7 The abuse continues here
Catherine removed from Newlands by Siblings 2 and 4
Care Centre demanded immediate unassessed placement
Company watch requested by Jane
R.C. care home bought by London firm in 2xxx
Occupancy levels low until 2xxx .
M/cr City Council Social Services concerns re nursing standards. .
Sibling 3 and associates welcomed.
Sibling 3 still identified as ‘carer’ by NHS Mental Health
Reinstatement of antipsychotic prescriptions,
Consultant’s report for Office of Public Guardian. April 2xxx
Gives wrong date for onset of dementia.
Dementia recognised, GP and NMGH records two and a half years earlier.
Known to Manchester Mental Health a year before diagnosis.
Age UK question inconsistencies in consultant’s report.
Solicitor, Alzheimer’s panel, disputed Catherine’s testatory capacity.
Same consultant’s letter to GP, Jane to make all decisions.
No information to Jane for over two years.
Deterioration in Catherine’s mental health.
Increased use of antipsychotics
Found in soiled bedding, faeces and urine, May 13th 2009. ,
Lasting Power of Attorney application May 29th
Papers given to Sibling 2 by social worker.
William’s NHS records. Jane ’s complaints about his care.
Internal meeting, North Manchester General Hospital
Care manager did not attend.
Sibling 2, new will for Catherine, August 2xxx. No role for Jane .
Sibling 3, unemployed, demands allowance from Catherine.
Abuse reported by Jane .
Catherine found in heavily soiled bedding again.
Consultant’s assessment of Catherine
‘ We had to go by what we had been told’
Another resident with dementia crushed by fire door.
Care centre prosecuted and convicted .
Catherine’s deterioration continued. Staff opposed any move.
Jane referred complaints to Care Quality Commission
CQC Inspection, 27th July 2xxx
Original CQC report citing seven serious problems taken down.
Company meetings, Catherine to be removed.
'The abuse continues here.’ 1
This was stated at the former Alexian Brothers Care Centre in New Moston, Manchester, on September 16th 2xxx, by Catherine’s social worker, following the long overdue meeting held at the Alexian’s on that day, to discuss Catherine’s care needs. The Alexian Brothers Care Centre was acquired by the Hospital Management Trust in 2xxx. In 2015, following a fatal accident to a resident, prosecution of the home and 2014 conviction, the centre was bought by MBI Social Care Ltd. The company marketed buy to let care home rooms, indicating a potential 10% return for investors. 2 Following the April 2017 CQC inspection, which found that improvement was required in every aspect of care provision, the centre was acquired by Qualia Care of Bradford and is now St Mary’s Nursing Home.
Arriving at the Alexians for the long delayed review of Catherine’s placement, Jane and Sibling 2 found Catherine extremely distressed. Sibling 3, unemployed, who was with two other adults and two infants, had been seeking an allowance from Catherine. Only Sibling 3 had signed in. Recognising and responding to Catherine’s distress, one of the nursing staff present at this meeting insisted that the meeting must reconvene in another place. Catherine’s distress must be respected.
Four days after this meeting, Catherine was admitted to the NMGH, after fainting and vomiting. Admission records refer to ‘severe dementia’.‘Florid piles’ and ‘impacted faeces in rectum’. Faecal impaction is an unpleasant condition. Catherine would have been feeling very unwell and could have been in pain. Alzheimer’s Scotland has published a comprehensive information sheet detailing aspect of this condition 3 Serious failings in personal care for Catherine are implicated. Constipation is one of the many side effects of antipsychotic medications, and also, people like Catherine, in the mid to later stages of dementia, are likely not to recognise the need to empty their bowels.
Catherine had been removed from Newlands to the Alexian Brothers Care Centre on March 20th 2xxx. A penalty charge of £2,2000 for removing Catherine without notice was sent to Jane , as Catherine’s nearest relative, by the company which owns the Newlands Care Home. Jane had opposed this precipitate move. No assessment of Catherine’s complex needs had been made. There was no evidence that the Alexians could meet Catherine’s care needs. 4
Whenever possible, care home placements should not be hurried. In March 2xxx, there was no urgency. After William’s death, Catherine had been supported by the whole Newlands community,
In the first days after his death, she was never alone, even when family members could not be there 5 There was no assessment of Catherine’s care needs, current or future. Catherine’s capacity had not been determined. Confirmed in her NMGH records in July 2xxx, dementia is a progressive disease for which there is still no effective treatment. Now aged eighty-eight, Catherine’s mental and physical health would continue to deteriorate. Suffering from dementia, she needed above all, safeguarding from further abuse, stability, and familiar surroundings. Discharged from the North Manchester General Hospital on September 12th 2xxx, to Sibling 3, the person identified in formal vulnerable adult safeguarding referrals, Catherine hadn’t returned to the house which had been her home for fifty-nine years. In the unfamiliar environment of Sibling 3’s house, Catherine had been unable to see friends. Some of her friends, including former teaching colleagues, contacted Jane to report this. All access to Catherine and William had been controlled by Sibling 3 – a situation fully documented in Catherine’s NHS Mental Health records, and regretably, respected by NHS mental health professionals. ’ Following the authorisation of fully funded placement in permanent care, in April 2xxx, there were four extended placements in ‘ respite’ and a long hospital stay, instead of the support and treatment which had been authorised for a recognised mental illness.
The unassessed placement was instigated by Siblings 2 and 4. Both NHS mental health and Manchester Social services recognised serious problems. Both failed to intervene. Catherine’s new CPN warned that such a move was ‘not always a positive thing for people who have Dementia’ 6 Catherine’s social worker also protested about the move, warning that it would be wrong. The social worker made a pre-arranged call to Jane, who was on her way to Sheffield, where her younger daughter had been ill for several days, requiring hospital tests. Jane’s husband was present throughout this call. Catherine’s social worker, who had visited the Alexians herself, insisted that the placement was wrong, and that staff at the Alexians ‘ would not be kind’. The social worker made this call to Jane, even though she and the care manager had failed to report the ongoing and well documented abuse of William and Catherine to the police. Recognising that the move to the Alexians was not in Catherine’s interests, and having seen evidence of extensive abuse by family members, Manchester Social Services allowed the move to take place. Social Services were still directing Catherine’s care. Aware that the move would be damaging, the care manager and social worker could have and should have intervened. Such intervention would, inevitably, require them to acknowledge the abuse which had been reported to the social worker, to the care manager, and to the NHS consultant old age psychiatrist. Shortly after Catherine’s removal to the Alexian Brothers’ Care Centre on March 20th 2xxx, Catherine’s social worker had a road accident and was absent for several weeks. Visiting Catherine soon after the move, her new CPN found that Catherine ‘did not look as well as I had seen her on my last visit’. 7
Newlands provides care primarily for the local Jewish community. Throughout Catherine’s short time here, her own Catholic traditions were respected, including the displaying of Catholic devotional images in her room. Jane had made arrangements for visiting, and, if Catherine wished, Holy Communion with the parish priest of the local Catholic church. Both rabbis visiting the home were friendly and welcoming. Catherine and William had many Jewish friends and through her mother's family, Catherine had Jewish ancestry. 8 Working in tailoring in Manchester, William had many Jewish colleagues. On the Rhine, after WWII, he served in the Jewish Brigade of the Royal Corps of Signals. Some family members strongly opposed the placement at Newlands.
Until their health declined, Catherine and William had been active members of an inter-church, international association based at Manchester’s Anglican cathedral. On admission to Newlands, Catherine was seriously underweight, needing prescribed supplementary nutrition, but at Newlands, despite her bereavement, her appetite was good. She had no problems with the kosher menu, which was prepared on site, and had enjoyed Jewish bakery products all her life. NHS Mental Health professionals recognised the improvement, but Catherine’s NHS records don’t include any questions regarding the unlikely explanations which had been accepted for Catherine’s severe weight loss while living with Sibling 3.
In the second week of March 2xxx, Sibling 2 informed Jane that she needed to visit a care centre operated originally by a Roman Catholic order. An appointment had been made for Wednesday March 11th. When Catherine’s NHS records were released to Jane in September 2xxx, entries showed that Catherine’s removal to this home had already been arranged by Siblings 2 & 4. Arriving at the home, Jane was shown a vacant room. Occupancy records for this date indicate other vacancies. Jane was not taken to any part of the home where she would meet residents. Without meeting any residents and observing both typical daily activities and the relationship between care workers and residents, an accurate assessment of a home isn’t possible. When Jane visited, a social event for local people was in progress. They did not appear to be care home residents. For five years (1992 – 1997) Jane was an Age Concern (Age UK) volunteer, working in client support. Her role in client support didn’t involve any financial responsibilities, but safeguarding checks and references were, of course, required. Jane was familiar with different kinds of care home.
Visiting the 72 bed R.C. care centre, Jane recognised immediately that a placement in this establishment would not be in Catherine’s interests, immediately or at any time. Visiting any care home, making an appointment is not advisable. The appointment had been arranged for her. Inspections, including both official examination by the Care Quality Commission or by family members investigating potential homes should never be pre-announced. Considering Catherine’s future care needs, Jane had visited the Alzheimer’s UK and Age UK offices in her local town, and had studied several published guides. 9
Leaving this care centre, Jane went to Newlands,where Sibling 2 was with Catherine. Sibling 2 informed Jane that their mother had something to tell her. When Catherine hesitated, Sibling 2 urged her to ‘say it’. Catherine then complied, stating, ‘I want to go to a Catholic home’. Next day, Sibling 2 indicated that Jane had made a bad impression at the Alexians. Potential residents and family members don’t visit care homes in order to make a favourable impression on a business which is selling a service. They go to find out whether a home will be able to provide the right kind of care for their family member. The environment of this centre could not and did not ever meet Catherine’s complex needs, medically, emotionally or legally. Having experienced prolonged and extensive abuse, evidence of which is documented throughout her NHS records, bank statements and other financial accounts, Catherine needed responsible and effective professional support, and, as the victim of many forms of abuse, she needed justice. Catherine had reported ongoing abuse to Jane, but Jane ’s attempts to report abuse had been dismissed by the police and suppressed by the care manager and social worker in Manchester's Mental Health and Social Care Trust,
Immediate transfer from Newlands would not be in Catherine’s interests. She had just experienced the most serious distress of all, the death of her husband, after almost sixty-three years of marriage. 10 Throughout the last year of his life, measures had been taken by the Mental Health and Social Care Trust to prevent her from being with William. Mental Health records give the reason for this. Identified as being a danger to her husband, to herself and to others, Catherine saw little of her husband in the last year of his life. Seen by her new CPN on January 22nd, Catherine said – accurately enough, given her experience since Sibling 3 became her ‘carer’, that she would not be seeing her husband, they wouldn’t let her. 11 When Jane challenged the supposed need for immediate uptake of a place at the Alexian brothers, a senior staff member made a confrontational call to Jane ’s landline, warning that if the place was not taken up immediately, Catherine could be waiting for two years. The hard sell tactics were both unprofessional and untrue. In March 2xxx, Catherine was 88. In 2011, an LSE study found the mean length of stay for a female over 85 to be 717 days.12 Jane knew, from the senior care manager himself,that Manchester City Council Social Services had concerns about the standard of nursing care at this establishment. Requesting a company search, Jane found that the home had been acquired by a London based company in 2xxx. Low occupancy had been a problem. Catherine needed above all a period of stability and security. Since August 23rd 2xxx, she had experienced prolonged and unnecessary hospitalisation, then immediate removal to the house of Sibling 3 and the loss of the house that had been her home since 1947. Suffering the distress and confusion of dementia, she had been denied mental health support for over fifteen months, and support for her heart condition. Then, her medical history had been ‘ misrepresented’ . Throughout 2xxx, there were repeated and lengthy placements in care. Except for two weeks in April 2xxx, when William was also placed in respite care at White Moss, Catherine had been on her own.
In legal and financial matters, Sibling 3’s actions are clearly and comprehensively documented. As Catherine reported, accurately, on July 11th 2xxx, Sibling 3 had ‘taken everything’ and she had ‘taken’ William. Assessing the precise nature of Sibling 3’s inappropriate relationship with her father is problematic. As Catherine herself had said, it wasn’t normal for an adult woman to have such a relationship with her own father. Making formal referrals, warning Mental Health and Social Care authorities in Manchester, Jane had focused firstly, on two aspects of physical risk, the combination of William’s blindness and Catherine’s already diagnosed dementia, and the alcohol administered to Catherine by Sibling 3, ‘to keep her quiet’. Secondly, and concerned for this sibling as well as for her frail parents - an aspect of these referrals apparently not recognised by public authorities, Jane reported Sibling 3’s history of brain tumour surgery, and ‘other serious health problems’ .
When Catherine and William’s placement at Newlands began, Catherine’s true history, including her financial status, was already known to the consultant old age psychiatrist at the Mental Health and Social Care Trust and to Catherine’s original CPN. The care manager and social worker also knew, and had themselves negotiated Catherine’s placement in care, at the home in Cheetham Hill, with a diagnosis on December 10th 2xxx of a serious mental health condition, identified in her records as psychotic depression. 13 The construction of the property near New Quay, Sibling 3’s acknowledged use of over £160,000 , extensive use of Catherine and Williams accounts and the imminent house sale were all known. Bank statements had been presented to the care manager, and copied to Greater Manchester Police by Cumbria Constabulary. Following the meeting with Jane and Sibling 2, at the Abbey/Santander branch in Cheetham Hill, Manchester, all use of these accounts should have ceased. No deputyship had been authorised by the Court of Protection, , nor had any Lasting Power of Attorney been granted. Identifying Catherine now as ‘ self funding’, Mental Health and Social Care Trust staff continued to recognise Sibling 3’ s supposed status as Catherine’s ‘ carer’ . In financial matters, Manchester City Council Social Services continue to interact with Sibling 3 until Lasting Power of Attorney was registered in July 2xxx.
Days after Catherine’s removal from Newlands, Jane’s elder daughter, a postgraduate student at Manchester university, visited her grandmother. She reported a marked deterioration, after the considerable recovery evident at Newlands. Visiting herself, Jane found the report accurate. Two and a half years later, receiving Catherine’s NHS Mental Health records, Jane discovered that this marked and almost immediate deterioration was recognised by some NHS Mental Health staff, including Catherine’s most recent CPN. 14 The Alexians had insisted on immediate uptake of a place. A new client had been secured for a care home with recent occupancy level problems. There was some initial enthusiasm, immediately after admission. Welcoming Sibling 3, management at this care centre stated that they ‘ liked families to get on.’ .
On April 16th, the consultant old age psychiatrist’s report on Catherine’s capacity for the Office of the Public Guardian stated that she had the capacity to grant Lasting Power of Attorney. The consultant identified Jane and Sibling 2. The report identifies both Alzheimer’s disease and vascular dementia. In this report to the Office of the Public Guardian, the date given for the onset of dementia is wrong, and very seriously wrong, more than two and a half years later than the date given in NMGH records, and by Catherine’s GP. 15 Given the imperative need for prompt treatment, and the vulnerability of dementia sufferers to abuse, accurate medical records are vital.
Catherine’s repeated statements to the effect that she wanted Jane to make all decisions for her are confirmed in NHS Mental Health records. The same consultant had made a separate report, in a letter to Catherine’s new GP. This report states that Catherine wanted Jane to make all decisions for her. 16 Jane took the capacity report for the OPG to the Age Concern ( Age UK) offices in Kendal. The senior advisor was not satisfied with this report, questioning serious inconsistencies. Jane was advised to consult solicitors on the Alzheimer’s panel and/or solicitors for the elderly.
The first firm she approached would be able to meet Catherine on April 28th 2xxx. Sibling 2 would be visiting that day. After meeting Catherine, this solicitor advised Sibling 2 that he did not agree with the report which identified Catherine as having capacity. Specifically, he was not satisfied that she had testatory capacity – that is, she was not mentally competent to make a new will. Sibling 2 did not accept this opinion, claiming that Catherine ‘did not have dementia’ 17 Denying that Catherine was suffering from dementia was inexplicable.
Jane again consulted Age UK. After this consultation, she approached the Mental Health and Social Care Trust, to discuss obtaining a second opinion. This approach was not accepted, and Jane did not have the support of Manchester City Council Social Services. Jane approached another firm on the Alzheimer’s panel and arranged to meet one of their staff at the Alexians. When Jane arrived at the care centre, one of the domestic staff informed her that Catherine had not left her room that day. This was in the early afternoon. Entering the room, the smell was extremely unpleasant. Catherine was lying in wet and soiled bedding, clearly unwell… Jane went to the reception desk to report Catherine’s condition, and the need for a doctor. When the solicitor arrived, Jane explained that her mother was unwell.
A meeting was summoned for May 29th, to be held at the care home, for the completion of ‘Joint and Several’ Lasting Power of Attorney forms, directed by Catherine’s social worker. Catherine was present, clean and neatly dressed, but did not take any active part in completion of the form, which was carried out by the social worked The social worker spoke almost exclusively to Sibling 2. Catherine’s signature was obtained, but she gave no indication of reading any of the document. Apart from signing where she was directed to sign, she had taken no part in the granting of Lasting Power of Attorney. The social worker then handed the completed forms to Sibling 2.
Until Joint and Several Lasting Power of Attorney was registered by the Office of the Public Guardian, Catherine’s named attorneys, Jane and Sibling 2 could not lawfully access Catherine’s accounts or manage her property. When Catherine’s financial data became available, including previous bank statements,it appeared that the care manager and social worker had continued to recognise the supposed authority of Sibling 3. 18 Both had seen the e-mails acknowledging the construction of a property near New Quay, using at least £100,000 of Catherine and William’s money. Bank statements recovered from the house in Blackley had been delivered to the care manager, at the same time that these statements were presented to the police. Evidence of extensive financial and other abuses was comprehensive, and the social worker herself had described the force feeding with liquidised sandwiches, apparently regarding this as acceptable treatment of a frail 87 year old. 19
Essential maintenance work at the house in Blackley continued, undertaken by Jane and her husband. At the same time, Jane was pursuing a complaint about William’s care at the North Manchester General Hospital, including the steps taken to prevent Catherine from visiting him, even on the afternoon of his death. ( To comply with complaint requirements, this had to be rephrased, as preventing William from being visited by his wife) . Jane also questioned William’s physical condition when discharged from the NMGH to Newlands. NMGH records indicate that he was unable to swallow. Discharged to receive continuing care, William should have been funded as an NHS patient. William’s nursing care for the eight and a half days he spent at Newlands cost over £800.
Held in response to Jane ’s complaints about her father’s care, the first meeting at the NMGH was on July 27th 2xxx. The care manager indicated that he would not be attending this meeting. Jane hoped to present a copy of the handwritten letter which she had sent on December 1st 2xxx, reporting extensive ongoing abuse. Visiting the Adult Social Care offices in Harpurhey on the morning of July 27 th, Jane asked to see the care manager, stating the purpose of her visit. The manager came down to meet Jane at the reception desk, returned to his office for some time, then came back to reception, claiming that could not find this letter. Jane did not know then that the scanned copy of her letter had been copied to him by email on December 11th the previous year. 20 The NMGH meeting was also attended by Jane ’s advocate. NHS staff insisted that it would not have been appropriate for Catherine to be with William when he was dying. Catherine was referred to as ‘rather an elderly lady, and rather a frail lady’ ‘Frailty’ is often used as a synonym or euphemism for dementia. 21 Nearly six months after William’s death, Catherine was still grieving, not because William had died at 98, but because she had not been allowed to be with him at the last. During this meeting, Jane reported Sibling 3’s action, in delivering to the care home a photograph taken of William after his death.
A partial apology was offered by the hospital. Members of the public are not necessarily familiar with the complex structure and terminology of the NHS complaints procedure. Studying the NMGH response, Jane ’s GP, who had advised and supported Jane in her attempts to obtain information about her parents, indicated that much more needed to be investigated. In February 2xxx, responding to Jane ’s further complaints about failings in William’s care, the Pennine Acute Hospitals Trust recognised some of the safeguarding failures, acknowledging that Jane had given grave warnings and that staff had failed to act upon these warnings. 22 At this point, other serious matters were unresolved. The complaint concerned the care of two very old people, married for over sixty years. Failings in the care of one had, inevitably, a serious negative impact on the wellbeing of the other. Catherine’s records from the NMGH and Mental Health and Social Care Trust would not be released to Jane for over two years. The prolonged delay in gaining access to Catherine’s NHS records impeded further complaints. Some of William’s records have still to be released. Once again, Jane's right to access any of her father's records has been
disputed by an NHS Trust.
Visiting Catherine at the Alexians, immediately after the NMGH meeting, Jane found her mother mystified by a framed photo of newborn twins. Did she know anybody who had had a baby ? Later, the twins would be identified incorrectly by Alexian staff as Sibling 3’s grandchildren. Sibling 3 had no children, either by birth or by adoption. Catherine’s inability to recognise grandchildren appears in her NHS Mental Health records. None of Catherine’s grandchildren lived in Manchester. Two grandchildren spent most of their childhood and adolescence in other countries. Her youngest grandchild was born in London in July 2xxx shortly before Catherine’s memory problems and changing behaviour became evident.
On July 28th, the day after this meeting at the NMGH Sibling 2 rang Jane , claiming, incorrectly, that Jane had applied to become Catherine’s deputy. This was untrue, but, as Catherine’s social worker had directed on January 21st that Jane should apply for deputyship, Jane had approached the solicitors, in preparation for an application. Deputies: make decisions for someone who lacks capacity. 23 The consultant old age psychiatrist who reported, incorrectly, that Catherine began to suffer from dementia in December 2007 had reported to the Office of the Public Guardian that Catherine had the capacity to grant Lasting Power of Attorney.
Jane approached the Court of Protection, in case the application for deputyship had been processed by mistake. Jane was informed by letter that an application for deputyship for Catherine had been received, but this had been made by another person. There had been no error on the part of her solicitor. The maker of this application was not identified by the Court of Protection. Jane tried to discuss the matter with the care manager who had witnessed her statement reporting ongoing abuse. The care manager stated that he could not discuss anything with her. Jane's husband was present when this call was made. Sibling 2 also informed Jane that she could not work with her and would be ‘taking charge’.
Although questioned by Age UK and the Alzheimer’s panel solicitor, who did not recognise Catherine as having testatory capacity, the consultant’s report had authorised the granting of Lasting Power of Attorney by Catherine, jointly and severally to Sibling 2 and to Jane . The social worker had given the completed forms to Sibling 2. Initially, Sibling 2 sent Jane a photo copy of the LPA document. Photocopies are not acceptable. An official hologrammed copy was required. Eventually, in September 2xxx a hologrammed copy was sent to Jane , but in August 2xxx, Sibling 2 had already drawn up a new will for Catherine. In the new will, Sibling 4 is identified as sole executor. Jane was not informed about the making of this will. Having the Lasting Power of Attorney document, Sibling 2 had assumed sole authority. Legally, an Attorney cannot make a new will for a donor. It is possible for an attorney to arrange for a new will to be drawn up, but an application must be made to the Court of Protection. 24
According to the Office of the Public Guardian, only one original Lasting Power of Attorney document is issued. Questions submitted by Jane ’s MP received the same response. The OPG offered no explanation for this policy. Historically, the OPG’s position cannot be justified. Important documents are always copied. There were four originals of Magna Carta, and around two hundred of the Declaration of Independence. The duplicated text of indentures written on parchment provided simple contract copying. The issuing of only one primary document devalued the supposed joint and several status of Lasting Power of Attorney, in that a named attorney not holding the original document has, demonstrably, less authority than the holder. Most financial institutions, including Santander, HSBC and Nationwide declined to accept Jane ’s hologrammed copy. Confusion over the status of joint and several Lasting Power of Attorney was widespread in England and Wales. As the eldest sibling and since William’s death, Catherine’s nearest relative, Jane ’s ability to act in Catherine’s best interests was seriously compromised. Jane had no access to any of Catherine’s remaining assets, to meet any necessary expenditure on Catherine’s behalf.
Jane could not be refused access to the bank statements, which documented extensive misuse of Catherine and William’s assets,. Atypical use of their accounts appears to have begun some time before their removal to the house of Sibling 3, including what appears to be extensive use of cards. Detailed forensic accounting would be required to confirm this. In 2xxx the statements include the transfer of a debt recovery payment and Sibling 3’s utility bills and all other household expenses. The initial monthly transfer of £450 became £1450 . The person operating this account had unlimited use of Catherine and William’s bank cards. A major long term investment bond with the Prudential had been cashed in at a low value, before the first death. Sibling 3’s name had been added to accounts, then Catherine’s name had been removed. All the major movements of funds were into this account, now in the names of Sibling 3 and William, On William’s death, Sibling 3 had sole access to this account. In November 2xxx, Jane made an appointment at the nearest branch of Santander, questioning the lack of access to this account, but was publicly rebuked by bank staff for seeking access to another person’s private bank account, i.e, the account to which Sibling 3’s name had been added, then Catherine’s name removed. All these financial movements had been made at the instigation of a person who was not a Deputy and did not have Power of Attorney.
3.7 No Secrets
Roles and responsibilities within and between agencies.
When an allegation of abuse is made, the receiving agency must always notify the appropriate regulatory body, within any stipulated time limits, and also any other authority who may be using the service provider. Residential care homes are required under the Registered Homes Act 1984 (as amended in 1991) ‘to notify the Registration Authority not later than 24 hours from the time of its occurrence...of any event in the home which affects the well-being of any resident’, and specifically of: any serious injury to any person residing in the home (Regulation 14(1)(b)); and • any event in the home which affects the well-being of any resident
(Regulation 14 (1) (d)).
Approaching Action on Elder Abuse, Jane ’s position was constrained by her lack of access to any of Catherine’s remaining assets. She could not engage a solicitor and had already incurred significant costs. While returning from taking her younger daughter back to university, Jane took a pre-arranged call from Action on Elder Abuse, who advised that she should refer the case to a named person on Manchester’s Adult Safeguarding Board. No reply was received.
Cumbria CID had acted appropriately, examining the evidence of financial abuse of vulnerable adults presented to them and referring all this data to Greater Manchester. In Manchester the financial and physical abuse of vulnerable older people aged 98 and 88, suffering from dementia, blindness and uncorrected hearing impairment was dismissed, repeatedly, as ‘ a domestic, we don’t get involved’. At Collyhurst police station, keeping an early morning appointment, the desk sergeant’s response was specific: ‘ This is about three sisters, isn’t it ? It’s a domestic. We don’t get involved.’ Another desk officer suggested that ‘ in a lucid moment’, Jane ’s parents could have agreed to everything. Issued by Manchester City Council, ten years before the reported ongoing abuse, William’s Registered Blind Person’s card was presented to the Greater Manchester Police, proof that the reported six figure abuse involved a victim who was blind. No action was taken, but in the summer of 2xxx, Jane was warned that she could be charged with ‘ wasting police time’, an offence which can result in a six months prison sentence. NHS records documenting blindness, dementia and the findings of a Best Interests meeting conducted at the NMGH were submitted to Greater Manchester Police. Jane’s husband, who works in the financial sector, prepared an analysis of the misuse of William and Catherine’s assets, which was presented to their MP. The MP then approached the Chief Constable. The alleged abuse of Catherine and William was identified as Criminal Deception.
During the autumn of 2xxx, police assessment of the evidence began, but the case had been assigned to a young constable. As the Social Care Institute for Excellence has recognised, the investigation of financial abuse requires skilled and experienced officers. 25 The constable liaised primarily with Sibling 2,who had instructed a solicitor to identify the matter as contested probate. Drawn up, supposedly, by two people suffering from dementia, one of them being also blind and hearing impaired and including many mis-identifications of legatees and one executrix, this will was seriously flawed and should have been challenged as invalid. 26
William's Registered Blind Person's card could be issued only when William’s GP and the local authority had received their copy of the certificate confirming that William was blind. Why GMP did not accept the card as evidence of William’s blindness is unclear. Requesting access to William’s opthalmology records from the Manchester Royal Eye Hospital, NHS access to records protocols should have led to sight of the original certificate confirming blindness, held by the Medical Legal departmen of the Central Manchester University Hospitals . GMP reported, by email, that the investigation into abuse was now closed, because William would have been able to read. The email cites GMP’s incorrect interpretation of opthalmology data which confirms that William was blind. Not medically trained, GMP officers apparently did not understand the significance of the number which a trainee registrar had given to a constable. GMP seem to think that the number meant that William would be able to see clearly for up to a metre. In fact, the ratio means that the patient can only see at one metre what a normally sighted person can see at 36 metres. Crucially, suffering from macular degeneration, William had no focal vision, so was unable to read anything. In one eye, he could detect only hand movements.
Later, GMP officers would accept the will drawn up in 2xxx by Sibling 3 as valid, GMP also accepted claims by witnesses to this will that William had no problems with his sight, and a claim from the other executrix that he ' definitely wanted to move to Wales'. When Jane submitted medical records from the Manchester Royal Eye Hospital which confirm that William was blind, GMP ‘s reply was that ‘ there is no evidence to support your belief that your father could not see anything’ . ( writer’s italics) Jane’s MP then submitted the same evidence, that is, William’s Registered Blind Person’s card, and the certificate completed by his consultant opthalmic surgeon, registering him as blind. GMP’s response was almost identical ‘ No evidence to support your constituent’s belief that her father could not see anything’ The addition of the ‘weasel word’ ‘anything’ negates the legal status of blindness. Only a minority- around 4% - of people legally blind can’t see anything. Most people who are registered as blind have some residual sight. Severely sight impaired/blind, they ‘cannot do any work for which eyesight is essential’ . Only the minority who have no light perception (NLP) cannot see anything
On December 16th 2xxx, Sibling 2 rang Jane to report that many of Catherine and William’s possessions were in store at a container depot on the outskirts of Manchester. Sibling 2 supplied the name and contact details of the person charging for this storage. Jane was informed that the outstanding fee for storage was already £200. At the time, the Greater Manchester Police investigation into a case identified as Criminal Deception was still active. The goods held in storage belonged to Catherine and had been taken from her. For this reason, Jane hoped for police support. None was offered. The storage depot confirmed that a named contractor leased space. Meeting the contractor in a public place, Jane paid the £200 he required. A receipt was supplied. The misappropriation of Catherine and William’s possessions is relevant to this serious case review because NHS and Adult Social Care staff in Manchester were responsible for the safeguarding of Catherine and William. Their duty of care included the protection of their property. Before the Care Act of 2014, Catherine and William’s property should have been protected in accordance with the guidance presented in existing legislation. Every aspect of the abuses experienced by William and Catherine is defined in ‘ No Secrets’ . The duty of care towards property is also defined on the National Assistance Act of 1948 and in subsequent legislation.
At the container depot office, Jane and her husband faced a problem, in that the contractor appeared to be taking directions by phone from Sibling 3, who directed the site operators that Jane and her husband should not be allowed to recover Catherine’s property. Jane presented her hologrammed copy of the lasting power of Attorney. 27 Jane and her husband took as much as they could, to store at the house in Blackley. Retrieving all contents wasn’t possible. Severe weather was imminent and they needed to collect a large wall clock , placed with a clock repairer, whose bill of £1200 had not been paid by Sibling 3. In snow, the return to Cumbria was difficult. In January, when conditions improved, Jane and her husband collected the rest of William and Catherine’s possessions from the container depot, to be stored on the upper floor of the house in Blackley, because the ground floor was now unsafe.
On March 25th 2xxx, one psychiatrist with the Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust reported, incorrectly, that ‘none of the daughters have visited for a very long time’ 28. Jane had visited on January 22nd,February 26th, March 14th and March 16th . In December 2xxx, the same psychiatrist is identified in letters about Catherine sent to different GP practices on successive days. 29 Even without access to the NHS records, difficulties affecting Catherine’s quality of life were obvious. The care placement was in no way appropriate for any resident with Catherine’s complex needs. Her constant distress affected other residents. Calling for William, she often expressed her wish to die. Monotony exacerbated her distress. Just once, eighteen months after her arrival, Catherine – still referred to by this care home as ‘Mary’ was taken out, to visit a supermarket. Supermarkets can be stressful for healthy adults in control of their lives. Small children express their own distress. From choice, when in good health herself, Catherine hadn’t shopped at the store which she was taken to visit.
On March 16th 2xxx, at the invitation of Catherine’s new GP, Jane kept a surgery appointment in Catherine’s name. Asked if she believed her mother’s care needs were being met, Jane gave the only answer possible. Catherine’s needs were not being met. Two days later- a Mental Health Trust psychologist ‘s report for 18th March 2xxxrefers to Catherine hitting out at staff, ‘ very low in mood since moving to the home’ suffering from hallucinations and delusions. Throws used toilet paper around the room.' 30 In March 2xxx, focused on occupancy rates, rather than their ability to meet Catherine’s complex care needs, the management of the Alexians had been determined to secure Catherine’s presence. Family members with little or no experience of care homes responded to hard-sell tactics wholly inappropriate when the product peddled in this way is the end of life care of people no longer able to care for themselves.
Dementia doesn’t progress in accordance with fixed rules. No longer able to manage personal hygiene , including use of the lavatory and disposal of dirty paper, Catherine could still respond to core interests. At Easter 2xxx, Jane visited Catherine, bringing a copy of a recently published history book she had written. History was Catherine’s principal subject as a trainee teacher. She expressed delight, adding that ‘ Granddad would be so proud’, adding that she meant her own father, Jane ’s grandfather. Noticing an injury to the back of Catherine’s hand, Jane approached staff to ask what had happened. The response was brusque. Catherine had been ‘violent’ Used to describe people suffering from dementia, the word is not acceptable. Catherine was 89. As an adult, her maximum height had been barely 5ft 2”. According to her consultant old age psychiatrist, she was suffering from two forms of dementia. NMGH records document two damaged heart valves. She suffered from chronic breathing problems, probably associated with both her heart condition and stress. Prescribed anti-psychotics and antidepressants could cause difficult side effects. In-depth analysis of so-called challenging behaviour exhibited by people with dementia will not be attempted in this review. People suffering from degenerative brain diseases, heart disease and many other distressing conditions of later life could be in pain, feeling unwell, affected by medication, or simply frightened. Staff skilled and experienced in dementia care should respond to the person in distress, not dismiss them as ‘violent’. Catherine was a victim, not a perpetrator. She had experienced many forms of abuse, which she had reported to her eldest daughter. Though the abuse had been reported and evidence produced, no action had been taken by Social Services, NHS Mental Health, or the Police. At Newlands, the nature of the abuse Catherine had experienced was recognised and appropriate safeguarding measures had been taken. No such support was given at the Alexians.
Catherine’s illness and hospital admission in September 2xxx with impacted faeces, florid piles and other bowel problems wasn’t an isolated incident. On May 14th2xxx, Jane had two commitments in Manchester. The first was a mandatory appointment with utility companies, so that gas and electrical safety tests could be conducted at the empty house, which was not in a safe condition.. The appointment would be at some time within a two hour slot. Secondly, Jane would be meeting Catherine’s new social worker, to discuss her care at the Alexians. Jane had given written notice of her earlier and unavoidable commitment. When she reached the care home, the social worker had already ended her assessment. As usual, for a pre-arranged visit, Catherine was clean and tidily dressed. Jane normally did not give the home any notice. During this visit, the Alexians care manager rebuked Jane severely for trying to report abuse to the police. This was said while walking along a corridor, with the Manchester Social Services social worker.
A week later, on her way to a meeting in Derbyshire, Jane returned to the home, this time, without giving notice, and found Catherine in bedding so heavily soiled and the room in such a condition that this could not be a recent accident. Jane did not take photographs. Catherine’s distressing condition must be reported to staff immediately. Taking photos of a parent lying in bedding caked with faeces, with dirty toilet paper scattered around the room would be difficult for anybody. The situation demands prompt action. Increasingly, families are installing hidden cameras in care home rooms. When Jane complained about this serious neglect, the care home claimed that she had requested personal care for Catherine, which was given immediately.
Photographic evidence of Catherine’s condition is unnecessary. Jane had arrived without notice after 11.a.m. Proof of the condition in which Jane found her mother is to be found in reports made by NHS psychiatrists, undertaking assessments of Catherine. Many of these reports confirm and enlarge on Catherine’s frequent soiling, her habit of keeping dirty toilet paper after use, and other ‘ Fairly frequent and severe behavioural difficulties.’ Reports made by psychiatrists detail some of these ‘ difficulties’, including pulling out her hair, keeps dirty toilet paper with her, faeces and dirty toilet paper, aggression and disinhibition. ‘ 31 As their health deteriorates, some people suffering from dementia can no longer manage bodily waste – a stage which is distressing for both carers and sufferers. Most dementia care has been consigned to the private sector. Only minimally trained and poorly paid, care workers cannot be expected to provide the psychological support needed by an angry and frightened person with dementia. Catherine had been given formal diagnoses of serious mental health conditions. In a standard residential care home, staff would not have the qualifications and expertise required to support a patient suffering from dementia and, according to Catherine's NHS mental health records, psychotic depression. Care home staff are among some of the lowest paid workers in the UK, with an average hourly wage of £7.46., considerably less than checkout assistants. 32 Unsurprisingly, nearly half UK care home workers leave within a year. 33 The average NHS psychiatric nurse earns £25,633 per year. Caseloads are increasing, the workforce aging. 34
Supposedly ‘the family’ were still happy with Catherine’s care at the Alexians. Not involved in placing Catherine in this home, and, though Catherine’s nearest relative and the person Catherine had wanted to make all decisions for her, not recognised as ‘next of kin’ by the Alexian staff, Jane tried to report her serious concerns about Catherine to Social Services. Approaches to Manchester Social Services met with no response. Finding no named person identified as Director of Social Services on the city’s website, Age UK in Kendal applied for the information and gave Jane the name of the current office holder. Correctly addressed, including the postmark, this letter was returned by the Royal Mail, marked ‘addressee gone away’. 35
Throughout 2xxx, Jane was still trying to obtain Catherine’s NHS general and mental health records. Also, she was trying to find out why no action had been taken after she made her formal statement to the social worker and care manager on January 19th 2xxx, presenting evidence of six figure abuse, and the ongoing construction of the property near New Quay. After Jane ’s own submissions to Manchester City Council had failed, Jane ’s MP wrote to Manchester’s Director of Social Services. The reply he received identifies the sender as Acting Head of Social Services, informing him that ‘ the two officers have no recollection of any such encounter’.
According to Manchester City Council, there was no evidence that Jane had been to Manchester. Presented with scanned copies of train tickets, Manchester Social Services acknowledged that Jane could have visited the city, but there was no evidence that she had visited the Adult Social Care offices. Jane ’s MP copied this response to her immediately. Entering a public building, signing the visitors book on arrival and on leaving is mandatory and in case of fire or other safety emergency, essential. Manchester claimed that there were no records of Jane’s many visits to the Adult Social Care offices.
Knowing that people in public office have made untrue statements about their actions in that office is disturbing. Such conduct negates the concept of a social contract. The care manager and social worker were responsible for securing the wellbeing and safeguarding of vulnerable people, including Catherine and William. Making their untrue statements, the care manager and the social worker had the support of Manchester City Council. Jane’s MP challenged the original response, receiving another dismissive reply. The City Council’s Social Services department was the lead agency, responsible for coordinating the response to any report of abuse. In the case of Catherine and William, the report of ongoing abuse was supported by documented evidence of extensive financial abuse.
After a weekend of urgent remedial work on Catherine and William’s long-neglected house, Jane and her husband visited four Manchester care homes specialising in dementia and Elderly Mentally Ill care. No appointments were made. Late on a Sunday afternoon, staff were able and willing to discuss a potential placement. Residents who were well enough were enjoying family visits. Unable as they were to provide appropriate care for a resident with Catherine’s complex needs, the Alexian Brothers Care Centre opposed Jane ’s attempts to identify an Elderly Mentally Ill placement for Catherine , informing her that she was not allowed to do this. 36
Jane’s applications for Catherine’s NHS records were still unsuccessful.. The request for these records was again referred to her MP. Catherine’s consultant psychiatrist agreed to meet Jane at the care home on October 13th 2xxx. Just before the meeting with the consultant Jane found the residents sitting in the usual three sided arrangement, but in a much larger room, not normally used as a residents’ day room. A larger screen TV was on, but no other provision was apparent. The reason for this change appeared to be internal work on the building. Sibling 2, who had visited recently, did not attend the meeting. The consultant asked Catherine if she could identify the ‘lady’ who was with them Catherine identified Jane as her eldest daughter. Asked how many children she had, Catherine responded correctly, giving their birth order and gender. Asked about employment, she stated that she had been a headteacher, naming the school. When Jane challenged the extensive misrepresentation of Catherine’s personal, medical and career history, the consultant stated that
‘ We had to go by what we had been told’ 37
This is totally unacceptable. No personal, medical or career information concerning a vulnerable person should be accepted without evidence. Sibling 3’s serious ‘ misrepresentations’ included the claim that Catherine had begun to develop memory problems in May/June 2xxx. Catherine’s NHS records refer to her being known to Manchester Mental Health’s Park House three years earlier. GP and NMGH recognition of dementia is on record in June and July 2xxx, with a history of memory problems and altered behavior for three or four years before dementia was confirmed. Dementia was recognised again at the NMGH in August and September 2xxx, Dr A, Catherine’s GP at Practice A, in Blackley, confirmed that Catherine was concerned about her mental health. 38
Dementia being a very seriously disabling mental health condition, early recognition and accurate record keeping is imperative for patient safeguarding. Sibling 3’s falsification of Catherine’s medical history could have been corrected immediately, if NHS staff had checked existing NHS records.
On August 31st 2xxx, over fifteen months before the date given by this consultant to the Office of the Public Guardian for the onset of dementia, he had attempted to visit Catherine, at her home address, in Blackley. The visit had been requested by Catherine’s original GP at Practice A. . Catherine and William had agreed to this visit. As reported in Chapter Five, Serious Negative Outcomes, Catherine wasn’t at home because she was a patient on Ward D3 of the North Manchester General Hospital and would remain there until September 12th 2xxx, when she was discharged to the house of Sibling 3.
On November 7th 2xxx, three weeks after the consultant’s assessment of Catherine, one of the residents at the Alexians was crushed by a falling fire door., so heavy, three men were needed to lift it off the victim. The lady died of her injuries, which included a fractured pelvis. Construction work was in progress on the premises. No provision had been made foe the residents’ safety. 39 . Aged 92, this lady was suffering from dementia The investigation into the fatal accident is on record, in the public domain. 40 The Alexian Brothers Care Centre and the construction firm they had engaged were both prosecuted by the Health and Safety Executive. Both parties were found guilty. Although investigations into the circumstances of Mrs X death began immediately, the case didn’t come to court until 2014. 41
Jane ’s last visit to her mother in 2xxx was on November 25th. Prolonged severe weather affecting most of the country restricted further visits until 24th January 2xxx Catherine’s increasing distress continued to affect other residents. During Jane ’s visits, Catherine would cry out constantly for William. A Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust psychiatrist reported, as usual, that the family was happy for her to remain at the Alexians. Jane was definitely not content for Catherine to remain there, but her position remained compromised. After the original care manager, social worker and consultant had taken no action in response to Jane’s reports of ongoing and extensive abuse, she was effectively excluded from decisions concerning her parents’ care.
Visiting on Sunday July 3rd, Jane and her husband found the care centre silent. Eventually, Jane found a member of staff, explaining that she had come to see Catherine. The staff member replied that she had just ‘ settled Catherine for the night’. It was just before ten to five, on a warm sunny afternoon. Visiting several other care centres in Manchester at this time on a Sunday in September, hoping to identify more appropriate care for Catherine, Jane and her husband had seen residents alert and wearing normal daytime clothes. Jane made no comment, leaving a small gift for her mother. The multiplicity of failings in Catherine’s care had to be challenged. Her care needs were not being met, and the inappropriate placement had been secured by means of unprofessional sales tactics. A mental health assessment carried out on August 1st found that Catherine was ‘ verbally and physically aggressive, wants to die, and that she would spend days in bed. 42 This report also refers to Catherine’s aggressive behaviour towards other residents.
Four days later, Jane visited in the late morning of Saturday, August 5th 2011. Catherine was, as usual, reluctant to drink her tea, asking Jane to taste it. Tea was served with milk to all residents, The tea Jane tasted was also very sweet. Catherine had never taken sugar in tea or coffee. At the office, Jane explained that her mother didn’t want to drink tea with sugar. One of the staff replied,
‘ She’s got dementia.’
Jane stated, again, that her mother had never taken sugar. Another member of staff took down Catherine’s file. An allergy to strawberries was on record. Nothing else, just strawberries..
The strawberry allergy record was correct. Always taking drinks without sugar was Catherine’s lifelong dietary preference, unrelated to dementia. 43 As a resident of this care home, Catherine had experienced a number of urinary tract infections, and also, the faecal impaction documented in her NMGH records for September 2009. According to staff, Catherine’s infections were because she didn’t drink enough. Presented with communally prepared pre-sugared tea, Catherine’s reluctance to accept a drink which she found distasteful is understandable. Catherine’s physical care needs were not being met. Hygiene failings increased the risk of UTI’s.
The letter given in full below was sent to all members of the Hospital Management Trust and copied to the Care Quality Commission. The manager of the Alexians rebuked Jane for seeking to involve the CQC.
August 8th 2xxx
The Hospital Management Trust
14, Queen Anne’s Gate
London,
SW1H 9AA
Your Ref : Mrs Catherine X 16/12/1920 The Alexian Brothers’ Care Centre,
Copied to : Care Quality Commission.
Dear …..
On September 18th 2xxx, being extremely dissatisfied with the quality of care my mother was receiving at the Alexian Brothers’ Care Centre in Manchester, I wrote to the Chairman and to the then Matron at the Alexians. I gave many reasons for my concern. One matter was serious enough to warrant an approach to the Care Quality Commission. For your convenience, I am enclosing a copy of that letter. As a Trustee appointed to manage a group of private hospitals and care centres, I hope that you have concern for any serious matters affecting the wellbeing of the people in your care. In my many visits to the Alexians since my mother’s admission on March 19th, 2xxx I have found little evidence of respect for her privacy, dignity and individuality. Nor have I experienced the professed warm and caring atmosphere indicated in your promotional literature.
My mother’s residency began after staff at the Alexians exercised undue and highly misleading pressure on my sister and brother. Our father had died on February 4th. Following his death, a post-mortem was ordered. Very serious NHS, Social Services and legal investigations into my parents’ case had already commenced. Arranging our father’s Requiem and comforting our widowed mother, we faced an extremely grave situation. When I visited the Alexians in March, 2xxx, to consider whether it would be suitable for my mother, I was not introduced to any residents. Having worked in client support as an Age UK volunteer, I was already familiar with normal practice at care homes in my own area, including initial visits made by families. I was shown just one vacant room. Visiting separately, my sister was shown other accommodation. My sister and my brother were advised by one of your care managers that if they failed to take up a place immediately, they could be waiting two years for another opportunity. This was, I believe, an untruth. I had investigated the recent history of the centre and was aware of recent problems especially in the nursing departments. Moving my mother without notice from the establishment which had cared for my parents during the last days of my father’s life, the family faced costs of over £2,200, in lieu of notice. Moving my mother without an initial visit of some days, or assessments by key staff was not in her best interests. Her recent experiences had been very grave indeed. When in good health, my parents, as lifelong supporters of many Catholic charities, would not have acted so intemperately, incurring substantial costs. Speaking to me on my landline, the same care manager, a rebuked me for these observations. Subsequently, it was indicated to other family members that I had made a very bad impression. According to your own records, occupancy at the Alexians had been poor in 2006, but in 2009, it improved to 93%, but not, I note, to 100%. There is no excuse for the personal rebukes delivered by staff, or the claims of a two year wait. The Alexians website presents the following statements :
Prior to admission, the Matron or a designated nurse will arrange to visit a prospective resident to answer any questions about the home and to establish individual needs and expectations. Residents and their family are encouraged to visit the home prior to the assessment. If the Care Centre is able to meet the resident’s needs a trial stay at the home will be offered.
This was certainly not my experience in March, 2009. Unlike many elderly people, my mother had a formal diagnosis of both vascular dementia and Alzheimer’s disease. Her mental capacity had been assessed on March 5th by her consultant, reporting to the Office of the Public Guardian. She achieved a borderline score. Given the very difficult circumstances, including my father’s recent death, her own physical condition, and other grave matters, the consultant decided to repeat the test after she had had more time to recover from emaciation and other matters. .
The Chaplain and some of the Brothers provide pastoral care for residents, their families, friends and staff. Reliability, honesty, integrity, friendliness and professionalism are all qualities we look for when recruiting staff. Prospective employees are screened by the Criminal Records Bureau and the Independent Safeguarding Authority and references thoroughly checked prior to commencement in post.
I have no personal experience of the professed pastoral care, only of reprimands and rebukes from Alexian staff. Many aspects of my mother’s case are far beyond the remit of any care provider. On January 1st, 2xxx, I made my first report to the police. By January 19th, I was able to present evidence of six-figure financial abuse, and by January 25th, my sister and I had been able to supply both the police and Social Services with evidence of very grave misuse of our parents’ assets.
It is not usual for the circumstances of a care home resident to be under investigation by CID, the Parliamentary Health Service Ombudsman, the Local Government Ombudsman, the Financial Ombudsman Service and the General Social Care Council. The gravity of this situation should be clear to all Trustees and to all staff engaged in caring for my mother. The word trauma has been devalued by overuse. In my mother’s case, it is entirely appropriate.
On April 16th, 2xxx, repeating his assessment at the Alexians, my mother’s consultant reported that she had the capacity to appoint her own attorneys, clearly identifying her two elder daughters as the people whom she wished to manage her affairs. It would have been proper for my sister and me to secure Lasting Power of Attorney for Health and Welfare at the same time. Difficult circumstances intervened, concerning Manchester Social Services. We were granted LPA for our mother’s property and financial affairs. I cannot provide any further information concerning serious and highly confidential investigations. I can report marked and repeated insensitivity and actual hostility towards me, on the part of staff at the Alexians. Three examples should be sufficient :
1. When I arrived to visit my mother on May 13th, 2xxx at lunch time, one of the cleaning staff advised me that my mother was still in bed. I found her in some distress and in need of personal care. Her distress concerned the very serious matters under investigation by CID and the other agencies. Less than a month after the capacity report, I hoped she would be well enough to meet a solicitor experienced in work with the elderly. A member of staff known to me only as S**** rebuked me very discourteously. After travelling to Manchester from Cumbria, I had been addressing urgent practical matters at my parents’ former house. This member of staff, together with my mother’s then care manager and inevitably, other Alexian staff insisted that my youngest sister must be allowed to visit. The professed ‘ pastoral care’ at the Alexians centred on a statement that ‘ We’ like families to get on.’ Treating mature adults as if they were squabbling teenagers is not pastoral care. It is both insensitive and inappropriate. The eldest of my mother’s brothers, who is in his late eighties, was evidently identified as ‘ head’ of the family. For some meetings concerning my mother’s care, neither I, nor my sister and co-attorney, nor my mother’s social worker were notified, only the supposed head of the family. My sister and I wished to protect our elderly uncle and our aunt from any distress associated with the CID and other investigations.
On January 26th, 2xxx, my mother had been removed from a very difficult situation. Following a formal NHS Best Interests meeting at the North Manchester General Hospital, my father was discharged, for the last week of his life, to nursing care, at the Jewish-run establishment which could offer a nursing bed and a residential place. The police had been alerted, and the extent to which my mother had been stripped of her personal history began to emerge. Staff at the Newlands Care Home in Salford had responded admirably in what must have been exceptionally difficult circumstances. Crucially, their qualified and experienced nursing staff recognised the profound distress my mother had experienced while in the supposed care of my youngest sister. I had made many warning referrals to Manchester Social Services and to Manchester Mental Health concerning this sister, the only one of four siblings to remain in Manchester. My other sister lives in xxx I am in xxx, and our brother accompanies his wife, who works for the Foreign and Commonwealth Office. According to Manchester Social Services, our parents’ personal history was very different. As a retired headteacher and mother of four, my mother, already affected by the brain damage of vascular dementia, had been stripped of her true identity. Though she was with them for such a short time, staff at the Newlands home recognised a very dangerous and distressing situation. Separated from my father throughout much of the last year of his life, my mother was not even allowed to be with him at his death. The Divisional Director of Medicine has offered an unreserved apology for what has happened, promising additional safeguarding measures, and acknowledging that staff had failed to act upon grave warnings. NHS investigations continue, and all my late father’s medical records are already with CID.
2. September 16th, 2xxx
Some of the events of this day prompted my previous letter. Poor record keeping and reception desk monitoring allowed a visit to my mother’s room by five people, though only one had been recorded. Two were infants. This is a breach of Health and Safety and Fire regulations. When xxxx and I arrived a few minutes apart, to attend a meeting with Alexian staff and Social Services, my mother was clearly profoundly distressed. Further pressure had evidently been placed on her by one or all of the three adults who had been present, urging that she should pay my youngest sister a regular allowance. My mother stated repeatedly that she did not want visits from this sister. I suggest that care staff should be aware of the phenomenon known as Stockholm syndrome, and the tendency of victims to appease their abusers. Repeatedly, my mother’s room was filled with images of my late father, with my youngest sister, including greetings of a kind not usual between a mature daughter and her father. My late father was registered blind in October, 1998. He could not see those cards. My mother could. As a retired headteacher, she discussed the subject of Electra complex with me and with xxxx indicating that it was completely abnormal for an adult woman to have that relationship with her own father. My father had by this time been diagnosed with vascular dementia himself. It was my mother who had always been the principal breadwinner, and it is the suspected misuse of what should be my mother’s assets which is under investigation, a six figure sum and a newly built property. That is why my mother is rightly distressed. Dementia does not remove the capacity to feel pain and grief.
3. May 14th - May 21st 2xxx
On May 14th, travelling as usual from Cumbria, I had an urgent mandatory appointment at my parents’ vacant house, meeting gas and electricity representatives, so that safety checks could be carried out. My presence throughout the allotted two hour slot was essential. After the inspection, I travelled to the Alexians, to find that my mother’s Social Services assessment had taken place in my absence. The meeting which followed was with the Alexians manager, my mother’s current social workers, and another member of staff. The manager indicated her displeasure regarding the police involvement. I am, of course, sorry that this lady finds the case ‘ very upsetting’. The manager addressed me by my given name. In a formal business meeting, it would have been appropriate to ask whether I preferred to be identified as Mrs . I do. People often mispronounce my given name. In a business meeting, especially a first meeting, a degree of formality is appropriate.
Alerted to the support available to victims of serious elder abuse by professionals in my own area, I wanted to identify support for my mother. The manager indicated that I ‘ had made various allegations’ and that ‘ nothing had been proved.’ The tense is incorrect. The investigations by Manchester CID are still in progress and further investigations have begun, most recently, those of the General Social Care Council. CID and the other national level investigations are not conducted at such length merely because a family member has made allegations. Investigations of this nature are usually prolonged. As my mother’s eldest daughter, I find the ongoing CID, Ombudsman and other investigations more than upsetting. The manager’s response was presented as a rebuke. Just one week later, on Friday, May 21st, I had a business meeting in the Peak District and decided to visit my mother again, as a surprise. Arriving just after twenty past eleven, I was advised by cleaning staff that she was still in bed. I found her in heavily soiled bedding. I had four children of my own. I can tell the difference between recent faecal soiling and soiling which has been present for some time. Soiled lavatory paper was littered about the room and around the ensuite facilities. In establishments which offer additional support for people affected by dementia, visual prompts including clear colour coding help to prevent such confusion. In this case, my mother was evidently unwell. She has suffered a number of urinary tract infections, which will, inevitably, exacerbate existing mental health problems . My other sister accepts the Alexians’ assurances that the infections occur because my mother does not drink enough. Dehydration is a contributory factor, not the sole cause . In the case of elderly women, poor perineal hygiene allows faecal contamination. I am not a doctor, but after my M.Sc at Bristol, I worked as an epidemiologist in the health agency now known as NICE.
The Home has a mini bus adapted to accommodate wheelchairs. A driver is available to take residents to hospital appointments or on an outing with trained care staff to local places of interest. The minibus is used to collect and return day-care visitor from and to their homes. A member of trained care staff always accompanies residents/clients when travelling in the minibus
The Home has a minibus ? True. I have seen it. A driver is available to take residents to hospital appointments ? Not in my experience. I live in Cumbria. My sister xxx lives in xxx. The walk-on train fare from xxxxxx to Manchester is very costly indeed. My mother’s eyesight has been deteriorating for some time. I do not understand why staff at the Alexians failed to alert my sister to my mother’s absolute right to a free NHS eye test, at the care centre. Subsequently, it became clear that further investigations were required. I was asked if I could accompany my mother to an appointment at the Manchester Eye Hospital. I could not. The first train to Manchester leaves my nearest station after 9 a.m. Moreover, I knew that the Alexian’s website includes the above claim. There is no reason why relatives living a considerable distance from Manchester should be required or expected to accompany family members to hospital appointments. My mother is suffering from vascular dementia and Alzheimer’s disease. She is 90. She is, as we now know, also suffering from macular degeneration, losing her focal vision. Any one of those conditions would qualify her for NHS patient transport to the hospital, which could have been authorised by her GP. The Alexians website claims that staff are available. This claim is either true or untrue. Requiring a relative to accompany a resident to a hospital appointment compromises NHS provision for the vulnerable. As for visits to local places of interest... I was informed that my mother had been taken to Tescos. This was her first visit anywhere, well over a year after her admission. My mother did not shop at Tesco’s, and as her illness progressed, she found crowded stores very stressful.
During the first few days following admission, staff will identify specific needs and discuss these with the resident and the family and a ‘care plan’ will be developed taking into account physical, clinical, emotional and spiritual needs as well as input from health and social care professionals. This plan will be reviewed every month, more often if required and the plan revised accordingly. Residents and their relatives are invited to discuss their plans of care with the Matron Manger or the nursing staff on a six monthly basis or more frequently if required.
Staff did not identify the specific needs of a lady in her late eighties who had experienced profoundly damaging emotional and physical circumstances. While my mother was at the Newlands Care Home, senior staff asked me to provide a detailed personal history, including my mother’s career, how she had met my father ( through the Catholic Evidence Guild, when she was a fifteen year old schoolgirl at Notre Dame High School in Manchester) , her memories of WWII, the names and birthdays of all her grandchildren and their contact details. One senior nurse, fluent in four languages, explained that in order to support residents, they needed to know about their lives before they became ill. I assume this lady spoke Hausa and Ibo fluently. Her French was excellent. So was my mother’s and my late father’s. They had many French friends. Earlier this year, bringing with me a book in very clear print, I showed her a page of French text - the commentary for Nuit et Brouillard.. Turning the page, the language changes to German and a list of familiar names, Auschwitz, Belsen, Buchenwald etc. My mother asked immediately if I had been to Germany , to visit the camps. At Notre Dame school in Manchester in the late 1930’s, some of her fellow pupils were Jewish refugees from Poland. Some became lifelong friends.
At a meeting held at the Alexians in April, 2009, I was advised by the then matron that they expect families to engage in any reminiscence work with relatives. They advised that they could not have anything to do with greetings and contact with grandchildren. Staff were too busy. Nor had they been aware that my mother is a retired headteacher. It was several months before a T was found for the middle of her name, on the list of residents . That might seem to be a trivial detail. It is not. My mother’s names were given to her at her baptism. She had known the story of her name saint.
As for physical needs... Visiting my mother last Saturday morning, I saw that there was a soft drink of some kind on the table, in a plastic cup. She was given a cup of tea. She drank a little, then urged me to taste it. The tea was very sweet . All my life, my mother has never taken sugar in tea and rarely took sugar in coffee either. I can understand why she didn’t wish to drink it. I would find it equally hard to drink tea or coffee with milk.
Another resident offered to tell staff, but I decided I should have a quick word with them myself. Does he take sugar ?: was the deliberately cynical title of a BBC programme challenging poor attitudes towards the disabled. In the office, Sheila indicated that she would check my mother’s file. All that was on record was her allergy to strawberries. No mention of sugar. This information was delivered as a rebuke to me. I admit to a degree of personal prejudice regarding the use of chewing gum. It might be more courteous if staff could refrain from chewing gum while speaking to residents and their families. The assessment had been carried out by a previous manager, no longer a member of staff, soon after my mother’s admission. My mother could have been consulted herself regarding such a minor and yet very important matter. A member of staff whom I had not met on any previous visits added, as if this might be unfamiliar information, ‘ She’s got dementia.’ That is not a summary of who my mother is. She is a person, not a disease process, and she can still speak fluently. In my presence, she never uses words inaccurately.
Services
Only one item on this list is relevant to my mother, who does indeed suffer from dementia. When I have found her in need of urgent care, I have been the one to summon staff. Is she actually able to summon assistance, and does she do so ?
There is a fully integrated nurse call system in each resident room and in the bathroom and toilet areas.
Twice, and on both those occasions, I was making an unannounced visit, I have found her in urgent and long overdue need of personal care. My own GP and Age UK have advised that I should take photos immediately. My first thought has been, on both occasions, securing help for my mother. I failed to take photos. Photographing one’s mother in a heavily soiled bed and clothing would not be easy. I will try to do so if I find her in this condition again. Staff at the Alexians have given a different account - one being that I requested personal care for her mother, which was delivered immediately. The present manager had already indicated with displeasure that I had made various allegations. My position vis a vis certain members of staff at the Alexians is impossible and I believe it has been impossible from the outset. The problems extend far beyond the habitual absence of courtesy, extending to open criticism of my family, because of our very difficult situation. The situation is not of my making, and it is on record within the NHS, in the letter sent by the Divisional Director of Medicine for the local primary care trust in Manchester that I issued grave warnings, that staff had failed to act, and that additional safeguarding came too late for my parents.
My mother, Catherine , and my late father, William had served their local community and many Catholic organisations throughout most of their long lives. My mother, who had an unbroken teaching career of forty years was an outstanding headteacher, a claim I can support by producing HMI reports for her school. She was, I repeat, stripped of her almost her entire personal history and deliberately separated from my father, to whom she had been married for over sixty years. The misuse of most of her assets is very much a secondary matter. Dementia is a profoundly distressing condition. Adding to that distress by stripping her of so much of her identity was the act of a very unsafe person, I had warned both the NHS and Social Services that my youngest sister had had a major brain tumour, and had other serious health problems. One of these problems was a manifestly abnormal attachment to my late father. In March, 2008, Manchester social workers authorised my mother’s permanent placement in residential care, supposedly as a state pensioner with one daughter. Plans were in progress for my youngest sister to move ‘back’ to Wales, with my father, to a new build property still under construction. My father, much older than my mother, was then 98, blind, deaf and suffering from vascular dementia. A return to Wales was a fantasy. My late father had distant Welsh ancestry on one side. Both his father and grandfather were Mancunians. Family holidays were never taken in Wales.
Our aim at The Alexian Brothers Care Centre is to preserve and maintain the privacy, dignity, and individuality of all residents in a warm and caring atmosphere and with sensitivity to the residents’ ever-changing needs.
My mother needs access to justice. Two major financial institutions have been under investigation. It was necessary to provide evidence of my mother’s permanent address to their Fraud departments. Staff at the Alexians repeatedly failed to do so, even when provided with letters and first class stamped addressed envelopes. Eventually, my other sister resorted to the expense of a solicitor’s letter. We were already our mother’s legally appointed attorneys, registered at the Office of the Public Guardian.
Yesterday, Monday, August 8th, I received a phone call from the Alexians, informing me that my mother had suffered a fall, but was not injured. I indicated that my elder daughter, a twenty-five year old postgraduate student at Manchester University lives in the city centre and can be contacted at once, should my mother need hospital attention. My informant was the member of staff known to me as Sheila. She declined to discuss any contact with my daughter, indicating that this is not on Alexian records. First contact with my daughter was discussed and supposedly agreed at the meeting on September 16th 2xxx. In light traffic, it would take at least two hours for me to reach Manchester and for my other sister, very considerably longer. Ill-advisedly, I again raised the matter of my mother’s lifelong preference for tea without sugar. Once again, I was rebuked. Further disparaging observations were made about my family. I was informed that I would need to speak to Social Services about my daughter. I had just been informed that my 90 year old mother had suffered a fall, and I knew that my elder daughter could be at the Alexians very quickly indeed. Alexian staff had previously indicated that they could not involve children. My daughter was then twenty three. She is now twenty five and certainly not a child. Contacting Manchester Social Services is not easy. Supported by my MP, I was the prime mover in presenting evidence which has been accepted as warranting investigation by the LGO and the General Social Care Council.
Repeatedly, I have been rebuked by staff at the Alexians, almost invariably by xxx, about my mother’s so-called ‘ violence’, adding ‘ We can’t ‘ave that.’ - the message given being that my very old and ill mother has the status of a delinquent child. I had asked how my mother had sustained a minor injury. The word violence is widely and inappropriately used in the context of dementia care. Old, ill, aware of their own weakness, people suffering from dementia are afraid and should be treated with loving kindness by appropriately trained staff. My mother is 90, barely five feet tall, losing her sight and her recent personal experiences have been heartbreaking. Identified as my father’s ‘ next of kin’, it was my very unsafe youngest sister who was called to be with him the afternoon he died, in the A & E department of a Manchester hospital. I use the word unsafe, because I am not qualified to judge her mental state. All of this medical information is emerging as the major national and Manchester based investigations continue. Removed from their own house into our sister’s, in a nearby suburb, all access to my parents was controlled by her. Trustees and others involved in an important charity will, I hope, recognise classic and very distressing elder abuse. Recognising that one’s existence has not been acknowledged is an extraordinary process. My parents had lived in the same house, in the same parish all their married life, and my mother had taught at the parish school. I am their eldest child. At the hospital, I was asked by ward staff whether I was a half sibling. Enduring all of this is hard enough, without the constantly unhelpful and extremely discourteous conduct of some members of the Alexian staff.
In September last year, my husband and I visited several care homes in the Manchester area where staff have E.M.I. experience and training. We saw the many facilities available which help to conserve and support the impairment caused by the disease process. I did try to arrange an assessment visit. Another member of staff at the Alexians rang my home number to rebuke me. Her manner was extremely unsympathetic, delivering a reprimand, rather than discussing in a normal professional manner how my mother’s needs could be met. When, at last, several weeks later, permission was granted for this lady to visit my mother, she reported that my mother’s needs are so complex they cannot be met at their establishment. I cannot see that they are being met in any way at the Alexians.
Unlike my sister , who needs to book tickets from the south coast to Manchester well in advance, I can and do make many unannounced visits, from mid morning to early evening. At six o’clock on the warm and sunny evening of July 3rd, I found that my mother had already been put to bed. On every other occasion, I find her sitting in a chair, doing nothing. The constantly blaring television has been removed. I am not sure what activity or entertainment has been offered instead. Whenever I have visited, at 11, 12, 1, 2, 3, 4, or 5 o’clock, I have found my mother sitting in a chair, doing nothing at all. This is not dementia care . Considering the Alexians’ care centre as I might any other product or service, I would identify the claims made on the website to be contravening advertising standards and trades description legislation. No pastoral care and support of any kind has been offered in an extremely difficult situation. On the contrary, unsympathetic and sometimes hostile staff have behaved as if I and my mother are delinquent. The present matron identified me as a person who had made unproven allegations. When I have reported, truthfully, finding my mother in very unpleasant need of care, my report has been misrepresented. While the grave investigations continue, one person is ending her life in a situation I would never have chosen for her.
I said that three examples of the uncaring attitude of staff would be sufficient, but I will add another. None of my visits to the Alexians are easy, primarily because of the very unpleasant conduct of some staff members. On July 27th last year, travel on the West Coast line to Manchester was disrupted by a tragedy - a suicide on the line, sad and shocking for everyone. Reaching Manchester some hours later, once coach transfers had been organised, I asked staff on reception if they could allow me to use a phone book, so that I could ring the train information line, checking how soon the lines would reopen. Staff informed me that I could come back at the end of the afternoon. I was not asking to use their phone, only for a brief opportunity to find a contact number, because my return journey was likely to be difficult. I am not prepared to accept the habitual lack of courtesy any longer.
Yours sincerely, etc ‘
At the end of August, Catherine’s records from the North Manchester General Hospital were released to Jane . Many records are heavily redacted. Studying the records would be an exacting task, complicated by the apparent disorder in which they had been presented. Records from the Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust were sent to Jane by recorded delivery on September 13th and collected from the Post Office on September 17th. Again, the records appeared extremely disordered. Scanned and copied onto disks, the records were sent by recorded delivery to Greater Manchester Police and to Jane ’s MP.
One NHS Mental Health record confirms the date, location and the names of those present during the long meeting on January 19th 2xxx, when Jane gave her statement to the care manager and social worker, reporting ongoing financial abuse well into six figures. 43 Studying the records, the misrepresentation of Catherine’s medical history by Sibling 3, together with the use of alternating GP practices in Blackley and Crumpsall became clear.
Published early in September 2011, the original CQC report on the Alexian Brothers Care Centre, following the inspection of July 27th identified seven major problems. The centre would be allowed to continue operating on condition that these problems were resolved. Catherine’s NHS Mental Health records state that she was not eating, and refused to use the lavatory. 44 On September 30th a significantly different report was published, presenting the Alexian Brothers Care Centre in an entirely positive light.
In response to Jane ’s written complaints to the Hospital Management Trust, a meeting at the centre was offered. Jane was unable to accept the first date because she would be on holiday. Jane would be free the following working week, 19th - 23rd September. According to the HMT, this date wasn’t possible. Two dates were offered, September 28th or 29th. Her meeting with the Trust’s representative was on September 29th 2011 During this meeting, the HMT representative mentioned their meeting with Siblings 2 and 4, which had taken place the previous week.
Jane continued to search for an alternative placement for Catherine , who needed an Elderly Mentally Ill placement. As her NHS Mental Health records confirm. Catherine’s status as an Elderly Mentally Ill patient was not a new development. According to her Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust records, Catherine had needed such care in April 2xxx. This is confirmed in her NHS records, which cite Care Cluster 12. 45 After eight months of lengthy respite placements and twenty-four days in hospital, the case was reopened in December that year, when psychotic depression was diagnosed. Entered in Catherine’s NHS mental health records, the accuracy of these diagnoses cannot be determined, but they are the official NHS mental health records. .Knowing that Catherine had been recognised as Elderly Mentally Ill, Manchester Social Services should have intervened before the inappropriate move to the Alexians could take place. Suppressing Jane’s written and face to face reports of ongoing abuse, Manchester Social Services and NHS staff consigned an eighty eight year old victim of many forms of abuse to years of wholly inadequate care and serious negligence. When the manager of the Alexian Brothers Care Centre was rebuking Jane for approaching the Care Quality Commission, the centre was already under investigation following the fatal accident to a resident, for which the firm would be prosecuted and convicted.
In September 2xxx, more than two years after registration of Joint and Several Power of Attorney, Sibling 2 allowed Jane access to £7, 500 of Catherine’s remaining assets. After Catherine’s death, Jane submitted a spreadsheet, documenting expenditure on Catherine’s behalf.
In November 2xxx, a Best Interests meeting was conducted for Catherine at the Alexian Brothers Care Centre. Jane was informed of this meeting by Sibling 2 but did not receive any formal notification. Jane was already committed to meeting the advocate who would be attending the first NHS meeting with the Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust, to discuss Jane’s complaints about her mother’s NHS care. The date and timing of the two meetings was determined by this Trust. The Mental Health and Social Care Trust would also be leading the Best Interests meeting. Many failings in Catherine’s care are evident in her records from the North Manchester General Hospital, including a seven week delay in notifying her GP about Catherine’s concerns about her ‘ excessive drinking’ , the very seriously unsafe discharge to Sibling 3, and the NMGH acquiescence in prolonged hospital stays, both for more than three weeks after Catherine was medically fit for discharge.
The Best Interests meeting found that Catherine needed Elderly Mentally Ill care. According to her Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust records, Catherine had needed such care in April 2xxx. The Best Interests meeting also reported that Catherine was too unwell to be removed from Manchester. Elderly Mentally Ill places were available in Manchester. Despite this ruling, Siblings 2 and 4 removed Catherine to a care home near Rawthenstall, over twenty miles away. No explanation is available for this. Jane tried to oppose this unsafe move, but without success. A formal Best Interests meeting had reported its findings, yet the findings were disregarded. Removing Catherine from Manchester was wholly inappropriate. She died nineteen days later, three days before her ninety-first birthday. Death at this age is hardly unexpected, but moving a very old and ill woman so far at the end of her life could not be in her best interests.
The second NHS complaints meeting for both Trusts was on December 1st, at Park House, at 10.a.m. This time, the usual advocate was able to attend. The meeting had been delayed by industrial action in Manchester. At Park House, no clerk was present to take minutes. Jane complained about this The Trust representative stated that she would take the minutes herself. For any formal meeting , record keeping is essential. Instead of written records, some NHS Trusts now routinely record formal resolution meetings to ensure accurate record keeping. 46
A Manchester City Council social worker rang Jane to report that Catherine had been discharged from their care, and was now the responsibility of another authority. Washing its hands of the matter, Manchester City Council could declare that Catherine was no longer a resident of the city where she had lived for more than ninety years and had worked as a dedicated teacher.
1 Social worker, Manchester City Council Social Services/ Mental Health and Social care Trust, , 16th September 2xxx
2 . Care home rooms offered for sale to private investors on ' Buy to let' basis. ... - The Independent
https://www.independent.co.uk
3 Constipation and Faecal Impaction Information, Alzheimer’s Scotland. https://www.alzscot.org/assets/0000/0175/constipation-and-faecal-impaction.pdf
4 Unfair terms in care home contracts: OFT635 – GOV.UK Changes in case law have prompted changes in trading legislation. Care homes market study: summary of final report – GOV.UK https://www.gov.uk/.
5. Effectively, Catherine was supported in accordance with the Jewish tradition of shiva, usually for the seven days after burial – William’s funeral was delayed by over a fortnight.
6 6/3/2xxx Event 132. MMH/SCT
7 23/03/2xxx Event 136 CPN report. MMH/SCT
8 Through her mother, Catherine had Sephardic Jewish ancestry. Catherine’s mother talked about this family history to Jane, her eldest grandchild. Until recently, the family had kept some traditional Jewish items. Among the last books bought by Catherine before her memory problems began were two works on Christianity and Judaism.
9 Published in 2017, one useful report is Towards Quality Care: Outcomes for Older People in Care Homes Caroline Mozley Routledge, 22 Nov 2017
10 Holmes TH, Rahe RH (1967). "The Social Readjustment Rating Scale". J Psychosom Res. 11 (2): 213–8. doi:10.1016/0022-3999(67)90010-4. PMID 6059863.
11 22/01/2xxx Event 116, MMH/SCT.
12 Length of stay in care homes - LSE Research Onlineprints.lse.ac.uk/33895/1/dp2769.pdf by J Forder - 2011
13 10/12 2xxx NHS Trust psychiatrist, Sprite referral to GP practice B.
Same referring psychiatrist to GP A. 12/12/2xxx Anti-psychotics to commence.
14 01/04/2009 Event 140 MMH/SCT
15 . Consultant ‘s report to the OPG, cf. GP recognition of dementia two and a half years earlier, also NMGH records.
16 16/04/2xxx, consultant to GP, re Catherine’s wish for Jane to make all decisions.
17 Phone call to Jane, Jane’s husband present.
18 Abbey/Santander Bank Statements
19 23/04/2xxx. Manchester City Council Social Services.
20 11/12/2xxx, Event 61 MMH/SCT records
21 Frailty and Social Care: Over- or Under-Familiar Terms? https://www.cambridge.org/core/produc
22 Letter, Divisional Director of Medicine, Pennine Acute Hospitals Trust.
23 https://www.gov.uk/become-deputy/responsibilities
24 Lasting power of attorney: acting as an attorney – GOV.UK https://www.gov.uk/lasting-power-attorney-duties
25 Assessment: Financial crime against vulnerable adults - Social Care ...
https://www.scie.org.uk/publications/reports/report49.pdf
26 https://www.cps.gov.uk/legal-guidance/older-people-prosecuting-crimes-against older people
27 Banks and other fianncial institutions , including Nationwide, HSBC and Barclays had declined to recognise the status of a hologrammed copy,. At the depot, the LPA hologram was respected.
28 25/03/2xxx Psychiatrist to GP. MMH/SCT
28 11/12/2xxxx, NHS psychiatrist to GP Practice B.
29 18/03/2010 25./03.2010. MMH/SCT
30 18/03/2010,. 28/10/2010, 3/11/2010. MMH/SCT
31 May 2018. Care Worker Salary (United Kingdom) -PayScalehttps://www.payscale.com/research/UK
32 www.independent.co.uk › May Bulman
33 NHS Registered Mental Health Nurse Salaries in the United Kingdom ...https://www.indeed.co.uk › NHS › Salaries
34 Sending letters by post, Jane has always given her address on the reverse of an envelope.
35 Phone call with CPN, Jane’s husband present.
36 October 13th, 2010. Assessment of Catherine. NHS Mental Health records.
37 GP Practice A, to chest clinic, NMGH, 04/12/2006,
38 Two firms fined for 92-year-old resident's death at care home during renovation works. ...www.careforumwales.co.uk/.
39 Firms to be prosecuted after death of dementia sufferer, 92, who was crushed by a falling door. ...ms ttps://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk
40 Firms admit door fall death of Manchester woman, 92 - BBC News www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-manchester-26583284
41 01/08/2011 Event 179 Incontinet of faeces and urine.
42 Why nutrition is important in dementia – SCIE https://www.scie.org.uk/dementia/living...dementia/eating.../importance-of-nutrition.as.
43 20/01/2009 Event 113 MMH/SCT
44 08/09/2011 Event 181 MMH/SCT
45 Original CQC report on the Alexian Brothers Care Centre , following the inspection of July 27th 2011. Part of this report recovered.
46 See, for example, The Trust's complaints and concerns policy - East and North Herts ...
www.enherts-tr.nhs.uk/files/2010/03/Trust_complaints_and_concerns_policy.pdf
Care Centre demanded immediate unassessed placement
Company watch requested by Jane
R.C. care home bought by London firm in 2xxx
Occupancy levels low until 2xxx .
M/cr City Council Social Services concerns re nursing standards. .
Sibling 3 and associates welcomed.
Sibling 3 still identified as ‘carer’ by NHS Mental Health
Reinstatement of antipsychotic prescriptions,
Consultant’s report for Office of Public Guardian. April 2xxx
Gives wrong date for onset of dementia.
Dementia recognised, GP and NMGH records two and a half years earlier.
Known to Manchester Mental Health a year before diagnosis.
Age UK question inconsistencies in consultant’s report.
Solicitor, Alzheimer’s panel, disputed Catherine’s testatory capacity.
Same consultant’s letter to GP, Jane to make all decisions.
No information to Jane for over two years.
Deterioration in Catherine’s mental health.
Increased use of antipsychotics
Found in soiled bedding, faeces and urine, May 13th 2009. ,
Lasting Power of Attorney application May 29th
Papers given to Sibling 2 by social worker.
William’s NHS records. Jane ’s complaints about his care.
Internal meeting, North Manchester General Hospital
Care manager did not attend.
Sibling 2, new will for Catherine, August 2xxx. No role for Jane .
Sibling 3, unemployed, demands allowance from Catherine.
Abuse reported by Jane .
Catherine found in heavily soiled bedding again.
Consultant’s assessment of Catherine
‘ We had to go by what we had been told’
Another resident with dementia crushed by fire door.
Care centre prosecuted and convicted .
Catherine’s deterioration continued. Staff opposed any move.
Jane referred complaints to Care Quality Commission
CQC Inspection, 27th July 2xxx
Original CQC report citing seven serious problems taken down.
Company meetings, Catherine to be removed.
'The abuse continues here.’ 1
This was stated at the former Alexian Brothers Care Centre in New Moston, Manchester, on September 16th 2xxx, by Catherine’s social worker, following the long overdue meeting held at the Alexian’s on that day, to discuss Catherine’s care needs. The Alexian Brothers Care Centre was acquired by the Hospital Management Trust in 2xxx. In 2015, following a fatal accident to a resident, prosecution of the home and 2014 conviction, the centre was bought by MBI Social Care Ltd. The company marketed buy to let care home rooms, indicating a potential 10% return for investors. 2 Following the April 2017 CQC inspection, which found that improvement was required in every aspect of care provision, the centre was acquired by Qualia Care of Bradford and is now St Mary’s Nursing Home.
Arriving at the Alexians for the long delayed review of Catherine’s placement, Jane and Sibling 2 found Catherine extremely distressed. Sibling 3, unemployed, who was with two other adults and two infants, had been seeking an allowance from Catherine. Only Sibling 3 had signed in. Recognising and responding to Catherine’s distress, one of the nursing staff present at this meeting insisted that the meeting must reconvene in another place. Catherine’s distress must be respected.
Four days after this meeting, Catherine was admitted to the NMGH, after fainting and vomiting. Admission records refer to ‘severe dementia’.‘Florid piles’ and ‘impacted faeces in rectum’. Faecal impaction is an unpleasant condition. Catherine would have been feeling very unwell and could have been in pain. Alzheimer’s Scotland has published a comprehensive information sheet detailing aspect of this condition 3 Serious failings in personal care for Catherine are implicated. Constipation is one of the many side effects of antipsychotic medications, and also, people like Catherine, in the mid to later stages of dementia, are likely not to recognise the need to empty their bowels.
Catherine had been removed from Newlands to the Alexian Brothers Care Centre on March 20th 2xxx. A penalty charge of £2,2000 for removing Catherine without notice was sent to Jane , as Catherine’s nearest relative, by the company which owns the Newlands Care Home. Jane had opposed this precipitate move. No assessment of Catherine’s complex needs had been made. There was no evidence that the Alexians could meet Catherine’s care needs. 4
Whenever possible, care home placements should not be hurried. In March 2xxx, there was no urgency. After William’s death, Catherine had been supported by the whole Newlands community,
In the first days after his death, she was never alone, even when family members could not be there 5 There was no assessment of Catherine’s care needs, current or future. Catherine’s capacity had not been determined. Confirmed in her NMGH records in July 2xxx, dementia is a progressive disease for which there is still no effective treatment. Now aged eighty-eight, Catherine’s mental and physical health would continue to deteriorate. Suffering from dementia, she needed above all, safeguarding from further abuse, stability, and familiar surroundings. Discharged from the North Manchester General Hospital on September 12th 2xxx, to Sibling 3, the person identified in formal vulnerable adult safeguarding referrals, Catherine hadn’t returned to the house which had been her home for fifty-nine years. In the unfamiliar environment of Sibling 3’s house, Catherine had been unable to see friends. Some of her friends, including former teaching colleagues, contacted Jane to report this. All access to Catherine and William had been controlled by Sibling 3 – a situation fully documented in Catherine’s NHS Mental Health records, and regretably, respected by NHS mental health professionals. ’ Following the authorisation of fully funded placement in permanent care, in April 2xxx, there were four extended placements in ‘ respite’ and a long hospital stay, instead of the support and treatment which had been authorised for a recognised mental illness.
The unassessed placement was instigated by Siblings 2 and 4. Both NHS mental health and Manchester Social services recognised serious problems. Both failed to intervene. Catherine’s new CPN warned that such a move was ‘not always a positive thing for people who have Dementia’ 6 Catherine’s social worker also protested about the move, warning that it would be wrong. The social worker made a pre-arranged call to Jane, who was on her way to Sheffield, where her younger daughter had been ill for several days, requiring hospital tests. Jane’s husband was present throughout this call. Catherine’s social worker, who had visited the Alexians herself, insisted that the placement was wrong, and that staff at the Alexians ‘ would not be kind’. The social worker made this call to Jane, even though she and the care manager had failed to report the ongoing and well documented abuse of William and Catherine to the police. Recognising that the move to the Alexians was not in Catherine’s interests, and having seen evidence of extensive abuse by family members, Manchester Social Services allowed the move to take place. Social Services were still directing Catherine’s care. Aware that the move would be damaging, the care manager and social worker could have and should have intervened. Such intervention would, inevitably, require them to acknowledge the abuse which had been reported to the social worker, to the care manager, and to the NHS consultant old age psychiatrist. Shortly after Catherine’s removal to the Alexian Brothers’ Care Centre on March 20th 2xxx, Catherine’s social worker had a road accident and was absent for several weeks. Visiting Catherine soon after the move, her new CPN found that Catherine ‘did not look as well as I had seen her on my last visit’. 7
Newlands provides care primarily for the local Jewish community. Throughout Catherine’s short time here, her own Catholic traditions were respected, including the displaying of Catholic devotional images in her room. Jane had made arrangements for visiting, and, if Catherine wished, Holy Communion with the parish priest of the local Catholic church. Both rabbis visiting the home were friendly and welcoming. Catherine and William had many Jewish friends and through her mother's family, Catherine had Jewish ancestry. 8 Working in tailoring in Manchester, William had many Jewish colleagues. On the Rhine, after WWII, he served in the Jewish Brigade of the Royal Corps of Signals. Some family members strongly opposed the placement at Newlands.
Until their health declined, Catherine and William had been active members of an inter-church, international association based at Manchester’s Anglican cathedral. On admission to Newlands, Catherine was seriously underweight, needing prescribed supplementary nutrition, but at Newlands, despite her bereavement, her appetite was good. She had no problems with the kosher menu, which was prepared on site, and had enjoyed Jewish bakery products all her life. NHS Mental Health professionals recognised the improvement, but Catherine’s NHS records don’t include any questions regarding the unlikely explanations which had been accepted for Catherine’s severe weight loss while living with Sibling 3.
In the second week of March 2xxx, Sibling 2 informed Jane that she needed to visit a care centre operated originally by a Roman Catholic order. An appointment had been made for Wednesday March 11th. When Catherine’s NHS records were released to Jane in September 2xxx, entries showed that Catherine’s removal to this home had already been arranged by Siblings 2 & 4. Arriving at the home, Jane was shown a vacant room. Occupancy records for this date indicate other vacancies. Jane was not taken to any part of the home where she would meet residents. Without meeting any residents and observing both typical daily activities and the relationship between care workers and residents, an accurate assessment of a home isn’t possible. When Jane visited, a social event for local people was in progress. They did not appear to be care home residents. For five years (1992 – 1997) Jane was an Age Concern (Age UK) volunteer, working in client support. Her role in client support didn’t involve any financial responsibilities, but safeguarding checks and references were, of course, required. Jane was familiar with different kinds of care home.
Visiting the 72 bed R.C. care centre, Jane recognised immediately that a placement in this establishment would not be in Catherine’s interests, immediately or at any time. Visiting any care home, making an appointment is not advisable. The appointment had been arranged for her. Inspections, including both official examination by the Care Quality Commission or by family members investigating potential homes should never be pre-announced. Considering Catherine’s future care needs, Jane had visited the Alzheimer’s UK and Age UK offices in her local town, and had studied several published guides. 9
Leaving this care centre, Jane went to Newlands,where Sibling 2 was with Catherine. Sibling 2 informed Jane that their mother had something to tell her. When Catherine hesitated, Sibling 2 urged her to ‘say it’. Catherine then complied, stating, ‘I want to go to a Catholic home’. Next day, Sibling 2 indicated that Jane had made a bad impression at the Alexians. Potential residents and family members don’t visit care homes in order to make a favourable impression on a business which is selling a service. They go to find out whether a home will be able to provide the right kind of care for their family member. The environment of this centre could not and did not ever meet Catherine’s complex needs, medically, emotionally or legally. Having experienced prolonged and extensive abuse, evidence of which is documented throughout her NHS records, bank statements and other financial accounts, Catherine needed responsible and effective professional support, and, as the victim of many forms of abuse, she needed justice. Catherine had reported ongoing abuse to Jane, but Jane ’s attempts to report abuse had been dismissed by the police and suppressed by the care manager and social worker in Manchester's Mental Health and Social Care Trust,
Immediate transfer from Newlands would not be in Catherine’s interests. She had just experienced the most serious distress of all, the death of her husband, after almost sixty-three years of marriage. 10 Throughout the last year of his life, measures had been taken by the Mental Health and Social Care Trust to prevent her from being with William. Mental Health records give the reason for this. Identified as being a danger to her husband, to herself and to others, Catherine saw little of her husband in the last year of his life. Seen by her new CPN on January 22nd, Catherine said – accurately enough, given her experience since Sibling 3 became her ‘carer’, that she would not be seeing her husband, they wouldn’t let her. 11 When Jane challenged the supposed need for immediate uptake of a place at the Alexian brothers, a senior staff member made a confrontational call to Jane ’s landline, warning that if the place was not taken up immediately, Catherine could be waiting for two years. The hard sell tactics were both unprofessional and untrue. In March 2xxx, Catherine was 88. In 2011, an LSE study found the mean length of stay for a female over 85 to be 717 days.12 Jane knew, from the senior care manager himself,that Manchester City Council Social Services had concerns about the standard of nursing care at this establishment. Requesting a company search, Jane found that the home had been acquired by a London based company in 2xxx. Low occupancy had been a problem. Catherine needed above all a period of stability and security. Since August 23rd 2xxx, she had experienced prolonged and unnecessary hospitalisation, then immediate removal to the house of Sibling 3 and the loss of the house that had been her home since 1947. Suffering the distress and confusion of dementia, she had been denied mental health support for over fifteen months, and support for her heart condition. Then, her medical history had been ‘ misrepresented’ . Throughout 2xxx, there were repeated and lengthy placements in care. Except for two weeks in April 2xxx, when William was also placed in respite care at White Moss, Catherine had been on her own.
In legal and financial matters, Sibling 3’s actions are clearly and comprehensively documented. As Catherine reported, accurately, on July 11th 2xxx, Sibling 3 had ‘taken everything’ and she had ‘taken’ William. Assessing the precise nature of Sibling 3’s inappropriate relationship with her father is problematic. As Catherine herself had said, it wasn’t normal for an adult woman to have such a relationship with her own father. Making formal referrals, warning Mental Health and Social Care authorities in Manchester, Jane had focused firstly, on two aspects of physical risk, the combination of William’s blindness and Catherine’s already diagnosed dementia, and the alcohol administered to Catherine by Sibling 3, ‘to keep her quiet’. Secondly, and concerned for this sibling as well as for her frail parents - an aspect of these referrals apparently not recognised by public authorities, Jane reported Sibling 3’s history of brain tumour surgery, and ‘other serious health problems’ .
When Catherine and William’s placement at Newlands began, Catherine’s true history, including her financial status, was already known to the consultant old age psychiatrist at the Mental Health and Social Care Trust and to Catherine’s original CPN. The care manager and social worker also knew, and had themselves negotiated Catherine’s placement in care, at the home in Cheetham Hill, with a diagnosis on December 10th 2xxx of a serious mental health condition, identified in her records as psychotic depression. 13 The construction of the property near New Quay, Sibling 3’s acknowledged use of over £160,000 , extensive use of Catherine and Williams accounts and the imminent house sale were all known. Bank statements had been presented to the care manager, and copied to Greater Manchester Police by Cumbria Constabulary. Following the meeting with Jane and Sibling 2, at the Abbey/Santander branch in Cheetham Hill, Manchester, all use of these accounts should have ceased. No deputyship had been authorised by the Court of Protection, , nor had any Lasting Power of Attorney been granted. Identifying Catherine now as ‘ self funding’, Mental Health and Social Care Trust staff continued to recognise Sibling 3’ s supposed status as Catherine’s ‘ carer’ . In financial matters, Manchester City Council Social Services continue to interact with Sibling 3 until Lasting Power of Attorney was registered in July 2xxx.
Days after Catherine’s removal from Newlands, Jane’s elder daughter, a postgraduate student at Manchester university, visited her grandmother. She reported a marked deterioration, after the considerable recovery evident at Newlands. Visiting herself, Jane found the report accurate. Two and a half years later, receiving Catherine’s NHS Mental Health records, Jane discovered that this marked and almost immediate deterioration was recognised by some NHS Mental Health staff, including Catherine’s most recent CPN. 14 The Alexians had insisted on immediate uptake of a place. A new client had been secured for a care home with recent occupancy level problems. There was some initial enthusiasm, immediately after admission. Welcoming Sibling 3, management at this care centre stated that they ‘ liked families to get on.’ .
On April 16th, the consultant old age psychiatrist’s report on Catherine’s capacity for the Office of the Public Guardian stated that she had the capacity to grant Lasting Power of Attorney. The consultant identified Jane and Sibling 2. The report identifies both Alzheimer’s disease and vascular dementia. In this report to the Office of the Public Guardian, the date given for the onset of dementia is wrong, and very seriously wrong, more than two and a half years later than the date given in NMGH records, and by Catherine’s GP. 15 Given the imperative need for prompt treatment, and the vulnerability of dementia sufferers to abuse, accurate medical records are vital.
Catherine’s repeated statements to the effect that she wanted Jane to make all decisions for her are confirmed in NHS Mental Health records. The same consultant had made a separate report, in a letter to Catherine’s new GP. This report states that Catherine wanted Jane to make all decisions for her. 16 Jane took the capacity report for the OPG to the Age Concern ( Age UK) offices in Kendal. The senior advisor was not satisfied with this report, questioning serious inconsistencies. Jane was advised to consult solicitors on the Alzheimer’s panel and/or solicitors for the elderly.
The first firm she approached would be able to meet Catherine on April 28th 2xxx. Sibling 2 would be visiting that day. After meeting Catherine, this solicitor advised Sibling 2 that he did not agree with the report which identified Catherine as having capacity. Specifically, he was not satisfied that she had testatory capacity – that is, she was not mentally competent to make a new will. Sibling 2 did not accept this opinion, claiming that Catherine ‘did not have dementia’ 17 Denying that Catherine was suffering from dementia was inexplicable.
Jane again consulted Age UK. After this consultation, she approached the Mental Health and Social Care Trust, to discuss obtaining a second opinion. This approach was not accepted, and Jane did not have the support of Manchester City Council Social Services. Jane approached another firm on the Alzheimer’s panel and arranged to meet one of their staff at the Alexians. When Jane arrived at the care centre, one of the domestic staff informed her that Catherine had not left her room that day. This was in the early afternoon. Entering the room, the smell was extremely unpleasant. Catherine was lying in wet and soiled bedding, clearly unwell… Jane went to the reception desk to report Catherine’s condition, and the need for a doctor. When the solicitor arrived, Jane explained that her mother was unwell.
A meeting was summoned for May 29th, to be held at the care home, for the completion of ‘Joint and Several’ Lasting Power of Attorney forms, directed by Catherine’s social worker. Catherine was present, clean and neatly dressed, but did not take any active part in completion of the form, which was carried out by the social worked The social worker spoke almost exclusively to Sibling 2. Catherine’s signature was obtained, but she gave no indication of reading any of the document. Apart from signing where she was directed to sign, she had taken no part in the granting of Lasting Power of Attorney. The social worker then handed the completed forms to Sibling 2.
Until Joint and Several Lasting Power of Attorney was registered by the Office of the Public Guardian, Catherine’s named attorneys, Jane and Sibling 2 could not lawfully access Catherine’s accounts or manage her property. When Catherine’s financial data became available, including previous bank statements,it appeared that the care manager and social worker had continued to recognise the supposed authority of Sibling 3. 18 Both had seen the e-mails acknowledging the construction of a property near New Quay, using at least £100,000 of Catherine and William’s money. Bank statements recovered from the house in Blackley had been delivered to the care manager, at the same time that these statements were presented to the police. Evidence of extensive financial and other abuses was comprehensive, and the social worker herself had described the force feeding with liquidised sandwiches, apparently regarding this as acceptable treatment of a frail 87 year old. 19
Essential maintenance work at the house in Blackley continued, undertaken by Jane and her husband. At the same time, Jane was pursuing a complaint about William’s care at the North Manchester General Hospital, including the steps taken to prevent Catherine from visiting him, even on the afternoon of his death. ( To comply with complaint requirements, this had to be rephrased, as preventing William from being visited by his wife) . Jane also questioned William’s physical condition when discharged from the NMGH to Newlands. NMGH records indicate that he was unable to swallow. Discharged to receive continuing care, William should have been funded as an NHS patient. William’s nursing care for the eight and a half days he spent at Newlands cost over £800.
Held in response to Jane ’s complaints about her father’s care, the first meeting at the NMGH was on July 27th 2xxx. The care manager indicated that he would not be attending this meeting. Jane hoped to present a copy of the handwritten letter which she had sent on December 1st 2xxx, reporting extensive ongoing abuse. Visiting the Adult Social Care offices in Harpurhey on the morning of July 27 th, Jane asked to see the care manager, stating the purpose of her visit. The manager came down to meet Jane at the reception desk, returned to his office for some time, then came back to reception, claiming that could not find this letter. Jane did not know then that the scanned copy of her letter had been copied to him by email on December 11th the previous year. 20 The NMGH meeting was also attended by Jane ’s advocate. NHS staff insisted that it would not have been appropriate for Catherine to be with William when he was dying. Catherine was referred to as ‘rather an elderly lady, and rather a frail lady’ ‘Frailty’ is often used as a synonym or euphemism for dementia. 21 Nearly six months after William’s death, Catherine was still grieving, not because William had died at 98, but because she had not been allowed to be with him at the last. During this meeting, Jane reported Sibling 3’s action, in delivering to the care home a photograph taken of William after his death.
A partial apology was offered by the hospital. Members of the public are not necessarily familiar with the complex structure and terminology of the NHS complaints procedure. Studying the NMGH response, Jane ’s GP, who had advised and supported Jane in her attempts to obtain information about her parents, indicated that much more needed to be investigated. In February 2xxx, responding to Jane ’s further complaints about failings in William’s care, the Pennine Acute Hospitals Trust recognised some of the safeguarding failures, acknowledging that Jane had given grave warnings and that staff had failed to act upon these warnings. 22 At this point, other serious matters were unresolved. The complaint concerned the care of two very old people, married for over sixty years. Failings in the care of one had, inevitably, a serious negative impact on the wellbeing of the other. Catherine’s records from the NMGH and Mental Health and Social Care Trust would not be released to Jane for over two years. The prolonged delay in gaining access to Catherine’s NHS records impeded further complaints. Some of William’s records have still to be released. Once again, Jane's right to access any of her father's records has been
disputed by an NHS Trust.
Visiting Catherine at the Alexians, immediately after the NMGH meeting, Jane found her mother mystified by a framed photo of newborn twins. Did she know anybody who had had a baby ? Later, the twins would be identified incorrectly by Alexian staff as Sibling 3’s grandchildren. Sibling 3 had no children, either by birth or by adoption. Catherine’s inability to recognise grandchildren appears in her NHS Mental Health records. None of Catherine’s grandchildren lived in Manchester. Two grandchildren spent most of their childhood and adolescence in other countries. Her youngest grandchild was born in London in July 2xxx shortly before Catherine’s memory problems and changing behaviour became evident.
On July 28th, the day after this meeting at the NMGH Sibling 2 rang Jane , claiming, incorrectly, that Jane had applied to become Catherine’s deputy. This was untrue, but, as Catherine’s social worker had directed on January 21st that Jane should apply for deputyship, Jane had approached the solicitors, in preparation for an application. Deputies: make decisions for someone who lacks capacity. 23 The consultant old age psychiatrist who reported, incorrectly, that Catherine began to suffer from dementia in December 2007 had reported to the Office of the Public Guardian that Catherine had the capacity to grant Lasting Power of Attorney.
Jane approached the Court of Protection, in case the application for deputyship had been processed by mistake. Jane was informed by letter that an application for deputyship for Catherine had been received, but this had been made by another person. There had been no error on the part of her solicitor. The maker of this application was not identified by the Court of Protection. Jane tried to discuss the matter with the care manager who had witnessed her statement reporting ongoing abuse. The care manager stated that he could not discuss anything with her. Jane's husband was present when this call was made. Sibling 2 also informed Jane that she could not work with her and would be ‘taking charge’.
Although questioned by Age UK and the Alzheimer’s panel solicitor, who did not recognise Catherine as having testatory capacity, the consultant’s report had authorised the granting of Lasting Power of Attorney by Catherine, jointly and severally to Sibling 2 and to Jane . The social worker had given the completed forms to Sibling 2. Initially, Sibling 2 sent Jane a photo copy of the LPA document. Photocopies are not acceptable. An official hologrammed copy was required. Eventually, in September 2xxx a hologrammed copy was sent to Jane , but in August 2xxx, Sibling 2 had already drawn up a new will for Catherine. In the new will, Sibling 4 is identified as sole executor. Jane was not informed about the making of this will. Having the Lasting Power of Attorney document, Sibling 2 had assumed sole authority. Legally, an Attorney cannot make a new will for a donor. It is possible for an attorney to arrange for a new will to be drawn up, but an application must be made to the Court of Protection. 24
According to the Office of the Public Guardian, only one original Lasting Power of Attorney document is issued. Questions submitted by Jane ’s MP received the same response. The OPG offered no explanation for this policy. Historically, the OPG’s position cannot be justified. Important documents are always copied. There were four originals of Magna Carta, and around two hundred of the Declaration of Independence. The duplicated text of indentures written on parchment provided simple contract copying. The issuing of only one primary document devalued the supposed joint and several status of Lasting Power of Attorney, in that a named attorney not holding the original document has, demonstrably, less authority than the holder. Most financial institutions, including Santander, HSBC and Nationwide declined to accept Jane ’s hologrammed copy. Confusion over the status of joint and several Lasting Power of Attorney was widespread in England and Wales. As the eldest sibling and since William’s death, Catherine’s nearest relative, Jane ’s ability to act in Catherine’s best interests was seriously compromised. Jane had no access to any of Catherine’s remaining assets, to meet any necessary expenditure on Catherine’s behalf.
Jane could not be refused access to the bank statements, which documented extensive misuse of Catherine and William’s assets,. Atypical use of their accounts appears to have begun some time before their removal to the house of Sibling 3, including what appears to be extensive use of cards. Detailed forensic accounting would be required to confirm this. In 2xxx the statements include the transfer of a debt recovery payment and Sibling 3’s utility bills and all other household expenses. The initial monthly transfer of £450 became £1450 . The person operating this account had unlimited use of Catherine and William’s bank cards. A major long term investment bond with the Prudential had been cashed in at a low value, before the first death. Sibling 3’s name had been added to accounts, then Catherine’s name had been removed. All the major movements of funds were into this account, now in the names of Sibling 3 and William, On William’s death, Sibling 3 had sole access to this account. In November 2xxx, Jane made an appointment at the nearest branch of Santander, questioning the lack of access to this account, but was publicly rebuked by bank staff for seeking access to another person’s private bank account, i.e, the account to which Sibling 3’s name had been added, then Catherine’s name removed. All these financial movements had been made at the instigation of a person who was not a Deputy and did not have Power of Attorney.
3.7 No Secrets
Roles and responsibilities within and between agencies.
When an allegation of abuse is made, the receiving agency must always notify the appropriate regulatory body, within any stipulated time limits, and also any other authority who may be using the service provider. Residential care homes are required under the Registered Homes Act 1984 (as amended in 1991) ‘to notify the Registration Authority not later than 24 hours from the time of its occurrence...of any event in the home which affects the well-being of any resident’, and specifically of: any serious injury to any person residing in the home (Regulation 14(1)(b)); and • any event in the home which affects the well-being of any resident
(Regulation 14 (1) (d)).
Approaching Action on Elder Abuse, Jane ’s position was constrained by her lack of access to any of Catherine’s remaining assets. She could not engage a solicitor and had already incurred significant costs. While returning from taking her younger daughter back to university, Jane took a pre-arranged call from Action on Elder Abuse, who advised that she should refer the case to a named person on Manchester’s Adult Safeguarding Board. No reply was received.
Cumbria CID had acted appropriately, examining the evidence of financial abuse of vulnerable adults presented to them and referring all this data to Greater Manchester. In Manchester the financial and physical abuse of vulnerable older people aged 98 and 88, suffering from dementia, blindness and uncorrected hearing impairment was dismissed, repeatedly, as ‘ a domestic, we don’t get involved’. At Collyhurst police station, keeping an early morning appointment, the desk sergeant’s response was specific: ‘ This is about three sisters, isn’t it ? It’s a domestic. We don’t get involved.’ Another desk officer suggested that ‘ in a lucid moment’, Jane ’s parents could have agreed to everything. Issued by Manchester City Council, ten years before the reported ongoing abuse, William’s Registered Blind Person’s card was presented to the Greater Manchester Police, proof that the reported six figure abuse involved a victim who was blind. No action was taken, but in the summer of 2xxx, Jane was warned that she could be charged with ‘ wasting police time’, an offence which can result in a six months prison sentence. NHS records documenting blindness, dementia and the findings of a Best Interests meeting conducted at the NMGH were submitted to Greater Manchester Police. Jane’s husband, who works in the financial sector, prepared an analysis of the misuse of William and Catherine’s assets, which was presented to their MP. The MP then approached the Chief Constable. The alleged abuse of Catherine and William was identified as Criminal Deception.
During the autumn of 2xxx, police assessment of the evidence began, but the case had been assigned to a young constable. As the Social Care Institute for Excellence has recognised, the investigation of financial abuse requires skilled and experienced officers. 25 The constable liaised primarily with Sibling 2,who had instructed a solicitor to identify the matter as contested probate. Drawn up, supposedly, by two people suffering from dementia, one of them being also blind and hearing impaired and including many mis-identifications of legatees and one executrix, this will was seriously flawed and should have been challenged as invalid. 26
William's Registered Blind Person's card could be issued only when William’s GP and the local authority had received their copy of the certificate confirming that William was blind. Why GMP did not accept the card as evidence of William’s blindness is unclear. Requesting access to William’s opthalmology records from the Manchester Royal Eye Hospital, NHS access to records protocols should have led to sight of the original certificate confirming blindness, held by the Medical Legal departmen of the Central Manchester University Hospitals . GMP reported, by email, that the investigation into abuse was now closed, because William would have been able to read. The email cites GMP’s incorrect interpretation of opthalmology data which confirms that William was blind. Not medically trained, GMP officers apparently did not understand the significance of the number which a trainee registrar had given to a constable. GMP seem to think that the number meant that William would be able to see clearly for up to a metre. In fact, the ratio means that the patient can only see at one metre what a normally sighted person can see at 36 metres. Crucially, suffering from macular degeneration, William had no focal vision, so was unable to read anything. In one eye, he could detect only hand movements.
Later, GMP officers would accept the will drawn up in 2xxx by Sibling 3 as valid, GMP also accepted claims by witnesses to this will that William had no problems with his sight, and a claim from the other executrix that he ' definitely wanted to move to Wales'. When Jane submitted medical records from the Manchester Royal Eye Hospital which confirm that William was blind, GMP ‘s reply was that ‘ there is no evidence to support your belief that your father could not see anything’ . ( writer’s italics) Jane’s MP then submitted the same evidence, that is, William’s Registered Blind Person’s card, and the certificate completed by his consultant opthalmic surgeon, registering him as blind. GMP’s response was almost identical ‘ No evidence to support your constituent’s belief that her father could not see anything’ The addition of the ‘weasel word’ ‘anything’ negates the legal status of blindness. Only a minority- around 4% - of people legally blind can’t see anything. Most people who are registered as blind have some residual sight. Severely sight impaired/blind, they ‘cannot do any work for which eyesight is essential’ . Only the minority who have no light perception (NLP) cannot see anything
On December 16th 2xxx, Sibling 2 rang Jane to report that many of Catherine and William’s possessions were in store at a container depot on the outskirts of Manchester. Sibling 2 supplied the name and contact details of the person charging for this storage. Jane was informed that the outstanding fee for storage was already £200. At the time, the Greater Manchester Police investigation into a case identified as Criminal Deception was still active. The goods held in storage belonged to Catherine and had been taken from her. For this reason, Jane hoped for police support. None was offered. The storage depot confirmed that a named contractor leased space. Meeting the contractor in a public place, Jane paid the £200 he required. A receipt was supplied. The misappropriation of Catherine and William’s possessions is relevant to this serious case review because NHS and Adult Social Care staff in Manchester were responsible for the safeguarding of Catherine and William. Their duty of care included the protection of their property. Before the Care Act of 2014, Catherine and William’s property should have been protected in accordance with the guidance presented in existing legislation. Every aspect of the abuses experienced by William and Catherine is defined in ‘ No Secrets’ . The duty of care towards property is also defined on the National Assistance Act of 1948 and in subsequent legislation.
At the container depot office, Jane and her husband faced a problem, in that the contractor appeared to be taking directions by phone from Sibling 3, who directed the site operators that Jane and her husband should not be allowed to recover Catherine’s property. Jane presented her hologrammed copy of the lasting power of Attorney. 27 Jane and her husband took as much as they could, to store at the house in Blackley. Retrieving all contents wasn’t possible. Severe weather was imminent and they needed to collect a large wall clock , placed with a clock repairer, whose bill of £1200 had not been paid by Sibling 3. In snow, the return to Cumbria was difficult. In January, when conditions improved, Jane and her husband collected the rest of William and Catherine’s possessions from the container depot, to be stored on the upper floor of the house in Blackley, because the ground floor was now unsafe.
On March 25th 2xxx, one psychiatrist with the Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust reported, incorrectly, that ‘none of the daughters have visited for a very long time’ 28. Jane had visited on January 22nd,February 26th, March 14th and March 16th . In December 2xxx, the same psychiatrist is identified in letters about Catherine sent to different GP practices on successive days. 29 Even without access to the NHS records, difficulties affecting Catherine’s quality of life were obvious. The care placement was in no way appropriate for any resident with Catherine’s complex needs. Her constant distress affected other residents. Calling for William, she often expressed her wish to die. Monotony exacerbated her distress. Just once, eighteen months after her arrival, Catherine – still referred to by this care home as ‘Mary’ was taken out, to visit a supermarket. Supermarkets can be stressful for healthy adults in control of their lives. Small children express their own distress. From choice, when in good health herself, Catherine hadn’t shopped at the store which she was taken to visit.
On March 16th 2xxx, at the invitation of Catherine’s new GP, Jane kept a surgery appointment in Catherine’s name. Asked if she believed her mother’s care needs were being met, Jane gave the only answer possible. Catherine’s needs were not being met. Two days later- a Mental Health Trust psychologist ‘s report for 18th March 2xxxrefers to Catherine hitting out at staff, ‘ very low in mood since moving to the home’ suffering from hallucinations and delusions. Throws used toilet paper around the room.' 30 In March 2xxx, focused on occupancy rates, rather than their ability to meet Catherine’s complex care needs, the management of the Alexians had been determined to secure Catherine’s presence. Family members with little or no experience of care homes responded to hard-sell tactics wholly inappropriate when the product peddled in this way is the end of life care of people no longer able to care for themselves.
Dementia doesn’t progress in accordance with fixed rules. No longer able to manage personal hygiene , including use of the lavatory and disposal of dirty paper, Catherine could still respond to core interests. At Easter 2xxx, Jane visited Catherine, bringing a copy of a recently published history book she had written. History was Catherine’s principal subject as a trainee teacher. She expressed delight, adding that ‘ Granddad would be so proud’, adding that she meant her own father, Jane ’s grandfather. Noticing an injury to the back of Catherine’s hand, Jane approached staff to ask what had happened. The response was brusque. Catherine had been ‘violent’ Used to describe people suffering from dementia, the word is not acceptable. Catherine was 89. As an adult, her maximum height had been barely 5ft 2”. According to her consultant old age psychiatrist, she was suffering from two forms of dementia. NMGH records document two damaged heart valves. She suffered from chronic breathing problems, probably associated with both her heart condition and stress. Prescribed anti-psychotics and antidepressants could cause difficult side effects. In-depth analysis of so-called challenging behaviour exhibited by people with dementia will not be attempted in this review. People suffering from degenerative brain diseases, heart disease and many other distressing conditions of later life could be in pain, feeling unwell, affected by medication, or simply frightened. Staff skilled and experienced in dementia care should respond to the person in distress, not dismiss them as ‘violent’. Catherine was a victim, not a perpetrator. She had experienced many forms of abuse, which she had reported to her eldest daughter. Though the abuse had been reported and evidence produced, no action had been taken by Social Services, NHS Mental Health, or the Police. At Newlands, the nature of the abuse Catherine had experienced was recognised and appropriate safeguarding measures had been taken. No such support was given at the Alexians.
Catherine’s illness and hospital admission in September 2xxx with impacted faeces, florid piles and other bowel problems wasn’t an isolated incident. On May 14th2xxx, Jane had two commitments in Manchester. The first was a mandatory appointment with utility companies, so that gas and electrical safety tests could be conducted at the empty house, which was not in a safe condition.. The appointment would be at some time within a two hour slot. Secondly, Jane would be meeting Catherine’s new social worker, to discuss her care at the Alexians. Jane had given written notice of her earlier and unavoidable commitment. When she reached the care home, the social worker had already ended her assessment. As usual, for a pre-arranged visit, Catherine was clean and tidily dressed. Jane normally did not give the home any notice. During this visit, the Alexians care manager rebuked Jane severely for trying to report abuse to the police. This was said while walking along a corridor, with the Manchester Social Services social worker.
A week later, on her way to a meeting in Derbyshire, Jane returned to the home, this time, without giving notice, and found Catherine in bedding so heavily soiled and the room in such a condition that this could not be a recent accident. Jane did not take photographs. Catherine’s distressing condition must be reported to staff immediately. Taking photos of a parent lying in bedding caked with faeces, with dirty toilet paper scattered around the room would be difficult for anybody. The situation demands prompt action. Increasingly, families are installing hidden cameras in care home rooms. When Jane complained about this serious neglect, the care home claimed that she had requested personal care for Catherine, which was given immediately.
Photographic evidence of Catherine’s condition is unnecessary. Jane had arrived without notice after 11.a.m. Proof of the condition in which Jane found her mother is to be found in reports made by NHS psychiatrists, undertaking assessments of Catherine. Many of these reports confirm and enlarge on Catherine’s frequent soiling, her habit of keeping dirty toilet paper after use, and other ‘ Fairly frequent and severe behavioural difficulties.’ Reports made by psychiatrists detail some of these ‘ difficulties’, including pulling out her hair, keeps dirty toilet paper with her, faeces and dirty toilet paper, aggression and disinhibition. ‘ 31 As their health deteriorates, some people suffering from dementia can no longer manage bodily waste – a stage which is distressing for both carers and sufferers. Most dementia care has been consigned to the private sector. Only minimally trained and poorly paid, care workers cannot be expected to provide the psychological support needed by an angry and frightened person with dementia. Catherine had been given formal diagnoses of serious mental health conditions. In a standard residential care home, staff would not have the qualifications and expertise required to support a patient suffering from dementia and, according to Catherine's NHS mental health records, psychotic depression. Care home staff are among some of the lowest paid workers in the UK, with an average hourly wage of £7.46., considerably less than checkout assistants. 32 Unsurprisingly, nearly half UK care home workers leave within a year. 33 The average NHS psychiatric nurse earns £25,633 per year. Caseloads are increasing, the workforce aging. 34
Supposedly ‘the family’ were still happy with Catherine’s care at the Alexians. Not involved in placing Catherine in this home, and, though Catherine’s nearest relative and the person Catherine had wanted to make all decisions for her, not recognised as ‘next of kin’ by the Alexian staff, Jane tried to report her serious concerns about Catherine to Social Services. Approaches to Manchester Social Services met with no response. Finding no named person identified as Director of Social Services on the city’s website, Age UK in Kendal applied for the information and gave Jane the name of the current office holder. Correctly addressed, including the postmark, this letter was returned by the Royal Mail, marked ‘addressee gone away’. 35
Throughout 2xxx, Jane was still trying to obtain Catherine’s NHS general and mental health records. Also, she was trying to find out why no action had been taken after she made her formal statement to the social worker and care manager on January 19th 2xxx, presenting evidence of six figure abuse, and the ongoing construction of the property near New Quay. After Jane ’s own submissions to Manchester City Council had failed, Jane ’s MP wrote to Manchester’s Director of Social Services. The reply he received identifies the sender as Acting Head of Social Services, informing him that ‘ the two officers have no recollection of any such encounter’.
According to Manchester City Council, there was no evidence that Jane had been to Manchester. Presented with scanned copies of train tickets, Manchester Social Services acknowledged that Jane could have visited the city, but there was no evidence that she had visited the Adult Social Care offices. Jane ’s MP copied this response to her immediately. Entering a public building, signing the visitors book on arrival and on leaving is mandatory and in case of fire or other safety emergency, essential. Manchester claimed that there were no records of Jane’s many visits to the Adult Social Care offices.
Knowing that people in public office have made untrue statements about their actions in that office is disturbing. Such conduct negates the concept of a social contract. The care manager and social worker were responsible for securing the wellbeing and safeguarding of vulnerable people, including Catherine and William. Making their untrue statements, the care manager and the social worker had the support of Manchester City Council. Jane’s MP challenged the original response, receiving another dismissive reply. The City Council’s Social Services department was the lead agency, responsible for coordinating the response to any report of abuse. In the case of Catherine and William, the report of ongoing abuse was supported by documented evidence of extensive financial abuse.
After a weekend of urgent remedial work on Catherine and William’s long-neglected house, Jane and her husband visited four Manchester care homes specialising in dementia and Elderly Mentally Ill care. No appointments were made. Late on a Sunday afternoon, staff were able and willing to discuss a potential placement. Residents who were well enough were enjoying family visits. Unable as they were to provide appropriate care for a resident with Catherine’s complex needs, the Alexian Brothers Care Centre opposed Jane ’s attempts to identify an Elderly Mentally Ill placement for Catherine , informing her that she was not allowed to do this. 36
Jane’s applications for Catherine’s NHS records were still unsuccessful.. The request for these records was again referred to her MP. Catherine’s consultant psychiatrist agreed to meet Jane at the care home on October 13th 2xxx. Just before the meeting with the consultant Jane found the residents sitting in the usual three sided arrangement, but in a much larger room, not normally used as a residents’ day room. A larger screen TV was on, but no other provision was apparent. The reason for this change appeared to be internal work on the building. Sibling 2, who had visited recently, did not attend the meeting. The consultant asked Catherine if she could identify the ‘lady’ who was with them Catherine identified Jane as her eldest daughter. Asked how many children she had, Catherine responded correctly, giving their birth order and gender. Asked about employment, she stated that she had been a headteacher, naming the school. When Jane challenged the extensive misrepresentation of Catherine’s personal, medical and career history, the consultant stated that
‘ We had to go by what we had been told’ 37
This is totally unacceptable. No personal, medical or career information concerning a vulnerable person should be accepted without evidence. Sibling 3’s serious ‘ misrepresentations’ included the claim that Catherine had begun to develop memory problems in May/June 2xxx. Catherine’s NHS records refer to her being known to Manchester Mental Health’s Park House three years earlier. GP and NMGH recognition of dementia is on record in June and July 2xxx, with a history of memory problems and altered behavior for three or four years before dementia was confirmed. Dementia was recognised again at the NMGH in August and September 2xxx, Dr A, Catherine’s GP at Practice A, in Blackley, confirmed that Catherine was concerned about her mental health. 38
Dementia being a very seriously disabling mental health condition, early recognition and accurate record keeping is imperative for patient safeguarding. Sibling 3’s falsification of Catherine’s medical history could have been corrected immediately, if NHS staff had checked existing NHS records.
On August 31st 2xxx, over fifteen months before the date given by this consultant to the Office of the Public Guardian for the onset of dementia, he had attempted to visit Catherine, at her home address, in Blackley. The visit had been requested by Catherine’s original GP at Practice A. . Catherine and William had agreed to this visit. As reported in Chapter Five, Serious Negative Outcomes, Catherine wasn’t at home because she was a patient on Ward D3 of the North Manchester General Hospital and would remain there until September 12th 2xxx, when she was discharged to the house of Sibling 3.
On November 7th 2xxx, three weeks after the consultant’s assessment of Catherine, one of the residents at the Alexians was crushed by a falling fire door., so heavy, three men were needed to lift it off the victim. The lady died of her injuries, which included a fractured pelvis. Construction work was in progress on the premises. No provision had been made foe the residents’ safety. 39 . Aged 92, this lady was suffering from dementia The investigation into the fatal accident is on record, in the public domain. 40 The Alexian Brothers Care Centre and the construction firm they had engaged were both prosecuted by the Health and Safety Executive. Both parties were found guilty. Although investigations into the circumstances of Mrs X death began immediately, the case didn’t come to court until 2014. 41
Jane ’s last visit to her mother in 2xxx was on November 25th. Prolonged severe weather affecting most of the country restricted further visits until 24th January 2xxx Catherine’s increasing distress continued to affect other residents. During Jane ’s visits, Catherine would cry out constantly for William. A Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust psychiatrist reported, as usual, that the family was happy for her to remain at the Alexians. Jane was definitely not content for Catherine to remain there, but her position remained compromised. After the original care manager, social worker and consultant had taken no action in response to Jane’s reports of ongoing and extensive abuse, she was effectively excluded from decisions concerning her parents’ care.
Visiting on Sunday July 3rd, Jane and her husband found the care centre silent. Eventually, Jane found a member of staff, explaining that she had come to see Catherine. The staff member replied that she had just ‘ settled Catherine for the night’. It was just before ten to five, on a warm sunny afternoon. Visiting several other care centres in Manchester at this time on a Sunday in September, hoping to identify more appropriate care for Catherine, Jane and her husband had seen residents alert and wearing normal daytime clothes. Jane made no comment, leaving a small gift for her mother. The multiplicity of failings in Catherine’s care had to be challenged. Her care needs were not being met, and the inappropriate placement had been secured by means of unprofessional sales tactics. A mental health assessment carried out on August 1st found that Catherine was ‘ verbally and physically aggressive, wants to die, and that she would spend days in bed. 42 This report also refers to Catherine’s aggressive behaviour towards other residents.
Four days later, Jane visited in the late morning of Saturday, August 5th 2011. Catherine was, as usual, reluctant to drink her tea, asking Jane to taste it. Tea was served with milk to all residents, The tea Jane tasted was also very sweet. Catherine had never taken sugar in tea or coffee. At the office, Jane explained that her mother didn’t want to drink tea with sugar. One of the staff replied,
‘ She’s got dementia.’
Jane stated, again, that her mother had never taken sugar. Another member of staff took down Catherine’s file. An allergy to strawberries was on record. Nothing else, just strawberries..
The strawberry allergy record was correct. Always taking drinks without sugar was Catherine’s lifelong dietary preference, unrelated to dementia. 43 As a resident of this care home, Catherine had experienced a number of urinary tract infections, and also, the faecal impaction documented in her NMGH records for September 2009. According to staff, Catherine’s infections were because she didn’t drink enough. Presented with communally prepared pre-sugared tea, Catherine’s reluctance to accept a drink which she found distasteful is understandable. Catherine’s physical care needs were not being met. Hygiene failings increased the risk of UTI’s.
The letter given in full below was sent to all members of the Hospital Management Trust and copied to the Care Quality Commission. The manager of the Alexians rebuked Jane for seeking to involve the CQC.
August 8th 2xxx
The Hospital Management Trust
14, Queen Anne’s Gate
London,
SW1H 9AA
Your Ref : Mrs Catherine X 16/12/1920 The Alexian Brothers’ Care Centre,
Copied to : Care Quality Commission.
Dear …..
On September 18th 2xxx, being extremely dissatisfied with the quality of care my mother was receiving at the Alexian Brothers’ Care Centre in Manchester, I wrote to the Chairman and to the then Matron at the Alexians. I gave many reasons for my concern. One matter was serious enough to warrant an approach to the Care Quality Commission. For your convenience, I am enclosing a copy of that letter. As a Trustee appointed to manage a group of private hospitals and care centres, I hope that you have concern for any serious matters affecting the wellbeing of the people in your care. In my many visits to the Alexians since my mother’s admission on March 19th, 2xxx I have found little evidence of respect for her privacy, dignity and individuality. Nor have I experienced the professed warm and caring atmosphere indicated in your promotional literature.
My mother’s residency began after staff at the Alexians exercised undue and highly misleading pressure on my sister and brother. Our father had died on February 4th. Following his death, a post-mortem was ordered. Very serious NHS, Social Services and legal investigations into my parents’ case had already commenced. Arranging our father’s Requiem and comforting our widowed mother, we faced an extremely grave situation. When I visited the Alexians in March, 2xxx, to consider whether it would be suitable for my mother, I was not introduced to any residents. Having worked in client support as an Age UK volunteer, I was already familiar with normal practice at care homes in my own area, including initial visits made by families. I was shown just one vacant room. Visiting separately, my sister was shown other accommodation. My sister and my brother were advised by one of your care managers that if they failed to take up a place immediately, they could be waiting two years for another opportunity. This was, I believe, an untruth. I had investigated the recent history of the centre and was aware of recent problems especially in the nursing departments. Moving my mother without notice from the establishment which had cared for my parents during the last days of my father’s life, the family faced costs of over £2,200, in lieu of notice. Moving my mother without an initial visit of some days, or assessments by key staff was not in her best interests. Her recent experiences had been very grave indeed. When in good health, my parents, as lifelong supporters of many Catholic charities, would not have acted so intemperately, incurring substantial costs. Speaking to me on my landline, the same care manager, a rebuked me for these observations. Subsequently, it was indicated to other family members that I had made a very bad impression. According to your own records, occupancy at the Alexians had been poor in 2006, but in 2009, it improved to 93%, but not, I note, to 100%. There is no excuse for the personal rebukes delivered by staff, or the claims of a two year wait. The Alexians website presents the following statements :
Prior to admission, the Matron or a designated nurse will arrange to visit a prospective resident to answer any questions about the home and to establish individual needs and expectations. Residents and their family are encouraged to visit the home prior to the assessment. If the Care Centre is able to meet the resident’s needs a trial stay at the home will be offered.
This was certainly not my experience in March, 2009. Unlike many elderly people, my mother had a formal diagnosis of both vascular dementia and Alzheimer’s disease. Her mental capacity had been assessed on March 5th by her consultant, reporting to the Office of the Public Guardian. She achieved a borderline score. Given the very difficult circumstances, including my father’s recent death, her own physical condition, and other grave matters, the consultant decided to repeat the test after she had had more time to recover from emaciation and other matters. .
The Chaplain and some of the Brothers provide pastoral care for residents, their families, friends and staff. Reliability, honesty, integrity, friendliness and professionalism are all qualities we look for when recruiting staff. Prospective employees are screened by the Criminal Records Bureau and the Independent Safeguarding Authority and references thoroughly checked prior to commencement in post.
I have no personal experience of the professed pastoral care, only of reprimands and rebukes from Alexian staff. Many aspects of my mother’s case are far beyond the remit of any care provider. On January 1st, 2xxx, I made my first report to the police. By January 19th, I was able to present evidence of six-figure financial abuse, and by January 25th, my sister and I had been able to supply both the police and Social Services with evidence of very grave misuse of our parents’ assets.
It is not usual for the circumstances of a care home resident to be under investigation by CID, the Parliamentary Health Service Ombudsman, the Local Government Ombudsman, the Financial Ombudsman Service and the General Social Care Council. The gravity of this situation should be clear to all Trustees and to all staff engaged in caring for my mother. The word trauma has been devalued by overuse. In my mother’s case, it is entirely appropriate.
On April 16th, 2xxx, repeating his assessment at the Alexians, my mother’s consultant reported that she had the capacity to appoint her own attorneys, clearly identifying her two elder daughters as the people whom she wished to manage her affairs. It would have been proper for my sister and me to secure Lasting Power of Attorney for Health and Welfare at the same time. Difficult circumstances intervened, concerning Manchester Social Services. We were granted LPA for our mother’s property and financial affairs. I cannot provide any further information concerning serious and highly confidential investigations. I can report marked and repeated insensitivity and actual hostility towards me, on the part of staff at the Alexians. Three examples should be sufficient :
1. When I arrived to visit my mother on May 13th, 2xxx at lunch time, one of the cleaning staff advised me that my mother was still in bed. I found her in some distress and in need of personal care. Her distress concerned the very serious matters under investigation by CID and the other agencies. Less than a month after the capacity report, I hoped she would be well enough to meet a solicitor experienced in work with the elderly. A member of staff known to me only as S**** rebuked me very discourteously. After travelling to Manchester from Cumbria, I had been addressing urgent practical matters at my parents’ former house. This member of staff, together with my mother’s then care manager and inevitably, other Alexian staff insisted that my youngest sister must be allowed to visit. The professed ‘ pastoral care’ at the Alexians centred on a statement that ‘ We’ like families to get on.’ Treating mature adults as if they were squabbling teenagers is not pastoral care. It is both insensitive and inappropriate. The eldest of my mother’s brothers, who is in his late eighties, was evidently identified as ‘ head’ of the family. For some meetings concerning my mother’s care, neither I, nor my sister and co-attorney, nor my mother’s social worker were notified, only the supposed head of the family. My sister and I wished to protect our elderly uncle and our aunt from any distress associated with the CID and other investigations.
On January 26th, 2xxx, my mother had been removed from a very difficult situation. Following a formal NHS Best Interests meeting at the North Manchester General Hospital, my father was discharged, for the last week of his life, to nursing care, at the Jewish-run establishment which could offer a nursing bed and a residential place. The police had been alerted, and the extent to which my mother had been stripped of her personal history began to emerge. Staff at the Newlands Care Home in Salford had responded admirably in what must have been exceptionally difficult circumstances. Crucially, their qualified and experienced nursing staff recognised the profound distress my mother had experienced while in the supposed care of my youngest sister. I had made many warning referrals to Manchester Social Services and to Manchester Mental Health concerning this sister, the only one of four siblings to remain in Manchester. My other sister lives in xxx I am in xxx, and our brother accompanies his wife, who works for the Foreign and Commonwealth Office. According to Manchester Social Services, our parents’ personal history was very different. As a retired headteacher and mother of four, my mother, already affected by the brain damage of vascular dementia, had been stripped of her true identity. Though she was with them for such a short time, staff at the Newlands home recognised a very dangerous and distressing situation. Separated from my father throughout much of the last year of his life, my mother was not even allowed to be with him at his death. The Divisional Director of Medicine has offered an unreserved apology for what has happened, promising additional safeguarding measures, and acknowledging that staff had failed to act upon grave warnings. NHS investigations continue, and all my late father’s medical records are already with CID.
2. September 16th, 2xxx
Some of the events of this day prompted my previous letter. Poor record keeping and reception desk monitoring allowed a visit to my mother’s room by five people, though only one had been recorded. Two were infants. This is a breach of Health and Safety and Fire regulations. When xxxx and I arrived a few minutes apart, to attend a meeting with Alexian staff and Social Services, my mother was clearly profoundly distressed. Further pressure had evidently been placed on her by one or all of the three adults who had been present, urging that she should pay my youngest sister a regular allowance. My mother stated repeatedly that she did not want visits from this sister. I suggest that care staff should be aware of the phenomenon known as Stockholm syndrome, and the tendency of victims to appease their abusers. Repeatedly, my mother’s room was filled with images of my late father, with my youngest sister, including greetings of a kind not usual between a mature daughter and her father. My late father was registered blind in October, 1998. He could not see those cards. My mother could. As a retired headteacher, she discussed the subject of Electra complex with me and with xxxx indicating that it was completely abnormal for an adult woman to have that relationship with her own father. My father had by this time been diagnosed with vascular dementia himself. It was my mother who had always been the principal breadwinner, and it is the suspected misuse of what should be my mother’s assets which is under investigation, a six figure sum and a newly built property. That is why my mother is rightly distressed. Dementia does not remove the capacity to feel pain and grief.
3. May 14th - May 21st 2xxx
On May 14th, travelling as usual from Cumbria, I had an urgent mandatory appointment at my parents’ vacant house, meeting gas and electricity representatives, so that safety checks could be carried out. My presence throughout the allotted two hour slot was essential. After the inspection, I travelled to the Alexians, to find that my mother’s Social Services assessment had taken place in my absence. The meeting which followed was with the Alexians manager, my mother’s current social workers, and another member of staff. The manager indicated her displeasure regarding the police involvement. I am, of course, sorry that this lady finds the case ‘ very upsetting’. The manager addressed me by my given name. In a formal business meeting, it would have been appropriate to ask whether I preferred to be identified as Mrs . I do. People often mispronounce my given name. In a business meeting, especially a first meeting, a degree of formality is appropriate.
Alerted to the support available to victims of serious elder abuse by professionals in my own area, I wanted to identify support for my mother. The manager indicated that I ‘ had made various allegations’ and that ‘ nothing had been proved.’ The tense is incorrect. The investigations by Manchester CID are still in progress and further investigations have begun, most recently, those of the General Social Care Council. CID and the other national level investigations are not conducted at such length merely because a family member has made allegations. Investigations of this nature are usually prolonged. As my mother’s eldest daughter, I find the ongoing CID, Ombudsman and other investigations more than upsetting. The manager’s response was presented as a rebuke. Just one week later, on Friday, May 21st, I had a business meeting in the Peak District and decided to visit my mother again, as a surprise. Arriving just after twenty past eleven, I was advised by cleaning staff that she was still in bed. I found her in heavily soiled bedding. I had four children of my own. I can tell the difference between recent faecal soiling and soiling which has been present for some time. Soiled lavatory paper was littered about the room and around the ensuite facilities. In establishments which offer additional support for people affected by dementia, visual prompts including clear colour coding help to prevent such confusion. In this case, my mother was evidently unwell. She has suffered a number of urinary tract infections, which will, inevitably, exacerbate existing mental health problems . My other sister accepts the Alexians’ assurances that the infections occur because my mother does not drink enough. Dehydration is a contributory factor, not the sole cause . In the case of elderly women, poor perineal hygiene allows faecal contamination. I am not a doctor, but after my M.Sc at Bristol, I worked as an epidemiologist in the health agency now known as NICE.
The Home has a mini bus adapted to accommodate wheelchairs. A driver is available to take residents to hospital appointments or on an outing with trained care staff to local places of interest. The minibus is used to collect and return day-care visitor from and to their homes. A member of trained care staff always accompanies residents/clients when travelling in the minibus
The Home has a minibus ? True. I have seen it. A driver is available to take residents to hospital appointments ? Not in my experience. I live in Cumbria. My sister xxx lives in xxx. The walk-on train fare from xxxxxx to Manchester is very costly indeed. My mother’s eyesight has been deteriorating for some time. I do not understand why staff at the Alexians failed to alert my sister to my mother’s absolute right to a free NHS eye test, at the care centre. Subsequently, it became clear that further investigations were required. I was asked if I could accompany my mother to an appointment at the Manchester Eye Hospital. I could not. The first train to Manchester leaves my nearest station after 9 a.m. Moreover, I knew that the Alexian’s website includes the above claim. There is no reason why relatives living a considerable distance from Manchester should be required or expected to accompany family members to hospital appointments. My mother is suffering from vascular dementia and Alzheimer’s disease. She is 90. She is, as we now know, also suffering from macular degeneration, losing her focal vision. Any one of those conditions would qualify her for NHS patient transport to the hospital, which could have been authorised by her GP. The Alexians website claims that staff are available. This claim is either true or untrue. Requiring a relative to accompany a resident to a hospital appointment compromises NHS provision for the vulnerable. As for visits to local places of interest... I was informed that my mother had been taken to Tescos. This was her first visit anywhere, well over a year after her admission. My mother did not shop at Tesco’s, and as her illness progressed, she found crowded stores very stressful.
During the first few days following admission, staff will identify specific needs and discuss these with the resident and the family and a ‘care plan’ will be developed taking into account physical, clinical, emotional and spiritual needs as well as input from health and social care professionals. This plan will be reviewed every month, more often if required and the plan revised accordingly. Residents and their relatives are invited to discuss their plans of care with the Matron Manger or the nursing staff on a six monthly basis or more frequently if required.
Staff did not identify the specific needs of a lady in her late eighties who had experienced profoundly damaging emotional and physical circumstances. While my mother was at the Newlands Care Home, senior staff asked me to provide a detailed personal history, including my mother’s career, how she had met my father ( through the Catholic Evidence Guild, when she was a fifteen year old schoolgirl at Notre Dame High School in Manchester) , her memories of WWII, the names and birthdays of all her grandchildren and their contact details. One senior nurse, fluent in four languages, explained that in order to support residents, they needed to know about their lives before they became ill. I assume this lady spoke Hausa and Ibo fluently. Her French was excellent. So was my mother’s and my late father’s. They had many French friends. Earlier this year, bringing with me a book in very clear print, I showed her a page of French text - the commentary for Nuit et Brouillard.. Turning the page, the language changes to German and a list of familiar names, Auschwitz, Belsen, Buchenwald etc. My mother asked immediately if I had been to Germany , to visit the camps. At Notre Dame school in Manchester in the late 1930’s, some of her fellow pupils were Jewish refugees from Poland. Some became lifelong friends.
At a meeting held at the Alexians in April, 2009, I was advised by the then matron that they expect families to engage in any reminiscence work with relatives. They advised that they could not have anything to do with greetings and contact with grandchildren. Staff were too busy. Nor had they been aware that my mother is a retired headteacher. It was several months before a T was found for the middle of her name, on the list of residents . That might seem to be a trivial detail. It is not. My mother’s names were given to her at her baptism. She had known the story of her name saint.
As for physical needs... Visiting my mother last Saturday morning, I saw that there was a soft drink of some kind on the table, in a plastic cup. She was given a cup of tea. She drank a little, then urged me to taste it. The tea was very sweet . All my life, my mother has never taken sugar in tea and rarely took sugar in coffee either. I can understand why she didn’t wish to drink it. I would find it equally hard to drink tea or coffee with milk.
Another resident offered to tell staff, but I decided I should have a quick word with them myself. Does he take sugar ?: was the deliberately cynical title of a BBC programme challenging poor attitudes towards the disabled. In the office, Sheila indicated that she would check my mother’s file. All that was on record was her allergy to strawberries. No mention of sugar. This information was delivered as a rebuke to me. I admit to a degree of personal prejudice regarding the use of chewing gum. It might be more courteous if staff could refrain from chewing gum while speaking to residents and their families. The assessment had been carried out by a previous manager, no longer a member of staff, soon after my mother’s admission. My mother could have been consulted herself regarding such a minor and yet very important matter. A member of staff whom I had not met on any previous visits added, as if this might be unfamiliar information, ‘ She’s got dementia.’ That is not a summary of who my mother is. She is a person, not a disease process, and she can still speak fluently. In my presence, she never uses words inaccurately.
Services
Only one item on this list is relevant to my mother, who does indeed suffer from dementia. When I have found her in need of urgent care, I have been the one to summon staff. Is she actually able to summon assistance, and does she do so ?
There is a fully integrated nurse call system in each resident room and in the bathroom and toilet areas.
Twice, and on both those occasions, I was making an unannounced visit, I have found her in urgent and long overdue need of personal care. My own GP and Age UK have advised that I should take photos immediately. My first thought has been, on both occasions, securing help for my mother. I failed to take photos. Photographing one’s mother in a heavily soiled bed and clothing would not be easy. I will try to do so if I find her in this condition again. Staff at the Alexians have given a different account - one being that I requested personal care for her mother, which was delivered immediately. The present manager had already indicated with displeasure that I had made various allegations. My position vis a vis certain members of staff at the Alexians is impossible and I believe it has been impossible from the outset. The problems extend far beyond the habitual absence of courtesy, extending to open criticism of my family, because of our very difficult situation. The situation is not of my making, and it is on record within the NHS, in the letter sent by the Divisional Director of Medicine for the local primary care trust in Manchester that I issued grave warnings, that staff had failed to act, and that additional safeguarding came too late for my parents.
My mother, Catherine , and my late father, William had served their local community and many Catholic organisations throughout most of their long lives. My mother, who had an unbroken teaching career of forty years was an outstanding headteacher, a claim I can support by producing HMI reports for her school. She was, I repeat, stripped of her almost her entire personal history and deliberately separated from my father, to whom she had been married for over sixty years. The misuse of most of her assets is very much a secondary matter. Dementia is a profoundly distressing condition. Adding to that distress by stripping her of so much of her identity was the act of a very unsafe person, I had warned both the NHS and Social Services that my youngest sister had had a major brain tumour, and had other serious health problems. One of these problems was a manifestly abnormal attachment to my late father. In March, 2008, Manchester social workers authorised my mother’s permanent placement in residential care, supposedly as a state pensioner with one daughter. Plans were in progress for my youngest sister to move ‘back’ to Wales, with my father, to a new build property still under construction. My father, much older than my mother, was then 98, blind, deaf and suffering from vascular dementia. A return to Wales was a fantasy. My late father had distant Welsh ancestry on one side. Both his father and grandfather were Mancunians. Family holidays were never taken in Wales.
Our aim at The Alexian Brothers Care Centre is to preserve and maintain the privacy, dignity, and individuality of all residents in a warm and caring atmosphere and with sensitivity to the residents’ ever-changing needs.
My mother needs access to justice. Two major financial institutions have been under investigation. It was necessary to provide evidence of my mother’s permanent address to their Fraud departments. Staff at the Alexians repeatedly failed to do so, even when provided with letters and first class stamped addressed envelopes. Eventually, my other sister resorted to the expense of a solicitor’s letter. We were already our mother’s legally appointed attorneys, registered at the Office of the Public Guardian.
Yesterday, Monday, August 8th, I received a phone call from the Alexians, informing me that my mother had suffered a fall, but was not injured. I indicated that my elder daughter, a twenty-five year old postgraduate student at Manchester University lives in the city centre and can be contacted at once, should my mother need hospital attention. My informant was the member of staff known to me as Sheila. She declined to discuss any contact with my daughter, indicating that this is not on Alexian records. First contact with my daughter was discussed and supposedly agreed at the meeting on September 16th 2xxx. In light traffic, it would take at least two hours for me to reach Manchester and for my other sister, very considerably longer. Ill-advisedly, I again raised the matter of my mother’s lifelong preference for tea without sugar. Once again, I was rebuked. Further disparaging observations were made about my family. I was informed that I would need to speak to Social Services about my daughter. I had just been informed that my 90 year old mother had suffered a fall, and I knew that my elder daughter could be at the Alexians very quickly indeed. Alexian staff had previously indicated that they could not involve children. My daughter was then twenty three. She is now twenty five and certainly not a child. Contacting Manchester Social Services is not easy. Supported by my MP, I was the prime mover in presenting evidence which has been accepted as warranting investigation by the LGO and the General Social Care Council.
Repeatedly, I have been rebuked by staff at the Alexians, almost invariably by xxx, about my mother’s so-called ‘ violence’, adding ‘ We can’t ‘ave that.’ - the message given being that my very old and ill mother has the status of a delinquent child. I had asked how my mother had sustained a minor injury. The word violence is widely and inappropriately used in the context of dementia care. Old, ill, aware of their own weakness, people suffering from dementia are afraid and should be treated with loving kindness by appropriately trained staff. My mother is 90, barely five feet tall, losing her sight and her recent personal experiences have been heartbreaking. Identified as my father’s ‘ next of kin’, it was my very unsafe youngest sister who was called to be with him the afternoon he died, in the A & E department of a Manchester hospital. I use the word unsafe, because I am not qualified to judge her mental state. All of this medical information is emerging as the major national and Manchester based investigations continue. Removed from their own house into our sister’s, in a nearby suburb, all access to my parents was controlled by her. Trustees and others involved in an important charity will, I hope, recognise classic and very distressing elder abuse. Recognising that one’s existence has not been acknowledged is an extraordinary process. My parents had lived in the same house, in the same parish all their married life, and my mother had taught at the parish school. I am their eldest child. At the hospital, I was asked by ward staff whether I was a half sibling. Enduring all of this is hard enough, without the constantly unhelpful and extremely discourteous conduct of some members of the Alexian staff.
In September last year, my husband and I visited several care homes in the Manchester area where staff have E.M.I. experience and training. We saw the many facilities available which help to conserve and support the impairment caused by the disease process. I did try to arrange an assessment visit. Another member of staff at the Alexians rang my home number to rebuke me. Her manner was extremely unsympathetic, delivering a reprimand, rather than discussing in a normal professional manner how my mother’s needs could be met. When, at last, several weeks later, permission was granted for this lady to visit my mother, she reported that my mother’s needs are so complex they cannot be met at their establishment. I cannot see that they are being met in any way at the Alexians.
Unlike my sister , who needs to book tickets from the south coast to Manchester well in advance, I can and do make many unannounced visits, from mid morning to early evening. At six o’clock on the warm and sunny evening of July 3rd, I found that my mother had already been put to bed. On every other occasion, I find her sitting in a chair, doing nothing. The constantly blaring television has been removed. I am not sure what activity or entertainment has been offered instead. Whenever I have visited, at 11, 12, 1, 2, 3, 4, or 5 o’clock, I have found my mother sitting in a chair, doing nothing at all. This is not dementia care . Considering the Alexians’ care centre as I might any other product or service, I would identify the claims made on the website to be contravening advertising standards and trades description legislation. No pastoral care and support of any kind has been offered in an extremely difficult situation. On the contrary, unsympathetic and sometimes hostile staff have behaved as if I and my mother are delinquent. The present matron identified me as a person who had made unproven allegations. When I have reported, truthfully, finding my mother in very unpleasant need of care, my report has been misrepresented. While the grave investigations continue, one person is ending her life in a situation I would never have chosen for her.
I said that three examples of the uncaring attitude of staff would be sufficient, but I will add another. None of my visits to the Alexians are easy, primarily because of the very unpleasant conduct of some staff members. On July 27th last year, travel on the West Coast line to Manchester was disrupted by a tragedy - a suicide on the line, sad and shocking for everyone. Reaching Manchester some hours later, once coach transfers had been organised, I asked staff on reception if they could allow me to use a phone book, so that I could ring the train information line, checking how soon the lines would reopen. Staff informed me that I could come back at the end of the afternoon. I was not asking to use their phone, only for a brief opportunity to find a contact number, because my return journey was likely to be difficult. I am not prepared to accept the habitual lack of courtesy any longer.
Yours sincerely, etc ‘
At the end of August, Catherine’s records from the North Manchester General Hospital were released to Jane . Many records are heavily redacted. Studying the records would be an exacting task, complicated by the apparent disorder in which they had been presented. Records from the Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust were sent to Jane by recorded delivery on September 13th and collected from the Post Office on September 17th. Again, the records appeared extremely disordered. Scanned and copied onto disks, the records were sent by recorded delivery to Greater Manchester Police and to Jane ’s MP.
One NHS Mental Health record confirms the date, location and the names of those present during the long meeting on January 19th 2xxx, when Jane gave her statement to the care manager and social worker, reporting ongoing financial abuse well into six figures. 43 Studying the records, the misrepresentation of Catherine’s medical history by Sibling 3, together with the use of alternating GP practices in Blackley and Crumpsall became clear.
Published early in September 2011, the original CQC report on the Alexian Brothers Care Centre, following the inspection of July 27th identified seven major problems. The centre would be allowed to continue operating on condition that these problems were resolved. Catherine’s NHS Mental Health records state that she was not eating, and refused to use the lavatory. 44 On September 30th a significantly different report was published, presenting the Alexian Brothers Care Centre in an entirely positive light.
In response to Jane ’s written complaints to the Hospital Management Trust, a meeting at the centre was offered. Jane was unable to accept the first date because she would be on holiday. Jane would be free the following working week, 19th - 23rd September. According to the HMT, this date wasn’t possible. Two dates were offered, September 28th or 29th. Her meeting with the Trust’s representative was on September 29th 2011 During this meeting, the HMT representative mentioned their meeting with Siblings 2 and 4, which had taken place the previous week.
Jane continued to search for an alternative placement for Catherine , who needed an Elderly Mentally Ill placement. As her NHS Mental Health records confirm. Catherine’s status as an Elderly Mentally Ill patient was not a new development. According to her Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust records, Catherine had needed such care in April 2xxx. This is confirmed in her NHS records, which cite Care Cluster 12. 45 After eight months of lengthy respite placements and twenty-four days in hospital, the case was reopened in December that year, when psychotic depression was diagnosed. Entered in Catherine’s NHS mental health records, the accuracy of these diagnoses cannot be determined, but they are the official NHS mental health records. .Knowing that Catherine had been recognised as Elderly Mentally Ill, Manchester Social Services should have intervened before the inappropriate move to the Alexians could take place. Suppressing Jane’s written and face to face reports of ongoing abuse, Manchester Social Services and NHS staff consigned an eighty eight year old victim of many forms of abuse to years of wholly inadequate care and serious negligence. When the manager of the Alexian Brothers Care Centre was rebuking Jane for approaching the Care Quality Commission, the centre was already under investigation following the fatal accident to a resident, for which the firm would be prosecuted and convicted.
In September 2xxx, more than two years after registration of Joint and Several Power of Attorney, Sibling 2 allowed Jane access to £7, 500 of Catherine’s remaining assets. After Catherine’s death, Jane submitted a spreadsheet, documenting expenditure on Catherine’s behalf.
In November 2xxx, a Best Interests meeting was conducted for Catherine at the Alexian Brothers Care Centre. Jane was informed of this meeting by Sibling 2 but did not receive any formal notification. Jane was already committed to meeting the advocate who would be attending the first NHS meeting with the Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust, to discuss Jane’s complaints about her mother’s NHS care. The date and timing of the two meetings was determined by this Trust. The Mental Health and Social Care Trust would also be leading the Best Interests meeting. Many failings in Catherine’s care are evident in her records from the North Manchester General Hospital, including a seven week delay in notifying her GP about Catherine’s concerns about her ‘ excessive drinking’ , the very seriously unsafe discharge to Sibling 3, and the NMGH acquiescence in prolonged hospital stays, both for more than three weeks after Catherine was medically fit for discharge.
The Best Interests meeting found that Catherine needed Elderly Mentally Ill care. According to her Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust records, Catherine had needed such care in April 2xxx. The Best Interests meeting also reported that Catherine was too unwell to be removed from Manchester. Elderly Mentally Ill places were available in Manchester. Despite this ruling, Siblings 2 and 4 removed Catherine to a care home near Rawthenstall, over twenty miles away. No explanation is available for this. Jane tried to oppose this unsafe move, but without success. A formal Best Interests meeting had reported its findings, yet the findings were disregarded. Removing Catherine from Manchester was wholly inappropriate. She died nineteen days later, three days before her ninety-first birthday. Death at this age is hardly unexpected, but moving a very old and ill woman so far at the end of her life could not be in her best interests.
The second NHS complaints meeting for both Trusts was on December 1st, at Park House, at 10.a.m. This time, the usual advocate was able to attend. The meeting had been delayed by industrial action in Manchester. At Park House, no clerk was present to take minutes. Jane complained about this The Trust representative stated that she would take the minutes herself. For any formal meeting , record keeping is essential. Instead of written records, some NHS Trusts now routinely record formal resolution meetings to ensure accurate record keeping. 46
A Manchester City Council social worker rang Jane to report that Catherine had been discharged from their care, and was now the responsibility of another authority. Washing its hands of the matter, Manchester City Council could declare that Catherine was no longer a resident of the city where she had lived for more than ninety years and had worked as a dedicated teacher.
1 Social worker, Manchester City Council Social Services/ Mental Health and Social care Trust, , 16th September 2xxx
2 . Care home rooms offered for sale to private investors on ' Buy to let' basis. ... - The Independent
https://www.independent.co.uk
3 Constipation and Faecal Impaction Information, Alzheimer’s Scotland. https://www.alzscot.org/assets/0000/0175/constipation-and-faecal-impaction.pdf
4 Unfair terms in care home contracts: OFT635 – GOV.UK Changes in case law have prompted changes in trading legislation. Care homes market study: summary of final report – GOV.UK https://www.gov.uk/.
5. Effectively, Catherine was supported in accordance with the Jewish tradition of shiva, usually for the seven days after burial – William’s funeral was delayed by over a fortnight.
6 6/3/2xxx Event 132. MMH/SCT
7 23/03/2xxx Event 136 CPN report. MMH/SCT
8 Through her mother, Catherine had Sephardic Jewish ancestry. Catherine’s mother talked about this family history to Jane, her eldest grandchild. Until recently, the family had kept some traditional Jewish items. Among the last books bought by Catherine before her memory problems began were two works on Christianity and Judaism.
9 Published in 2017, one useful report is Towards Quality Care: Outcomes for Older People in Care Homes Caroline Mozley Routledge, 22 Nov 2017
10 Holmes TH, Rahe RH (1967). "The Social Readjustment Rating Scale". J Psychosom Res. 11 (2): 213–8. doi:10.1016/0022-3999(67)90010-4. PMID 6059863.
11 22/01/2xxx Event 116, MMH/SCT.
12 Length of stay in care homes - LSE Research Onlineprints.lse.ac.uk/33895/1/dp2769.pdf by J Forder - 2011
13 10/12 2xxx NHS Trust psychiatrist, Sprite referral to GP practice B.
Same referring psychiatrist to GP A. 12/12/2xxx Anti-psychotics to commence.
14 01/04/2009 Event 140 MMH/SCT
15 . Consultant ‘s report to the OPG, cf. GP recognition of dementia two and a half years earlier, also NMGH records.
16 16/04/2xxx, consultant to GP, re Catherine’s wish for Jane to make all decisions.
17 Phone call to Jane, Jane’s husband present.
18 Abbey/Santander Bank Statements
19 23/04/2xxx. Manchester City Council Social Services.
20 11/12/2xxx, Event 61 MMH/SCT records
21 Frailty and Social Care: Over- or Under-Familiar Terms? https://www.cambridge.org/core/produc
22 Letter, Divisional Director of Medicine, Pennine Acute Hospitals Trust.
23 https://www.gov.uk/become-deputy/responsibilities
24 Lasting power of attorney: acting as an attorney – GOV.UK https://www.gov.uk/lasting-power-attorney-duties
25 Assessment: Financial crime against vulnerable adults - Social Care ...
https://www.scie.org.uk/publications/reports/report49.pdf
26 https://www.cps.gov.uk/legal-guidance/older-people-prosecuting-crimes-against older people
27 Banks and other fianncial institutions , including Nationwide, HSBC and Barclays had declined to recognise the status of a hologrammed copy,. At the depot, the LPA hologram was respected.
28 25/03/2xxx Psychiatrist to GP. MMH/SCT
28 11/12/2xxxx, NHS psychiatrist to GP Practice B.
29 18/03/2010 25./03.2010. MMH/SCT
30 18/03/2010,. 28/10/2010, 3/11/2010. MMH/SCT
31 May 2018. Care Worker Salary (United Kingdom) -PayScalehttps://www.payscale.com/research/UK
32 www.independent.co.uk › May Bulman
33 NHS Registered Mental Health Nurse Salaries in the United Kingdom ...https://www.indeed.co.uk › NHS › Salaries
34 Sending letters by post, Jane has always given her address on the reverse of an envelope.
35 Phone call with CPN, Jane’s husband present.
36 October 13th, 2010. Assessment of Catherine. NHS Mental Health records.
37 GP Practice A, to chest clinic, NMGH, 04/12/2006,
38 Two firms fined for 92-year-old resident's death at care home during renovation works. ...www.careforumwales.co.uk/.
39 Firms to be prosecuted after death of dementia sufferer, 92, who was crushed by a falling door. ...ms ttps://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk
40 Firms admit door fall death of Manchester woman, 92 - BBC News www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-manchester-26583284
41 01/08/2011 Event 179 Incontinet of faeces and urine.
42 Why nutrition is important in dementia – SCIE https://www.scie.org.uk/dementia/living...dementia/eating.../importance-of-nutrition.as.
43 20/01/2009 Event 113 MMH/SCT
44 08/09/2011 Event 181 MMH/SCT
45 Original CQC report on the Alexian Brothers Care Centre , following the inspection of July 27th 2011. Part of this report recovered.
46 See, for example, The Trust's complaints and concerns policy - East and North Herts ...
www.enherts-tr.nhs.uk/files/2010/03/Trust_complaints_and_concerns_policy.pdf