4 A Broken Trust…

One Patient. Two NHS Trusts.  Two GP Practices.  Two Histories 

Untrue claims by Sibling 3 that Catherine was ‘Always well and active up to May/June  2xxxx accepted by NHS Mental Health and Social Care Trust and Social Services.
NMGH and GP records record actual history,
Catherine suffered from aortic and mitral valve disease, caused by rheumatic fever when she was seven.
NHS documented history included dementia, believed to be vascular, diagnosed  two years earlier by her GP
MANCAS .Care assessment schedule refers to his diagnosis,
Dementia recognised by the NMGH on July 4th 2xxx, also August and September 2xxx. 
Chest X-ray, NMGH, August 22nd 2006 identified calcifications, exacerbating original damage.
Breathing problems from childhood, identified in NHS records as COPD
( lifelong non-smoker) or asthma. .
CPN staff and Social Services accept claims of bulimia/laxative abuse for continuing weight loss. (Housebound 87 year old, no access to money)
Force-feeding of liquidised sandwiches  to 87 year old endorsed by Manchester City Council as ‘imaginative’
‘A danger to her husband, to herself and to others.
Care Cluster 12   psychosis identified.
Permanent and funded placement in care applied for and granted
Use of two GP practices begins. 
In care, Catherine reported ongoing financial abuse to Jane 


Summary

Despite many referrals warning that Catherine and William were at risk from Sibling 3, the NMGH discharged Catherine to the home of Sibling 3.   In hospital for three weeks after she had been found medically fit for discharge, Catherine had missed the home visit by the consultant old age psychiatrist which her GP had requested.  Controlling all access, and failing to respond to  NHS letters and phone calls, Sibling 3 then prevented Catherine from receiving mental health and general medical care, which should have included treatment for her heart condition. .After fifteen months of de facto deprivation of liberty and denial of  mental health and general medical care, unverified misrepresentations by Sibling 3 were entered in Catherine’s NHS records as if they were medical facts.  ‘ Misrepresentations‘ included the extremely unsafe claim  that Catherine was   'always well and active until May or June 2007'. 1
As a patient of the Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust, with a  GP and NHS trust diagnosis of dementia in 2xxx,  every aspect of Catherine’s personal, medical and career history had been misrepresented by Sibling 3.  Mentally and physically, the misrepresentation of medical histories had serious consequences, damaging the medical care and personal wellbeing of two frail and vulnerable older people.  NHS  and Social Services safeguarding protocols were disregarded –  This was  acknowledged by Manchester City Council, but the Council disclaimed responsibility for the consequences of this failure. .   Instead of contacting Catherine and William’s nearest relative,  the eldest of their four children and at the time, named  as next of kin in NHS records. an NHS Trust liaised with the very person identified in written referrals.
On December 13th 2xxx, Sibling 3 described Catherine s being ‘ well and active until May /June 2xxx.  Information sourced from Sibling 3 is not consistent with  any of Catherine’s existing medical history. Documenting Catherine’s general and mental health history,  NHS records from both trusts correct this and other claims made by  Sibling 3.  Catherine had been known to Park House  for three years already. 2  Dementia had been diagnosed by Catherine’s GP by June 2xxx, certainly before the  ManCas Assessment Schedule  of 21/06/2xxx.  Dementia was recognised by A & E staff  at the NMGH on July 4th 2xxx, and again during inpatient care , 23rd August to  12th September  the following year.

Claims made by Sibling 3 regarding any aspect of Catherine’s health, behaviour and general demeanour cannot be accepted at face value, but NHS Mental Health and Adult Social Care professionals accepted such claims without seeking any verification.   ‘Daughter described’ is not an acceptable documentation of a patient’s medical or personal history. Catherine’s  general medical history included her significant cardiac conditions, the aortic and mitral regurgitation,  caused by rheumatic fever  when she was seven. 3   Following a chest X ray and other tests at the NMGH on August 22nd 2xxx,complications of the original damage were identified as  calcified hyperexpanded  small heart syndrome.  Catherine’s chronic breathing problems are usually identified as asthma and COPD , but there are indications  in her NHS records that the reason for her  breathlessness was more complex.  In Catherine’s childhood, chronic rheumatic heart disease was the major pre-occupation of the practising cardiologist. 

‘Rheumatic fever had peaked in the 1920s and 1930s; indeed in 1927 the British Medical Research Council reported that 10 to 15% of all children in the country had been affected by rheumatism. Heart disease in pregnancy was a major problem,justifying weekly cardiological clinics in the maternity hospitals of both Edinburgh and Boston. Although benign systolic murmurs were the most frequent reason for referral, mitral stenosis was the commonest organic lesion and, in many cases, quite severe .’ 4.


Before antibiotics, rheumatic fever was a big killer even in developed countries:

‘‘One of the dreaded infections that were modified by penicillin was streptococcal pharyngitis (rheumatic fever [RF]), which had a high mortality rate. In the early years of the last century, RF was a big killer even in the developed countries of that era. In the USA in the 1920s, RF was the leading cause of death in individuals between 5 and 20 years of age and was second only to tuberculosis in those between 20 and 30 years.[2] The only treatment was salicylates and bed rest. The majority remained at home for weeks, more often for months, with a smoldering illness; in the USA and Europe, the sicker children were managed in foster homes or special institutions for the chronically ill.[2]

RF is caused by a preceding Group A streptococcal (strep) infection. Acute RF (ARF) primarily affects the heart, joints, and central nervous system. Of these symptoms, the autoimmune cardiac sequelae are the most dreaded for it causes fibrosis of heart valves, leading to crippling valvular heart disease, heart failure, strokes, endocarditis, and death. Generations of medical students have been taught that treating strep throat with antibiotics can prevent RF. Moreover, regular antibiotics (usually monthly injections) can prevent patients with RF from contracting further strep infections and causing progression of valve damage.  5

The ‘misrepresentation’ of Catherine’s mental health history is equally serious. She did not suddenly begin to develop memory problems in May or even June 2xxx, June being the date identified in a letter from the consultant old age psychiatrist to  GP A. 6  In his capacity report for the Office of the Public Guardian, the same consultant gives a date of onset for dementia of December  that year.  This  incorrect claim  had the effect of appearing to validate the new wills  for William and Catherine drawn up  by Sibling 3 in May 2xxx 7

NHS records confirm that Catherine was denied essential and urgent mental health care for over fifteen months because mental health staff chose to comply with instructions given by the person who controlled all access to Catherine and to William. Throughout this period, most of Jane’s information was, inevitably, secondhand, via friends and former neighbours of her parents, and former teaching colleagues of Catherine’s.  The hiatus in NHS records speaks for itself and is the direct consequence of NHS Mental Health compliance with third party control over a vulnerable older person.  Throughout this period of absolute control over William and Catherine, there was other significant activity.

For the new wills,  drawn up in May 2xxx Sibling 3 and another family member are named as executrixes.  Revoking the will made in 2000, in which 40% of their assets are bequeathed to their four children, and the remaining 60% divided between seven grandchildren, William and Catherine’s new wills identify one primary beneficiary, Sibling 3.  Other family members were to receive household items, most of which were of little monetary value, some being broken.  Family members previously well known to Catherine and William for decades are identified incorrectly. Their daughter in law is identified as a granddaughter, and a granddaughter is identified as one of their own  as one of their own children.  Recognising such major discrepancies, Jane would have challenged the validity of this will, citing Catherine and William’s NHS documented  histories of dementia, blindness and uncorrected hearing impairment, and the fact that Sibling 3 had controlled all access to them since  September 2006, and had denied Catherine mental health and general medical care.  Surely no responsible solicitor would present such a seriously flawed will for probate ? 

Aged  96 and 86 when this will was made, William had been blind for ten years.   Legal blindness was recognised at the Manchester Royal Eye Hospital on January 14th  1997, though registration did not take place until October 1998. 8   Drawn  up when both Catherine and William were suffering from dementia, and William had been blind for years, the May 2007 ‘will’  could have been and should have been challenged.   People who are severely sight impaired/blind can make a valid will, but only if  specific conditions are met.  Solicitors in Longsight, Manchester had  been involved, but they did not drawn up the actual will.   Neither William nor Catherine had any connection with this area of the city.   Staff  at this firm  reported that they were unaware of William’s blindness.  The will was apparently witnessed  at the house of Sibling 3, by associates of  Sibling 3.  Greater Manchester Police officers accepted as true claims made by  these witnesses that William had no problems with his sight.   William, who had always obtained spectacles in his own area of Manchester, had been taken to opticians  several miles away.  Having some residual vision, like the majority of people recognised as being legally blind, he could still benefit from spectacles.  Opticians dispensing such a prescription would recognise that the client was severely sight /impaired blind, but with some peripheral vision. 

In July 2xxx, Sibling 3 held a ‘family reunion’ in Snowdonia.    As this report has stated, William’s connection with Wales was slight, in one male line, three generations back.  Jane and her family were not invited.  With other members of Catherine’s family, they were in Devon, attending the funeral of one of Catherine’s brothers.  On December 7th 2xxx, a Sprite network letter was sent to Catherine’s GP at practice A.  December 7th 2xxx is the date given to Jane  for the removal of her name as Catherine’s ‘next of kin’ in NHS records.  Once again, the Sprite form cites, inappropriately,  Catherine’s previous refusal of services, which was a historic position, no longer maintained, and not relevant to Catherine’s circumstances in 2xxx .9   Stigmatising a patient as having ‘previously refused services’ is judgemental and unhelpful.  Facing a serious diagnosis, patients are likely to be distressed.  With appropriate support, and arguably, recognising her teaching experience,  Catherine could have been encouraged to consider treatment options and therapeutic stratagems.  Visited by Jane and her family during the four week care home placement in March and April 2xxx, Catherine was encouraged to talk about her interest in pictogram communication in early years education.     

In August 2xxx, Catherine had attended the NMGH three times in less than a fortnight.
This is not the action of a person refusing health care.   After she was discharged, Sibling 3 , not Catherine herself, had refused service, directing that  access to ‘Mary’,  i.e, Catherine, had to be arranged through her.   Catherine became  routinely identified by  NHS  mental health staff and Social Services as   ‘ Mary’ . On  December 13th 2xxx, the consultant old age psychiatrist again attempted  a home visit to Catherine, at her own long-deserted home, more than fifteen months after his previous unsuccessful visit on August 31st 2xxx.  Redirected to  the house of Sibling 3, in another suburb,  he was, according to his own report,  surprised to find the local community health team already involved in her care.   In his letter to Catherine’s GP, the consultant reports that Catherine denied resisting when daughter helped her to dress. William  agreed.’ 

‘ Sibling 3 was somewhat amazed by the contradictory report of her parents. She felt that they were trying to hide things. 10

Later, the consultant found that Catherine apparently had no notes.  How could an eighty-six year old  UK resident have no notes ?  Catherine was a mother of four, and a lifelong resident of the same city.    Her NHS records would include the births of her children. How could a patient whom he was intending to visit  fifteen months earlier, on August 31st 2xxx have no notes ? It isn’t clear why this consultant does not appear to be aware that dementia is on record in Catherine’s North Manchester General Hospital records for July 4th  2xxx and in August and September  the following year.  Dementia had been recognised by Catherine’s GP  at practice A in the summer of 2xxx, certainly before the  Manchester care and assessment schedule dated 21st June that year.  This diagnosis had been discussed with Jane  and Sibling 2 at their parents’ house, on September 21st.   

On December 14th 2xxx, Sibling 3 requested a sitting service, and raised the question of welfare rights.   11   

Financial conditions for  such welfare payments are precise.

‘You must earn no more than £120 a week after tax and expenses. Expenses can include some of your pension contributions - and some of the costs of caring for your children or the disabled person while you’re at work’. 12

Until December 2xxx, £450 per month was transferred from William and Catherine’s account to Sibling 3.  When Sibling 3 applied for sitting services, the  regular monthly transfers   to Sibling 3 had increased to £1450.  Utility bills, supermarket shopping and general purchases, including petrol, wine, books and clothing were now charged to William and Catherine’s joint account.  In addition, with all utility bills paid, and groceries paid for by card, a further £450 was withdrawn from ATMs . Card payments of over £190 were made at Marks and Spencer.  All Catherine and William’s financial and other correspondence was still delivered to the deserted house in Blackley, to which Catherine, William and also Jane  had no access.

William was blind.   Recognition of this legally documented fact is crucial.   Having no focal vision, he could not read anything .  His opthalmologist  at the Manchester Royal Eye Hospital recognised the severity of visual impairment as blindness in January 1997. He was registered as blind the following year, on October 13th 1998, legally recognised as unable to do any work for which eyesight is essential.  Catherine’s memory problems  were recognised by her GP as dementia by June 2xxx.  On December  20th 2xxx, i.e, over fifteen months after the  consultation date originally agreed with Catherine, the consultant found that  she  could not remember three items.  The consultant  reports that he told Sibling 3 that in his opinion, Catherine was suffering from dementia.  13  Two and a half years after the first GP and NMGH recognition of dementia, and over fifteen months after Catherine’s in-patient stay, during which dementia is frequently cited by NMGH staff,  the diagnosis would hardly be news to this sibling.  Sibling 3 had rejected all mental health support for Catherine since her discharge on September 12th 2xxx.   Just before the consultant’s  visit,  Catherine was prescribed  prednisalone by  her usual GP at practice A, in Blackley. 14  Following the consultant’s visit, and once again recognised as a mental health patient, suffering from dementia, Catherine was prescribed Donepezil, (Aricept) and escitalopram ( Lexapro).   Assigned to Catherine’s care on  13/12/2xxx, most of the CPN’s reports  throughout the following year refer to information obtained from Sibling 3, rather than from Catherine herself. On January  28th 2xxx  Sibling 3 stated that Catherine’s conduct was always different if doctors and nurses were present. 15

In January and February 2xxx, Catherine is reported as being willing to try day care, if her husband can come too.  According to Catherine’s mental health records, the proposed day care trial didn’t go ahead because William was unwell. 16  On  March 3rd 2xxx,   the CPN reported that Catherine’s daughter and husband were feeling the strain  caused by Catherine’s behaviour and wanted her to go into day care. 17  On the 6th March, the consultant psychiatrist wrote   to Catherine’s GP at Practice A, concerning proposed treatment for Catherine, and information he had from William’s social worker, concerning the effect of Catherine’s ill health on William’s mental health. 18  In Catherine’s records, there is no indication that  an effect on William had been observed by the consultant himself. 

A home care package was authorised, before permanent residential  placement.  Placed in respite care for a month, Catherine remained at the White Moss Care Centre in Blackley  until April 18th. 
Jane was informed by Sibling 2 that Catherine was in  this local authority care home.  Visiting  this  home for the first time, Jane was shocked by her mother’s emaciation. Barely 5ft 2”,  Catherine had been sturdily built, her usual dress size being 14 or 16- the average dress size  for British women.  Two years previously, NMGH admission records identified her as ' average height and weight'.   So thin, she was almost unrecognisable, Catherine knew her eldest daughter at once, saying, ‘ I thought I would never see you again.’  In marked contrast to other accounts entered in NHS records for 2xxx, she walked steadily, without requiring any walking aids.  Jane  made two more visits during this four week placement. The second visit was with her husband and their daughters, then on her own.  For the third visit,in April, William was also at White Moss.  He was, as always, highly sociable, but as  one of Jane's aunts  had reported the previous year,  the change in his mental state was obvious.   Also, William appeared to have formed a friendship with another resident, paying attention to this lady rather than to Catherine.  Trying to talk to both parents, Jane  saw her father excluding Catherine by gesture.  When Jane was saying goodbye, William initiated an intimate kiss.  Jane reported this  difficult experience to her GP,  but felt unable to talk to her husband about her father’s  action  until September that year.   Visiting Catherine  at this local authority care home in March, April, July, October and November 2xxx, Jane ’s requests for information were invariably refused, on the supposed grounds that she was ‘not an authorised person’, a phrase often repeated by staff.     
On April 21st,  a CPN reported that William’s latest TIA ‘ might have been brought on by stress’.   According to this report, Catherine thumped her husband and hit out at her daughter.’ 19   Stress is identified as a factor in transient ischaemic attacks, but William began to suffer TIA’s in the late 1980’s.  Released to Jane  in  late October 2013,  William’s records from the Manchester Royal Infirmary  date one attack to October  10th 1988, two months before the birth of Jane’s youngest daughter.    

On April 22nd 2xxx,  Catherine’s social worker sent a care  cluster report to Manchester City Council.  The code identifies ongoing or recurrent psychosis.
Identified as presenting a danger to her husband, to herself and to others, Catherine is reported as lacking insight, and having no recollection of her aggressive behaviour.  20

It is reported that Catherine refused to eat.  According to the social worker, 
‘her daughter has had to liquidise food and spoon feed her’  After a meal, she rushes to the bathroom, after which particles of food are seen in the wash hand basin. ‘ 

Supposedly, the daughter suspected bulimia.  Catherine was 87.  Eating disorders usually present in childhood or adolescence.  Anorexia  can affect people in later life, especially women, but the average age of onset is 16 /17, and bulimia slightly later.  21 Suffering from bulimia, people do not refuse to eat.  They consume excessive amounts of food, then, typically, induce vomiting.  Force fed liquidised sandwiches, the victim of such physical abuse might well be nauseated and vomit.  The force feeding of liquidised sandwiches has not been disputed.   Responding to the Local Government Ombudsman, Manchester City Council staff refer to this treatment of Catherine as ‘imaginative’ .   Released to Jane , the Manchester City Council report does not include any panel discussion regarding the ethics or legality of force-feeding liquidised sandwiches to a frail 87 year old.  

NHS Mental Health and Social Services staff accepted , apparently without question or evidence, varying explanations offered by Sibling 3 for Catherine’s extreme weight loss.  On June 2nd  that year,  an NHS mental health  neuropsychiatric score sheet records, without presenting evidence, a history of abusing laxatives.  In other mental health records, it is reported that Catherine never went out.  She had no access to any money, was not able to leave the house, yet the 'laxative abuse'  claim is entered as if fact.  22

Some states continue the force feeding of prisoners.  In this review, there is no need to give examples.  In the context of international law, the United Nations  has often wavered, intermittently denouncing force-feeding as torture or in some cases, essential. 23  In any circumstances, force feeding is abuse.24  Force-feeding of the suffragettes is recognised as abuse suffered in the cause of democratic rights. In 1991, reaffirming the position stated in the 1975 Declaration of Tokyo the World Medical Association said that forcible feeding is "never ethically acceptable"."Even if intended to benefit, feeding accompanied with threats, coercion, force or use of physical restraints is a form of inhuman and degrading treatment. Equally unacceptable is the force feeding of some detainees in order to intimidate or coerce other hunger strikers to stop fasting," it said. 

The  Manchester City Council panel approved funded permanent placement.  The social worker’s account of Catherine’s extreme behaviour and the risks presented to her husband and daughter includes the observation that Catherine ‘seems to behave differently with strangers and could be more articulate with them.’ 25  The account of Catherine’s reported verbal and physical aggression towards her daughter and husband is in marked contrast to her observed demeanour in respite care and in hospital.

Regarding Manchester ‘s  authorisation of Catherine’s placement in permanent care, Jane  was her parents’ nearest relative. Referring Catherine for permanent placement, the social worker identified her as presenting a danger to her husband, to herself and to others, and lacking insight.  Authorised by public authorities, any placement in care, whether temporary or permanent,on the grounds that either of them presented a risk to themselves or to others,  should have been referred to Catherine and William’s  nearest relative.  Claims that Jane  had now ceased to be the nearest relative, on the grounds that Catherine and William were now ‘residing’ with Sibling 3 are invalid . In repeated safeguarding referrals, by phone, landline, in a formal Frail and Vulnerable adults letter, and finally, face to face at the PALS office of the NMGH on August 22nd 2xxx, Jane  had warned that Catherine and William were at risk both because of the physical risks of dementia and blindness, and also, that they were at risk from Sibling 3, giving grave reasons for this. 
The social worker’s report includes a reference made by a CPN on this panel to Jane ’s Vulnerable Adults referral, sent to the  city council in February 2xxx,  more than two years previously, warning that Catherine was at risk from Sibling 3. No attempt was made by Manchester City Council  to contact Jane .
On April 30th, the social worker reported that funding for 24 hour care had been granted. Sibling 3 could inspect local care homes. 26   Catherine would have to complete financial assessments with Sibling 3 and her brother.  The wording of this entry is ambiguous. It could mean Sibling 4,  still in  South America,  or Catherine’s own brother, who lived in Greater Manchester.  The eldest of Catherine’s four brothers, he was in his  mid eighties.

Authorising anybody’s permanent placement in care is a serious matter. Identified as suffering from dementia, defined in her NHS mental health records as ‘advanced’,and wrongly identified as ‘Mary’ who had only minimal assets and a different medical and personal history,  Catherine was to be deprived permanently of her liberty.  Sometimes, for serious health reasons, it is necessary to restrict a vulnerable person’s liberty.   The denial of  health care is just one of the abuses identifiable in Catherine’s  NHS records Furthermore, she was to become the unwilling and wholly innocent party to a supposed fraud, censured by Manchester City Council for failing to disclose her true assets. 

NHS Mental Health and Social Services staff failed to undertake the most basic checks to establish Catherine’s personal history, including her medical history. Authorising fully funded placement,  the senior manager and social worker did not undertake any financial review. Properly conducted, enabling Catherine to speak for herself rather than be represented always by a third party could have identified many  of the ‘ misrepresentations’ which damaged  Catherine, . These failures took place in the city which had employed Catherine as a teacher for her entire forty year career, and now paid her headteacher’s pension.

The funding of any mental health care for Catherine raises many questions. As a mental health patient, in the care of the NHS, Catherine should have received care appropriate to her  assessed mental and physical needs.  Identified by her consultant old age psychiatrist as suffering from two kinds of dementia  she was identified as having a Care Cluster 12 mental disorder in April 2xxx. In December 2008, the psychiatrist’s report to her GP identifies psychotic depression. Submitted in April 2xxx the Care Cluster 12 application for Catherine  was reopened  on December  9th  2xxx  Catherine’s   NHS hospital and social care experiences since the first long placement had been difficult.23

When somebody in their twenties, thirties, forties or fifties is recognised to be suffering from a serious mental health condition, they are entitled, and in some situations,  must be compelled to receive treatment and care as an NHS  mental health patient.   The same should be true for anybody in their sixties, seventies, eighties or older  who is suffering from a mental health condition  which identifies them as a danger to themselves and others.  Catherine’s mental health had been assessed by NHS doctors, with some input from community psychiatric nurses.  In her late eighties, if she was suffering from a mental illness,  Catherine was entitled to be treated for this illness, in the same way as any other NHS patient.

Catherine had also been identified as suffering from dementia.  This review does not seek to differentiate between the fiscal status of Catherine’s mental health conditions. The funding of care for people affected by dementia is a political decision.  The majority of those affected by any form of dementia are over 65, but dementia it is not a normal and inevitable concomitant of ageing.  Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s are diseases which occur as a result of neurodegenerative processes  In Catherine’s case, heart disease is implicated as a contributory factor to her illness.

Neuro-degenerative diseases which cause the conditions identified as dementias  have different names. Currently, all such conditions are incurable.   The NHS functions successfully if patients respond to treatment and get better.   Dementia doesn’t fit well into such concepts as the Quality and Outcomes Framework  or any  other model of positive patient outcomes. 27   Delivering Social Care, Social Services departments throughout the country focus on positive outcomes too.  Positive outcomes are cost-effective … Until effective treatment is developed, and ideally, prevention, people living with dementia cannot get better and their increasing inability to live as independent adults is frequently defined in the vocabulary of anti-social behaviour and criminality.  People with dementia are described as being ‘violent’ , ‘verbally and physically aggressive’ ‘sexually disinhibited’  28

Determining how Catherine’s  care and mental health care was to be funded is far from straightforward, and further complicated by the misrepresentation of her history and extensive misuse of her assets by Sibling 3, and the approval of a funded placement, as a danger to herself and others.   Serious referrals, warning that William and Catherine were both  at risk from Sibling 3 had been ignored by the NHS and by Social Services.  Discharged by the NMGH into the ‘ care’ of the person identified in all safeguarding referrals,  Catherine’s  NHS mental health and general medical care was obstructed for over fifteen months,  Between September 2xxxand late January 2xxx, she lost almost all the assets which should have been hers.  From August 23rd 2xxx Catherine had no access to her headteacher’s pension, her state pension, or any use of her bank accounts and savings, and no access to her own house,  where the locks had been changed and to which  all financial correspondence was still delivered,.  The  continued use of this house for all  Catherine and William’s correspondence enabled Sibling 3   unrestricted use of Catherine and William’s accounts.   If any of these circusental health condition, the need for prompt and effective police action would be clear. As a patient of the Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust, with a  GP and NHS trust diagnosis of dementia in 2xxx,  every aspect of Catherine’s personal, medical and career history had been misrepresented by Sibling 3,  including her financial status. 

Permanent care had been authorised by the Manchester City Council panel after Catherine had been identified as presenting a danger to her husband, to herself and to others.  29   Given such a diagnosis , Catherine should have received treatment and specialist mental health care, as an NHS patient, whatever her age.   Yet the placement did not go ahead.  For reasons which have not been investigated either by the NHS or by the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman, Sibling 3 was able to regard this serious mental health placement as optional, choosing instead a succession of placements in ‘respite care’.  After Catherine was identified as as presenting a danger to others as well as to herself, why was Sibling 3 then permitted to disregard the local authority panel decision ?  The succession of  ‘respite’ placements used in March, April, July, August, October and November 2xxx, and the  extended twenty-four day  hospital stay in July and August  of the same year  cannot have been beneficial to Catherine’s mental health.  30

Why didn’t the  authorised placement proceed ?   In Catherine’s records, this would appear to be entirely Sibling 3’s decision,.  Shortly after  Catherine’s permanent placement in care was authorised,  Sibling 3 was advised that a financial review would be required.   Instead of  the authorised NHS placement and appropriate treatment and support for extreme mental distress, Catherine’s serial placements in respite care began. Financially, the requirements for payment are different.  The expectation is that people will return to their own homes.  31    Whatever the reason for Sibling 3’s decision,  Catherine’s mental health needs should have been paramount.  Instead, they were disregarded.  Mental Health professionals had identified an urgent and immediate need for care and treatment.  In Catherine’s Mental Health records, no evidence for Sibling 3’s sudden reversal is presented.  No searching questions were asked.  Crucially for Catherine,  mental health support was denied.  By  May 21st  and despite the recognition of Catherine’s mental health needs by the Mental Health and Social Care Trust,Sibling 3   had decided against permanent care.  32 Sibling 3 had no legal authority over Catherine whatsoever.  She had not been appointed as Catherine’s deputy, nor had she been granted Lasting Power of Attorney for health or financial affairs.  In the case of serious mental illness, Catherine and William’s  supposed or actual financial circumstances are not relevant.  They were lifelong UK residents, with a right to NHS  healthcare.  Some NHS patients have well paid professional careers. Others need to claim benefits.  All have a right to medical care, for mental or physical illness. . In April 2xxx, according to Catherine’s NHS records,  an urgent and immediate  mental health need had been identified, and a serious decision sought from  Manchester City Council.  In December 2xxx, the social worker would request that the  case should be reopened.

On May 21st, Catherine’s CPN, still referring to her client as ‘ Mary,’ discussed the decision not to pursue the option of permanent care for her mother. 33  On April 22nd, the social worker had reported that a client was a danger to her husband, to herself and to others.  This is not a statement which should be made lightly, nor is the decision reached by the panel one which should be so easily overturned. Sibling 3’s  ability  to care adequately for anyone affected by the mental health problems detailed on April 22nd  does not appear to be questioned.  Catherine had been identified as suffering from a serious mental disorder.  There  are no reports  in Catherine’s  NHS mental health records of any  treatment or therapy  during  extended respite placements.

FUNDING

‘Temporary’ stays in a care home can be for up to 52 weeks and can be paid for in two ways:

1. the local authority can apply the financial assessment straight away or
2. they can ask the person that needs care to pay a ‘reasonable amount’ for the first eight weeks, then apply the financial assessment.

The financial assessment for respite care in a care home is similar to that used for permanent care in a care home. The local authority will use the same upper and lower limits when assessing capital (see Capital limits for care homes), but they will ignore:

1.0 the value of your relative’s home as they intend to go back to it
2.0 some of your relative’s income so that they can continue to pay bills at home, such as water rates and insurance
3.0 any Housing Benefit and the housing cost element in Pension Credit.

On June 2nd 2xxx, Catherine was seen at the  memory clinic. The gastric and cardiac effects of cognitive enhancers were discussed with Sibling 3.  The best known of such enhancers is donepezil, usually known as Aricept  34   On June 13th, the report of this consultation was sent to Dr A, at the Blackley practice.   Catherine’s GP needed to know what medication had been prescribed to one of his patients by a hospital.  35  Aricept is not a ‘ magic bullet.  It does not cure dementia.  As the drug information warns  ‘ Therapy with donepezil should only be started if a caregiver is available who will regularly monitor medicinal product intake for the patient.’  36   On June 30th 2xxx , Catherine was again seen at the memory clinic with Sibling 3. The psychiatrist’s letter was sent to Dr A on July 3rd, detailing prescribed medication.  Catherine’s anxiety was recognised, but reasons for such a degree of anxiety do not appear to have been considered.  Catherine’s belief that she was to be, as she expressed it,  ‘ put away’ was correct and though not yet effected,  permanent placement had been approved.   Her next placement at White Moss would begin the next day. 
Early in July 2xxx, Sibling 2 alerted Jane  to this placement.. Reaching the residents’ day room, Jane  saw that Catherine appeared to be asleep.  She asked staff to tell Catherine that her daughter had come to see her.  Catherine immediately expressed intense fear, burying her face in the chair.  Recognising the implications, Jane, who was still standing at the entrance to the day room, asked a member of staff to go back, tell Catherine it was Jane.   Catherine then came across the room to meet Jane , walking steadily, distressed, but no longer expressing fear. She said : ‘ I know my mind doesn’t work, but this is right.   She’s  taken everything, and has taken your Dad.’
Remembering her father’s inappropriate kiss in April,  Jane had some indication of Catherine’s profound distress, but did not, of course, say anything to Catherine about this.  

No Secrets

This guidance builds on the Government’s respect for human rights and results from its firm intention to close a significant gap in the delivery of those rights alongside the coming into force of the Human Rights Act 1998.
The agencies’ primary aim should be to prevent abuse where possible but, if the preventive  strategy fails, agencies should ensure that robust procedures are in place for dealing with incidents of abuse. The circumstances in which harm and exploitation occur are known to be extremely diverse, as is the  membership of the at-risk group. The challenge has been to identify the next step forward in responding to this diversity.’

One step which has still not been taken is identifying the at risk group  not safeguarded in any way, because their self identified carers are not  assessed in accordance with any legislation governing vulnerable groups,  Suffering from dementia, Catherine tried, repeatedly, to tell people  about herself, including the house she and William owned in Blackley. 37

On July 11th 2xxx, Catherine  had reported ongoing and very extensive abuses to her eldest daughter, Jane   Jane  had no part in organising this  or any other placement.   Querying payment arrangements for Catherine’s repeated placements, identified as ‘ respite care’, she was informed once again  by care home staff that she could not  have  any information, because she was ‘ not an authorised person’.   One member of staff added that as Catherine was a pensioner, there was no charge.   As a retired headteacher, with an unbroken forty year career, including ten years as a deputy head, and ten as headteacher, Catherine had both the appropriate professional pension and her state pension.  Catherine and her husband owned their own house outright, having bought the property in 1947,  Jane  did not as yet have access to any financial records.  Obtaining legitimate access to this information would take many months. 

Catherine herself asked staff if she and Jane could go somewhere private to talk.  The request was granted.  Catherine spoke more about the ongoing abuse.  Catherine and William’s bank statements document extensive activity throughout a summer of repeated care placements and a long hospital stay.  As NHS and Social Services staff had already authorised Catherine’s placement in permanent care,  as a risk to herself and others,  reference to her own and her husband’s assets is appropriate.  Both the NHS and Social services had  a legal responsibility to safeguard Catherine and William’s  property.   

On July 14th 2xxx, Catherine  was returned to the house of Sibling 3.  Two days later, she was referred to the North Manchester General Hospital, suffering from breathing problems.  The referral was made from GP practice B,  in Crumpsall, which had no records for this new patient.  For this admission, Catherine’s status as a UK resident is queried and laboratory tests assigned the NHS emergency code ZZZZ 999.  38  As one NHS Trust website explains, ‘ The Laboratory recognises that the NHS number of a patient may not always be readily available. In such circumstances, where the patient may be a temporary resident or new to the practice, this must be indicated on the request card. Please use the code “ZZZZ 999” on the request card if the NHS number is unavailable. Warrington & Halton Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust .

Triage records  for this admission include bruising to her hands. 39  Bruising identified on admission should have been accurately documented, detailing the site of any bruises.  Catherine had just returned from a care home operated by Manchester City Council.  Further triage records report that Catherine was able to speak in full sentences, explaining that her breathing was not always so bad. 

Records for the following day include a reference to ‘ underlying dementia, diagnosed recently.’  40  This statement is untrue.  Catherine’s diagnosis of dementia was far from recent.  How had this incorrect information been provided ?    For such a serious condition, accurate monitoring of a patient’s illness is essential if effective support and care is to be delivered.   Dementia was recognised by her GP at Practice A,  in Blackley three years earlier, before June 21st 2xxx, cited in the  Manchester Care Assessment Schedule of that date, and is documented in her North Manchester General Hospital records for July 4th 2xxx  NMGH.  Dementia had been recognised at this hospital  in August and September 2006, and in the discharge letter for her GP . 41    Discharged, despite all safeguarding referrals, to Sibling 3, further mental health care  was then denied for fifteen months.

On July 18th 2xxx , two days after she was referred to the NMGH from  GP practice B, in Crumpsall, Catherine’s records identify ‘no indication for acute admission, medically fit for discharge’  Sibling 3 is described as ‘very worried’ about Catherine and William being together and could not be with the patient at all times. 42   Catherine was moved to Ward C4 and remained in hospital until August 8th, twenty four days after being referred by a new practice, and twenty-two days after she was identified as medically fit for discharge,. She was then   placed in Temple Bank Care Home, a placement for which the discharge date is unclear. On August 27th an Admiral nurse came to Sibling 3’s house to visit Catherine . 43 

On  September  1st 2xxx the CPN assigned to this case wrote to the consultant psychiatrist, informing him that the patient  this nurse always refers to as  ‘Mary’ was now stable.   The CPN considered discharge was appropriate.  Visiting  the woman  she calls ‘ Mary’ since December the previous year,  this CPN had never recognised the name used by Catherine all her life.  The impact of the wrong forename on  anybody suffering from dementia  is hard to imagine.   On September 3rd 2xxx the discharge letter, including the medications prescribed following Catherine’s 24 day  hospital stay was sent to the referring  GP practice in Crumpsall. 44

In September, Sibling 2 informed Jane of the ongoing plans to move to Wales. Catherine’s position at this point seemed uncertain.  Placed repeatedly in ‘respite care’ in Manchester, such placements were likely to continue in Wales.   Sibling 2  then indicated that  Catherine ‘might not be well enough to move to Wales’ but Sibling 3 would  be moving there with William.   Jane , who did not know about the  permanent placement authorised  on April 23rd 2xxx by Manchester City Council,   consulted Age Concern immediately ( Age UK).  Meetings were arranged with senior Age UK staff. Jane  was advised to refer the matter again to the local authority.  Once again, no action was taken.  Jane  contacted Catherine’s original CPN again. The CPN responded that Catherine’s consent would be required before Jane  could have access to NHS information concerning Catherine.  As Jane  explained, this would not be possible, as she did not have access to her mother.  45   On the few occasions when access was  possible,  Catherine was  usually  in the local authority care home, where Jane  was ‘ not an authorised person’, and not allowed  any information.  Just once, Jane  had access to her mother at the house of Sibling 3. 

For several days in October that year,  Sibling 2 was at this house, in charge of William and Catherine, while Sibling 3 and an associate went to Wales, in connection with the property under construction.  On Saturday October 4th, Jane  was able to see her parents at the house to which they had been removed in September 2006. Sibling 2 present throughout  Jane’s visit.  Obvious in April, William’s mental deterioration had continued.  Catherine appeared to be asleep for most of Jane ’s visit.  As William complained
‘ Sleep, sleep, all she ever does is sleep’ 

The clothes Catherine was wearing were faded and evidently second hand.  She had lost so much weight, none of her former size 14 + clothes would have fitted.  Waking intermittently, Catherine was distressed, saying, repeatedly, ‘ I don’t know who I am. I’m not me.’   Supporting anybody suffering from dementia, responsible carers do everything possible to maintain the sense of identity and enable people to take part in daily life.  Catherine was still able to read, but couldn't remember what she had just read.  Core memories were her strong.    Even two and a half years later, on March 4th 2xxx in another care home, she asked about a book which she could see in Jane ’s bag.  The book was in French, which Catherine had  read and spoken well,  but on the second page, the narrative introduces German  place names, Auschwitz, Belsen, Ravensbruck, Dachau.  Catherine said, immediately, ‘Have you been there ? Have you been to the camps ?  46

Later in October 2xxx  Sibling 2 notified Jane  that Catherine was once again in care. The change in Catherine’s condition was striking.  On October 4th, she had been asleep most of the time and distressed when awake.   Dementia symptoms fluctuate, but not usually so dramatically.   On October 27th,  Catherine was focused, coherent, able to define her situation, and to express clear wishes.    She did  not wish to remain with Sibling 3.  She recognised the need for support, and wanted to be in care with William.  They should have enough money to pay for this. They had their savings, the house. She used to have her headteacher’s pension.  Catherine’s use of the past tense was accurate.  Although there were no witnesses present, reporting this discussion is legitimate. This time, they did not move to a private room.  The entire visit took place in the main day room of the White Moss care centre.   Staff were  present in the room.  Bank statements released to Jane  in 2xxx confirm that Catherine’s reports regarding her own and her husband’s assets were correct. They had had savings, and their own house, and in addition to two state pensions, they had had Catherine’s headteacher’s pension – more than enough to meet the needs of two people in their late eighties and late nineties, but, as  Catherine reported to Jane  on July 11th,  also at  White Moss Sibling 3 had taken everything.  The  initial move was to add Sibling 3’s name to a joint savings account.   Catherine’s name was then removed.  47


Protect yourself and others from abuse - Age UK

Elder abuse can take many forms, including financial, emotional, physical and sexual. ... Call the Age UK Advice Line 0800 678 1174 if you are concerned about abuse ... When you report abuse to Adult Social Services, they will listen to the information you give them and assess what action is required.

Financial Abuse

Financial Abuse/harm is another name for stealing or defrauding someone of goods and/or property. It is always a crime but is not always prosecuted. Sometimes the issue is straightforward, for example a careworker stealing from an older person’s purse, but at other times it is more difficult to address. This is because very often the perpetrator can be someone’s son or daughter, or age prejudice means that other people assume it is not happening or that the older person is to blame.
Two common issues that come to our attention are (a) sons or daughters attempting to justify their actions on the basis that they are simply obtaining their inheritance  in advance and (b) the misuse of Powers of Attorney.
Financial abuse/harm can happen because the older person can be seen as an easy way of getting money, particularly if they are dependent or confused. It can happen because there is an assumption that the likelihood of criminal penalties is small if the perpetrator is caught. And it can happen because the current protective systems  are weak.

What are the signs of Financial abuse/harm?

1. Signatures on cheques etc., that do not resemble the older person’s signature, or signed when the older person cannot write.
2. Sudden changes in bank accounts, including unexplained withdrawals of large sums of money by a person accompanying the older person.
3. The inclusion of additional names on an older person’s bank account.
4. Abrupt changes to, or the sudden establishment of, wills.
5. The sudden appearance of previously uninvolved relatives claiming their rights to an older person’s affairs or possessions.
6. The unexplained sudden transfer of assets to a family member or someone outside the family
7. Numerous unpaid bills, or overdue rent, when someone else is supposed to be paying the bills.
8. Unusual concern by someone that an excessive amount of money is being expended on the care of the older person.
9. Lack of amenities, such as TV, personal grooming items, appropriate clothing, that the older person should be able to afford.
10. The unexplained disappearance of funds or valuable possessions such as art, silverware, or jewellery.
11. Deliberate isolation of an older person from friends and family, resulting in the caregiver alone having total control

At the White Moss office, Jane  was again refused any information about her mother.  Catherine had taught in this Manchester suburb for forty years.  Many of her former pupils still lived in the area.  Jane had to leave, intending to visit William,  who was a patient at the NMGH, after another TIA. Recognising Jane, a member of staff followed her outside the building and called out her name.  She didn’t know what was going on, only that during her shifts, William had never been brought to visit Catherine.   At the NMGH,  William  appeared more confused than he had been on October 4th.  During Jane ’s visit ,  he needed the lavatory.  He was away for so long that Jane  became concerned, asking ward staff how he would find his way back.  Staff didn’t recognise the reason for her concern.  When Jane  referred to William’s blindness, staff asked why she was claiming that William was blind ?  William had been blind for more than ten years.  Living in his own home, as a blind resident,  with a Registered Blind Person’s card, issued by Manchester City Council, he had received local authority sensory support.  Trying to obtain any information about her father, Jane  asked to see the ward manager.  This elicited the following question: 
‘Who are you?  Where do you come in this family?  Are you a half sibling?'

Born in this hospital, the address stated on her full birth certificate, eldest of William and Catherine’s children, and the only sibling to make any safeguarding referrals warning of the risks presented by Sibling 3, Jane became even more concerned.  Why were ward staff not aware of William’s blindness, surely essential for the safety of any visually impaired patient?

The nature of  Catherine’s illness compromised her  many attempts to report her situation. When someone is suffering from dementia, struggling with an increasingly imperfect memory, they may attempt to make sense of situations and confusing  experiences  through a narrative device identified as  'confabulation’.   Abuses reported  by dementia patients, including financial abuse, can be too readily identified as confabulation.  Analysis of Catherine’s NHS records confirm that throughout the years of deliberate misrepresentation by others, she  was reporting the truth,  the whole truth,  in so far as this was known to her, and  always, nothing but the truth. 48


1 Manchester City Council assessment form, 13/12/2007, also 13/12/2007 Event 9 . MMH/SCT
2   1/09/2xxx Known to Park House. P 67728.  NMGH
3  Combined aortic and mitral regurgitation-a scenario difficult to manage  https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article
4.Rheumatic fever – Circulation circ.ahajournals.org/content/circulationaha/76/6/1190.full.pdf
by EF Bland - ‎1987
5   Hajar R. Rheumatic Fever and Rheumatic Heart Disease a Historical Perspective. Heart Views : The Official Journal of the Gulf Heart Association. 2016;17(3):120-126. doi:10.4103/1995-705X.192572.
6  Event 12 20/12/2xxx  Consultant to GP  Practice A, MMH/SCT 
7 17/04/2xxxConsultant to Jane’s solicitors, regarding Court iof Protection. 
8  BD8 1990, completed by consultant opthalmic surgeon, Manchester Royal Eye Hospital     13/10/1998
9 28 07/12/2007 ‘ Previously refused services’ See 04/12/2006. letter, GP practice A  to chest clinic, NMGH.
10 20/12/2xxx Event 12  Consultant to GP practice A.
11   14/12/2xxx  request sitting service.   & welfare rights.   
12   Carer's Allowance – GOV.UK    https://www.gov.uk/carers-allowance
13   20/12/2xxx, Consultant to GP practice A. MMH/SCT 
14 08/12/2xxx NMGH  Clinical notes  ‘ prednisalone prescribed by GP two days ago
 i.e, December 6th. 
15.  28/01/2008 Event 21        CPN MMH/SCT   
16  09/01/2xxx Event 17. Client visit   Willing to try day care, but only if husband can go too…
17  Event 24, 03/03/2008.   CPN,
18 06/03/2008, consultant to GP    at  practice  A, in Blackley. 
19  21/04/2xxx Event 30.  MMH/SCT.
20 , 23  04 2xxx. Manchester Mental Health & Manchester City Council records, care placements
21  About Eating Disorders | Anorexia & Bulimia Care www.anorexiabulimiacare.org.uk/about/about-eating-disorder
22   NHS Mental Health,  02/06/2008.
23  Force-Feeding Authorised for War Crimes defendant.www.washingtonpost.com 
24  Recognising adult abuse, exploitation and neglect | nidirect
https://www.nidirect.gov.uk/articles/recognising-adult-abuse-exploitation-and-neglect
25   23 04 2xxx, MMH/SCT & M/cr City Council .
26   30/04/2xxx Event 31. MMH/SCT
27  Quality and Outcomes Framework: what have we learnt? BMJ 2016;354:i4060
28  How to deal with violent and aggressive patients in acute medical ...https://www.rcpe.ac.uk/sites/default/files/jrcpe_47_2_harwood.pd
29   23/04 2xxx, and 9/12/2xxx    Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust.
30  - The Alzheimer's Society says dementia sufferers were being forced to endure long stays in frightening and unfamiliar hospital surroundings. March 2015
31  30/04/2xxx Event 31.  MMH/SCT
32  Paying for temporary care in a care home - Age UK  https://www.ageuk.org.uk
33  21/05/2008 Event 35 ‘ decided against residential care, instead, respite  MMH/SCT 
34  02/06/2xxx MMH/SCT 
35  Intern Med. 2012;51(6):575-8. Epub 2012 Mar 15.Cardiac safety of donepezil in elderly patients with Alzheimer disease.Isik AT1, Yildiz GB, Bozoglu E, Yay A, Aydemir E. 
36  www.medicines.org.uk/
37  25/03/2xxx   MMH/SCT.
38 16/07/2xxx NMGH
39  16/07/2xxx  2.p.m. Triage NMGH. 
40  17.07 2xxx NMGH.  
41 1/08/2xxx, 22/08/2xxx 23/08,  01/09/2006 and other entries
42  18/07 2xxx, NMGH
43  27/08/2xxx , event 44 Admiral Nurse, MMH/SCT
44   Consultant Chest physician, to GP Practice B.  03/09/2xxx
45   31/10 2xxx , 18/11/2xxx   Letters from Jane to  origianl CPN,  reporting lack of access to Catherine.
46  March 4th 2xxx  The book was Nuit et Brouillard
47  Abbey/Santander accounts, which document major financial activity .
48 What is Confabulation? Alzheimer's and Dementia Support -https://medtransportcenter.com/what-is-confabulation-alzheimers-dementia-support

Why conduct a Serious Case Review ?

4.1.2 An adult at risk has sustained a potentially life-threatening injury through abuse or neglect suffered, serious sexual abuse, or sustained serious and permanent impairment of health or development through abuse or neglect, and the case gives rise to concerns about the way in which local professionals and services work together to safeguard adults in vulnerable situations

44.1.4 Financial, institutional or systemic abuse where the outcome may not be life threatening but may have a long-term detrimental effect on a person’s well-being and it is of a nature where there are serious negative outcomes for the individuals concerned