5 Serious Negative Outcomes ?
Sibling 2 provided the address of the property being built in Ceredigion.
Catherine in care again.
Catherine not allowed to visit her husband in hospital, because of her dementia.
Use of two GP practices continues.
Financial and legal activity ongoing, and new build in Wales. .
Office of the Public Guardian advises report to the police.
Greater Manchester Police reject ‘unfounded allegations’ .
Jane:Letter to Manchester Mental Health, reporting human rights and financial abuse.
Gives address of ongoing construction in Wales.
Consultant old age psychiatrist received Jane’s letter.
Consultant directed letter should be copied to care manager, by email.
(NHS electronic records)
Letters from NHS Trust psychiatrist to both GP practices on successive days.
Diagnosis of psychotic depression.
Catherine‘s placement in permanent care.
Collapse, slow heart, borderline renal impairment, fits.
Catherine, in hospital, reports emotional and psychological abuse, Sibling 3’s sexually inappropriate conduct with William.
Sibling 3 insists Catherine be returned
Care manager directs NMGH staff – discharge Catherine to Sibling 3
’sure she will be well looked after.’ - NHS records
Care manager had received Jane's written report of extensive ongoing financial abuse, and had evidence of Catherine’s distress at the house of Sibling 3,
including quantities of hair she'd pulled out.
Sibling 2 forwards email documenting six-figure abuse.
Reported to Manchester Social Services by Jane.
No action taken.
Are you a half-sibling ?
The ward manager’s question was extraordinary. Eldest of four, always living with her parents until leaving home for university at eighteen, visiting regularly, warning they were at risk the day before losing contact for over 18 months, Jane would have to prove this claim repeatedly. The ward manager questioned Jane ’s claim regarding William’s blindness. Why say that her father was blind ? Concealing the fact that William had been blind for years was all too easy. Sensory Support services had been provided to him, as a blind resident, by Manchester City Council but this was at his home address in Blackley. 1 Next day,October 28th 2xxx, Jane rang the White Moss care home, asking if she would be able to take her mother to visit her father in hospital. The White Moss manager raised no objection to the proposed visit. At the hospital, the response was very different. NMGH ward staff informed Jane that her mother could not be allowed to visit William because of her dementia.
Dismissed repeatedly as ‘not an authorised person’ by care home staff, Jane began to recognise the significance of what had been achieved. Removed from their own home, and effectively, their whole world, Catherine and William had ceased to be her parents. More accurately, Jane herself had ceased to be recognised as her parents’ child, except, that is, by people who had known her and her parents when they lived in Blackley for so many decades. Eldest child of their marriage, and therefore their nearest relative after each other, Jane had not been included in the narrative now accepted by NHS Mental Health and Social Services staff and by the NMGH. Neither NHS nor Social Services staff can have checked Catherine's existing NHS and social care records. They appear to have accepted fictions from a single source. William’s blindness had been concealed. The concealment of William’s blindness and other serious health problems is evident in NHS reports concerning Catherine’s acknowledged mental illness.
The ease with which this concealment was achieved is most readily understood by moving forward to the release of Catherine’s records to Jane in August and September 2011, October 2013, June 2014, and, via Greater Manchester Police, in July 2016, when GMP released their own correspondence with the Central Manchester University Hospitals' ( Requested as Freedom of Information from GMP but not released as such.) Receiving the first two consignments of records, the first impression was of chaos. Numbering each document in pencil and retaining the original order, as released from Trust headquarters, every record was then scanned and a timeline created. Reports on Catherine’s mental health came from different community mental health teams. Catherine and William’s surname was extremely common. Removed from the suburb where she had lived for almost 86 years, then denied mental health support for over fifteen months, Catherine – routinely referred to and addressed as ‘ Mary’ by community psychiatric nurses and by social services, could become another person, her existing medical history comprehensively ‘misrepresented’ or falsified by Sibling 3. Even the claim that Catherine had been well and active until May/June 2xxx was accepted without question – this despite Catherine’s three weeks of inpatient care at the NMGH in August and September the previous year., and existing three year contact with Manchester’s mental health services for older people. Visited by a new mental health team, Catherine’s connection with the world she had now lost wasn’t recognised, This abrupt and total separation from the social environment of her life before dementia is very likely to have exacerbated disorientation. The emotional and psychological distress of dementia would be magnified. 2
The area where Catherine had spent almost her entire life became, to an NHS hospital psychiatrist, prescribing anti-psychotic and antidepressant medication, only ‘where she’d lived as a child’. On November 7th 2xxx Jane visited Catherine again at the White Moss care home. Shortly after this visit, Sibling 2 provided the address of the property under construction, near New Quay, at the southern end of Cardigan Bay and approximately twenty-eight miles by road from the nearest hospital which has an A & E department. Supposedly, William would move there with Sibling 3, but at 98, he was increasingly frail, with a history of vascular dementia, uncorrected hearing impairment, and had been blind for nearly twelve years. Sibling 2 now indicated to Jane that Catherine ‘might not be well enough’ to leave Manchester. According to Catherine’s NHS Mental Health records, which include the diagnosis of a serious mental disorder, identified by NHS psychiatrists as ‘ psychotic depression’, she was to remain in Manchester, in the permanent care, authorised nearly eight months previously, following the referral by her social worker and senior care manager and approval by the Manchester City Council panel.
When Sibling 2 provided the address of the property near New Quay, and the information that Catherine could be remaining in Manchester, Jane approached the Office of the Public Guardian immediately. OPG staff advised that the matter should be reported to the police at once. This is the advice regarding ongoing elder abuse given on the UK government website, but Greater Manchester Police dismissed Jane ’s report as an unfounded allegation. During the same week of November 2008, Jane’s younger daughter, then a student in her second year at Sheffield university, rang to report that Sibling 3 was urging her to bring a powered wheelchair to Manchester, which Sibling 3 had sourced on ebay. How an able bodied young woman was to transport an unoccupied powered wheelchair by train and transport this vehicle across the city was not explained. William was blind. How could he use such a vehicle ? Jane’s daughter did not comply with Sibling 3’s request.
Repeated safeguarding referrals had been ignored. Following Jane’s direct referral at the North Manchester General PALS office, Catherine had been discharged to the person named in all safeguarding referrals. NHS staff then accepted Sibling 3’s directions controlling all access to Catherine. Suffering from dementia and aortic and mitral valve damage, Catherine had been denied medical care for fifteen months. Reporting ongoing abuse to the police had failed. On December 1st 2xxx, Jane wrote to the Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust, identifying ongoing human rights abuses and financial abuse. At the time, evidence of other abuse was less easily demonstrated. Catherine’s records confirm that NHS mental health professionals had accepted claims of ‘ bulimia’ and ‘laxative abuse’ to explain Catherine’s severe weight loss. Now, there was considerable evidence for the proposed permanent separation of husband and wife and the extensive misuse of their assets. The address of the property under construction was provided. To confirm Jane ’s position in the family and identify her as the person who had made many safeguarding referrals, the letter was sent to the CPN who had been involved in Catherine’s mental health care in 2xxx – 2xxx, during the early stages of Catherine’s illness. In October and November 2xxx, this CPN had been informed by letter that Jane was not able to obtain access to her parents. Catherine and William’s MP had the same information, and advised Jane that she could refer the situation to her own MP. Catherine’s original CPN had invited Jane to contact her again if she had further concerns. Sent by first class post, the letter had to be handwritten. In severe weather, Jane had no access to a computer or printer.
In November 2xxx, Catherine was still in respite care. This was her third prolonged placement at White Moss since March. In July and August, she had spent twenty-four days as an inpatient at the NMGH, and was then discharged to a different care home. Not notified about this placement, Jane didn’t know about Catherine’s time there until contacted by one of her mother’s friends. On July 11th, at White Moss, well aware of the ongoing financial abuse Catherine had reported to Jane that Sibling 3 had ‘ taken everything’ and had taken William. Bank statements and other records not released until the following year confirm the accuracy of Catherine’s report of financial abuse. NHS and social care records confirm that mental health professionals and Manchester City Council Social Services supported the relationship between Sibling 3 and William. 3
On December 8th, William was admitted to the NMGH. This would be his last illness. His NHS records for this period identify the history of vascular dementia, uncorrected hearing impairment and macular degeneration, but not the more detailed visual records held by the Central Manchester University Hospitals, documenting the two causes of irreversible sight loss. 4 On the same day, Jane’s letter is identified in NHS Mental Health records. The letter was then referred to Catherine’s consultant psychiatrist, as the lead professional.5 Three days later, the CPN to whom Jane ’s letter had been sent rang requesting consent to scan the handwritten letter, so that other members of staff could read it. Catherine’s consultant directed that the scanned letter be copied to Catherine’s care manager. The letter was copied to this manager by email on December 11th. 6
After receiving Jane’s written referral, reporting ongoing human rights and financial abuses of two very old and vulnerable people, no action was taken to address the abuse and prevent further abuse. The NHS consultant old age psychiatrist and the Social Services care manager should have reported the ongoing abuse of vulnerable adults in their care to the police within 24 hours of receiving Jane ’s letter.
Fraud Act 2006
If someone in public office, responsible for the safeguarding of vulnerable person has information concerning financial abuse and fails to disclose that information, they could be breaching the Fraud Act.
Fraud by failing to disclose information (Section 3)
The defendant:
1. failed to disclose information to another person
2. when he was under a legal duty to disclose that information
3. dishonestly intending, by that failure, to make a gain or cause a loss.
Like Section 2 (and Section 4) this offence is entirely offender focussed. It is complete as soon as the Defendant fails to disclose information provided he was under a legal duty to do so, and that it was done with the necessary dishonest intent. It differs from the deception offences in that it is immaterial whether or not any one is deceived or any property actually gained or lost.
Misconduct in Public Office
Failing in the performance of a public duty, in this case, the safeguarding of vulnerable older people, one of whom had been blind for over a decade, and both suffering from dementia, could be Misconduct in Public Office.
The elements of the offence are summarised in Attorney General's Reference No 3 of 2003 [2004] EWCA Crim 868. The offence is committed when:
. a public officer acting as such
. wilfully neglects to perform his duty and/or wilfully misconducts himself
. to such a degree as to amount to an abuse of the public's trust in the office holder
. without reasonable excuse or justification
.
In December 2xxx, alternating GP practices were used even when Catherine was about to be placed in permanent care, after an eight month delay in taking up the place kept open for her by a care provider which specialises in provision for people suffering from dementia. On December 10th 2xxx , Catherine was examined by a psychiatrist from the Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust. 7 The antipsychotic olanzapine was prescribed. There is no evidence that the psychiatrist or other mental health professionals had considered potential reasons for Catherine’s mental state. 8
On December 8th, two days before she was examined by the psychiatrist, her husband had been taken to hospital by ambulance. Paramedic records for this occasion record him as calling out ‘ Help me.’ 9 Catherine and William had been married for 62 years. Throughout the past year, she had been placed in respite care for extended periods away from him, and, as Jane was informed by a ward manager at the NMGH, could not be allowed to visit him because of her dementia. On record as presenting a danger to her husband, to herself and to others, she was not allowed to visit him in hospital. On December 9th, Catherine’s social worker had requested that Catherine’s case be re-opened, authorising permanent placement in care. A Care Cluster 12 form was requested, and faxed to the social worker.10
Catherine’s mental health records for this date do not include any consideration of her existing heart disease. The importance of physical examination for mental health patients had been stressed in many publications. 11 Medication used in the treatment of dementia must be strictly monitored. Directions concerning the timing of administration and the safety of any alcohol consumption must be respected. Given the comprehensive misrepresentation of Catherine’s general and mental health history by Sibling 3, reports from Sibling 3 of how well medication was tolerated by Catherine cannot be regarded as safe. After rejecting all mental health care for Catherine for fifteen months, Sibling 3 had claimed that Catherine was ‘ well and active’ until the summer of 2xxx, whereas her existing NHS documented history included dementia, aortic and mitral valve disease, and chronic breathing difficulties.
Throughout this period in December 2xxx, during which the intended outcome was that Catherine was to move into permanent care, in Manchester, letters from an NHS Trust concerning Catherine’s mental health were being sent to the two practices, even on successive days. On December 11th, the psychiatrist’s letter was sent to the GP practice B, in Crumpsall, which had made the July 16th referral to hospital of a new patient whose UK resident status was queried, and hospital tests undertaken using the NHS emergency code ZZZZ 999. 12 On December 12th 2xxx, the same psychiatrist is named in the Sprite network document identifying Catherine’s condition as psychotic depression. 13 This document was sent to GP practice A, in Blackley, identifying the GP who knew Catherine and had discussed his diagnosis of vascular dementia with Jane before 21st June 2xxx. The referral identifies Catherine’s husband as James, though he was always known as William, which was his only given name. 14
Following the diagnosis of psychotic depression, in a dementia patient aged almost 88 the introduction of anti-psychotics does not include any reference to Catherine’s history of heart valve disease. 15 A history of aggression is reported on the continuation sheet of this referral. An assessment was undertaken to confirm that the care home which had kept Catherine’s place open since April could meet Catherine’s care needs. The standard of care provided by this operator is consistently good. The manager of this home, care staff, and the operator of this home were not responsible in any way for Catherine’s illness during her brief time in their care. On the contrary, they responded promptly and appropriately to serious adverse events. Identified as an Elderly Mentally Ill person, Catherine would be entitled to NHS care for her illness. In April 2xxx, the senior manager for her case, and her social worker had submitted a request for her placement in permanent care. At a care home which specialises in supporting people with dementia, a place was allocated. In December 2xxx, the manager did not know why Catherine’s admission had been delayed for so long. Nor, evidently, did the manager know that after the health crisis which prompted referral to hospital, Catherine would be returned to Sibling 3, despite serious medical and other reasons why this would place Catherine at risk of further abuse.
On the day Catherine’s permanent placement was due to begin, the new CPN observed quantities of grey hair on the floor, which Catherine had been pulling out. Enquiring about food, this CPN reports Sibling 3’s ‘surprise ‘ when Catherine ate . Sibling 3 then reported that she had bought a house in Wales and intended to move there with both parents next year. 15 Care home admission records for December 29th identify the placement as permanent. Soon after she was admitted, Catherine expressed a wish to ‘go home’. Admitted to care, many people who have dementia want to ‘go home’, but what does this plea for ‘home’ mean ? Discharged from the NMGH on September 12th 2xxx, Catherine hadn’t been able to return to the house which had been her home for almost sixty years, where she had given birth to three of her four children, close to the school where she had taught for forty years and the church community she had known all her life.
Just before entering what was identified on admission as permanent placement in care, Catherine’s prescribed medication and the times when it should be taken is given as follows :
Singulair, 10 mg 22.00
Olanzapine 2.5mg 22.00
Theophylline, 200mg 8.00, 17 .00
Bambuterol 10mg 22.00
Escitalopram 10 mg 8. 00
Donepezil, 10mg 8. 00
This is a complex regime, in which medication needs to be administered at set times, by a responsible care giver, who will monitor accurately any problems which could be caused by the medication. Olanzapine was introduced following the diagnosis of ‘ psychotic depression’ 16
From July 2xxx, Catherine’s NHS records document the alternating use of two GP practices. Especially for a frail woman in her late eighties, prescribed complex medications, this was a very unsafe situation. There is no evidence that any doctor or other mental health professional was monitoring consistently the impact of the six medications which had been prescribed for Catherine, including any possible effect on her already damaged heart. 17
In pharmaceutical publications and patient information leaflets, none of the medications listed above is compatible with alcohol, especially for an elderly patient. For the medications listed above, interactions associated with the use and misuse of alcohol range from excessive drowsiness to serious toxic effects if alcohol is consumed while taking theophylline. 18 Corresponding with two GP practices about the same patient, even on successive days, NHS psychiatrists in the Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust could not have reliable, objective data identifying Catherine’s response to any of this medication or any reliable reports of serious ‘side effects’.
Observed by independent witnesses at the care home to which Catherine was taken on December 29th significant events merit close attention. On December 29th Catherine was delivered to the care home by her eldest granddaughter. 19 Sibling 3 was at the hospital, needing, but not obtaining William’s signature, to complete the sale of William and Catherine’s house. Next day, Catherine collapsed. The care home manager called an ambulance. Triage notes record her history on admission ‘Seen to collapse in chair vomiting, episodes of bradycardia ( abnormally slow heart beat) incontinent, discolouration evident to fingertips, history of Raynaud’s.20 Observation records made at the NMGH on December 30th include hypertension . Further tests identified borderline renal impairment. 21 Discharged at 16.50, Catherine was returned to the care home. Staff reported that she had a seizure. An ambulance was called. At 19. 40, the A & E Triage report identifies Fits. Clinical notes for Catherine entered on 30th December 2008 identify, in capitals, ‘SEVERE DEMENTIA’. This time, Catherine was admitted for observation.
Next day, New Year’s Eve 2xxx, Jane and Sibling 2 travelled to Manchester from the south coast and Cumbria. Sibling 2 knew that Catherine had been admitted to supposedly permanent care,giving this information to Jane . Jane , eldest child of Catherine and William, had not been notified about this admission, or about any of Catherine’s previous placements in care. When Jane rang the care home, from a train, the manager said that she could not give Jane any information. Sibling 2 had further information, phoning Jane to report that Catherine had been admitted to the NMGH. At this stage, medical details were slight. Jane probably could not be refused access to her mother if Catherine was a patient in an NHS hospital,
Meeting at Piccadilly station, Jane and Sibling 2 travelled to the NMGH and were allowed to see their mother immediately. In the city centre, they had bought flowers, not realising that flowers are no longer allowed in hospitals. 22 Catherine was extremely thin, but appeared calm and composed, sitting in chair when they arrived. She spoke lucidly, expressing great distress with academic clarity :
‘It isn’t normal for a grown woman to have this relationship with her own father. Is this what they used to call ‘the Electra complex’ ? 23
Catherine did not elaborate. Sibling 3’s relationship with William was now far from normal. Remembering the intimate kiss her father had expected at White Moss in April, Jane heard what Catherine was saying, but did not comment. Catherine’s precision regarding the nature of the ‘Electra complex’ is important, recognising that the sexual psychology theories of Freud and Jung are controversial and disputed. As a teacher and ultimately, headteacher, she had specialised in early years education and child development. Her extra curricular activities included what was then defined as marriage guidance, now identified as relationship counselling. 24 Before she could be accepted to undertake this voluntary work, Catherine had to undertake training in counselling to professional standards. 25
Quietly, through clearly distressed, Catherine talked about the ways in which she was constantly excluded from her husband’s company, physically pushed away, told, by Sibling 3,
‘ You’re just his wife. He’s mine’ ( Stated on Ward H3,NMGH to Jane and Sibling 2. )
Catherine gave more information about her experiences with Sibling 3, including how she was not allowed to sit with her husband, and that she was not allowed any of her own money to pay for a taxi to the hospital, which she knew to be about a quarter of a mile away – actually, about half a mile. Reporting this physical, psychological and sexual abuse, Catherine begged not to be returned to Sibling 3. She continued to express her wish to be with William, whom she had not seen since he was taken to the NMGH by ambulance on December 8th. .
Talking to Jane , Sibling 2 had already acknowledged that Sibling 3 gave their father ‘ a great deal of physical affection.’ Speaking or writing about the inappropriate sexual conduct of a parent who is suffering from dementia can never be easy. Expressed in hugs and non-sexual kisses, physical affection between fathers and daughters of any age is normal, loving, welcome. When the father is suffering from dementia, and the kisses between father and daughter are sexual, and even accepted by a family ‘ carer’ a line has been crossed. 26 Sexual exploitation of a confused senior is shocking and distressing, as is every other aspect of elder abuse. Most of the published reports on the sexual abuse and exploitation of people with dementia focuses on situations in care homes, abuses committed by care staff, and the disinhibition affecting some patients. 27
Abuse can take place in any setting but abuse within the home by family members is almost always unobserved. 28 Even without Jane ’s brief but very difficult experience with her father at the White Moss care home, Catherine’s account of the abnormal relationship between William and Sibling 3 is wholly credible, documented, perhaps inadvertently, in Catherine’s NHS Mental Health records. Community Psychiatric Nurses and Social Services focus on supporting the relationship between Sibling 3 and her father. Represented, accurately or otherwise, as presenting a serious threat to her husband, to herself and to others, Catherine was repeatedly placed in respite care and unable to report the abuses she had experienced and the financial abuse which she suspected. ‘ Respite’ contained her in another place. Such placements did not offer any support for her distress, or any opportunity to speak freely about her experiences. When she reported abuse to Jane , the reports were dismissed by the Police. No action was taken by NHS Mental Health staff who could and should have acted. Later, the care manager and social worker would deny ‘any recollection’ of their three hour meeting with Jane . (See Chapter Six, A Long Meeting) Emails cannot be denied. NHS Mental Health electronic records document the delivery to this care manager of the letter reporting human rights and financial abuse of two very old and vulnerable people.
On New Year's Eve 2xxx, Jane and Sibling 2 intended to visit their father, still a patient in this hospital. Would Catherine be allowed to see him ? She had vomited the previous day, but ward staff did not attribute this to norovirus . Notices displayed throughout the hospital warned that norovirus was present, but William’s ward remained open. On December 31st 2xxx, neither Jane nor, presumably, Sibling 2 were party to any of the communication between staff at the NMGH and Social Services, specifically, Adult Social Care staff working in what was then the Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust. During her meeting with a senior staff member on Ward H3, Jane provided as much information as she could, including Catherine’s accounts of actual assaults by Sibling 3, the withholding of all money,and the intention that William would be moving to Wales with Sibling 3, whereas Catherine was to remain in care, in Manchester. No action was taken. This was a serious report of ongoing abuse of a vulnerable older person, made in an NHS hospital, to ward staff, by the alleged victim’s nearest relative.
Initially, it appeared that Catherine’s visit to William could go ahead. With Catherine in a hospital wheelchair, Jane and Sibling 2 reached a lift, but were directed to return to the ward. Further consultations took place. Would the hospital allow a woman of 88 to visit her dying 98 year old husband ? The wait continued. Allowed to proceed at last, they reached William’s ward. Jane and Sibling 2 gave their mother as much privacy as was possible in a crowded ward, hearing her say, it’s me, Catherine. William could barely speak, but was heard to say, ‘my wife’ and reach for her hand.
Jane went to the ward office, to ask medical staff whether her father was likely to die within the next day. Living two hundred miles nearer to Manchester, it would be easier for Jane to stay in the city or return at short notice. Staff advised that he wasn’t expected to die yet. Displayed at the foot of the bed, William’s records included a history of vascular dementia, macular degeneration and uncorrected hearing impairment. Dual sensory impairment exacerbates the effects of dementia. 29 Withdrawn from the social and church based community he had known with Catherine, William too was isolated. Behind closed doors, the fiction of William retaining all his faculties could continue, repeated, by Manchester City Council, to the Local Government Ombudsman.
Before the current policy of open visiting was introduced in 2016, afternoon visiting ended at four. Leaving the ward, Catherine said she wouldn’t pray now for William to get better. In her own words ‘He’s going to God’. She spoke about his great age, plans for his funeral, as a celebration of his long life. Returning to the south coast, Sibling 2 couldn’t return to Catherine’s ward. On New Year’s Eve, the rail network would close early. Jane could stay a little longer. Reaching the ward, Jane repeated the warning to staff. Catherine should not be returned to Sibling 3. Within minutes, Sibling 3 arrived, with a male friend, not known to Jane . In the presence of ward staff, Sibling 3 made a verbal attack on Jane and greeted Catherine exuberantly. Jane left to catch the last train North.
NHS records for this period confirm that Sibling 3 had insisted that she wanted Catherine back. Permanent funded placement had been authorised in April, in response to Catherine’s defined needs, identified as Care Cluster 12, in the social worker’s words, a danger to her husband, to herself and to others. Now, an NHS Mental Health hospital psychiatrist had reported ‘ psychotic depression’ 30 The care home had been keeping Catherine’s place open since April.
Despite Catherine’s records of collapse, slow heartbeat and fits, observed by care home staff, necessitating two referrals to hospital in one day and admission for observation, the senior care manager had directed that Catherine should be returned to Sibling 3. According to Catherine’s NHS records, he was ‘ sure she will be well cared for. ‘ 31 This was not true. The care manager already knew about very serious ongoing abuse of Catherine Copied to him by email on December 11th, as directed by the consultant old age psychiatrist, the manager already had detailed information about extensive ongoing human rights and financial abuse, Neither he nor the consultant, the most senior people directly responsible for Catherine’s care, had reported this abuse to the Police. The manager also knew about the many indications of other abuses. Catherine had pulled out so much of her hair, there was an extensive bald area on the left side of her head. There was other evidence too, which appears to have been ignored or not recognised by NHS Mental Health professionals. The commonest reason for extreme weight loss is not an eating disorder or laxative abuse. It is insufficient intake of food. Fully mobile, and articulate, able to indicate psychological debate regarding the supposed ‘ Electra complex’ Catherine was not yet in the late stages of dementia, where significant weight loss might be expected. She was very seriously underweight, but NHS and Social Services staff had accepted Sibling 3’s claims of suspected bulimia or laxative abuse. In an 87 year old who never left the house and had no access to any money ? Mental Health records include several references to Catherine’s unsteadiness in walking. . Unsteadiness can be an aspect of dementia, but mental health professionals do not appear to have considered the most usual reason for unsteadiness. The physiotherapist who examined Catherine could find no physical cause. Visiting Catherine in respite care, Jane did not observe any unsteadiness. Evidence of the misuse of alcohol by Sibling 3 will be examined in the next chapter, including alcohol misuse associated with attempted financial abuse, which was reported by care home staff. Once again, no action was taken by Manchester’s NHS Mental Health staff, or by Manchester Social Services. 32
William was dying. Until mid-December, securing Catherine’s placement in permanent care was identified as a priority. Mental health attention for Catherine focused on this objective. On December 31st, as a patient on Ward H3, at the North Manchester General Hospital, Catherine had described the serious abuse she was experiencing, financial, physical, psychological, and the sexually inappropriate conduct of Sibling 3 towards William. The extent to which Catherine had been misrepresented as ‘Mary’, a state pensioner with a very different personal, medical and career history would emerge only slowly, when Catherine’s NHS records were released. Apart from William’s surname, neither he nor Catherine had any connection with Wales, yet Social Services staff and other authorities often referred to William moving ‘ back to Wales’, William’s father and paternal grandfather were born and lived in Manchester His maternal grandparents were entirely Irish, born in County Wicklow and moving to Manchester as adults. With a former partner, Sibling 3 had owned a property in Wales, but this had been repossessed by the mortgage lender. No other family member had any connection with Wales.
After listening to Catherine’s account of the abuses which she was experiencing, and having already some evidence of the property construction, Jane attempted once again to report ongoing abuse to the Police. Once again, the allegations were dismissed, but this time, Jane was advised by Greater Manchester Police that she could report to the police in her own area. On New Year’s Day, Cumbria Police took a preliminary record, giving the case a reference number identifying the abuse of vulnerable adults. Jane and her husband would return to Cumbria Police later in January, with bank statements which document extensive financial abuse.
After New Year, Manchester Adult Social Care and the Mental Health and Social Care Trust provided some contact details. Provided with the care manager’s email address, Jane sent several emails to him, detailing her concerns. All of these emails were delivered to him,@manchester.gov.uk. Until late September 2xxx, when she received Catherine’s NHS mental health records Jane did not know that this manager had received the copy of her letter reporting ongoing human rights abuses and financial abuse by email , on December 11th 2xxx Having this information, reporting serious ongoing abuse of a vulnerable adult, for whom he was care manager, he did nothing.
Mental Health and Social Care responses to reports of the ongoing abuse of Catherine and William were difficult. On January 3rd, during a telephone discussion with Jane , three days after he had directed that Catherine should be returned to Sibling 3, the care manager agreed that there was clearly a major discrepancy between Sibling 3’s accounts and reports from staff at the White Moss centre. During this call, the manager referred to reports from care staff that Catherine asked very firmly to be in residential care, and not with Sibling 3. At White Moss, on July 11th that year, Catherine’s fear of Sibling 3 had been obvious – and Catherine’s very different response when told by staff that the visitor was Jane. On January 6th 2xxx, Jane spoke to Catherine’s new Community Psychiatric Nurse regarding access to Catherine for family members. According to this CPN, Jane had ‘ issues’ with Sibling 3. This response was inappropriate and unprofessional. The CPN could know nothing about Jane . From Catherine herself, and from personal experience. Jane had serious information concerning the ongoing abuse. On New Year’s Eve, with Sibling 2, Jane had witnessed Catherine’s profound distress, as she described the ways in which she was constantly excluded from her husband’s company, by their own youngest daughter. Reporting the call, the CPN states that ‘ Mrs X was quite sharp in her tone’ The CPN questioned the lack of support Jane had given to Sibling 3, described by this nurse ‘struggling to care for both of them’. The nurse then indicated that they were ‘ all supporting her, the poor girl’ 33 This CPN had just been assigned to the case and appears to have accepted Sibling 3’s narrative without question. NHS mental health records records confirm the ease with which NHS mental health professionals were denied all contact with Catherine, and the ease with which Catherine’s existing medical history was misrepresented.
Mental Health and Social Services staff , including the new CPN, continued to recognise Sibling 3 as a dedicated carer. In 2xxx, after being denied any mental health support for fifteen months, at the direction of Sibling 3, Catherine was in ‘respite care’ in March, April, July, August, October and November. In July and August 2008, admitted only two days after a fortnight in ‘ respite’, Catherine was a patient at the NMGH for twenty-four days, even though she was medically fit for discharge on the second day. Discharged, she was placed in respite care immediately. Bank statements identify Sibling 3’s location and activities during Catherine’s extended periods in ‘ respite’ or in hospital. Financial activity was extensive, including a single transaction for £150,000 34
In the second week of January 2xxx, it was announced that a Best Interests meeting would be held on January 16th. On January 14th, the psychiatrist who had examined Catherine on December 12th 2xxx, recording a diagnosis of psychotic depression, reported a remarkable improvement in Catherine’s mental state. In a letter to Catherine’s GP at practice A, the hospital psychiatrist reported a remarkable improvement’. Catherine is reported as feeling much better in herself. 35 He considered that Catherine had the capacity to make decisions about where she would live. The ‘remarkable improvement‘ found by the psychiatrist is attributed to the new medication. The combination of olanzapine, escitalopram, donepezil, theophylline, bambuterol and singulair is not likely to be responsible for the apparent remarkable transformation in so short a time. On December 30th, Catherine had collapsed, her heartbeat was slow, borderline renal impairment was identified, she had seizures, and NMGH staff identified her mental condition as ‘ Severe Dementia’ 36
This review does not seek to examine all potential side effects of the six medications prescribed for Catherine. 37 The misuse of alcohol by Sibling 3 as a means of managing Catherine was included in referrals to Manchester Social Services and community mental health. Medication prescribed then for Catherine’s aortic and mitral valve regurgitation was not compatible with alcohol. The writer of this review has not been able to identify any reports concerning the combined effect of the six medications named above, prescribed for an eighty-eight year old with a history of dementia , cardiovascular disease and chronic breathing problems, usually identified as COPD/asthma, in a life long non-smoker. Regarding the effect of the medications, there is no indication here that the hospital psychiatrist would have considered the potential misuse of alcohol by a carer. Alcohol is not compatible with five of the prescribed medications listed on 29th December 2xxx. Prescription guidance for montelukast varies, but the medication can cause drowsiness. Side effects could be exacerbated by alcohol. 38 The independently documented administration of 40% proof alcohol to Catherine by Sibling 3, in the context of financial abuse is examined in the next chapter, A Long Meeting.
In January 2xxx, via email correspondence between Siblings 2,3 & 4, Jane had written evidence concerning the use of a six figure sum, money taken from William and Catherine’s accounts to pay for the construction of the property near New Quay, Ceredigion. Sibling 2 had copied this e-mail to Jane . Taking further legal advice, Jane knew that the ongoing abuse must be reported once again. On January 15th, the consultant old age psychiatrist confirmed that he would be willing to attend the Best Interests meeting scheduled for January 16th. Jane reported that she would not be able to attend. In Cumbria, severe weather had again closed local roads. Sibling 2 travelled to Manchester, but Sibling 3 would not be attending, reporting symptoms of norovirus. Catherine’s records for this period also include reported symptoms of norovirus, Aged 88, suffering from dementia and known to be seriously underweight Catherine received no medical attention. In the interests of infection control, people in normal health are advised not to seek medical attention for norovirus. For babies, young children, and the frail elderly, norovirus can be serious and even fatal. The bug is extremely unpleasant. It isn’t Ebola. Provision could be made for essential visits to frail elderly people with the virus. 39
The Best Interests meeting was rescheduled to January 21st. Returning to the south by train, on the evening of Friday, January 16th, Sibling 2 received a phone call from Sibling 3, during which Catherine was directed to state that she wished to remain with Sibling 3 According to Sibling 2, male voices urged her to go on, say it, Catherine. Sibling 2 expressed concerns about the extent of abuse Catherine was experiencing. Jane told Sibling 2 that she would contact Manchester’s Adult Social Care in the morning, reporting ongoing abuse of an older person. Next day, the duty officer’s response was not encouraging. There was no indication that any action would be taken. Road conditions had improved, enabling Jane and her husband to travel to Sheffield on Sunday, January 18th, delivering some of their younger daughter’s property. From Sheffield, Jane emailed Sibling 2, confirming that she would go to Manchester the next day, to report ongoing abuse, including the location of the property under construction in Wales and presenting the first definite evidence of the extensive misuse of William and Catherine’s assets. Safeguarding referrals had warned, accurately, that both were at risk, and that the risk to Catherine was greatest.
‘ No Secrets’ Department of Health, 2000
2.17 Patterns of abuse/abusing. Patterns of abuse and abusing vary and reflect very different dynamics. These include:
• serial abusing in which the perpetrator seeks out and ‘grooms’ vulnerable individuals. Sexual abuse usually falls into this pattern as do some forms of financial abuse;
• long term abuse in the context of an ongoing family relationship such as domestic violence between spouses or generations; • opportunistic abuse such as theft occurring because money has been left around;
• situational abuse which arises because pressures have built up and/or because of difficult or challenging behaviour;
• neglect of a person’s needs because those around him or her are not able to be responsible for their care, for example if the carer has difficulties attributable to such issues as debt, alcohol or mental health problems;
• unacceptable ‘treatments’ or programmes which include sanctions or punishment such as withholding of food and drink, seclusion, unnecessary and unauthorised use of control and restraint (see Harris et al 1996) or over-medication;
• failure to access key services such as health care, dentistry, prostheses;
• misappropriation of benefits and/or use of the person’s money by other members of the household;
• fraud or intimidation in connection with wills, property or other assets.
1 . Freedom of Information request, response to Jane by Manchester City Council
2 Home environment and dementia – NHS.UK https://www.nhs.uk › Health A-Z › Dementia guide
3 Health Soc Care Community. 2011 Jan;19(1):3-14. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2524.2010.00964.x. Epub 2010 Oct 11. The impact of domestic abuse for older women: a review of the literature.
McGarry J1, Simpson C, Hinchliff-Smith K.
4 Bilateral macular degeneration, bilateral ischaemic optic neuropathy. Manchester Royal Eye Hospital Records, 1986 – 2004.
4 08/12/2xxx, Events 57 and 58. MMH/SCT
5 11/12/2xxx. Event 61 MMH/SCT
6 10/12/2xxx MH/SCT. The psychiatrist defined Catherine’s condition as ‘ psychotic depression’.
7 https://www.nursingtimes.net/roles/mental.dementia...depression/5084104.article
Differentiating dementia, delirium and depression | Clinical Nursing ..
8 08/12/2008 NMGH
9 09/12/2008 Records requested M/cr City Council CC12 as requested, CPN.
10 Garden, G. (2005). Physical examination in psychiatric practice. Advances in Psychiatric Treatment, 11(2), 142-149. doi:10.1192/apt.11.2.142
11 11/12/2xxx NHS Hospital psychiatrist, to GP Practice B. MMH/SCT
12 Sprite Network, Manchester City Council. Referring psychiatrist to GP A. 12/12/2xxx Anti-psychotics to commence.
13 Civil registration records, England and Wales.
14 Shulman M, Miller A, Misher J, Tentler A. Managing cardiovascular disease risk in patients treated with antipsychotics: a multidisciplinary approach. Journal of Multidisciplinary Healthcare. 2014;7:489-501. doi:10.2147/JMDH.S49817.
15 29/12/2xxx Event 68 MMH/ SCT
16 Lenzer J. FDA warns about using antipsychotic drugs for dementia. BMJ : British Medical Journal. 2005;330(7497):922.
17 Marano, 2011, Cardiologic side effects of psychotropic drugs NCBI - NIH
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3390089/-
by G Marano - 2011
18 NHS Digital publishes dementia and antipsychotic drug prescription ...https://digital.nhs.uk/15 December, 2017:
19 29/12/2xxx, Event 71, MMH/SCT
20 30/12/2008 Event 74 collapse, incontinent A & E, NMGH
21 30 12/08 clinical notes, NMGH
22 .Wards of the roses BMJ 2009; 339 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.b5257 (Published 17 December 2009)
23 Electra vs Oedipus -by HC Freud - 2010 Taylor & Francis Group
24 https://www.marriagecare.org.uk
25 pmj.The work of marriage guidance counsellors - Postgraduate Medical ...bmj.com/content/postgradmedj/48/563/563.full.pdf by N Tyndall - 1972 -
26 Action on Elder Abuse | Sexual Abuse https://www.elderabuse.org.uk/sexual
27 Safeguarding people with dementia – SCIE https://www.scie.org.uk/dementia/after-diagnosis/support/safeguarding.asp
28 Abuse of patients with dementia by carers - out ... - Wiley Online Library onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/gps.930100903/pdf
29 Yukari Yamada, Michael D. Denkinger, Graziano Onder, Jean-Claude Henrard, HenriĆ«tte G. van der Roest, Harriet Finne-Soveri, Tomas Richter, Martina Vlachova, Roberto Bernabei, Eva Topinkova; Dual Sensory Impairment and Cognitive Decline: The Results From the Shelter Study, The Journals of Gerontology Series A, Volume 71, Issue 1, 1 January 2016, Pages 117–123, https://doi.org/10.1093/gerona/glv036
30 10/12/2xxx, MMH/SCT
31 31/12/2008 Event 80 Will be discharged to daughter’s address.
32 Alcohol and Older People - Royal College of Psychiatrists
33 06/01/2009 Event 84 Jane, phone call to CPN, RR to CPN
34 Abbey/Santander joint account, William and Catherine
released to Jane. .
35 07/01/2xxx Event 88, MMH/SCT
36 30/12/2xxx NMGH.
37 Guidance for Antipsychotic Use and Withdrawal in Dementia www.ipswichandeastsuffolkccg.nhs.uk
38 Singulair and Alcohol (Montelukast) – Drugsdb.com www.drugsdb.com › Prescription Drugs › Singulair
39 Deaths from Norovirus among the Elderly, England and Wales https://www.rcpsych.ac.uk/healthadvice/.../alcoholandolderpeople.aspxhttps://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2609872/
by JP Harris - 2008 -
Catherine in care again.
Catherine not allowed to visit her husband in hospital, because of her dementia.
Use of two GP practices continues.
Financial and legal activity ongoing, and new build in Wales. .
Office of the Public Guardian advises report to the police.
Greater Manchester Police reject ‘unfounded allegations’ .
Jane:Letter to Manchester Mental Health, reporting human rights and financial abuse.
Gives address of ongoing construction in Wales.
Consultant old age psychiatrist received Jane’s letter.
Consultant directed letter should be copied to care manager, by email.
(NHS electronic records)
Letters from NHS Trust psychiatrist to both GP practices on successive days.
Diagnosis of psychotic depression.
Catherine‘s placement in permanent care.
Collapse, slow heart, borderline renal impairment, fits.
Catherine, in hospital, reports emotional and psychological abuse, Sibling 3’s sexually inappropriate conduct with William.
Sibling 3 insists Catherine be returned
Care manager directs NMGH staff – discharge Catherine to Sibling 3
’sure she will be well looked after.’ - NHS records
Care manager had received Jane's written report of extensive ongoing financial abuse, and had evidence of Catherine’s distress at the house of Sibling 3,
including quantities of hair she'd pulled out.
Sibling 2 forwards email documenting six-figure abuse.
Reported to Manchester Social Services by Jane.
No action taken.
Are you a half-sibling ?
The ward manager’s question was extraordinary. Eldest of four, always living with her parents until leaving home for university at eighteen, visiting regularly, warning they were at risk the day before losing contact for over 18 months, Jane would have to prove this claim repeatedly. The ward manager questioned Jane ’s claim regarding William’s blindness. Why say that her father was blind ? Concealing the fact that William had been blind for years was all too easy. Sensory Support services had been provided to him, as a blind resident, by Manchester City Council but this was at his home address in Blackley. 1 Next day,October 28th 2xxx, Jane rang the White Moss care home, asking if she would be able to take her mother to visit her father in hospital. The White Moss manager raised no objection to the proposed visit. At the hospital, the response was very different. NMGH ward staff informed Jane that her mother could not be allowed to visit William because of her dementia.
Dismissed repeatedly as ‘not an authorised person’ by care home staff, Jane began to recognise the significance of what had been achieved. Removed from their own home, and effectively, their whole world, Catherine and William had ceased to be her parents. More accurately, Jane herself had ceased to be recognised as her parents’ child, except, that is, by people who had known her and her parents when they lived in Blackley for so many decades. Eldest child of their marriage, and therefore their nearest relative after each other, Jane had not been included in the narrative now accepted by NHS Mental Health and Social Services staff and by the NMGH. Neither NHS nor Social Services staff can have checked Catherine's existing NHS and social care records. They appear to have accepted fictions from a single source. William’s blindness had been concealed. The concealment of William’s blindness and other serious health problems is evident in NHS reports concerning Catherine’s acknowledged mental illness.
The ease with which this concealment was achieved is most readily understood by moving forward to the release of Catherine’s records to Jane in August and September 2011, October 2013, June 2014, and, via Greater Manchester Police, in July 2016, when GMP released their own correspondence with the Central Manchester University Hospitals' ( Requested as Freedom of Information from GMP but not released as such.) Receiving the first two consignments of records, the first impression was of chaos. Numbering each document in pencil and retaining the original order, as released from Trust headquarters, every record was then scanned and a timeline created. Reports on Catherine’s mental health came from different community mental health teams. Catherine and William’s surname was extremely common. Removed from the suburb where she had lived for almost 86 years, then denied mental health support for over fifteen months, Catherine – routinely referred to and addressed as ‘ Mary’ by community psychiatric nurses and by social services, could become another person, her existing medical history comprehensively ‘misrepresented’ or falsified by Sibling 3. Even the claim that Catherine had been well and active until May/June 2xxx was accepted without question – this despite Catherine’s three weeks of inpatient care at the NMGH in August and September the previous year., and existing three year contact with Manchester’s mental health services for older people. Visited by a new mental health team, Catherine’s connection with the world she had now lost wasn’t recognised, This abrupt and total separation from the social environment of her life before dementia is very likely to have exacerbated disorientation. The emotional and psychological distress of dementia would be magnified. 2
The area where Catherine had spent almost her entire life became, to an NHS hospital psychiatrist, prescribing anti-psychotic and antidepressant medication, only ‘where she’d lived as a child’. On November 7th 2xxx Jane visited Catherine again at the White Moss care home. Shortly after this visit, Sibling 2 provided the address of the property under construction, near New Quay, at the southern end of Cardigan Bay and approximately twenty-eight miles by road from the nearest hospital which has an A & E department. Supposedly, William would move there with Sibling 3, but at 98, he was increasingly frail, with a history of vascular dementia, uncorrected hearing impairment, and had been blind for nearly twelve years. Sibling 2 now indicated to Jane that Catherine ‘might not be well enough’ to leave Manchester. According to Catherine’s NHS Mental Health records, which include the diagnosis of a serious mental disorder, identified by NHS psychiatrists as ‘ psychotic depression’, she was to remain in Manchester, in the permanent care, authorised nearly eight months previously, following the referral by her social worker and senior care manager and approval by the Manchester City Council panel.
When Sibling 2 provided the address of the property near New Quay, and the information that Catherine could be remaining in Manchester, Jane approached the Office of the Public Guardian immediately. OPG staff advised that the matter should be reported to the police at once. This is the advice regarding ongoing elder abuse given on the UK government website, but Greater Manchester Police dismissed Jane ’s report as an unfounded allegation. During the same week of November 2008, Jane’s younger daughter, then a student in her second year at Sheffield university, rang to report that Sibling 3 was urging her to bring a powered wheelchair to Manchester, which Sibling 3 had sourced on ebay. How an able bodied young woman was to transport an unoccupied powered wheelchair by train and transport this vehicle across the city was not explained. William was blind. How could he use such a vehicle ? Jane’s daughter did not comply with Sibling 3’s request.
Repeated safeguarding referrals had been ignored. Following Jane’s direct referral at the North Manchester General PALS office, Catherine had been discharged to the person named in all safeguarding referrals. NHS staff then accepted Sibling 3’s directions controlling all access to Catherine. Suffering from dementia and aortic and mitral valve damage, Catherine had been denied medical care for fifteen months. Reporting ongoing abuse to the police had failed. On December 1st 2xxx, Jane wrote to the Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust, identifying ongoing human rights abuses and financial abuse. At the time, evidence of other abuse was less easily demonstrated. Catherine’s records confirm that NHS mental health professionals had accepted claims of ‘ bulimia’ and ‘laxative abuse’ to explain Catherine’s severe weight loss. Now, there was considerable evidence for the proposed permanent separation of husband and wife and the extensive misuse of their assets. The address of the property under construction was provided. To confirm Jane ’s position in the family and identify her as the person who had made many safeguarding referrals, the letter was sent to the CPN who had been involved in Catherine’s mental health care in 2xxx – 2xxx, during the early stages of Catherine’s illness. In October and November 2xxx, this CPN had been informed by letter that Jane was not able to obtain access to her parents. Catherine and William’s MP had the same information, and advised Jane that she could refer the situation to her own MP. Catherine’s original CPN had invited Jane to contact her again if she had further concerns. Sent by first class post, the letter had to be handwritten. In severe weather, Jane had no access to a computer or printer.
In November 2xxx, Catherine was still in respite care. This was her third prolonged placement at White Moss since March. In July and August, she had spent twenty-four days as an inpatient at the NMGH, and was then discharged to a different care home. Not notified about this placement, Jane didn’t know about Catherine’s time there until contacted by one of her mother’s friends. On July 11th, at White Moss, well aware of the ongoing financial abuse Catherine had reported to Jane that Sibling 3 had ‘ taken everything’ and had taken William. Bank statements and other records not released until the following year confirm the accuracy of Catherine’s report of financial abuse. NHS and social care records confirm that mental health professionals and Manchester City Council Social Services supported the relationship between Sibling 3 and William. 3
On December 8th, William was admitted to the NMGH. This would be his last illness. His NHS records for this period identify the history of vascular dementia, uncorrected hearing impairment and macular degeneration, but not the more detailed visual records held by the Central Manchester University Hospitals, documenting the two causes of irreversible sight loss. 4 On the same day, Jane’s letter is identified in NHS Mental Health records. The letter was then referred to Catherine’s consultant psychiatrist, as the lead professional.5 Three days later, the CPN to whom Jane ’s letter had been sent rang requesting consent to scan the handwritten letter, so that other members of staff could read it. Catherine’s consultant directed that the scanned letter be copied to Catherine’s care manager. The letter was copied to this manager by email on December 11th. 6
After receiving Jane’s written referral, reporting ongoing human rights and financial abuses of two very old and vulnerable people, no action was taken to address the abuse and prevent further abuse. The NHS consultant old age psychiatrist and the Social Services care manager should have reported the ongoing abuse of vulnerable adults in their care to the police within 24 hours of receiving Jane ’s letter.
Fraud Act 2006
If someone in public office, responsible for the safeguarding of vulnerable person has information concerning financial abuse and fails to disclose that information, they could be breaching the Fraud Act.
Fraud by failing to disclose information (Section 3)
The defendant:
1. failed to disclose information to another person
2. when he was under a legal duty to disclose that information
3. dishonestly intending, by that failure, to make a gain or cause a loss.
Like Section 2 (and Section 4) this offence is entirely offender focussed. It is complete as soon as the Defendant fails to disclose information provided he was under a legal duty to do so, and that it was done with the necessary dishonest intent. It differs from the deception offences in that it is immaterial whether or not any one is deceived or any property actually gained or lost.
Misconduct in Public Office
Failing in the performance of a public duty, in this case, the safeguarding of vulnerable older people, one of whom had been blind for over a decade, and both suffering from dementia, could be Misconduct in Public Office.
The elements of the offence are summarised in Attorney General's Reference No 3 of 2003 [2004] EWCA Crim 868. The offence is committed when:
. a public officer acting as such
. wilfully neglects to perform his duty and/or wilfully misconducts himself
. to such a degree as to amount to an abuse of the public's trust in the office holder
. without reasonable excuse or justification
.
In December 2xxx, alternating GP practices were used even when Catherine was about to be placed in permanent care, after an eight month delay in taking up the place kept open for her by a care provider which specialises in provision for people suffering from dementia. On December 10th 2xxx , Catherine was examined by a psychiatrist from the Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust. 7 The antipsychotic olanzapine was prescribed. There is no evidence that the psychiatrist or other mental health professionals had considered potential reasons for Catherine’s mental state. 8
On December 8th, two days before she was examined by the psychiatrist, her husband had been taken to hospital by ambulance. Paramedic records for this occasion record him as calling out ‘ Help me.’ 9 Catherine and William had been married for 62 years. Throughout the past year, she had been placed in respite care for extended periods away from him, and, as Jane was informed by a ward manager at the NMGH, could not be allowed to visit him because of her dementia. On record as presenting a danger to her husband, to herself and to others, she was not allowed to visit him in hospital. On December 9th, Catherine’s social worker had requested that Catherine’s case be re-opened, authorising permanent placement in care. A Care Cluster 12 form was requested, and faxed to the social worker.10
Catherine’s mental health records for this date do not include any consideration of her existing heart disease. The importance of physical examination for mental health patients had been stressed in many publications. 11 Medication used in the treatment of dementia must be strictly monitored. Directions concerning the timing of administration and the safety of any alcohol consumption must be respected. Given the comprehensive misrepresentation of Catherine’s general and mental health history by Sibling 3, reports from Sibling 3 of how well medication was tolerated by Catherine cannot be regarded as safe. After rejecting all mental health care for Catherine for fifteen months, Sibling 3 had claimed that Catherine was ‘ well and active’ until the summer of 2xxx, whereas her existing NHS documented history included dementia, aortic and mitral valve disease, and chronic breathing difficulties.
Throughout this period in December 2xxx, during which the intended outcome was that Catherine was to move into permanent care, in Manchester, letters from an NHS Trust concerning Catherine’s mental health were being sent to the two practices, even on successive days. On December 11th, the psychiatrist’s letter was sent to the GP practice B, in Crumpsall, which had made the July 16th referral to hospital of a new patient whose UK resident status was queried, and hospital tests undertaken using the NHS emergency code ZZZZ 999. 12 On December 12th 2xxx, the same psychiatrist is named in the Sprite network document identifying Catherine’s condition as psychotic depression. 13 This document was sent to GP practice A, in Blackley, identifying the GP who knew Catherine and had discussed his diagnosis of vascular dementia with Jane before 21st June 2xxx. The referral identifies Catherine’s husband as James, though he was always known as William, which was his only given name. 14
Following the diagnosis of psychotic depression, in a dementia patient aged almost 88 the introduction of anti-psychotics does not include any reference to Catherine’s history of heart valve disease. 15 A history of aggression is reported on the continuation sheet of this referral. An assessment was undertaken to confirm that the care home which had kept Catherine’s place open since April could meet Catherine’s care needs. The standard of care provided by this operator is consistently good. The manager of this home, care staff, and the operator of this home were not responsible in any way for Catherine’s illness during her brief time in their care. On the contrary, they responded promptly and appropriately to serious adverse events. Identified as an Elderly Mentally Ill person, Catherine would be entitled to NHS care for her illness. In April 2xxx, the senior manager for her case, and her social worker had submitted a request for her placement in permanent care. At a care home which specialises in supporting people with dementia, a place was allocated. In December 2xxx, the manager did not know why Catherine’s admission had been delayed for so long. Nor, evidently, did the manager know that after the health crisis which prompted referral to hospital, Catherine would be returned to Sibling 3, despite serious medical and other reasons why this would place Catherine at risk of further abuse.
On the day Catherine’s permanent placement was due to begin, the new CPN observed quantities of grey hair on the floor, which Catherine had been pulling out. Enquiring about food, this CPN reports Sibling 3’s ‘surprise ‘ when Catherine ate . Sibling 3 then reported that she had bought a house in Wales and intended to move there with both parents next year. 15 Care home admission records for December 29th identify the placement as permanent. Soon after she was admitted, Catherine expressed a wish to ‘go home’. Admitted to care, many people who have dementia want to ‘go home’, but what does this plea for ‘home’ mean ? Discharged from the NMGH on September 12th 2xxx, Catherine hadn’t been able to return to the house which had been her home for almost sixty years, where she had given birth to three of her four children, close to the school where she had taught for forty years and the church community she had known all her life.
Just before entering what was identified on admission as permanent placement in care, Catherine’s prescribed medication and the times when it should be taken is given as follows :
Singulair, 10 mg 22.00
Olanzapine 2.5mg 22.00
Theophylline, 200mg 8.00, 17 .00
Bambuterol 10mg 22.00
Escitalopram 10 mg 8. 00
Donepezil, 10mg 8. 00
This is a complex regime, in which medication needs to be administered at set times, by a responsible care giver, who will monitor accurately any problems which could be caused by the medication. Olanzapine was introduced following the diagnosis of ‘ psychotic depression’ 16
From July 2xxx, Catherine’s NHS records document the alternating use of two GP practices. Especially for a frail woman in her late eighties, prescribed complex medications, this was a very unsafe situation. There is no evidence that any doctor or other mental health professional was monitoring consistently the impact of the six medications which had been prescribed for Catherine, including any possible effect on her already damaged heart. 17
In pharmaceutical publications and patient information leaflets, none of the medications listed above is compatible with alcohol, especially for an elderly patient. For the medications listed above, interactions associated with the use and misuse of alcohol range from excessive drowsiness to serious toxic effects if alcohol is consumed while taking theophylline. 18 Corresponding with two GP practices about the same patient, even on successive days, NHS psychiatrists in the Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust could not have reliable, objective data identifying Catherine’s response to any of this medication or any reliable reports of serious ‘side effects’.
Observed by independent witnesses at the care home to which Catherine was taken on December 29th significant events merit close attention. On December 29th Catherine was delivered to the care home by her eldest granddaughter. 19 Sibling 3 was at the hospital, needing, but not obtaining William’s signature, to complete the sale of William and Catherine’s house. Next day, Catherine collapsed. The care home manager called an ambulance. Triage notes record her history on admission ‘Seen to collapse in chair vomiting, episodes of bradycardia ( abnormally slow heart beat) incontinent, discolouration evident to fingertips, history of Raynaud’s.20 Observation records made at the NMGH on December 30th include hypertension . Further tests identified borderline renal impairment. 21 Discharged at 16.50, Catherine was returned to the care home. Staff reported that she had a seizure. An ambulance was called. At 19. 40, the A & E Triage report identifies Fits. Clinical notes for Catherine entered on 30th December 2008 identify, in capitals, ‘SEVERE DEMENTIA’. This time, Catherine was admitted for observation.
Next day, New Year’s Eve 2xxx, Jane and Sibling 2 travelled to Manchester from the south coast and Cumbria. Sibling 2 knew that Catherine had been admitted to supposedly permanent care,giving this information to Jane . Jane , eldest child of Catherine and William, had not been notified about this admission, or about any of Catherine’s previous placements in care. When Jane rang the care home, from a train, the manager said that she could not give Jane any information. Sibling 2 had further information, phoning Jane to report that Catherine had been admitted to the NMGH. At this stage, medical details were slight. Jane probably could not be refused access to her mother if Catherine was a patient in an NHS hospital,
Meeting at Piccadilly station, Jane and Sibling 2 travelled to the NMGH and were allowed to see their mother immediately. In the city centre, they had bought flowers, not realising that flowers are no longer allowed in hospitals. 22 Catherine was extremely thin, but appeared calm and composed, sitting in chair when they arrived. She spoke lucidly, expressing great distress with academic clarity :
‘It isn’t normal for a grown woman to have this relationship with her own father. Is this what they used to call ‘the Electra complex’ ? 23
Catherine did not elaborate. Sibling 3’s relationship with William was now far from normal. Remembering the intimate kiss her father had expected at White Moss in April, Jane heard what Catherine was saying, but did not comment. Catherine’s precision regarding the nature of the ‘Electra complex’ is important, recognising that the sexual psychology theories of Freud and Jung are controversial and disputed. As a teacher and ultimately, headteacher, she had specialised in early years education and child development. Her extra curricular activities included what was then defined as marriage guidance, now identified as relationship counselling. 24 Before she could be accepted to undertake this voluntary work, Catherine had to undertake training in counselling to professional standards. 25
Quietly, through clearly distressed, Catherine talked about the ways in which she was constantly excluded from her husband’s company, physically pushed away, told, by Sibling 3,
‘ You’re just his wife. He’s mine’ ( Stated on Ward H3,NMGH to Jane and Sibling 2. )
Catherine gave more information about her experiences with Sibling 3, including how she was not allowed to sit with her husband, and that she was not allowed any of her own money to pay for a taxi to the hospital, which she knew to be about a quarter of a mile away – actually, about half a mile. Reporting this physical, psychological and sexual abuse, Catherine begged not to be returned to Sibling 3. She continued to express her wish to be with William, whom she had not seen since he was taken to the NMGH by ambulance on December 8th. .
Talking to Jane , Sibling 2 had already acknowledged that Sibling 3 gave their father ‘ a great deal of physical affection.’ Speaking or writing about the inappropriate sexual conduct of a parent who is suffering from dementia can never be easy. Expressed in hugs and non-sexual kisses, physical affection between fathers and daughters of any age is normal, loving, welcome. When the father is suffering from dementia, and the kisses between father and daughter are sexual, and even accepted by a family ‘ carer’ a line has been crossed. 26 Sexual exploitation of a confused senior is shocking and distressing, as is every other aspect of elder abuse. Most of the published reports on the sexual abuse and exploitation of people with dementia focuses on situations in care homes, abuses committed by care staff, and the disinhibition affecting some patients. 27
Abuse can take place in any setting but abuse within the home by family members is almost always unobserved. 28 Even without Jane ’s brief but very difficult experience with her father at the White Moss care home, Catherine’s account of the abnormal relationship between William and Sibling 3 is wholly credible, documented, perhaps inadvertently, in Catherine’s NHS Mental Health records. Community Psychiatric Nurses and Social Services focus on supporting the relationship between Sibling 3 and her father. Represented, accurately or otherwise, as presenting a serious threat to her husband, to herself and to others, Catherine was repeatedly placed in respite care and unable to report the abuses she had experienced and the financial abuse which she suspected. ‘ Respite’ contained her in another place. Such placements did not offer any support for her distress, or any opportunity to speak freely about her experiences. When she reported abuse to Jane , the reports were dismissed by the Police. No action was taken by NHS Mental Health staff who could and should have acted. Later, the care manager and social worker would deny ‘any recollection’ of their three hour meeting with Jane . (See Chapter Six, A Long Meeting) Emails cannot be denied. NHS Mental Health electronic records document the delivery to this care manager of the letter reporting human rights and financial abuse of two very old and vulnerable people.
On New Year's Eve 2xxx, Jane and Sibling 2 intended to visit their father, still a patient in this hospital. Would Catherine be allowed to see him ? She had vomited the previous day, but ward staff did not attribute this to norovirus . Notices displayed throughout the hospital warned that norovirus was present, but William’s ward remained open. On December 31st 2xxx, neither Jane nor, presumably, Sibling 2 were party to any of the communication between staff at the NMGH and Social Services, specifically, Adult Social Care staff working in what was then the Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust. During her meeting with a senior staff member on Ward H3, Jane provided as much information as she could, including Catherine’s accounts of actual assaults by Sibling 3, the withholding of all money,and the intention that William would be moving to Wales with Sibling 3, whereas Catherine was to remain in care, in Manchester. No action was taken. This was a serious report of ongoing abuse of a vulnerable older person, made in an NHS hospital, to ward staff, by the alleged victim’s nearest relative.
Initially, it appeared that Catherine’s visit to William could go ahead. With Catherine in a hospital wheelchair, Jane and Sibling 2 reached a lift, but were directed to return to the ward. Further consultations took place. Would the hospital allow a woman of 88 to visit her dying 98 year old husband ? The wait continued. Allowed to proceed at last, they reached William’s ward. Jane and Sibling 2 gave their mother as much privacy as was possible in a crowded ward, hearing her say, it’s me, Catherine. William could barely speak, but was heard to say, ‘my wife’ and reach for her hand.
Jane went to the ward office, to ask medical staff whether her father was likely to die within the next day. Living two hundred miles nearer to Manchester, it would be easier for Jane to stay in the city or return at short notice. Staff advised that he wasn’t expected to die yet. Displayed at the foot of the bed, William’s records included a history of vascular dementia, macular degeneration and uncorrected hearing impairment. Dual sensory impairment exacerbates the effects of dementia. 29 Withdrawn from the social and church based community he had known with Catherine, William too was isolated. Behind closed doors, the fiction of William retaining all his faculties could continue, repeated, by Manchester City Council, to the Local Government Ombudsman.
Before the current policy of open visiting was introduced in 2016, afternoon visiting ended at four. Leaving the ward, Catherine said she wouldn’t pray now for William to get better. In her own words ‘He’s going to God’. She spoke about his great age, plans for his funeral, as a celebration of his long life. Returning to the south coast, Sibling 2 couldn’t return to Catherine’s ward. On New Year’s Eve, the rail network would close early. Jane could stay a little longer. Reaching the ward, Jane repeated the warning to staff. Catherine should not be returned to Sibling 3. Within minutes, Sibling 3 arrived, with a male friend, not known to Jane . In the presence of ward staff, Sibling 3 made a verbal attack on Jane and greeted Catherine exuberantly. Jane left to catch the last train North.
NHS records for this period confirm that Sibling 3 had insisted that she wanted Catherine back. Permanent funded placement had been authorised in April, in response to Catherine’s defined needs, identified as Care Cluster 12, in the social worker’s words, a danger to her husband, to herself and to others. Now, an NHS Mental Health hospital psychiatrist had reported ‘ psychotic depression’ 30 The care home had been keeping Catherine’s place open since April.
Despite Catherine’s records of collapse, slow heartbeat and fits, observed by care home staff, necessitating two referrals to hospital in one day and admission for observation, the senior care manager had directed that Catherine should be returned to Sibling 3. According to Catherine’s NHS records, he was ‘ sure she will be well cared for. ‘ 31 This was not true. The care manager already knew about very serious ongoing abuse of Catherine Copied to him by email on December 11th, as directed by the consultant old age psychiatrist, the manager already had detailed information about extensive ongoing human rights and financial abuse, Neither he nor the consultant, the most senior people directly responsible for Catherine’s care, had reported this abuse to the Police. The manager also knew about the many indications of other abuses. Catherine had pulled out so much of her hair, there was an extensive bald area on the left side of her head. There was other evidence too, which appears to have been ignored or not recognised by NHS Mental Health professionals. The commonest reason for extreme weight loss is not an eating disorder or laxative abuse. It is insufficient intake of food. Fully mobile, and articulate, able to indicate psychological debate regarding the supposed ‘ Electra complex’ Catherine was not yet in the late stages of dementia, where significant weight loss might be expected. She was very seriously underweight, but NHS and Social Services staff had accepted Sibling 3’s claims of suspected bulimia or laxative abuse. In an 87 year old who never left the house and had no access to any money ? Mental Health records include several references to Catherine’s unsteadiness in walking. . Unsteadiness can be an aspect of dementia, but mental health professionals do not appear to have considered the most usual reason for unsteadiness. The physiotherapist who examined Catherine could find no physical cause. Visiting Catherine in respite care, Jane did not observe any unsteadiness. Evidence of the misuse of alcohol by Sibling 3 will be examined in the next chapter, including alcohol misuse associated with attempted financial abuse, which was reported by care home staff. Once again, no action was taken by Manchester’s NHS Mental Health staff, or by Manchester Social Services. 32
William was dying. Until mid-December, securing Catherine’s placement in permanent care was identified as a priority. Mental health attention for Catherine focused on this objective. On December 31st, as a patient on Ward H3, at the North Manchester General Hospital, Catherine had described the serious abuse she was experiencing, financial, physical, psychological, and the sexually inappropriate conduct of Sibling 3 towards William. The extent to which Catherine had been misrepresented as ‘Mary’, a state pensioner with a very different personal, medical and career history would emerge only slowly, when Catherine’s NHS records were released. Apart from William’s surname, neither he nor Catherine had any connection with Wales, yet Social Services staff and other authorities often referred to William moving ‘ back to Wales’, William’s father and paternal grandfather were born and lived in Manchester His maternal grandparents were entirely Irish, born in County Wicklow and moving to Manchester as adults. With a former partner, Sibling 3 had owned a property in Wales, but this had been repossessed by the mortgage lender. No other family member had any connection with Wales.
After listening to Catherine’s account of the abuses which she was experiencing, and having already some evidence of the property construction, Jane attempted once again to report ongoing abuse to the Police. Once again, the allegations were dismissed, but this time, Jane was advised by Greater Manchester Police that she could report to the police in her own area. On New Year’s Day, Cumbria Police took a preliminary record, giving the case a reference number identifying the abuse of vulnerable adults. Jane and her husband would return to Cumbria Police later in January, with bank statements which document extensive financial abuse.
After New Year, Manchester Adult Social Care and the Mental Health and Social Care Trust provided some contact details. Provided with the care manager’s email address, Jane sent several emails to him, detailing her concerns. All of these emails were delivered to him,@manchester.gov.uk. Until late September 2xxx, when she received Catherine’s NHS mental health records Jane did not know that this manager had received the copy of her letter reporting ongoing human rights abuses and financial abuse by email , on December 11th 2xxx Having this information, reporting serious ongoing abuse of a vulnerable adult, for whom he was care manager, he did nothing.
Mental Health and Social Care responses to reports of the ongoing abuse of Catherine and William were difficult. On January 3rd, during a telephone discussion with Jane , three days after he had directed that Catherine should be returned to Sibling 3, the care manager agreed that there was clearly a major discrepancy between Sibling 3’s accounts and reports from staff at the White Moss centre. During this call, the manager referred to reports from care staff that Catherine asked very firmly to be in residential care, and not with Sibling 3. At White Moss, on July 11th that year, Catherine’s fear of Sibling 3 had been obvious – and Catherine’s very different response when told by staff that the visitor was Jane. On January 6th 2xxx, Jane spoke to Catherine’s new Community Psychiatric Nurse regarding access to Catherine for family members. According to this CPN, Jane had ‘ issues’ with Sibling 3. This response was inappropriate and unprofessional. The CPN could know nothing about Jane . From Catherine herself, and from personal experience. Jane had serious information concerning the ongoing abuse. On New Year’s Eve, with Sibling 2, Jane had witnessed Catherine’s profound distress, as she described the ways in which she was constantly excluded from her husband’s company, by their own youngest daughter. Reporting the call, the CPN states that ‘ Mrs X was quite sharp in her tone’ The CPN questioned the lack of support Jane had given to Sibling 3, described by this nurse ‘struggling to care for both of them’. The nurse then indicated that they were ‘ all supporting her, the poor girl’ 33 This CPN had just been assigned to the case and appears to have accepted Sibling 3’s narrative without question. NHS mental health records records confirm the ease with which NHS mental health professionals were denied all contact with Catherine, and the ease with which Catherine’s existing medical history was misrepresented.
Mental Health and Social Services staff , including the new CPN, continued to recognise Sibling 3 as a dedicated carer. In 2xxx, after being denied any mental health support for fifteen months, at the direction of Sibling 3, Catherine was in ‘respite care’ in March, April, July, August, October and November. In July and August 2008, admitted only two days after a fortnight in ‘ respite’, Catherine was a patient at the NMGH for twenty-four days, even though she was medically fit for discharge on the second day. Discharged, she was placed in respite care immediately. Bank statements identify Sibling 3’s location and activities during Catherine’s extended periods in ‘ respite’ or in hospital. Financial activity was extensive, including a single transaction for £150,000 34
In the second week of January 2xxx, it was announced that a Best Interests meeting would be held on January 16th. On January 14th, the psychiatrist who had examined Catherine on December 12th 2xxx, recording a diagnosis of psychotic depression, reported a remarkable improvement in Catherine’s mental state. In a letter to Catherine’s GP at practice A, the hospital psychiatrist reported a remarkable improvement’. Catherine is reported as feeling much better in herself. 35 He considered that Catherine had the capacity to make decisions about where she would live. The ‘remarkable improvement‘ found by the psychiatrist is attributed to the new medication. The combination of olanzapine, escitalopram, donepezil, theophylline, bambuterol and singulair is not likely to be responsible for the apparent remarkable transformation in so short a time. On December 30th, Catherine had collapsed, her heartbeat was slow, borderline renal impairment was identified, she had seizures, and NMGH staff identified her mental condition as ‘ Severe Dementia’ 36
This review does not seek to examine all potential side effects of the six medications prescribed for Catherine. 37 The misuse of alcohol by Sibling 3 as a means of managing Catherine was included in referrals to Manchester Social Services and community mental health. Medication prescribed then for Catherine’s aortic and mitral valve regurgitation was not compatible with alcohol. The writer of this review has not been able to identify any reports concerning the combined effect of the six medications named above, prescribed for an eighty-eight year old with a history of dementia , cardiovascular disease and chronic breathing problems, usually identified as COPD/asthma, in a life long non-smoker. Regarding the effect of the medications, there is no indication here that the hospital psychiatrist would have considered the potential misuse of alcohol by a carer. Alcohol is not compatible with five of the prescribed medications listed on 29th December 2xxx. Prescription guidance for montelukast varies, but the medication can cause drowsiness. Side effects could be exacerbated by alcohol. 38 The independently documented administration of 40% proof alcohol to Catherine by Sibling 3, in the context of financial abuse is examined in the next chapter, A Long Meeting.
In January 2xxx, via email correspondence between Siblings 2,3 & 4, Jane had written evidence concerning the use of a six figure sum, money taken from William and Catherine’s accounts to pay for the construction of the property near New Quay, Ceredigion. Sibling 2 had copied this e-mail to Jane . Taking further legal advice, Jane knew that the ongoing abuse must be reported once again. On January 15th, the consultant old age psychiatrist confirmed that he would be willing to attend the Best Interests meeting scheduled for January 16th. Jane reported that she would not be able to attend. In Cumbria, severe weather had again closed local roads. Sibling 2 travelled to Manchester, but Sibling 3 would not be attending, reporting symptoms of norovirus. Catherine’s records for this period also include reported symptoms of norovirus, Aged 88, suffering from dementia and known to be seriously underweight Catherine received no medical attention. In the interests of infection control, people in normal health are advised not to seek medical attention for norovirus. For babies, young children, and the frail elderly, norovirus can be serious and even fatal. The bug is extremely unpleasant. It isn’t Ebola. Provision could be made for essential visits to frail elderly people with the virus. 39
The Best Interests meeting was rescheduled to January 21st. Returning to the south by train, on the evening of Friday, January 16th, Sibling 2 received a phone call from Sibling 3, during which Catherine was directed to state that she wished to remain with Sibling 3 According to Sibling 2, male voices urged her to go on, say it, Catherine. Sibling 2 expressed concerns about the extent of abuse Catherine was experiencing. Jane told Sibling 2 that she would contact Manchester’s Adult Social Care in the morning, reporting ongoing abuse of an older person. Next day, the duty officer’s response was not encouraging. There was no indication that any action would be taken. Road conditions had improved, enabling Jane and her husband to travel to Sheffield on Sunday, January 18th, delivering some of their younger daughter’s property. From Sheffield, Jane emailed Sibling 2, confirming that she would go to Manchester the next day, to report ongoing abuse, including the location of the property under construction in Wales and presenting the first definite evidence of the extensive misuse of William and Catherine’s assets. Safeguarding referrals had warned, accurately, that both were at risk, and that the risk to Catherine was greatest.
‘ No Secrets’ Department of Health, 2000
2.17 Patterns of abuse/abusing. Patterns of abuse and abusing vary and reflect very different dynamics. These include:
• serial abusing in which the perpetrator seeks out and ‘grooms’ vulnerable individuals. Sexual abuse usually falls into this pattern as do some forms of financial abuse;
• long term abuse in the context of an ongoing family relationship such as domestic violence between spouses or generations; • opportunistic abuse such as theft occurring because money has been left around;
• situational abuse which arises because pressures have built up and/or because of difficult or challenging behaviour;
• neglect of a person’s needs because those around him or her are not able to be responsible for their care, for example if the carer has difficulties attributable to such issues as debt, alcohol or mental health problems;
• unacceptable ‘treatments’ or programmes which include sanctions or punishment such as withholding of food and drink, seclusion, unnecessary and unauthorised use of control and restraint (see Harris et al 1996) or over-medication;
• failure to access key services such as health care, dentistry, prostheses;
• misappropriation of benefits and/or use of the person’s money by other members of the household;
• fraud or intimidation in connection with wills, property or other assets.
1 . Freedom of Information request, response to Jane by Manchester City Council
2 Home environment and dementia – NHS.UK https://www.nhs.uk › Health A-Z › Dementia guide
3 Health Soc Care Community. 2011 Jan;19(1):3-14. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2524.2010.00964.x. Epub 2010 Oct 11. The impact of domestic abuse for older women: a review of the literature.
McGarry J1, Simpson C, Hinchliff-Smith K.
4 Bilateral macular degeneration, bilateral ischaemic optic neuropathy. Manchester Royal Eye Hospital Records, 1986 – 2004.
4 08/12/2xxx, Events 57 and 58. MMH/SCT
5 11/12/2xxx. Event 61 MMH/SCT
6 10/12/2xxx MH/SCT. The psychiatrist defined Catherine’s condition as ‘ psychotic depression’.
7 https://www.nursingtimes.net/roles/mental.dementia...depression/5084104.article
Differentiating dementia, delirium and depression | Clinical Nursing ..
8 08/12/2008 NMGH
9 09/12/2008 Records requested M/cr City Council CC12 as requested, CPN.
10 Garden, G. (2005). Physical examination in psychiatric practice. Advances in Psychiatric Treatment, 11(2), 142-149. doi:10.1192/apt.11.2.142
11 11/12/2xxx NHS Hospital psychiatrist, to GP Practice B. MMH/SCT
12 Sprite Network, Manchester City Council. Referring psychiatrist to GP A. 12/12/2xxx Anti-psychotics to commence.
13 Civil registration records, England and Wales.
14 Shulman M, Miller A, Misher J, Tentler A. Managing cardiovascular disease risk in patients treated with antipsychotics: a multidisciplinary approach. Journal of Multidisciplinary Healthcare. 2014;7:489-501. doi:10.2147/JMDH.S49817.
15 29/12/2xxx Event 68 MMH/ SCT
16 Lenzer J. FDA warns about using antipsychotic drugs for dementia. BMJ : British Medical Journal. 2005;330(7497):922.
17 Marano, 2011, Cardiologic side effects of psychotropic drugs NCBI - NIH
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3390089/-
by G Marano - 2011
18 NHS Digital publishes dementia and antipsychotic drug prescription ...https://digital.nhs.uk/15 December, 2017:
19 29/12/2xxx, Event 71, MMH/SCT
20 30/12/2008 Event 74 collapse, incontinent A & E, NMGH
21 30 12/08 clinical notes, NMGH
22 .Wards of the roses BMJ 2009; 339 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.b5257 (Published 17 December 2009)
23 Electra vs Oedipus -by HC Freud - 2010 Taylor & Francis Group
24 https://www.marriagecare.org.uk
25 pmj.The work of marriage guidance counsellors - Postgraduate Medical ...bmj.com/content/postgradmedj/48/563/563.full.pdf by N Tyndall - 1972 -
26 Action on Elder Abuse | Sexual Abuse https://www.elderabuse.org.uk/sexual
27 Safeguarding people with dementia – SCIE https://www.scie.org.uk/dementia/after-diagnosis/support/safeguarding.asp
28 Abuse of patients with dementia by carers - out ... - Wiley Online Library onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/gps.930100903/pdf
29 Yukari Yamada, Michael D. Denkinger, Graziano Onder, Jean-Claude Henrard, HenriĆ«tte G. van der Roest, Harriet Finne-Soveri, Tomas Richter, Martina Vlachova, Roberto Bernabei, Eva Topinkova; Dual Sensory Impairment and Cognitive Decline: The Results From the Shelter Study, The Journals of Gerontology Series A, Volume 71, Issue 1, 1 January 2016, Pages 117–123, https://doi.org/10.1093/gerona/glv036
30 10/12/2xxx, MMH/SCT
31 31/12/2008 Event 80 Will be discharged to daughter’s address.
32 Alcohol and Older People - Royal College of Psychiatrists
33 06/01/2009 Event 84 Jane, phone call to CPN, RR to CPN
34 Abbey/Santander joint account, William and Catherine
released to Jane. .
35 07/01/2xxx Event 88, MMH/SCT
36 30/12/2xxx NMGH.
37 Guidance for Antipsychotic Use and Withdrawal in Dementia www.ipswichandeastsuffolkccg.nhs.uk
38 Singulair and Alcohol (Montelukast) – Drugsdb.com www.drugsdb.com › Prescription Drugs › Singulair
39 Deaths from Norovirus among the Elderly, England and Wales https://www.rcpsych.ac.uk/healthadvice/.../alcoholandolderpeople.aspxhttps://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2609872/
by JP Harris - 2008 -