8 Who is it that can tell me who I am ?
Who is it that can tell me who I am ? 1
Who is this person ?
Recognise the whole life experience, not just cognitive decline
Respect and Support for people with a degenerative brain disease, too often assigned to Social Services.
Any form of dementia is an illness, not delinquency.
Dementia diagnosis and formal registration of a legally recognised disability.
Verification of all third party claims regarding personal, medical and career histories.
Check existing NHS records and GP care
Vetting and barring of all self-identified carers, .
Monitoring of finances.
Reformed Deprivation of Liberty safeguards to apply in all cases of ‘ family’ or other non-professional care.
Effective Safeguarding, operated by the NHS, Social Services and the Police ?
Is this achievable ?
In written, phone and face to face referrals, Jane had warned repeatedly that her parents were at risk. Alzheimer’s UK listened and advised a next day delivery letter to Manchester’s Director of Social services. Observing Sibling 3’s interaction with Catherine, and the unsafe use of high proof alcohol, Jane had warned that the risk to Catherine was greatest. No action was taken, and after Catherine was discharged to Sibling 3’s care, NHS mental health professionals respected directions which they should have recognised as wholly inappropriate. No self identified ‘ carer’ has any right to control access to any adult, even if that adult is ‘residing’ at the same address. Sibling 3 had no authority over Catherine. She had not been appointed as Catherine’s deputy, nor had she been granted Lasting Power of Attorney, yet NHS Mental Health professionals behaved as if this were the case. When Sibling 3 began to exercise such absolute control, professionals responsible for supporting vulnerable older people accepted, without any verification, the comprehensive misrepresentation of Catherine’s history.
‘ I don’t know who I am. I’m not me.’
In Catherine’s own words, the despair and loss of dementia. The echo of King Lear’s appeal is a reminder of Catherine’s old self, before dementia. NHS psychiatrists and psychiatric nurses refer to ‘Mary,’ who talked a lot about where she’d lived as a child demonstrating, shockingly,
that they knew nothing about her, accepting unchallenged every claim made by someone else.
Supporting people with dementia, mental health professionals should find out all they can about the person who existed before illness – and continues to exist. Even when she was losing the ability to manage urine and faeces, Catherine could recognise that a book was in French, read the French text. Turning the page, she recognised German place names, Auschwitz, Neuengamme, Belsen, Ravensbruck, Dachau, could ask, urgently, ‘Have you been to Germany ? Have you been to the camps ?’
NHS mental health staff and others caring for Catherine should have been reaching this person, helping Catherine claim her intact self, still ‘ me’ .
All her life, Catherine loved classical music. For many years, she and William were members of the Halle Society, regularly attending concerts at the Bridgwater Hall. Bringing up seven children, Catherine’s parents had very little money to spare, but whenever they could, tickets were bought for Halle concerts, then at the Free Trade Hall. According to Catherine's younger sister, one parent and the older children walked four miles to the Free Trade Hall, to save on bus fares.
Everything Catherine said to NHS mental health professionals and social services was true. As a young teacher, she did lead the parish youth club. Wife, mother, full time teacher, she directed the local amateur dramatics society. Productions of Nativity and Passion plays were expected, linked to her local church community, but Catherine directed classics too, including She Stoops to Conquer. Throughout her teaching career, she was fascinated by the process of learning to read and write, intrigued by the global communication of pictograms and their use in early years education. As a headteacher, she sometimes worked with the educational publishers Blackie and Son. Retirement at sixty was unwelcome, but in the early years of retirement, Catherine was able to work with a severely disabled child, suffering from Duchenne muscular dystrophy, for whom there was then no adequate provision in mainstream schooling. 2 For several years, Catherine was a member of the North Manchester Community Health Council . She volunteered for a national charity, and until reaching the age limit, continued to work in relationship counseling. When William began to suffer from transient ischaemic attacks and macular degeneration affected his sight, Catherine read to him, including works in French, and also, as his amanuensis, enabled him to continue keeping a diary. The first indications of her mental health problems were distressing. Being ‘ in denial’ was a natural response. She didn’t want this to be true, so it wasn’t true. NHS mental health professionals should recognise and support people facing a difficult diagnosis. Reporting that a patient ‘ has refused services’ is a poor response to major health care needs.
People affected by dementia are at increased risk of abuse, including financial abuse. 3 They need support at every stage of their illness. This review does not seek to explain or otherwise interpret the actions of Sibling 3 or any other person associated with the financial and other abuses of William and Catherine. Catherine’s NHS records document the sequence of events, even when the information presented in these records is incorrect. Identifying the source of incorrect information is important.
1 Can be difficult to manage and manipulative’
2 ‘ PLEASE RING DAUGHTER PRIOR TO APPOINTMENT’
3 ‘ I later found that Mrs X does not have any notes’
4 A danger to her husband, to herself and to others’
5 ‘ Seems to behave differently with strangers and could be more articulate with them.’
6‘ ‘ Always behaves well if she has an audience’
7 ZZZZ 999 UK resident ?
8 ‘ Talks a lot about Blackley, where she lived as a child’
9‘ Claims she has her own property in Blackley ‘
10 ‘ Why won’t anyone listen to me ?’
All of the above extracts are taken, verbatim, from Catherine’s NHS Mental Health records. Why won’t anyone listen to me ? is Catherine herself. On January 8th 2XXX, Catherine’s exact words, as reported by her new CPN are as follows:
‘ Why won’t anyone listen to me ? Check my records with Dr A, that will tell you about me. I used to walk everywhere. I never had a day off school, and I ran the youth club as well.’
During the same visit, Catherine tried to report that she hadn’t seen anybody all day, and that she has had nothing to eat or drink. 4 On December 29th, just before Catherine was placed in what was supposed to be long planned and assessed permanent care, the same CPN reported Sibling 3’s ‘ surprise’ when her mother ate. 5 Mental health professionals and Social Services focus on reports made by Sibling 3, accepting ‘bulimia’ and ‘ laxative abuse’ as plausible explanations for Catherine’s dramatic weight loss. NHS mental health reports focus, almost without exception, on reports from Sibling 3, not from Catherine herself.
Difficult and manipulative ? The first extract is taken from the handwritten, unsigned and undated directions included in Catherine’s records, which appear to have been used in the completion of a Manchester Sprite mental health referral in September 2xxx. 6 According to NMGH records for September 2xxx, Catherine was ‘ pleasant and cooperative’ 7
The instruction PLEASE RING DAUGHTER PRIOR TO APPOINTMENT (sic) was respected by NHS mental health professionals, even though neither phone calls nor letters to the daughter met with any response. The third extract is taken from the report written by Catherine’s consultant old age psychiatrist on December 20th 2xxx, fifteen months after she was discharged by the NMGH to the home of Sibling 3. 8 The consultant should have visited Catherine on August 31st 2xxx, as agreed with Catherine and William, and requested by Dr A, in Blackley. 9 This was the appointment missed without good reason because Catherine was still an in-patient at the NMGH, remaining there for 21 days after she was found to be medically fit for discharge. The delayed discharge was because NHS staff accepted, without any verification, claims made to them by Sibling 3, who was not legally authorised to manage Catherine’s health care, yet was allowed to prevent the delivery of care. 10 Encountering absolute control over a vulnerable adult’s access to health care. NHS professionals accepted and tacitly endorsed such control. In the report dated April 23rd 2xxx a Manchester City Council social worker identified Catherine as- ‘A danger to her husband, to herself and to others’ . Spoon feeding with liquidised sandwiches was allegedly necessary. In the same Manchester report, the social worker acknowledges what seems to be an anomaly.. ‘ Seems to behave differently with strangers and be more articulate with them. ‘ 11
The ZZZZ 999 entry in Catherine’s records for the summer of 2xxx explains the sequence of records involving different GP practices. Taken to a new GP practice, in Crumpsall, two days after being discharged from a fortnight of ‘ respite care’ , Catherine would lose even more of the life that had been hers. In Blackley, at GP practice A, her GP knew a good deal of Catherine’s history, including her years as the headteacher of a local school. This GP had requested the consultant’s home visit, to which Catherine and William had both agreed. Admitting anybody to hospital, and especially an older person, recognisably affected by dementia, NHS staff should bear in mind the problems presented by failing short term memory and consider the likelihood that a patient may have existing hospital or GP appointments. Prompt communication with the patient’s GP would resolve this matter, and ensure that key appointments are kept or postponed.
Missing the appointment with the consultant had very serious consequences. Effective mental health support could have begun, and, equally important, appropriate support for Catherine’s heart condition, which could have alleviated the impact of dementia. No such treatment and care was available to Catherine for over fifteen months, during which dementia would progress, and her damaged heart continue to struggle. Isolation, and the misrepresentation of her history exacerbated the impact of dementia. So would the abrupt separation from her home and the community where she was known. As a patient of GP practice B, in Crumpsall, Catherine was an unknown old lady, UK resident ?, who talked a lot about Blackley, supposedly the place where she had lived as a child. Who would have provided this misinformation ? Two and a half years later, examined by the consultant himself, Catherine could still give her personal history correctly, including the name of the school where she had been headteacher. Examining her again in December 2xxx, the hospital psychiatrist who knew so little about Catherine could diagnose psychotic depression, prescribing powerful medication. Not knowing a patient’s correct history, how could any accurate diagnosis be reached, or appropriate medication be prescribed ? ‘ Daughter tells me’, and other phrases to this effect appears throughout Catherine’s records for this period.
How should such situations be prevented ? Press reports of extreme confinement, health , educational and social deprivation describe, almost invariably, the damaged lives of children and young adults controlled by parents. The term ‘ carer’ is used too freely, and far too often, associated with self-sacrificing virtue. 12 Both the NHS and Social Services cherish the useful myth of self sacrificing ‘ carers’ , willing and able to care effectively for people suffering from progressive and still untreatable brain damage.
The safeguarding of people affected by dementia is seriously inadequate. The first and arguably most crucial safeguarding move would be the equivalent of identifying any form of dementia as a notifiable disease. Some might argue that such a move would be an infringement of liberty. Liberty is not respected when anybody suffering from a neuro-degenerative disease becomes the victim of abuse. Coercing somebody with dementia into giving away or otherwise misusing their assets would be far more difficult if banks were alerted to a diagnosis. The same applies to the making of new wills, effected by Sibling 3 in 2007, and, though attorneys do not have this authority, Sibling 2 in 2xxx. Swift anticipates such essential restrictions in Gulliver’s Travels. Reaching eighty, the Struldbrugs become dead in law. 13 Dystopian fiction - or radical and essential safeguarding ? Legally barred from making new wills without reference to the Court of Protection, people suffering from dementia would be safe from abusers fabricating new wills in their favour.
The misrepresentation of Catherine’s history, just over a mile from the house where she had lived for decades was easy – far too easy, exposing grave failings in NHS record keeping. When she was discharged to Sibling 3, Catherine had existing serious health problems - dementia , damaged heart valves and chronic breathing problems . Fifteen months later, Sibling 3 was able to represent her as always well and active, until the very recent onset of memory problems and breathing difficulties. Using the NHS emergency identification , ZZZZ 999 UK resident ? Catherine could be referred to hospital from GP Practice B, then abandoned in hospital, for more than three weeks after she should have been discharged, simply because Sibling 3 claimed that she could not leave her parents together. No attempt was made by NHS professionals to contact William and Catherine’s actual nearest relative, Manchester’s own records confirm that they had Jane’s written safeguarding referrals, address, and landline number. Bank statements for William and Catherine document the extensive misuse of their assets throughout Catherine’s summer in ‘ respite care’ and in hospital. The statements also document Sibling 3's location during the summer.
Adult safeguarding can and does work, if existing safeguarding legislation is respected. Many people protected by the Mental Health Act are not affected by dementia, but by lifelong conditions such as cerebral palsy. Shopping on behalf of somebody physically and sometimes mentally impaired, all expenditure must be accounted for, checked, receipted, and the goods or services purchased defined. 14
Catherine’s records from the NMGH include the two seemingly casual entries
which had such very serious consequences.
…
‘ Social Services input required ( unless daughter happy to look after’) and
‘if daughter happy without input’ 15
No child would be discharged to any self identified ‘ carer’ in this casual way. All carers for vulnerable older people should be vetted and barred, exactly as they would be if applying for paid or voluntary work with vulnerable people.
The absolute control exercised over Catherine while she was ‘ residing’ with Sibling 3 breaches all Deprivation of Liberty standards ( DoLs) – or rather, such absolute control would breach these standards, if they applied in private homes. 16
Safeguards should apply in all cases of ‘ family ‘or other non professional care. Unregulated and self identified ‘ care’ for an older person, especially if that person is affected by dementia is frequently inadequate, because carers, even when well intentioned, are unable to meet increasingly complex needs. Potentially, such self identified ‘ caring ’ exposes vulnerable people to near-inevitable abuse.
When anybody affected by dementia is discharged to an address other than their address on admission to hospital, immediate investigation of their personal circumstances should be mandatory. All property owned by the vulnerable adult should be protected, and all financial and private correspondence monitored and protected. Crucially, the obstruction of any medical care by a third party should be recognised as abuse. 16 Reporting on the ‘ complexities of the situation’ and ‘family dynamics’, NHS mental health professionals failed to recognise a dangerously distorted dynamic. Ill as she was, suffering from a devastating and currently incurable illness, Catherine the former headteacher and experienced relationship counsellor recognised the abnormal nature of Sibling 3’s relationship with William. As Catherine said, at the NMGH, to Jane and Sibling 2.
‘ It isn’t normal for a grown woman to have this relationship with her own father’ .
Catherine’s NHS mental health records document the failure of mental health professionals and social workers to recognise an abnormal and dangerously inappropriate relationship. William, aged 98, blind for nearly twelve years and also hearing impaired, was suffering from dementia.
1 King Lear, Act One, Scene 4.
2 Before the Disability Discrimination Act 1995,Education Act 1996 and subsequent legislation the boy’s access to education was limited.
3 Alzheimer's Society's view on mistreatment and abuse of people with ...
https://www.alzheimers.org.uk/about-us/.../mistreatment-and-abuse-people-dementia
4 08/01/2009 Event 96 MMH/SCT
5 29/12/2xxx Event 68 MMH/SCT
6 19/09/2xxx Manchester City Council/Mental Health and Social Care Trust
7 1/09/2xxx NMGH
8 20/12/2xxx Event 12 MMH/SCT
9 Letter, consultant’s secretary, confirming 31/08/2xxxx MMH/SCT . appointment made by phone.
10 13/12/2007 MMH/SCT.
11 23/04/2xxx Manchester City Council, Social Services report
12 Abuse of people with dementia by family carers: representative cross sectional survey BMJ 2009; 338 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.b155 (Published 23 January 2009) Cite this as: BMJ 2009;338:b155
13 Gulliver’s Travels, Chapter 26
14 Safeguarding People from Financial Abuse https://www.oxfsn.org.uk/wp.../4-OxFSN-Money-Matters-2016-Ann-Craft-Trust.pdf One of Jane’s close relatives has cerebral palsy , uses a wheelchair and lives in supported accommodation. Able to use a computer, phone and bank account, this relative is rigorously safeguarded. Any expenditure on their behalf must be documented, with receipts.
15 24.08/2xxx , 29/08.2xxx NMGH
16 Government will legislate to replace Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards ...www.communitycare.co.uk/2018
17 Nurses' recognition of domestic violence and abuse
Beth Byrom, Elizabeth Collier, and Michaela Rogers British Journal of Mental Health Nursing 2017 6:6, 286-293
Who is this person ?
Recognise the whole life experience, not just cognitive decline
Respect and Support for people with a degenerative brain disease, too often assigned to Social Services.
Any form of dementia is an illness, not delinquency.
Dementia diagnosis and formal registration of a legally recognised disability.
Verification of all third party claims regarding personal, medical and career histories.
Check existing NHS records and GP care
Vetting and barring of all self-identified carers, .
Monitoring of finances.
Reformed Deprivation of Liberty safeguards to apply in all cases of ‘ family’ or other non-professional care.
Effective Safeguarding, operated by the NHS, Social Services and the Police ?
Is this achievable ?
In written, phone and face to face referrals, Jane had warned repeatedly that her parents were at risk. Alzheimer’s UK listened and advised a next day delivery letter to Manchester’s Director of Social services. Observing Sibling 3’s interaction with Catherine, and the unsafe use of high proof alcohol, Jane had warned that the risk to Catherine was greatest. No action was taken, and after Catherine was discharged to Sibling 3’s care, NHS mental health professionals respected directions which they should have recognised as wholly inappropriate. No self identified ‘ carer’ has any right to control access to any adult, even if that adult is ‘residing’ at the same address. Sibling 3 had no authority over Catherine. She had not been appointed as Catherine’s deputy, nor had she been granted Lasting Power of Attorney, yet NHS Mental Health professionals behaved as if this were the case. When Sibling 3 began to exercise such absolute control, professionals responsible for supporting vulnerable older people accepted, without any verification, the comprehensive misrepresentation of Catherine’s history.
‘ I don’t know who I am. I’m not me.’
In Catherine’s own words, the despair and loss of dementia. The echo of King Lear’s appeal is a reminder of Catherine’s old self, before dementia. NHS psychiatrists and psychiatric nurses refer to ‘Mary,’ who talked a lot about where she’d lived as a child demonstrating, shockingly,
that they knew nothing about her, accepting unchallenged every claim made by someone else.
Supporting people with dementia, mental health professionals should find out all they can about the person who existed before illness – and continues to exist. Even when she was losing the ability to manage urine and faeces, Catherine could recognise that a book was in French, read the French text. Turning the page, she recognised German place names, Auschwitz, Neuengamme, Belsen, Ravensbruck, Dachau, could ask, urgently, ‘Have you been to Germany ? Have you been to the camps ?’
NHS mental health staff and others caring for Catherine should have been reaching this person, helping Catherine claim her intact self, still ‘ me’ .
All her life, Catherine loved classical music. For many years, she and William were members of the Halle Society, regularly attending concerts at the Bridgwater Hall. Bringing up seven children, Catherine’s parents had very little money to spare, but whenever they could, tickets were bought for Halle concerts, then at the Free Trade Hall. According to Catherine's younger sister, one parent and the older children walked four miles to the Free Trade Hall, to save on bus fares.
Everything Catherine said to NHS mental health professionals and social services was true. As a young teacher, she did lead the parish youth club. Wife, mother, full time teacher, she directed the local amateur dramatics society. Productions of Nativity and Passion plays were expected, linked to her local church community, but Catherine directed classics too, including She Stoops to Conquer. Throughout her teaching career, she was fascinated by the process of learning to read and write, intrigued by the global communication of pictograms and their use in early years education. As a headteacher, she sometimes worked with the educational publishers Blackie and Son. Retirement at sixty was unwelcome, but in the early years of retirement, Catherine was able to work with a severely disabled child, suffering from Duchenne muscular dystrophy, for whom there was then no adequate provision in mainstream schooling. 2 For several years, Catherine was a member of the North Manchester Community Health Council . She volunteered for a national charity, and until reaching the age limit, continued to work in relationship counseling. When William began to suffer from transient ischaemic attacks and macular degeneration affected his sight, Catherine read to him, including works in French, and also, as his amanuensis, enabled him to continue keeping a diary. The first indications of her mental health problems were distressing. Being ‘ in denial’ was a natural response. She didn’t want this to be true, so it wasn’t true. NHS mental health professionals should recognise and support people facing a difficult diagnosis. Reporting that a patient ‘ has refused services’ is a poor response to major health care needs.
People affected by dementia are at increased risk of abuse, including financial abuse. 3 They need support at every stage of their illness. This review does not seek to explain or otherwise interpret the actions of Sibling 3 or any other person associated with the financial and other abuses of William and Catherine. Catherine’s NHS records document the sequence of events, even when the information presented in these records is incorrect. Identifying the source of incorrect information is important.
1 Can be difficult to manage and manipulative’
2 ‘ PLEASE RING DAUGHTER PRIOR TO APPOINTMENT’
3 ‘ I later found that Mrs X does not have any notes’
4 A danger to her husband, to herself and to others’
5 ‘ Seems to behave differently with strangers and could be more articulate with them.’
6‘ ‘ Always behaves well if she has an audience’
7 ZZZZ 999 UK resident ?
8 ‘ Talks a lot about Blackley, where she lived as a child’
9‘ Claims she has her own property in Blackley ‘
10 ‘ Why won’t anyone listen to me ?’
All of the above extracts are taken, verbatim, from Catherine’s NHS Mental Health records. Why won’t anyone listen to me ? is Catherine herself. On January 8th 2XXX, Catherine’s exact words, as reported by her new CPN are as follows:
‘ Why won’t anyone listen to me ? Check my records with Dr A, that will tell you about me. I used to walk everywhere. I never had a day off school, and I ran the youth club as well.’
During the same visit, Catherine tried to report that she hadn’t seen anybody all day, and that she has had nothing to eat or drink. 4 On December 29th, just before Catherine was placed in what was supposed to be long planned and assessed permanent care, the same CPN reported Sibling 3’s ‘ surprise’ when her mother ate. 5 Mental health professionals and Social Services focus on reports made by Sibling 3, accepting ‘bulimia’ and ‘ laxative abuse’ as plausible explanations for Catherine’s dramatic weight loss. NHS mental health reports focus, almost without exception, on reports from Sibling 3, not from Catherine herself.
Difficult and manipulative ? The first extract is taken from the handwritten, unsigned and undated directions included in Catherine’s records, which appear to have been used in the completion of a Manchester Sprite mental health referral in September 2xxx. 6 According to NMGH records for September 2xxx, Catherine was ‘ pleasant and cooperative’ 7
The instruction PLEASE RING DAUGHTER PRIOR TO APPOINTMENT (sic) was respected by NHS mental health professionals, even though neither phone calls nor letters to the daughter met with any response. The third extract is taken from the report written by Catherine’s consultant old age psychiatrist on December 20th 2xxx, fifteen months after she was discharged by the NMGH to the home of Sibling 3. 8 The consultant should have visited Catherine on August 31st 2xxx, as agreed with Catherine and William, and requested by Dr A, in Blackley. 9 This was the appointment missed without good reason because Catherine was still an in-patient at the NMGH, remaining there for 21 days after she was found to be medically fit for discharge. The delayed discharge was because NHS staff accepted, without any verification, claims made to them by Sibling 3, who was not legally authorised to manage Catherine’s health care, yet was allowed to prevent the delivery of care. 10 Encountering absolute control over a vulnerable adult’s access to health care. NHS professionals accepted and tacitly endorsed such control. In the report dated April 23rd 2xxx a Manchester City Council social worker identified Catherine as- ‘A danger to her husband, to herself and to others’ . Spoon feeding with liquidised sandwiches was allegedly necessary. In the same Manchester report, the social worker acknowledges what seems to be an anomaly.. ‘ Seems to behave differently with strangers and be more articulate with them. ‘ 11
The ZZZZ 999 entry in Catherine’s records for the summer of 2xxx explains the sequence of records involving different GP practices. Taken to a new GP practice, in Crumpsall, two days after being discharged from a fortnight of ‘ respite care’ , Catherine would lose even more of the life that had been hers. In Blackley, at GP practice A, her GP knew a good deal of Catherine’s history, including her years as the headteacher of a local school. This GP had requested the consultant’s home visit, to which Catherine and William had both agreed. Admitting anybody to hospital, and especially an older person, recognisably affected by dementia, NHS staff should bear in mind the problems presented by failing short term memory and consider the likelihood that a patient may have existing hospital or GP appointments. Prompt communication with the patient’s GP would resolve this matter, and ensure that key appointments are kept or postponed.
Missing the appointment with the consultant had very serious consequences. Effective mental health support could have begun, and, equally important, appropriate support for Catherine’s heart condition, which could have alleviated the impact of dementia. No such treatment and care was available to Catherine for over fifteen months, during which dementia would progress, and her damaged heart continue to struggle. Isolation, and the misrepresentation of her history exacerbated the impact of dementia. So would the abrupt separation from her home and the community where she was known. As a patient of GP practice B, in Crumpsall, Catherine was an unknown old lady, UK resident ?, who talked a lot about Blackley, supposedly the place where she had lived as a child. Who would have provided this misinformation ? Two and a half years later, examined by the consultant himself, Catherine could still give her personal history correctly, including the name of the school where she had been headteacher. Examining her again in December 2xxx, the hospital psychiatrist who knew so little about Catherine could diagnose psychotic depression, prescribing powerful medication. Not knowing a patient’s correct history, how could any accurate diagnosis be reached, or appropriate medication be prescribed ? ‘ Daughter tells me’, and other phrases to this effect appears throughout Catherine’s records for this period.
How should such situations be prevented ? Press reports of extreme confinement, health , educational and social deprivation describe, almost invariably, the damaged lives of children and young adults controlled by parents. The term ‘ carer’ is used too freely, and far too often, associated with self-sacrificing virtue. 12 Both the NHS and Social Services cherish the useful myth of self sacrificing ‘ carers’ , willing and able to care effectively for people suffering from progressive and still untreatable brain damage.
The safeguarding of people affected by dementia is seriously inadequate. The first and arguably most crucial safeguarding move would be the equivalent of identifying any form of dementia as a notifiable disease. Some might argue that such a move would be an infringement of liberty. Liberty is not respected when anybody suffering from a neuro-degenerative disease becomes the victim of abuse. Coercing somebody with dementia into giving away or otherwise misusing their assets would be far more difficult if banks were alerted to a diagnosis. The same applies to the making of new wills, effected by Sibling 3 in 2007, and, though attorneys do not have this authority, Sibling 2 in 2xxx. Swift anticipates such essential restrictions in Gulliver’s Travels. Reaching eighty, the Struldbrugs become dead in law. 13 Dystopian fiction - or radical and essential safeguarding ? Legally barred from making new wills without reference to the Court of Protection, people suffering from dementia would be safe from abusers fabricating new wills in their favour.
The misrepresentation of Catherine’s history, just over a mile from the house where she had lived for decades was easy – far too easy, exposing grave failings in NHS record keeping. When she was discharged to Sibling 3, Catherine had existing serious health problems - dementia , damaged heart valves and chronic breathing problems . Fifteen months later, Sibling 3 was able to represent her as always well and active, until the very recent onset of memory problems and breathing difficulties. Using the NHS emergency identification , ZZZZ 999 UK resident ? Catherine could be referred to hospital from GP Practice B, then abandoned in hospital, for more than three weeks after she should have been discharged, simply because Sibling 3 claimed that she could not leave her parents together. No attempt was made by NHS professionals to contact William and Catherine’s actual nearest relative, Manchester’s own records confirm that they had Jane’s written safeguarding referrals, address, and landline number. Bank statements for William and Catherine document the extensive misuse of their assets throughout Catherine’s summer in ‘ respite care’ and in hospital. The statements also document Sibling 3's location during the summer.
Adult safeguarding can and does work, if existing safeguarding legislation is respected. Many people protected by the Mental Health Act are not affected by dementia, but by lifelong conditions such as cerebral palsy. Shopping on behalf of somebody physically and sometimes mentally impaired, all expenditure must be accounted for, checked, receipted, and the goods or services purchased defined. 14
Catherine’s records from the NMGH include the two seemingly casual entries
which had such very serious consequences.
…
‘ Social Services input required ( unless daughter happy to look after’) and
‘if daughter happy without input’ 15
No child would be discharged to any self identified ‘ carer’ in this casual way. All carers for vulnerable older people should be vetted and barred, exactly as they would be if applying for paid or voluntary work with vulnerable people.
The absolute control exercised over Catherine while she was ‘ residing’ with Sibling 3 breaches all Deprivation of Liberty standards ( DoLs) – or rather, such absolute control would breach these standards, if they applied in private homes. 16
Safeguards should apply in all cases of ‘ family ‘or other non professional care. Unregulated and self identified ‘ care’ for an older person, especially if that person is affected by dementia is frequently inadequate, because carers, even when well intentioned, are unable to meet increasingly complex needs. Potentially, such self identified ‘ caring ’ exposes vulnerable people to near-inevitable abuse.
When anybody affected by dementia is discharged to an address other than their address on admission to hospital, immediate investigation of their personal circumstances should be mandatory. All property owned by the vulnerable adult should be protected, and all financial and private correspondence monitored and protected. Crucially, the obstruction of any medical care by a third party should be recognised as abuse. 16 Reporting on the ‘ complexities of the situation’ and ‘family dynamics’, NHS mental health professionals failed to recognise a dangerously distorted dynamic. Ill as she was, suffering from a devastating and currently incurable illness, Catherine the former headteacher and experienced relationship counsellor recognised the abnormal nature of Sibling 3’s relationship with William. As Catherine said, at the NMGH, to Jane and Sibling 2.
‘ It isn’t normal for a grown woman to have this relationship with her own father’ .
Catherine’s NHS mental health records document the failure of mental health professionals and social workers to recognise an abnormal and dangerously inappropriate relationship. William, aged 98, blind for nearly twelve years and also hearing impaired, was suffering from dementia.
1 King Lear, Act One, Scene 4.
2 Before the Disability Discrimination Act 1995,Education Act 1996 and subsequent legislation the boy’s access to education was limited.
3 Alzheimer's Society's view on mistreatment and abuse of people with ...
https://www.alzheimers.org.uk/about-us/.../mistreatment-and-abuse-people-dementia
4 08/01/2009 Event 96 MMH/SCT
5 29/12/2xxx Event 68 MMH/SCT
6 19/09/2xxx Manchester City Council/Mental Health and Social Care Trust
7 1/09/2xxx NMGH
8 20/12/2xxx Event 12 MMH/SCT
9 Letter, consultant’s secretary, confirming 31/08/2xxxx MMH/SCT . appointment made by phone.
10 13/12/2007 MMH/SCT.
11 23/04/2xxx Manchester City Council, Social Services report
12 Abuse of people with dementia by family carers: representative cross sectional survey BMJ 2009; 338 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.b155 (Published 23 January 2009) Cite this as: BMJ 2009;338:b155
13 Gulliver’s Travels, Chapter 26
14 Safeguarding People from Financial Abuse https://www.oxfsn.org.uk/wp.../4-OxFSN-Money-Matters-2016-Ann-Craft-Trust.pdf One of Jane’s close relatives has cerebral palsy , uses a wheelchair and lives in supported accommodation. Able to use a computer, phone and bank account, this relative is rigorously safeguarded. Any expenditure on their behalf must be documented, with receipts.
15 24.08/2xxx , 29/08.2xxx NMGH
16 Government will legislate to replace Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards ...www.communitycare.co.uk/2018
17 Nurses' recognition of domestic violence and abuse
Beth Byrom, Elizabeth Collier, and Michaela Rogers British Journal of Mental Health Nursing 2017 6:6, 286-293