hospital and at home, care is provided by the NHS. Dementia is punished, at every stage, treated, too often, as a form of delinquency, a social problem, referred to Social Services rather than to skilled mental health professionals. Assessments are undertaken, quantifying the supposed stage of deterioration and calculating the potential cost of ‘ care’, provided and marketed as ‘ social’. People suffering from dementia have a neuro-degenerative disease. They need far more than the supposed ‘ care’ of a chair to sit on in a ‘care home’, staffed, all too often, by some of the most poorly paid workers in the U.K. After their spouses, Jane was, in accordance with the Mental Health Act, her parents’ nearest relative.
On August 31st 2xxx, attempting to visit Catherine at her home, in response to the GP’s request, and in agreement with Catherine and William, the consultant old age psychiatrist found the house deserted. The house was deserted because on August 31st 2xxx Catherine was still an in-patient at the NMGH, where she had been since August 23rd and would remain there until September 12th. William was with Sibling 3. According to NHS Mental Health records, Catherine’s failure to keep the appointment with the consultant was identified as an indication that once again, mental health care was being rejected. It is important to recognise that Catherine herself did not fail to keep an appointment with the consultant old age psychiatrist. She had no means of indicating that this would not be possible. The explanation for Catherine’s failure to keep the appointment is simple, and Catherine was not in any way responsible for this failure. Admitted to the NMGH on August 23rd, she had been identified as medically fit for discharge the following day – and not, objectively, noticeably short of breath. 5
Following a prolonged and medically inappropriate stay in hospital, Catherine had been discharged into the ‘ care’ of the very person about whom serious warnings had been given. By phone, in formal Frail and Vulnerable Adult written referrals and finally, on August 22nd, face to face at the NMGH PALS office, Jane had given grave reasons why Catherine should not be discharged into the care of the unsafe person identified in referrals. Catherine was then denied all mental health and almost all general medical care for the next fifteen months. Catherine’s medically unnecessary twenty- one day hospital stay - three times the average hospital stay - was achieved because Sibling 3, self-identifying as ‘carer’ expressed unwillingness to have Catherine discharged sooner than this.
The cost per day of any hospital stay is considerable, and prolonged stays inappropriate for most patients. 6 Sibling 3 cited her supposed full time work, as a ‘lecturer’. The response of NMGH staff must be questioned. Contrary to claims entered in other Manchester NHS and Social Services records, including the June 2005 MANCAS schedule, no member of the family had power of attorney, for financial affairs or health care. Sibling 3’s commitments should not have been a consideration when Catherine was medically fit for discharge. Remaining in hospital for prolonged periods can be very damaging for people affected by dementia. 7 Hospital in-patient time is expensive, currently in the region of £400 a day. Fit for discharge a day after she was admitted, twenty days of Catherine’s in-patient stay were an unnecessary charge to the NHS, and certainly not in Catherine’s best interests. 8 In hospital, Catherine had indicated that she was eager to go home, by which she meant the house she had left by ambulance on August 23rd, to which she should have returned the next day. When Catherine was admitted to the NMGH on August 23rd 2xxx, neither she nor William were normally ‘residing’ with Sibling 3. 9 They had their own house, which they owned, in Blackley, in the community where they had lived throughout their marriage, close to the church where the elderly couple were well known. In July 2xxx both Catherine and William had confirmed that they were willing to accept the consultant’s home visit. 10
During Catherine’s three week stay in hospital,the NMGH and Social Services could have and should have contacted Catherine and William’s nearest relative, Jane. Jane , now with heightened concerns regarding the risks presented by Sibling 3 would have been able to support her parents. NHS and Social Services records document many failed attempts to contact Sibling 3, both during Catherine’s long in-patient stay of August and September 2xxx and on subsequent occasions. Two years later, Sibling 3 would once again leave Catherine in hospital for many weeks, after Catherine had been identified as fit for discharge within a day of admission. 11 Bank accounts identify this period as the most crucial for major financial abuse.
When Catherine was discharged by the NMGH in September 2xxx the discharge letter sent to her GP identifies dementia – a diagnosis which the GP had made himself fourteen months earlier. 12 Controlling all access to Catherine, Sibling 3 rejected ongoing mental health support, and also, general medical care, for an 85 year old with two damaged heart valves. Leaving the NMGH after three weeks instead of an overnight stay for assessment, Catherine was discharged, not to her own house, but to the house of Sibling 3, in a different suburb, served by a different Mental Health team. In August and September 2xxx, Catherine was a mature adult, not subject to any form of detention under the Mental Health Act. She had broken no laws. She and William were homeowners, with a retirement income more than sufficient for their needs. They had their state pensions, and also, Catherine’s headteacher’s pension, to which she had contributed throughout her unbroken forty year career. NMGH records for this period identify the ‘early stages’ of dementia. Absolute deprivation of liberty is not appropriate for people at this stage of dementia.13 Behind the closed doors of a private house, absolute deprivation of liberty can be imposed by a self-identified and unvetted carer. Under the control of another person, a vulnerable person can be effectively deprived of their liberty, under constant supervision and control, and not free to leave those premises at any time. Unable to leave the premises, they might have no control over food and drink, access to medical care, or to any social contact not sanctioned by the person who is controlling every aspect of their lives.
In Catherine’s case, this was respected by NHS mental health professionals, who did not challenge Sibling 3’s directions regarding access. From the day she was discharged from the NMGH to the address of Sibling 3, Catherine would be deprived of her liberty, unable to see her friends, and also, unable to access health care unless Sibling 3 permitted access to such care. Because all financial and other correspondence continued to be delivered to William and Catherine’s own house in Blackley, Catherine had no access to her personal accounts or to the joint account held with William.
Behind closed doors, Catherine would have no access to the house which had been her home for almost sixty years, to her personal possessions, to the health care which she had acknowledged was necessary, and the community where she had been known for so many years. Discharged to her own home, she and William could have been offered appropriate Social Services input. Because of William’s blindness, they could claim additional, non-means tested support. They would have had continuity of GP and consultant care, and time in which future care needs could be effectively and accurately assessed. Discharged to Sibling 3, Catherine would lose, immediately, what she needed most – NHS mental health support for a distressing and currently incurable illness. When a patient with recognised mental health problems is discharged from hospital, mental health support is offered. On September 19th 2xxx, when an initial post discharge Manchester City Council Mental Health Referral form was completed, Catherine was found to be confused. The completed form should have prompted immediate investigations. The address given is that of Sibling 3, identified in Jane ’s referrals as presenting a serious risk to two vulnerable older people. What would happen to Catherine and William’s own house, which they owned outright, paying council tax at that address? This is the address given in NMGH records when Catherine self referred on August 11th, 22nd and 23rd.
Supposedly, post discharge mental health care had been rejected by Catherine herself. Examination of Catherine’s NHS records confirms that care was rejected on Catherine’s behalf by Sibling 3. 14.
Mental and general health care for a newly discharged 85 year old vulnerable adult suffering from dementia, heart disease and breathing problems was vital. The use of the term ‘ vulnerable adult’ is much debated. Age doesn’t automatically indicate vulnerability, but anybody suffering from dementia is vulnerable. In July, Catherine had acknowledged her need for mental health support, agreeing to the proposed home visit by the consultant old age psychiatrist.
The response, or more accurately, the lack of response from NHS staff when faced with Sibling 3’s irregular conduct during Catherine’s in-patient stay and the failure to challenge the rejection of post discharge mental health care is unacceptable. Recognised by NMGH staff in July 2xxx, dementia was recognised again during Catherine’s in-patient care at the same hospital in August and September 2xxx and is cited in the discharge letter sent to her GP . Allowing a third party to reject medical care facilitated abuse. Denying anybody medical care is identified in the NHS Choices pages on Elder Abuse. Catherine was also denied appropriate medical treatment for the aortic and mitral valve damage and her chronic breathing problems. Doctors treating Catherine had suggested many reasons for her episodes of breathlessness. On the afternoon of August 22nd, the doctor to whom Jane reported that Catherine was a lifelong non-smoker was questioning the ‘ COPD’ diagnosis. Responding to the chest clinic at the NMGH, Catherine’s own GP suggested his interpretation of the breathing problems.
In September 2xxx, Catherine’s existing NHS documented medical history included three serious conditions. Rheumatic fever at the age of seven had caused permanent damage to her heart, sometimes identified in her NHS records as mitral stenosis. Other NHS records refer to aortic and mitral regurgitation. 15 Cardiovascular disease is an important risk factor in dementia. People with poorly controlled heart conditions are more likely to develop dementia, and neglect of heart conditions will exacerbate existing dementia. 16 In the interests of Catherine’s mental and physical health, treatment to alleviate the problems associated with the damaged aortic and mitral valve was vital. The association between dementia and heart disease is one of the examples presented in the BMA Safeguarding Vulnerable adults Toolkit. Card 11 includes the history of Mrs Edgman, who had faulty heart valve. 17 Maintaining optimal physical health, including the treatment of any chronic conditions, is important for everyone, including people who have dementia. 18 Denied general medical care for almost all of the fifteen months when she had no mental health care, Catherine’s existing dementia is likely to have been exacerbated by the lack of treatment for her heart condition for fifteen months.
Media attention focuses on abuse in care homes and occasional street attacks by strangers on vulnerable older people. Legislation and protocols define a plethora of safeguarding measures which operate in NHS hospitals, nursing and residential settings, and apply to employed caregivers, recruited by firms providing service. Guidance is offered by charities, including Action on Elder Abuse, Age UK and Alzheimer’s UK. Few, if any active safeguards operate in private households, where the self identified carer is typically a family member. If staff at a care home had informed NHS mental health staff that Catherine did not wish to received any health care, the response would have invited immediate questions. Self-identified carers, who are likely to be family members, were not vetted in accordance with the Safeguarding Vulnerable Groups Act 2006, which operated when Catherine and William were discharged to Sibling 3, or by the Care Act of 2014. Those responsible for elder abuse are frequently found to be family members. 19 Some carers are formally employed, through home care providers. Such carers will need to accept vetting. The NHS offers a list of providers. 20
Returning to Catherine’s situation after she was discharged from the NMGH on September 12th 2xxx, it’s clear that she had been actively and regularly seeking medical care. She had agreed to a visit from the consultant. Her GP recognised her anxiety about her mental health. When dementia is recognised or suspected, assessments are undertaken, quantifying the supposed stage of deterioration. In Catherine’s case, as her GP acknowledged during a telephone discussion with Jane , Catherine’s cognitive reserve could easily skew the results of the basic Mini Mental State Examination. (MIMS) 21 All her initial responses to mental health staff, including her reluctance to be referred to a consultant, should have been recognised by such professionals as an understandable response to a feared illness. At best, medications prescribed for dementia, such as donepezil ( Aricept) can slow down the disease in some patients, but for others, the value of such medication is limited, and the side effects unacceptable. Denying Catherine mental health care because her self-identified ‘carer’ rejected support was a serious failing on the part of NHS Mental Health staff, 22
References to the ‘early stages’ of dementia can be unhelpful. When pregnancy is confirmed, antenatal care isn’t delayed until it’s time to call the midwife. Unlike pregnancy, the identified ‘stages’ of dementia are only a rough guide. As a former headteacher, Catherine was markedly distressed by her mental deterioration, and initially, in denial. This had been Catherine’s position in the earliest stages of her illness. Self-referring to the hospital, and agreeing to a home visit from the consultant Catherine now wanted and needed help. Now, treatment was denied. 23 Treatment and other interventions at this earlier stage of Catherine’s illness was important. Deterioration might be arrested for a few months. 24
According to the Sprite referral form, Catherine :
Does not manage personal care
Forgets to wash or dress
Refusal to eat or drinking
Can be confused and forgetful
Accidentally overdosed on medication.
A handwritten record, linked to this SPRITE referral states that Catherine had ‘ overdosed on own medication and had given her husband too much warfarin’ . No other details of this reported incident are presented. The report states that she could be ‘ difficult to manage and ‘ manipulative’. No evidence is presented for these claims. It is also claimed that she had suffered a severe CVA, was very unsteady, and not suitable for rehab. According to this handwritten report, Catherine has carers twice a day. ‘Daughter is a full time teacher, home in the evening.’ PLEASE RING DAUGHTER PRIOR TO APPOINTMENT.(sic)
Undated, like too many of Catherine’s NHS records, which should be dated on every page, and should include the patient’s NHS number, the source of these unverified claims is not identified. Already, even at this early stage in Catherine’s exclusion from NHS care, an unverified claim regarding her supposed behaviour could discredit her position in any relationship with NHS and Social Services staff. NHS Mental Health professionals should not record such unverified and unsigned value judgements of any patient in their care. On the same handwritten sheet, the reference to a ‘severe’ CVA is not supported by other NHS records for this period. Claims concerning the supposed heart attack began circa July 4th 2xxx, and are not supported by the ECG at the NMGH that day. On July 4th, 2xxx, Catherine was discharged on the same day. No NHS hospital would discharge a patient on the day of a ‘severe heart attack.’
In the Sprite network referral of September 19th 2006, Catherine is identified as ‘ lacking insight, and failing to manage self care’ The same report refers to Catherine refusing to eat or drink. No action was taken, by Social Services or by any NHS mental health staff. Let us suppose that this case history is that of a child, also recently discharged from hospital, who has ‘accidentally overdosed on medication’, rather than an eighty-five year old, who was suffering from dementia. Action would be taken immediately. The child could be identified as being ‘at risk’ The parents or carers of this child would have serious questions to answer. Depending on the severity of the incident, the child might be removed. If,in addition to the obvious safety failing, parents or carers were refusing health care for the child, intervention would be urgent. In the case of an 85 year old, both NHS and Social Services staff appear to be indifferent.
Self-identifying as Catherine’s ‘carer’, Sibling 3 was preventing a recently discharged 85 year old with complex mental and general health needs from receiving NHS care and treatment. Given the serious consequences of the NHS response, repetition here is essential. Identified as ‘ lacking insight, and failing to manage self care’ , Catherine was reported as overdosing on her own medication and giving too much warfarin to her husband. For William, if this report is correct, too much warfarin could have had very serious, potentially fatal consequences 25 Whatever the accuracy of the statements made in this handwritten record, NHS mental health staff failed to investigate a report which includes a catalogue of claims which required investigation.
On October 10th 2xxx, the Community Psychiatric Nurse assigned to the case wrote to Catherine’s GP, informing him that the consultant, reporting that 'Instructions given on the referral emphasised to telephone Catherine’s daughter to facilitate a visit’
Referring to a care manager at the NMGH, the letter continues’ It is reported that she is now eating and appears well cared for’ ‘It is reported’ is not acceptable as medical evidence. The source of claims that Catherine, referred to incorrectly as ‘ Mary’ is now eating and appears well cared for is not given. Why did no NHS professionals know Catherine well enough to recognise that the name by which she was known was not ‘ Mary’. ? Second and third hand reports from Manchester City Council and NMGH staff are not acceptable when the subject is an 85 year old woman with serious health conditions, apparently rejecting all continuing care. Reports which use the wrong forename cannot be regarded as reliable. Claims regarding Catherine’s reported previous refusal to be referred to a consultant must be considered with the usual caveat. If a person clearly in need of support refuses help, this does not justify the withdrawal of all contact by NHS and Social Services staff. References to previous refusal of care are not consistent with her GP’s correspondence with the NMGH Chest Clinic about Catherine or her positive response when the consultant old age psychiatrist’s secretary rang to arrange a home visit.
The CPN’s letter to Catherine’s GP acknowledges that no contact has been achieved with Sibling 3, despite repeated letters and phone calls. The letter demonstrates that access to Catherine was prevented by Sibling 3, who declined to answer any phone calls, or respond to any letters. 26
On October 19th 2xxx, the consultant wrote to Catherine’s GP ( GP practice A) reporting that ‘our team have been unable to conduct a mental health assessment’ In his letter to the Chest Clinic on December 4th 2xxx, which gives Catherine and William’s own address, the GP refers to Catherine’s concerns regarding her mental health.
‘There is a question as to whether she is hyperventilating on occasions as she is very worried about her mental health.’ 27
Catherine’s general hospital records from September 2xxx to December 2xxx include three brief admissions to A & E by ambulance, on 28th September and 25th November 2xxx and 12th January 2xxx. According to A & E triage records, she was short of breath on all these occasions. On September 28th 2xxx and January 12th 2xxx, she was also distressed because William was ill. No other general medical care is identified in her records from September 2006 – December 2007. Catherine’s existing diagnosis of dementia confirmed that she needed and would benefit from mental health support, Timely support was denied to her.
On September 22nd 2xxx, having failed to obtain any response from her parents, Jane travelled to Manchester by train, bringing a birthday cake for her father and presents from the family, including a painting by one of her daughters, structured to be appreciated by William, using his remaining peripheral vision. Once again, the house was deserted. Family friends, including, this time, Mrs C, who had been able to help on August 22nd, did not know where William and Catherine were. On a warm September day, the birthday cake would deteriorate. Jane decided to take the cake and gifts to the church her parents had attended almost daily since Catherine’s retirement. Clergy agreed to find out where William and Catherine were and arrange for the presents and cake to be delivered. Jane provided her contact details. Nobody from this church contacted her.
On October 20th 2xxx Sibling 2 came to Manchester, and found that Catherine and William had been locked temporarily into their own house. In Manchester City Council’s response to the Local Government Ombudsman, this seems to be the only referral made by Sibling 2. Affected by dementia and blindness, neither Catherine nor William could open the door. The Fire and Rescue Service was called. 28 On October 26th, a letter was sent to the consultant by a community psychiatric nurse, claiming that Catherine’s care needs were being met by ‘ daughters and carers.’ As in the previous letter, the report presents information in quotes, including the approximations ‘appears to be’ and ‘ It is reported that’. Such unverified claims would not, it is to be hoped, be accepted in the case of a vulnerable child suffering from serious mental and physical conditions. 28 There is no evidence that any investigation into Catherine’s circumstances had been undertaken. Sibling 3 was not qualified to provide mental health care for anybody, nor was Sibling 3 qualified to treat serious heart disease. These records indicate troubling disregard for the mental and physical health of older people suffering from complex mental and physical health problems prevalent in later life. ‘ There’s a carer’ is not a substitute for the mental and general medical health care a patient like Catherine should have received from the NHS.
This review concerns safeguarding failures in the care of vulnerable adults suffering from dementia. Patient support and care for any other person is not usually included, but in the late autumn of 2xxx, the head of practice and the GP directly responsible for the health care of Jane and her family were aware of damaging action taken against them. On October 31st 2xxx, action taken by Sibling 3 and other family members would affect Jane and her family throughout the coming year. In August 2xxx, the head of practice urged that they should book a holiday for mid September 2xxx. They should not be in their home area for a high profile social event, held in South Lakeland at which many members of William and Catherine’s family would be present. In the 21st century, the misuse of various means of communication cannot be disregarded.
In December that year, Sibling 4, still in South America, informed Jane that Sibling 3 was ‘looking after’ Catherine and William. Friends of Catherine and William continued to contact Jane, reporting problems in gaining access to them. The distance between Catherine’s own house and that of Sibling 3 was short – just a mile and a half, but the area is poorly served by public transport, especially for anybody with mobility problems. Many of Catherine and William’s friends were no longer able to drive. As NHS records confirm, all access to Catherine had to be obtained with the consent of Sibling 3. All Jane ’s own attempts to contact her parents failed. Gifts, including flowers for Catherine and music for both were never acknowledged.
NHS Choices : Signs of family abuse.
What are the signs of Family Abuse?
Where abuse is intentional it is likely that the following signs will be apparent:
I. The older person may not be allowed to speak for themselves, or see others, without the presence of the family member (suspected abuser) being present
II. They may display attitudes of indifference or anger toward the older person, or the obvious absence of assistance
III. A family member may blame the elder person (e.g. accusation that incontinence is a deliberate act)
IV. They may display aggressive behaviour (threats, insults, harassment) toward the older person
V. They may have a previous history of abuse of others
VI. They may display inappropriate affection toward the older person
VII. They may display flirtatious behaviour, or coyness, etc that might be possible indicators of inappropriate sexual relationships
VIII. They may create social isolation of the family, or isolation or restriction of activity of the older person
IX. There may be conflicting accounts of incidents by family, supporters, or the older person
X. They may display inappropriate or unwarranted defensiveness
XI. There may be indications of unusual confinement (closed off in a room; tied to furniture; change in routine activity)
XII. There may be the obvious absence of assistance, or attendance
1. 17/07/2xxx GP requests home visit for Catherine by consultant (MMH/SCT)
2 White Moss Care Centre, Benmore Road, Blackley. Operated by Manchester City Council,. Now closed.
3 Event 106, 16/01/2xxx MMH/SCT,
4 This letter is cited in the Manchester City Council panel report of April 23rd 2xxx, a copy of which is included in Catherine’s MMH/SCT records.
5 24/08/2xxx NMGH
6 The UK had 2.6 hospital beds per 1,000 people in 2015, compared to 8.1 in ... Average length of stay for inpatient stays in the UK was 7.0 days in 2015
7 Half of Alzheimer's patients come out of hospital 'worse than when ...https://www.telegraph.co.uk 17 Nov 2009.
8 www.nhsconfed.org/resources/key-statistics-on-the-nhs
9 PHSO, assessment April 2013,
10 17/07 /2xxx, domiciliary visit request from GP to consultant.
11 . See A Broken Trust. NMGH records, July 16th – August 8th 2008.
12 23/08/2xxxX – 13/09/2xxx Discharge letter to GP, cites early dementia
13 A state of the nation report on dementia care and support in England
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/.../Dementia.pdf
14. North Manchester General Hospital, Manchester Mental Heakth and Social Care Trust, NHS records, August – October, 2xxx-
15 05/01/2xxx NMGH .
16 The later stages of dementia | Alzheimer's Society https://www.alzheimers.org.uk/about-dementia/symptoms-and...dementia.
17 52140 Safeguarding vulnerable adults PRINT_Ethics tool kit https://www.bma.org.uk
18 Living well with dementia - NHS.UK
https://www.nhs.uk › Health A-Z › Dementia guide
19 Financial : evidence review [PDF] Source: Age UK - - Publisher: Age UK
20 National homecare providers – NHS.UK
21 Cullen, Breda et al. “A Review of Screening Tests for Cognitive Impairment.” Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry 78.8 (2007): 790–799. PMC. Web. 19 Apr. 2018.
22Why early diagnosis is important - Dementia – SCIE https://www.scie.org.uk/dementia/symptoms/diagnosis/early-diagnosis.asp
23 Abuse and neglect of vulnerable adults – NHS.UK https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/social-care.../vulnerable-people-abuse-safeguarding/
24 Dementia: timely diagnosis and early intervention BMJ 2015; 350 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.h3029
25 Warfarin: MedlinePlus Drug Information https://medlineplus.gov
2610/10/2006. Visits to Mary have to be arranged with daughter. No response x2
27 GP to Chest clinic, 04/12/2xxx, The letter also refers to Catherine having developed dementia.
28 Greater Manchester Fire and Rescue Service, released William and Catherine in the late afternoon of October 20th.
29 Letters, 29 09 2xxx and 10 10 2xxx. No response from Sibling 3