9 An Inspector Calls…

The Police  and the Crown Prosecution Service. 
 Investigation into  extensive financial and other abuses closed.
 Police claim  a blind 98 year old would have been able to read, citing an opthalmology ratio  which confirms blindness.
 GMP officer  did not understand the significance of the number. 
 CEO of the Central manchester University Hospitals acknowledges that data provided by a trainee registrar to a constable signifies ‘severely sight impaired/blind – this cannot be disputed’.
The CMUH Trust disclaims  responsibility for Police interpretation of medical data.
Direct police access to patient records from members of staff,  without applying to  Medical Legal. 
CID Inspector and Sergeant from Greater Manchester Police travel to Cumbria.
 The detective inspector dismissed  NHS records  of dementia and blindness as ‘ irrelevant’
 ' Your problem is that you don't get on with your family'
' 


 Sibling 2  gave Jane the address of the property under construction   on Cardigan Bay, to which Sibling 3 intended to move with  98 year old William.   Catherine  ‘might not be well enough’  to move with them, and could be staying in Manchester.  

Aged 98 and almost 88, moving to Wales was not in the  interests of either William or Catherine.  In addition to the obvious  financial abuse – that is, theft of  their six figure  savings to fund a new build in Wales, the intended permanent separation of husband and wife was an abuse of their human rights, including their right to a family life,. Even if reports that  Catherine was a danger   to her husband, to herself and to others were correct,  absolute and permanent separation would not be justified.   In the case of proven mental illness,  provision equivalent to the ‘safe house’ contact arranged for children can be made.

Reporting abuse

Call 999 if you are reporting a crime that is in progress or if someone is in immediate danger.

Contact the local police if you think a crime has been committed or contact the local council if you think someone is at risk or is being abused.

Dismissed by Greater Manchester Police with a warning about unfounded allegations, Jane reported ongoing abuse to Social Services and NHS mental health professionals.   By letter in December, and during a three hour meeting  at Adult Social Care offices in North Manchester in January, Jane had reported ongoing abuse, well into six figures,  signing the statement made to a care manager and social worker.  Again, no action had been taken, yet  Catherine’s  social worker rang Jane repeatedly, urging her to go to the police.

Jane reported the abuse to Cumbria Constabulary, presenting bank statements recovered from William and  Catherine’s house.    Cumbria  Constabulary had  reported the abuse to Greater Manchester Police.

When the cash sale of William and Catherine ’s house was still pending, Jane and her husband searched bin bags  stored inside the property.   They found William’s  Registered Blind Person’s card , still in its high visibility yellow wallet.  William’s official white stick was  in the hallway.

Reported to  Greater Manchester Police,  the financial and physical abuse of vulnerable older people aged 98 and 88, suffering from dementia, blindness and uncorrected hearing impairment was dismissed, repeatedly, as ‘a domestic, we don’t get involved’.  Repeatedly, at police stations in North Manchester, Jane’s reports were disregarded and she was not allowed to make a statement.    At Collyhurst police station, keeping an early morning appointment, the desk sergeant’s response was specific : This is about three sisters, isn’t it ? It’s a domestic. We don’t get involved.’  Another GMP desk sergeant suggested that
‘ in a lucid moment’,  Jane’s parents could have agreed to everything.

Jane was  warned that she could be charged with ‘wasting police time’, an offence which can result in a six months prison sentence. 

Jane’s husband, who works in the financial sector, drew up a detailed analysis of William and Catherine’s misused assets.   Their MP referred the case to the Chief Constable of Greater Manchester Police.    Investigation into a case identified as ‘ criminal deception'  began.  The case had been assigned to a young  constable, who  approached Jane , requesting access to  William’s  opthalmology records.   GMP had already been presented with William’s Registered Blind Person’s card, issued by Manchester City Council and bearing his number on the city’s register.    GMP then informed Jane by email that the case was closed, because William would have been able to read, and also, the Crown Prosecution Service
 ‘ did not feel’ that there was enough evidence.   Claiming that William would have been able to read, GMP were citing opthalmology data which confirms that he was blind.    GMP had  been given William’s  North Manchester General Hospital records, confirming that he was suffering from vascular dementia, macular degeneration, and that his hearing impairment was uncorrected.  Jane’s MP had obtained a copy of the Best Interests meeting held for William while financial abuse was ongoing. In a case concerning the financial abuse of vulnerable older people, William then in his late nineties and Catherine in her late eighties,  why would the Crown Prosecution Service reject so much evidence of financial abuse , dementia and blindness ?

Jane rang the York office of the CPS . The call was transferred immediately to the Chief Crown Prosecutor for Manchester and Salford, who informed Jane  that no NHS records for William had been referred to him.  In a case of this nature, such evidence would be given to him. The  chief  crown prosecutor confirmed this by email, and also,  copied to Jane  an email from a GMP Inspector, acknowledging that no  medical records  for this case had been submitted to the CPS.   Claims made to Jane by GMP   officers about supposed rulings made by the CPS were incorrect.

 GMP continued to claim that William would have been able to read. Their evidence was  the visual acuity ratio confirming blindness.  The CMUH Medical Legal department claimed that any police officer seeking access to records would  be directed to them.  No records could be obtained directly from a member of  staff.  Jane applied for William’s  opthalmology records herself.  Knowing that her father had been blind for years, carrying the RBP card and using a white stick, this hadn’t seemed necessary.  The Central Manchester University Hospitals  confirmed that they had  William’s  records.   Jane paid the required fee. No records were released. Five months later, the CMUH claimed that the records ‘ had probably been destroyed’ . Jane contacted her MP’s office immediately.  Thirteen days later,  the records were released, but did not include any  evidence of contact with GMP.  After eight months of denials by the CMUH, Jane submitted a Freedom of Information request.  A letter from  a trainee registrar to a   GMP constable was then released.    This was the source of the visual acuity ratio which GMP officers took to mean that William would have been able to read.   The CMUH   then claimed that the hospital knew nothing about this, and the registrar had been ‘working outside his NHS employment.’    Jane referred her complaint to the PHSO.  Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman caseworkers supported this  claim.  If if the registrar was ' Working outside his NHS employment' , directly with the police, they couldn't investigate. Jane  requested sight of  a contract authorising  such secondary  employment .   No such authorisation could be produced.  The CMUH continued  to claim that   nobody at the trust was aware of the registrar’s actions .  The registrar’s letter to the constable  had been typed by the senior consultant’s secretary.   It was addressed to Greater Manchester Police. No data protection application  from the police could be produced, but GMP have produced their email correspondence with the CMUH.     The CEO of this Trust has acknowledged that the visual acuity ratio provided  by the registrar confirms that somebody is severely sight impaired/blind, adding ‘ this cannot be disputed – then indicated that Jane might take this up with the ‘ investigative authorities.’ .

 The Professional Standards branch of GMP, and then the IPCC – now the IOPC,  insisted , repeatedly, that there was no evidence that William could not see anything – The IPCC warned  that Jane  had made ‘ repetitious complaints’  - claiming that William was blind.   Manchester City Council Sensory Support Services confirmed that they had provided sensory support for William for many years,  as a blind resident,  but they were not  available to  confirm this to GMP. According to a senior member of   Manchester’s sensory support staf :

 ‘ the police can be very intimidating and bullying’.  

 A  GMP Detective Inspector and a Detective Sergeant came to Jane’s house in Cumbria for a meeting.   During this meeting, Jane did not refer to any  NHS or Social Services staff by name,  but  the  DI named the care manager to whom Jane had reported ongoing six figure abuse of her parents when both were suffering from dementia and her father had been blind for years.

The DI informed  Jane  that none of the NHS records were relevant, adding,

‘ Your problem is that you don’t get on with your family.’

Most  of the abuse of older people is by family members and other people known to the victims.