6 A Long Meeting

Financial, physical and other abuses reported
Evidence of ongoing six figure abuse by Sibling 3 presented.
Statement given, dating onset of  Catherine’s memory problems
Statement signed, witnessed by care manager and social worker.
No action taken.
Best Interests meeting held at North Manchester General Hospital
Bank statements and other financial data recovered from Catherine and William’s house.
Ongoing abuse reported to Cumbria Police. Bank statements presented.
Cumbria copied report to Greater Manchester Police.
Bank staff at a Manchester branch of Abbey ( Santander) reported problems  when Sibling 3  visited the branch with a very old man. A transaction  was questioned.
Death of 98 year old William  NMGH.
Catherine not allowed to be with him.  Sibling 3 was
Within an hour of his death, Sibling 3 gave Catherine 40% proof alcohol
Attempt to obtain Catherine’s signature on cheques interrupted by  care home staff.
Five bottles of alcohol, mostly screw cap , at least one 40%, placed in Catherine’s room.
Reported to  Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust manager by care home.
No action taken.
Sale of William and Catherine’s house still pending. 
Estate agents informed by Jane  of William’s death, Catherine’s status as his widow.
New will produced, drawn up in May 2007,
Sibling 3 now principal beneficiary  Sibling 3 and niece executrixes.
Siblings 2 and 4 organised Catherine’s unassessed move to a new care home.


Financial abuse by another person or persons is readily identified, in that from August 23rd, 2xxx, when she was admitted to the North Manchester General Hospital, Catherine ceased to have any access to her property, including many treasured personal items, some of which  were part of her family history.  Catherine had no access to her headteacher’s pension, her state pension, or any of her savings, and, since the locks had been changed soon after  she was discharged to Sibling 3, no access to the house which had been her home for over sixty years.  Later , many personal possessions  were placed in storage  at a container depot. Payment for storage ceased.1

On Monday 19th January, Jane  travelled from Sheffield to Manchester by train, then by bus to the Adult Social Care offices in Harpurhey, North Manchester, arriving just before 11 a.m.  Jane  was alone.  Her husband remained in Sheffield, resolving a problem affecting their daughter’s computer. Reporting abuse of vulnerable adults for which close relatives could be responsible isn’t easy. Provided with the information, by email, Sibling 2 had not reported the abuse, but had forwarded the information to Jane . Knowing the correct legal position already, Jane  sought further legal advice.  According to the Office of the Public Guardian, and the Government website, the abuse must be reported, but in Manchester, the police had rejected her previous attempts to report what was happening.  Now, she was reporting abuse in person, to the acknowledged lead agency, the Social Services department of the local authority, Manchester City Council.  In this case, there could be no doubt that the reported abuse was a crime.  Stealing  money or other property from somebody of twenty, thirty or forty is a crime.  Stealing money and other property from  people aged eighty, ninety and older is a crime.   The crime Jane  was about to report was the theft of over a hundred and sixty thousand pounds from a blind man of 98 and his 88 year old wife,  when both were suffering from dementia.   This sum is separate from the  misuse of bank accounts and the pending sale of their house.

Intending to report ongoing and very extensive abuse of vulnerable older people, to Social Services, in accordance with directions given on the Government  website, and advice from the Office of the Public Guardian, Jane  had not considered the need for witness support.  She would be going to the Adult Social Care offices, reporting ongoing abuse of two vulnerable older people,  The statement would be made to people in public office, legally and morally committed to the safeguarding of vulnerable adults.  Making such a statement, the presence of a witness or legal representation should not have been necessary.  Signing the register at the Adult Social Care reception desk,  Jane  stated the purpose of her visit.  She was introduced to her mother’s social worker.  Once again, Jane  explained why she had come. The social worker’s response was unexpected :

‘ Who are you ? How many more of you are there in this family ?’ 

The social worker appeared agitated,  pushing her hands through her hair, and said that she had asked many times to be taken off this case.  The social worker’s claimed unawareness of Jane ’s existence is curious.  The previous Friday, January 16th, instead of the postponed Best Interests meeting, this social worker had spent some hours with Sibling 2.  But for the severe weather conditions in Cumbria, preventing travel, Jane, eldest child of Catherine and William, would have been present.  The social worker and Sibling 2 discussed care placement options  Potential care providers were visited, including Nazareth House, the Roman Catholic care home which Catherine and William had considered before the onset of dementia.  At the time, Nazareth House would not have been  able to provide the care  they needed.   The manager  and Jane had been grammar school classmates and could discuss  the best approach to meeting Catherine’s needs. 2

On January 19th 2009, Jane  was meeting this social worker for the first time.
According to Catherine’s NHS Mental Health records, not released to Jane  until September 13th 2011, the social worker had known of Jane  for many months.  Refused any information at the White Moss Care Home, Jane  had been advised to speak to  Adult Social Care. The call had been transferred to the social worker but at time, Jane  did not know who she was speaking to.  Frequently, during phone calls, both NHS and Social,Services staff did not and still do not give their full names.  Sometimes, a forename would be given, but not a surname.  On  April 23rd  2xxx, one  member of the  panel considering care applications referred to Jane ’s formal Frail and Vulnerable Adults safeguarding letter of February 18th 2xxx, warning of problems concerning Sibling 3, and providing full contact details. Mental Health and Social Care Trust records include a reference to this social worker’s telephone discussion with Jane  in April 2008, just before the  social worker and the care manager recommended that Catherine needed a permanent care placement, citing the danger  Catherine presented to herself and others.  3

 Staff making permanent decisions concerning Catherine’s future claimed to be unaware that she had four children, of whom Jane  was the eldest.   The  need for a  financial review is recorded in Catherine’s NHS records 4  If properly conducted, such a review could have revealed Catherine’s  correct history.  Manchester City Council would later accuse Catherine and William of failing to disclose their assets.  When any ‘ misrepresentation’ or failure  of disclosure took place, Catherine and William were both suffering from dementia, and , as Manchester City Council’s own register confirms, William had been blind for more than ten years.  Furthermore, Catherine had been diagnosed by NHS psychiatrists as suffering from a serious mental disorder. For this reason, Manchester City Council had authorised her  funded placement in care.

Now, in this social worker’s office, Jane stated that she had come to report ongoing abuse, having with her email records documenting financial abuse. in excess of £160,000.     After stating the purpose of her visit, Jane  produced some ID, and referred to her previous safeguarding referrals, made by phone and by letter over a three year period. The social worker said that they would not be able to take action following a verbal report.  To report abuse, people would have to come in person.  This is not true. The social worker added that they would not have Jane ’s letters now. J ane  indicated that this wouldn’t be a problem, as she had all her own letters and the Manchester City Council responses on her hard disk.  In hindsight, this response  might have been inadvisable.  At the time, it was given simply to assure the social worker that all correspondence with Manchester City Council Social  Services concerning Catherine and William’s safety was on record.

The meeting proceeded as if all information concerning abuse of Catherine and William was new to the social worker. Information regarding the construction  of the property near New Quay, Ceredigion was certainly known to her senior colleague, the care manager to whom Jane ’s letter reporting human rights abuses and financial abuse had been copied by email on December 11th.  The social worker herself had been closely involved in arranging Catherine’s permanent placement in care.

The social worker then reached into her right hand desk drawer and asked Jane  if she knew what a PROVA was.  The usual acronym for the reporting matters concerning vulnerable adults was actually POVA, but until Jane  recognised this, she used this social worker’s slight variant.  The social worker then began to take down Jane ’s statement, line by line, often pausing to confirm details.  The procedure was exactly the same as making a police statement.  The first information required by the social worker concerned Jane ’s recognition of her mother’s mental health problems. The social worker asked Jane  to give the best date she could for the beginning of Catherine’s memory problems.  The onset of  different forms of dementia can be slow, insidious, almost imperceptible, but Jane could offer a precise date,  when other family members were present,  September 28th 2002, when Catherine became confused and unable to pay for goods in Marks and Spencer’s . 

Taking the statement continued.  Jane  reported her increasing concerns for her parents’ safety and a situation complicated by blindness, dementia and her mother’s altered behaviour.  The misuse of alcohol by an older person affected by dementia is a difficult subject.  Catherine’s own concerns about 'excessive drinking'were on record in her North Manchester General Hospital  records for July 4th  2xxx, which were not released to Jane  until 26th August 2xxx   Sibling 3’s misuse of alcohol, administered, supposedly, to keep Catherine quiet, had been reported to Adult Social Care by Jane in June 2xxx, and is documented in NHS  Mental Health records, not released to Jane  until September 13th 2xxx.

Reference to Sibling 3’s medical history was appropriate, especially the brain tumour, as this is cited in the formal Frail and Vulnerable Adults letter of February 18th 2xxx.  Reference to other concerns was appropriate too, including Catherine’s obvious fear when in respite care at White Moss, and also, aspects of Sibling 3’s lifestyle.  Allegations concerning substance abuse were hardly necessary, and making such ‘allegations’ could be problematic.  The most easily accessible and damaging substance which could be administered to Catherine was alcohol, which is readily available and is not a controlled or banned substance.  Regarding the ongoing construction of the property at the southern end of Cardigan Bay, Jane  repeated her report that her father’s connection with Wales was slight, three generations distant, and that Catherine had no connection with Wales.

On January 19th 2xxx Jane , as the only sibling who did not have the new keys to the house in Blackley, had as yet no access to bank statements or any other financial records documenting the extensive misuse of William and Catherine’s assets.  She could and did report what Catherine had said on July 11th, at the  White Moss Care Home . Catherine had stated, clearly, ‘I know my mind doesn’t work but this is right. She has taken everything  and she has taken your Dad.’  On October 27th 2008, at the same care home, Catherine had expressed her distress at being separated from William, reporting to Jane  that they had the house, her headteacher’s pension, and their savings. They could afford to be together.  Next, Jane  produced copies of the email correspondence between  Siblings 2, 3 and 4,  copied to Jane  by Sibling 2.  The emails detail the amount of money already being used to finance the construction of the property outside New Quay, and the £60,000 retained by Sibling 3, identified as a ‘pot’.  Siblings 3 and 4 had not disclosed any of this information to Jane .

 Discussing the chances of retaining all the monies taken from William and Catherine with Sibling 4,  Sibling 3 refers to the successful actions of a friend who had obtained significant assets from another older person, and, after a three year battle, had retained everything.  Jane  presented printed copies of these emails to the social worker.  Information of this kind is important and should have alerted  Manchester Social Services to the possibility of systematic, planned abuses of older people, undertaken by people who understood how to proceed.  The email correspondence between siblings does not refer to the new wills, supposedly drawn up by William and Catherine in May 2xxx, or to the £1450 transferred monthly to Sibling 3 since December 2xxx from William and Catherine’s joint account.  5
Continuing her statement, Jane  said she had written to the Mental Health and Social Care Trust on December 1st, informing them of the ongoing abuse. Jane ’s statement concluded with her account of December 31st 2xxx, including Catherine’s wish not to remain with Sibling 3.

When the text of this statement was complete, the social worker then rang her senior colleague, the care manager, to whom Jane  had already spoken by phone, and to whom she had already sent emails regarding the abuse.  The manager greeted Jane , saying, ‘We meet at last’  then acknowledged that he was familiar with her published work, often reading columns written by her. Jane  had been a  columnist and feature writer in Cumbria  and a freelance contributor to some national  newspapers and magazines.   The  care manager read the statement, which Jane  then signed.  The manager and the social worker signed as witnesses to this statement. Studying the emails exchanged between Siblings 3 and 4, the care manager commented that William could not have studied any plans for the property under construction, because he was blind. When the statement reporting ongoing abuses was given, Catherine and William’s house was about to be sold, a sale initiated by Sibling 3. At this point, Jane  should have been provided with a copy of her statement.  The two officers who had witnessed her statement should have provided one,  Failing to provide a copy would enable them to claim ‘no recollection of any such encounter’.  This claim was made first to the General Social Care Council, then to the Health Care Professions Council, which ruled that it was not in the public interest for Jane to make repeated complaints about the same two people.    According to Manchester City Council, there was no reference to any financial abuse until March 27th 2xxx.  The acknowledgement that financial abuse was known to Manchester City Council by this date is interesting.  Manchester City Council’s date is incorrect, but the council did acknowledge awareness of financial abuse by March 27th 2xxx.  There is no evidence that the Council had taken any action to investigate the abuse of two vulnerable adults, both suffering from dementia, in March 2xxx or at any other time.

Through Manchester City Council’s role in the joint Mental Health and Social Care Trust, ( created 2002 –  dissolved 2016)  the city council had reports of extensive financial abuse  of William and Catherine by December 8th 2xxx,  when Catherine’s  original CPN received Jane ’s letter, reporting  human rights abuses and ongoing six-figure abuse of two vulnerable older people suffering from dementia.  As the lead professional, the consultant was informed of Jane ’s report at 12.00 that day, the time identified in the email correspondence.    On December 11th  2xxx Jane’s  letter was copied to the care manager, by email, @ manchester.gov.uk . No reason for the three day delay in copying this letter  is given.   According to the accompanying letter, no CPN was currently involved in Catherine’s case. The meeting on January 19th 2xxx, during which the statement reporting ongoing abuse was given and witnessed is documented in Catherine’s Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust records.   Unknown to Jane  at the time, the social worker who took down this statement knew of and  apparently endorsed, Sibling 3’s force-feeding of Catherine with liquidised sandwiches. 6  Knowing of this abuse, which many would recognise as torture, no  action was taken by Manchester Services or by any NHS mental health professionals.

After the  care manager left  the social worker’s office, the social worker rang Sibling 3, questioning the use of William and Catherine’s assets to finance  a new property in  Wales. This phone call became volatile. The social worker shouted at Sibling 3, who was demanding that the social worker   should name the person giving such information.  After this call ended, the social worker produced the handwritten care record for Catherine, offering it to Jane.  The phrase ‘ daughter not coping’ recurs frequently.  Examination of Catherine and William’s bank statements for 2xxx can be examined in conjunction with the timing of  Catherine’s extended periods in respite care, and Catherine’s prolonged hospital stay in July and August 2008.  In care, Catherine had reported to Jane  what was happening, but despite Jane ’s reports to the police, to NHS Mental Health and to Social Services, no action was taken by any public authority. .

Taking back the handwritten file, the social worker observed

‘ Once we knew about the money, we knew why she wanted to keep them’.

The money to which the social worker referred included Catherine’s headteacher’s pension, Catherine and William’s state pensions, the property they owned, savings of over £160,000, and at the time, for people aged over 80, £800 a year Winter Fuel allowance. 7     The handwritten social care records shown to Jane  by this social worker on January 19th 2xxx  documented a situation  in which both social services and  NHS mental health staff believed that Catherine’s ‘behaviour’ was having a detrimental and potentially dangerous effect on her husband and her daughter.  This is documented in Catherine’s NHS mental health records.  Having only a brief opportunity to read any of these records, Jane  is not able to comment in any depth on the social services narrative.  Manchester City Council Social Services including the care manager and Catherine’s social worker had accepted Sibling 3 as their sole and unchallenged source of information about Catherine.

Usually, this review does not include any discussions  between two people only which  are  not documented in official NHS or local authority records. The care manager had left the room when Jane  was shown her mother’s care records and when the social worker made her phone call to Sibling 3.  As the very serious meeting denied by the care manager and social worker is documented in NHS Mental Health records, reporting the period during which only the social worker and Jane were present is justified.  The two officers failed to present a report, backed by documented evidence, of serious and ongoing abuse of vulnerable older people. Evidence of financial abuse exceeding £160,000 had been presented to them, When the statement reporting ongoing abuses was given, Catherine and William’s house was about to be sold, a sale initiated by a person who had no legal authority to conduct such a sale. William and Catherine’s mental and physical health at this time is a matter of record. The care manager and social worker the  denied ' any recollection' of this meeting,

Jane  confirmed that she expected to attend the rescheduled Best Interests meeting at the North Manchester General Hospital on January 21st.  Leaving the Adult Social Care offices, she signed the book to confirm that she was leaving the building. The meeting with the social, worker, and for part of the time, the care manager, had taken just over three hours.  Outside the offices, Jane  rang a close friend, who lived in Prestwich.  Their mother's had been colleagues. This friend was Jane ’s key source of information throughout the period when she had no contact with either of her parents.   Next, Jane  rang Sibling 2, to confirm that she had reported ongoing abuse, making a formal statement. Jane  then walked to the North Manchester General Hospital. Snow was causing  public transport problems.  She was able to see her father, but he did not appear to be aware of her presence. Jane  then returned to Sheffield by train.  Adverse weather conditions affected travel  During the delayed journey, the social,worker rang Jane ’s mobile repeatedly, urging that Jane  must go to the Police. Jane  had  just reported ongoing  and extensive abuse of two vulnerable older people to the  local authority, which is usually the lead agency responsible for coordinating the response to any report of abuse. Reporting the abuse to Greater Manchester Police was now the responsibility of two Social Services officers employed by Manchester City Council.  The Manchester Social Services care manager had most of the information on December 11th, and the consultant, lead  mental health professional in  the NHS Trust  had the information on December 8th.

Throughout the following week, Catherine ’s social worker continued to phone Jane’s mobile and landline, urging  that the abuse must be reported.  When these calls were made,  Jane’s husband  was usually present, taking leave from full time employment to support Jane when she was reporting abuse  and presenting the first evidence to Cumbria Police.  Jane had already tried to report abuse to Greater Manchester Police, initially, as directed by the OPG, in November 2xxx, and again on January 1st 2xxx.   Because  the social worker had directed that Jane must apply to become Catherine ’s deputy, Jane and her husband had meetings  at the Windermere office of their solicitors.

 When the Office of the Public Guardian directed Jane to report ongoing abuse to the police in November 2xxx,  Greater Manchester Police warned her about making ' unfounded allegations.   Jane's approach to GMP on January 1st was also unsuccessful.  Following Jane ’s statement on January 19th 2xxx,  which they had both witnessed, the manager and social worker had a legal duty  to report the ongoing abuse  of vulnerable people  to the police . Failing to do so was a very serious matter.  The abuse of 98 year old William and 88 year old Catherine  was reported five years before the Care Act of 2014, but safeguarding legislation enacted to protect vulnerable groups was already in force.  Safeguarding of vulnerable adults operated centuries before the Mental Health Acts of the 20th and 21st centuries.8
When Jane  was reporting the abuse of her parents, behind the closed doors of a private house, gaps in safeguarding legislation had  been recognised. In October 2008, the Department of Health had published Safeguarding Adults: A Consultation on the Review of the ‘No Secrets’ Guidance. This consulation is especially relevant to the abuse of William and Catherine, referring in the introduction to the 2007 report, which was a joint Department of Health and Comic Relief initiative   9
Stating the obvious, no legislation can be effective unless it is recognised, respected and enforced. Nor will potentially abusive situations be recognised if NHS and Social Services professionals fail to undertake elementary safeguarding checks.   Accepting any third party as the sole source of information concerning a vulnerable adult of any age is unsafe.   Safeguarding vulnerable adults will never be effective if reports of abuse are ignored and even denied by people in public office, Referrals warning that Catherine and William  were at risk had been ignored. Mental Health and Social Services  professionals responsible for adult safeguarding had accepted third party rejection of mental health care for a woman in her late eighties with complex needs.  In an NHS hospital, ward staff had challenged Jane ’s claim that her father was blind.    A housebound  88 year old woman’s emaciation  was attributed, successfully,  to such unlikely causes as ‘bulimia’ and ‘ laxative abuse’ .     On September 1st 2xxx, Catherine is described as ‘ average height and weight’ 10 Catherine’s medical history had been comprehensively ‘misrepresented’. Two equidistant GP practices had been used alternately, letters from a hospital psychiatrist being sent to the different practices.  On December  31st 2xxx, the care manager had authorised that Catherine should be returned to Sibling 3, even though he had written information reporting ongoing and very extensive abuses.  Why would any care manager knowingly  expose a vulnerable person to the risk of further abuse ?


No Secrets

6.7    Management and co-ordination of the response to the allegation of adult abuse. Procedures for receiving a referral: Information suggesting that abuse may have occurred can come from a variety of sources. The matter may, for example, be raised by the person who is abused, a concerned relative, or a member of staff. It may come in the form of a complaint, it may be an expression of concern, or it may come to light during a needs assessment. Exceptionally, the first  notification may be made to the police, especially if the matter is very serious. The issue of handling information from an anonymous informant must also be addressed. The early involvement of the police may have benefits. 

In particular: • early referral or consultation with the police will enable them to establish whether a criminal act has been committed and this will give them the opportunity of determining if, and at what stage, they need to become involved;

No action had been taken following Jane ’s letter of December 1st, reporting human rights abuses and financial abuse.  No action had been taken  following the long meeting at the Adult Social Care offices on January 19th 2xxx .  during which Jane  presented written evidence of six figure abuse.  No action was taken when the first bank statements documenting extensive misuse  of Catherine and William’s  money  were  delivered to the senior care  manager. NHS records and Catherine and William’s bank statements confirm that the public authorities in Manchester continued to identify Sibling 3 as Catherine’s ‘ carer’, long after ongoing abuse was reported.  Public authorities  engaged in financial transactions with Sibling 3, knowing that this person had no authority to access any of Catherine’s assets.  11

On Wednesday 21st January 2xxx, Jane  returned to Manchester, attending the rescheduled Best Interests meeting which would discuss William’s mental capacity and Best interests.  The full report of this meeting was released to Jane's MP.  Before the  Best Interests meeting began, plans for a second meeting were discussed with Jane  and Sibling 2.  After the first meeting, an NHS staff member would engage Sibling 3 in conversation, remaining with this sibling until they left the hospital. The meeting would then reconvene.

Both NHS and  Manchester City Council Social Services staff were present, including Catherine’s social worker.  The  care manager who  witnessed Jane ’s statement was not present.  Sibling 3, identified as William’s ‘ carer’, stated that William did not want to go into care because he’d had bad experiences in care as a child, after his father had deserted the family. This claim was corrected immediately by Jane .  A soldier’s death in action  in WWI cannot be described as deserting his family.  More than ten years older than his wife, William was born in 1910.  William, his elder brother James and their younger brother David lost their father in May 1915.  In the army reserves, having served in the Boer War, their father was recalled immediately when WWI began.  William, not quite four, remembered waving goodbye.  David, who was only two, didn’t remember their father. Like many thousands of WWI widows, their mother couldn’t earn enough to feed and house her children.  The boys were cared for at an orphanage. Like William and his brothers, many of the boys had lost their fathers, not both parents.  As soon as they could, the brothers lived with their mother again.  12

William’s  January NHS records differ from NHS claims that he was able to swallow, and differ radically from  Manchester City Council claims that he and Catherine agreed to go into care together.  Neither were present at the Best Interests meeting.  William was a patient at the hospital. The Best Interests meeting confirmed that he was no longer able to make any decisions.  Catherine, having been returned to Sibling 3,  as directed by the care manager, was still at the house of Sibling 3 and unable to leave this house.  Preparing the sale of Catherine and William’s house, estate agents  were still waiting for William’s signature.

After Sibling 3 left the hospital, the NHS staff member returned and a second meeting was held. The social worker directed, in the presence of all those taking part in this second meeting,  that Jane should apply to become Catherine’s deputy.  Also, this social worker reported that she had asked Sibling 3 to hand over Catherine and William’s bank cards.  According to  the social worker, Sibling 3 responded that her solicitor had advised that she should not.  No proof of this claim was requested or offered.  In January 2xxx, in addition to the usual transfer of £1450 directly to Sibling 3, utility bills, supermarket payments and other expenditure is documented.  In cash, £50 was withdrawn from an ATM on January 17th, £250 from another ATM on January 19th, and a further £250 on January 22nd.  13

When the social worker announced that they would not be going to the police, Jane  assumed that this meant there would be no police involvement in the removal of Catherine from Sibling 3’s house.  Reporting the abuse to Greater Manchester Police was mandatory. Jane  had presented evidence to Manchester social workers of  the  acknowledged use of £160,000, belonging to Catherine and William.  Their house was about to be sold.  Other financial abuse would be identified later in 2xxx.  Throughout the following week, Catherine’s social worker phoned  Jane ’s mobile and landline, urging that the abuse must be reported to the Police.  Jane’s  husband was  present during these calls, taking some of his annual leave to support Jane.  

Leaving the hospital on January 21st 2xxx, Jane and Sibling 2 walked just over a mile to their parents’ house, Sibling 2 having keys to the house. There was a considerable accumulation of post in the porch and in the hallway.  Unable to find the fuse box in the dark, they each collected everything they could, agreeing to scan everything, and copy the results to each other.  Bank statements and other financial records for October, November and December  indicated extensive use of accounts held by William and Catherine.  There was also correspondence with a bank, concerning recent withdrawals and some personal correspondence. The exchange of scanned records was completed by Saturday 24th January.  Addressed to the senior care manager,  who had witnessed Jane ’s statement, copies of the bank statements documenting extensive third party use of William and Catherine’s assets were sent to the Adult Social Care offices.  Delivered to this care manager,  Manchester City Council had independent evidence of ongoing financial abuse at the same time as  the Police.  Sent to him by email,documented in Catherine’s NHS mental health records,  the  same manager had written information regarding the ongoing abuse six weeks previously, including the address of the property in Wales,supposedly commissioned by 98 year old William.

Preparing  Jane ’s application to become Catherine’s deputy,   Jane and her husband had  meetings with their solicitor.  Jane reported the meetings held in Manchester during the previous week, and presented the first documented evidence of the use being made of Catherine and William’s assets.  The solicitor required the name and address of  Catherine’s GP.  The care manager identified a GP  practice in Crumpsall,  North Manchester, identified in this review as GP Practice B.   The  solicitor wrote to this practice twice.   There was no response.  Solicitors’ letters are expensive. Sending repeated letters  to this GP practice had achieved nothing, apart from significant legal costs. Until Catherine’s NHS records were released to Jane , over two and a half years later, no evidence concerning Sibling 3’s use of alternating GP practices was available

As the social worker had urged, ongoing abuse was reported to the Police. Cumbria police had given Jane ’s initial report a file number on January 1st 2xxx. Now, they were returning with the emails which identify the use of a six figure sum, and  bank statement evidence of other financial abuse.  A  Cumbria Constabulary CID officer examined the evidence presented and  took a report from Jane .  As the alleged abuse had taken place in Manchester, Cumbria Constabulary referred the evidence presented by the s to Greater Manchester Police.  Jane  then rang the social worker to confirm that a police report had been made. Her husband was present. 

William and Catherine’s joint placement at Newlands  on January 26th 2xxx was arranged at very short notice.  At the time, Newlands was one of the few homes in the area which could offer a residential  place for Catherine and nursing care for William.  At the time, the quality of care provided by Newlands was good.  Staff at Newlands had recognised the abusive situation immediately, reporting attempted further abuses by Sibling 3, which are documented in Catherine’s NHS mental health records.  When very serious incidents were reported to them, staff of  Manchester’s Mental Health  and Social Care Trust failed to take action. Making an unfounded claim that she must be present during any police interview of Catherine, the social worker obstructed police investigation into the abuse. .

Visiting Catherine at Newlands, Jane brought some personal possessions retrieved from Catherine and William’s house.  While at the house,  Jane and her husband  took many photos, documenting conditions there.  Standing empty since August 2xxx,  essential maintenance and repairs had not been undertaken.  While Catherine and William’s financial assets had been used for another purpose, of no benefit to either of them, their own house had been allowed to fall into decay.  Jane and her husband  arranged for a locksmith to change the locks.  Changing the locks was reported at Harpurhey Police station, close to  the Adult Social Care offices.  A set of the new keys was given to Sibling 2 immediately. 

Catherine often expressed concerns about her house.  Some of these concerns are documented in her NHS Mental Health records.  The house in Blackley had been her home for decades.  There were many serious maintenance problems at the property. While Catherine and William’s resources were being used to fund the construction of  the house near  New Quay, their own house had been left to fall into decay.  Plumbing needed urgent attention, rotting floorboards had been taken up but not replaced, and overgrown vegetation was exacerbating problems  at the rear of  house.   Gas and electricity meter readings and safety checks had to be organised.   The risk of dry rot damage to adjoining terraced properties had to be addressed.  Waiting  at the property, Jane was able to locate a number of important documents, including her father’s Manchester Royal Eye Hospital appointment records and Low Vision clinic reports
  
On January 28th, Jane  and Sibling 2 were both in Manchester.  Together, they visited the  Abbey branch  identified in correspondence retrieved from Catherine and William’s house.  Copies of bank statements were presented, together with other financial correspondence.  A member of staff reported that Sibling 3 had visited the bank with a very old man. Problems arose when an intended transaction was questioned. Sibling 3 had become difficult.  Jane  and Sibling 2 then went to Newlands. Catherine’s social worker was there. Jane  did not know that no action had been taken by the  care manager and social worker following her  signed and witnessed statement  nine days previously.  Jane  still believed that the social worker’s statement regarding ‘not going to the Police’  had referred only and exclusively to Catherine’s removal from the house of Sibling 3.

During this meeting  with the social worker  at the Newlands care home, deputyship for Catherine was  discussed again. The  initial meeting with the ’s solicitor had already taken place. Their solicitor had, of course, taken the names, addresses and birth order of Catherine and William’s four children,  Jane  was aware of the considerable legal and financial accountability required of deputies.  She did not know , and would not know until receiving the  NHS Mental Health records on September 17th 2xxx, that this social worker and  care manager  had referred Catherine for permanent funded  placement in care.

Responding to the matter of deputyship, Sibling 2 said  :

‘ It has to be you. You’re the one she trusts. You were never part of the Cleveland Road regime.’

Jane  had not been involved,  but in the presence of the social worker,  Sibling 2’s words  indicated that the other three siblings had been involved, though not to the same extent.   Sibling 2's  prior knowledge of all care placements, including supposedly permanent placement in December 2xxx was evident and she knew the address of the  property under construction in Wales.  After Catherine was admitted to the North Manchester General Hospital on 23rd August 2xxx,  and especially after her discharge into an area covered by a different community mental health team, Jane ’s existence was not acknowledged.  If appointed as Deputy, Jane would have serious responsibilities in making decisions for her mother, managing her finances, and making decisions regarding health and welfare, acting at all times in Catherine’s best interests, and preparing an annual account for the Court of Protection.  As deputy, Jane  would have, on Catherine’s behalf,  the right to access Catherine’s financial, NHS and  Adult Social Care  records  On January 21st,   the social worker had urged her to make an  immediate application.  Now, there were major obstacles.

Before an application for Deputyship can proceed, it is necessary to establish that a person lacks mental capacity.  People may lack mental capacity because, for example:they’ve had a serious brain injury or illness, they have dementia, or they have  severe learning disabilities. The question of Catherine’s capacity was referred to her consultant  old age psychiatrist.,   Catherine’s NHS Mental Health records for would not be released  to Jane  until September  Sent by recorded delivery, they were collected from the post office on September 17th, less than three months before Catherine’s death.  Only then could the consultant’s incorrect dating of the onset of dementia be recognised, and the many  NHS mental health records documenting Catherine’s deteriorating mental health from 2004 onwards, including the recognition of dementia by her GP and the NMGH in June and July 2005.
William died at 15.05 February 4th, 2009, aged 98 years, ( 21/09/1910 – 04/02/2009)  NHS records  When he suffered a stroke, an ambulance was called. Catherine was not allowed to be with him. This decision was made by  Catherine’s  new  CPN, who ruled that it would not be appropriate. 14
Jane  obtained the information  of her father’s death from the NMGH,and rang Sibling 2 to say that their father had died.  Catherine’s distress after William’s death was not because he had died.    Not being allowed to be with her husband as he was dying caused profound distress.  Catherine asked repeatedly who had been with him.   Just over an hour after William’s death, Sibling 3 was with Catherine at Newlands.   Staff recognised a serious situation. Prompt action was taken . 15 
Jane  travelled to Manchester next morning,  On arrival, she was warned by Newlands staff that Catherine was unwell. They explained what had happened shortly  after William’s death.  Sibling 3 had arrived at  Newlands.  Before anybody could intervene, she had given Catherine 40% proof alcohol, then attempted to obtain her signature on cheques.

NHS Mental Health records for this period include the report that Sibling 3 had
placed five bottles of alcohol  in Catherine’s room, most having screw caps. At least one is identified in Catherine’s NHS records as 40% proof.  16  Catherine’s prescribed medication at this time included  five  which were not compatible with alcohol, especially in an 88 year old woman, suffering from dementia and so underweight, supplementary nutrition was required for over a year. 

Newlands staff  reported the alcohol and cheques incident to Manchester  Mental Health and Social care immediately.  The  care manager directly responsible for Catherine made a number of visits to Newlands during Catherine’s time there. No action was taken by the care manager  and  in NHS records, Sibling 3 continued to be identified as Catherine’s ‘ next of kin’ . Despite the extensive financial and other abuse reported to NHS and Adult Social care staff, this identification continued,

In June 2xxx, Jane  had reported Sibling 3’s  misuse of whisky, giving Catherine whisky to ‘ keep her quiet’. Catherine herself had acknowledged concerns regarding alcohol at the NMGH.  17   Visiting the house, in response to Jane ’s referral, staff had seen evidence  , including the presence of whisky bottles,  but accepted Sibling 3’s claim that buying whisky for Catherine had stopped.   In January 2xxx,  after preventing any NHS mental health care for Catherine from September 2xxx until December 2xxx,  Sibling 3 reported problems associated with alcohol to  the Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust . Catherine’s NHS mental health records for January 2008 include the following report :

‘ Will request alcohol and regards it as a tonic.  The daughter reports that if left to her own devices she will drink large quantities of liquer.'  (sic) 18

Catherine’s previous relationship with alcohol has no place in this review of safeguarding failures. Adults in good mental health make their own decisions regarding the consumption of alcohol. From 2xxx onwards,  Catherine  was suffering memory problems and altered behaviour, identified by her GP as dementia by June 2005 but in July 2xxx, she was still well enough to express concerns regarding  excessive drinking, which she  identified as recent. 19   On February 4th 2xxx, Catherine was very newly bereaved, and had tried, repeatedly, through her eldest daughter, to report financial and other abuse.

Administering the 40% proof alcohol, in conjunction with the attempt to obtain Catherine’s signature  shortly after William’s death might be regarded as a one-off incident.  Placing five bottles of alcohol in Catherine’s care home room at Newlands was a  serious matter, treated as such by responsible care home staff.  References to Catherine’s unsteadiness and ‘ dramatic movements  were made . 20   Reports of ‘unsteadiness’  could be an aspect of dementia, but should also be  considered in conjunction with serious incident reported by Newlands. 

3.7  No Secrets

Roles and responsibilities within and between agencies. When an allegation of abuse is made, the receiving agency must always notify the appropriate regulatory body, within any stipulated time limits, and also any other authority who may be using the service provider. Residential care homes are required under the Registered Homes Act 1984 (as amended in 1991) ‘to notify the Registration Authority not later than 24 hours from the time of its occurrence...of any event in the home which affects the well-being of any resident’, and specifically of:  any serious injury to any person residing in the home (Regulation 14(1)(b)); and any event in the home which affects the well-being of any resident (Regulation 14 (1) (d)).

The manager and staff at the Newlands Care Home had acted promptly and had reported  the alcohol incident  and attempt to have cheques signed to the appropriate regulatory body. The regulatory body had failed to take any action.

The day after William’s death, Sibling 2 was travelling from the south coast and would be staying in Manchester until the weekend, when Jane  and her husband would return.  Just before Jane  left Newlands, the manager handed her an envelope.  Sibling 3 wanted this to be given to Catherine. The manager had decided that it would be appropriate to give this envelope to Jane .  Opening it, after leaving Newlands, Jane  found a photo of her dead father.  As William had died within 24 hours of admission, in fact,  moments  after arriving at the NMGH by ambulance,  an inquest was  required. 20  Sibling 4 had already arranged to travel from Brazil to the UK. The inquest requirement delayed William’s funeral by over a fortnight. A post-mortem found that the 98 year old had suffered a stroke.

Immediately after William’s death and before the funeral, the sale of the house in Blackley  must be stopped.  Lawfully,  despite Sibling 3’s interference with the Land Registry entry,  the house belonged to Catherine.  Married to William for almost sixty two years, she had been a full time teacher, deputy and head for forty years, becoming the principal earner for her family.  On her way to the estate agents in Middleton, who were expecting a cash sale to proceed, with William’s signature, Jane  took a call from Sibling 4. Sibling 4 questioned Jane ’s intervention and rebuked  her for trying to involve the Police. The house sale was cancelled, but Jane ’s attempt to report extensive abuse of older people to the Police was compromised. Assessment of Catherine’s capacity was also deferred.  

Throughout 2xxx, Sibling 2 had notified Jane  regarding  Catherine’s repeated placements in care. From November 2xxx until William’s death, Jane  and Sibling 2 appeared to cooperate successfully.  The transition from Jane ’s comprehensive exclusion from their parents’ lives had been rapid.  Deputyship, including responsibility for  Catherine’s health and welfare would have given Jane   prompt access to Catherine’s NHS records, and enable her to secure appropriate mental and other support. Deputyship would also enable Jane  to obtain  prompt access, on Catherine’s behalf, to all financial documents. 

Aware that there had been no sign of police action, Jane  contacted the police again herself, at the station close to the Adult Social Care offices. This time,  she was able to present William’s Registered Blind Person’s card, issued by Manchester City Council on October 13th 1998. When the cash sale of this house was still pending, Jane  and her husband found the card in a bin bag, one of a number of bin bags stored inside the property.  William’s official white stick was also in the house.

Following a report of abuse of an older person, prompt police involvement is important. Already, the social worker and manager had failed to report ongoing and extensive abuse to the police and would  deny any recollection of the three hour meeting, documented in Catherine’s NHS Mental Health records. Now, the social worker was insisting that Catherine could not be interviewed by the Police unless she too was present.  No legal proof of this requirement was offered.  At a time of considerable stress, researching every legal aspect of a situation is difficult. The social worker’s claim was untrue, but at the time, Jane  did not know this.  Lack of cooperation from  Manchester social services presented a serious obstacle to any prompt police investigation. Catherine herself had reported ongoing financial abuse to Jane  in July and October 2xxx.  Other profoundly distressing abuse had been reported to Jane  and Sibling 2 on New Year’s Eve 2xxx.  When the abuse was reported by Jane on January 19th 2xxx  police requirements for interviewing children or vulnerable witnesses were as follows  : 

‘ Before the 1 April 2003 Code C of the Codes of Practice to the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 (PACE) suggested that the presence of an appropriate adult was required during interviews with children and vulnerable adult witnesses. Specifically, paragraph 11.14 said:
A juvenile or a person who is mentally disordered or mentally handicapped, whether suspected or not, must not be interviewed or asked to provide or sign a written statement in the absence of an appropriate adult unless paragraph 11.1 or Annex C applies

The question of whether or not an appropriate adult should be present during interviews with witnesses was finally resolved when the revised PACE Codes of Practice were published on 1 April 2003. The paragraphs of Code C have been renumbered a little so that what used to be 11.14 became 11.15. The revised  paragraph in the most recent edition (2008) of the Codes now says:
A juvenile or person who is mentally disordered or otherwise mentally vulnerable must not be interviewed regarding their involvement or suspected involvement in a criminal offence or offences, or asked to provide or sign a written statement under caution or record of interview, in the absence of the appropriate adult unless paragraphs 11.1, 11.18 to 11.20 apply. See Note 11C
The effect of this is that appropriate adults are no longer required in interviews with witnesses

The ACPO Position
While appropriate adults are no longer required, witnesses who fall within the scope of the interview guidance that succeeded the Memorandum of Good  Practice, Achieving Best Evidence in Criminal Proceeding: Guidance on Interviewing Victims and Witnesses, and Using Special Measures (Office for Criminal Justice Reform 2007) are entitled to an interview supporter if they want one. It is important to note that, unlike the Memorandum of Good Practice, Achieving Best Evidence refers to all investigative interviews with vulnerable, intimidated or significant witnesses they are recorded on video or not
(Introduction, page 1, ACPO Position Statement: The Presence of Supporters during Interviews with Witnesses   National Investigative Interviewing Strategic Steering Group (NIISG)

The social worker’s presence was not required. A police interview could have been organised. Jane , now Catherine’s nearest relative, could have been present as an interview supporter.  Without Social Services support, reporting the abuse of Catherine and William was now seriously compromised . The care manager and social worker had suppressed or actually destroyed Jane ’s signed statement made on January 19th, reporting ongoing  and very extensive  financial abuse. The focus on this  form of abuse is because it is most readily identified.  Given the existence of a property under construction, and the money trail from Catherine and William’s bank accounts, the evidence of financial abuse was strong. Repeatedly, the social worker had directed Jane  to go to the police, but offered no support when the abuse was dismissed by GMP officers as ‘a domestic’, in which the police would not get involved.   When  responsible care home staff reported a very serious incident to the regulatory body,  no action was taken. 

1  Property from the storage depot was retrieved by Jane and husband. Abuse of vulnerable adults and the abandonment of some property at the depot had been reported to the Police and to Social Services. 
2 This personal history was  helpful  when discussing Catherine’s care needs.  The manager advised Jane  that the best care available locally for Catherine would be at Heathlands Village in Prestwich.
3   23rd April, 2xxx,   Manchester City Council  Social Services, Community Care
4  21/05/2xxx, MMH/SCT 
5. e-mail correspondence,  copied to Jane by Sibling 2. 
6  Manchester City Council  Social  Services.  Report by social worker and panel agreement.
  , 23rd April 2xxx. 
7 The Winter Fuel  Allowance  was reduced in  2017
8  A Practical Treatise on the Law of Non Compotes Mentis
...https://books.google.co.uk/booksJohn Shapland Stock - 1838
9   UK Study of Abuse and Neglect of Older People:Prevalence Survey Report,M O’Keefe et al. (Department of Health and Comic Relief, 2007).
11 Bank statements, Abbey Santander.
12  Family papers,  including some held by members of William’s  extended family. ( none live in Wales)
13 Bank statements, Abbey  Santander 
14  04/02/2xxx Event 122   MMH/SCT   
15  04/02/2xxx, Event 123. MMH/SCT
16  05/02/2xxx.  Event 124  MMH/SCT
17  04/07 2xxx, NMGH
18  02/01/2xxx Event 15 MMH.SCT     
19   04/07/2xxx.  NMGH
20 12/01/2xxx  Event 99.   MMH/SCT
21 Which deaths must be reported to the Coroner ? www.manchester.gov.uk